Starting the day with breakfast??
MrJamsieboi
Posts: 22
I have never been one for breakfast normally because I am running late but have been trying to make sure I have something in the morning recently.
The problem is when I eat breakfast say around 7:30am by the time it gets to lunch I am really hungry to the point I think about snacking. When I didn't eat breakfast I could go all day without eating but I would normally eat loads between dinner and bed.
Is anyone else like this or just me lol, I know eating in the morning makes sence but food seems to be on my mind all day after it.
The problem is when I eat breakfast say around 7:30am by the time it gets to lunch I am really hungry to the point I think about snacking. When I didn't eat breakfast I could go all day without eating but I would normally eat loads between dinner and bed.
Is anyone else like this or just me lol, I know eating in the morning makes sence but food seems to be on my mind all day after it.
0
Replies
-
I used to be the same way. You don't have to eat breakfast, lots of people don't. Your reasoning is sensible and is what works for you.
As long as you stay within a calorie allotment, you can eat whenever you want.
That old "Eat breakfast" and "eat five times a day" is all dieting myth.0 -
I think in your particular case you should not eat breakfast.
Your meal timing and frequency should be dictated by personal preference and gym performance. Since not eating breakfast makes it easier for you to stick to your calorie goal (at least that's what I'm getting from your post), you should do that.0 -
While I agree that breakfast isn't necessary if you aren't hungry, I personally think it is ok to snack between breakfast and lunch because that is what works for me. So, if you should happen to wake up hungry and want breakfast, don't sweat it if you get hungry and snack before lunch because there truly is nothing wrong with that method either!0
-
Listen to this man!I think in your particular case you should not eat breakfast.
Your meal timing and frequency should be dictated by personal preference and gym performance. Since not eating breakfast makes it easier for you to stick to your calorie goal (at least that's what I'm getting from your post), you should do that.0 -
Of course you are hungrier by lunch because you started your metabolism by eating breakfast!... When you don't eat breakfast at all you don't start your metabolism and that's why you don't feel as hungry. If you have a weight loss goal this is a bad habit. I would have a light snack between your breakfast and lunch times... either that or eat half your breakfast at breakfast and the other half two hours later then you will be able to last til lunch. Which ever you choose your body adapt to your eating habits if you keep them consistent. Be Consistent! Be healthy! hope this helps
0 -
If I'm in a phase where I never eat breakfast, I feel the same... Until lunch is there, I'm fine.
But lately, I'd become accustomed to eating breakfast and find I can't go without. If I do, I feel crabby, hungry, etc. But I simply don't have time (I hate mornings), so I've started eating a hard boiled egg and I'm perfect until lunch.
I think it's often what you're used to and how you feel. But as SS said... If it works fine for you to not eat until lunch, then by all means, don't eat until lunch.0 -
received wisdom says that you should eat breakfast, largest meal,
and then eat small meals during the day - you do not have to be tied to breakfast, lunch and dinner. 4,5,6,8 meals of small size are just fine.
Then I have seen diets that like you to fast from going to bed till about 3 hours before going to bed again - for me that would be
eat at 7pm everyday. No more than 300 calories during the day. I haven't tried it, goes against everything that you are supposed to believe but I believe hunter gatherers used to eat but once a day and that was just before sunset.0 -
Of course you are hungrier by lunch because you started your metabolism by eating breakfast!... When you don't eat breakfast at all you don't start your metabolism and that's why you don't feel as hungry. If you have a weight loss goal this is a bad habit. I would have a light snack between your breakfast and lunch times... either that or eat half your breakfast at breakfast and the other half two hours later then you will be able to last til lunch. Which ever you choose your body adapt to your eating habits if you keep them consistent. Be Consistent! Be healthy! hope this helps
Your metabolism does not start and stop. Meal timing is irrelevant.0 -
I did have the same problem. If I ate cereat for breakfast I was hungry by 10:00. A piece of whole wheat 45 cal. toast with hoop cheese melted under the broiler (5 min.) worked best for me and I mix up Barley Green with Acai pomagranite / blueberry juice and that helps to hold me. I am not longer having problems so I am changing up now. I stay prepared with fruit and veggies in plastic bags ready to go in the fridge. I keep cantalope in a plastic container and if I have to leave in a hurry I throw it in the car with me to eat while I am on my way. Some people might say this is a bad idea, but it works for me and I am determined to get this FAT off and get healthy. Good luck to ya!!!0
-
Of course you are hungrier by lunch because you started your metabolism by eating breakfast!... When you don't eat breakfast at all you don't start your metabolism and that's why you don't feel as hungry. If you have a weight loss goal this is a bad habit. I would have a light snack between your breakfast and lunch times... either that or eat half your breakfast at breakfast and the other half two hours later then you will be able to last til lunch. Which ever you choose your body adapt to your eating habits if you keep them consistent. Be Consistent! Be healthy! hope this helps
The problem here is that your metabolism doesn't stop when you're sleeping or... anything other than dead. So you don't really need to "start" it
0 -
Of course you are hungrier by lunch because you started your metabolism by eating breakfast!... When you don't eat breakfast at all you don't start your metabolism and that's why you don't feel as hungry. If you have a weight loss goal this is a bad habit. I would have a light snack between your breakfast and lunch times... either that or eat half your breakfast at breakfast and the other half two hours later then you will be able to last til lunch. Which ever you choose your body adapt to your eating habits if you keep them consistent. Be Consistent! Be healthy! hope this helps
Your metabolism is not a car. It does not need a "kickstart" in the morning. Some people do great eating breakfast, others don't need breakfast.0 -
received wisdom says that you should eat breakfast, largest meal,
and then eat small meals during the day - you do not have to be tied to breakfast, lunch and dinner. 4,5,6,8 meals of small size are just fine.
Then I have seen diets that like you to fast from going to bed till about 3 hours before going to bed again - for me that would be
eat at 7pm everyday. No more than 300 calories during the day. I haven't tried it, goes against everything that you are supposed to believe but I believe hunter gatherers used to eat but once a day and that was just before sunset.
No it does not.0 -
received wisdom says that you should eat breakfast, largest meal,
and then eat small meals during the day - you do not have to be tied to breakfast, lunch and dinner. 4,5,6,8 meals of small size are just fine.
Then I have seen diets that like you to fast from going to bed till about 3 hours before going to bed again - for me that would be
eat at 7pm everyday. No more than 300 calories during the day. I haven't tried it, goes against everything that you are supposed to believe but I believe hunter gatherers used to eat but once a day and that was just before sunset.
Who is this "received wisdom" person?? Because you don't need to do any of that.0 -
I think in your particular case you should not eat breakfast.
Your meal timing and frequency should be dictated by personal preference and gym performance. Since not eating breakfast makes it easier for you to stick to your calorie goal (at least that's what I'm getting from your post), you should do that.
Ditto... and I usually I don't eat it either. Unless by some miracle I am actually hungry. Which today I was so I did. Usually if I eat too early it makes me over eat later too. Ikk. Do what you feel your body needs.0 -
I did have the same problem. If I ate cereat for breakfast I was hungry by 10:00. A piece of whole wheat 45 cal. toast with hoop cheese melted under the broiler (5 min.) worked best for me and I mix up Barley Green with Acai pomagranite / blueberry juice and that helps to hold me. I am not longer having problems so I am changing up now. I stay prepared with fruit and veggies in plastic bags ready to go in the fridge. I keep cantalope in a plastic container and if I have to leave in a hurry I throw it in the car with me to eat while I am on my way. Some people might say this is a bad idea, but it works for me and I am determined to get this FAT off and get healthy. Good luck to ya!!!
I don't think this is a bad idea and anyone who says so probably doesn't know what they're talking about. If it works for you and fits your macros, go for it.0 -
received wisdom says that you should eat breakfast, largest meal,
and then eat small meals during the day - you do not have to be tied to breakfast, lunch and dinner. 4,5,6,8 meals of small size are just fine.
Then I have seen diets that like you to fast from going to bed till about 3 hours before going to bed again - for me that would be
eat at 7pm everyday. No more than 300 calories during the day. I haven't tried it, goes against everything that you are supposed to believe but I believe hunter gatherers used to eat but once a day and that was just before sunset.
Uh no and no and NO! Who is this the wisdom of a 2 year old named Received?????0 -
I think in your particular case you should not eat breakfast.
Your meal timing and frequency should be dictated by personal preference and gym performance. Since not eating breakfast makes it easier for you to stick to your calorie goal (at least that's what I'm getting from your post), you should do that.
Agreed!! Everyone is different and there is no such thing as meal frequency just make sure you are hitting your calorie goals for that day... I am totally different than you I eat over 3400 calories a day and am a Type 2 Diabetic so I eat Breakfast upon waking do to my overnight fasting and low blood sugar but you have to do what works best for you.... Best of Luck...0 -
0
-
Of course you are hungrier by lunch because you started your metabolism by eating breakfast!... When you don't eat breakfast at all you don't start your metabolism and that's why you don't feel as hungry. If you have a weight loss goal this is a bad habit. I would have a light snack between your breakfast and lunch times... either that or eat half your breakfast at breakfast and the other half two hours later then you will be able to last til lunch. Which ever you choose your body adapt to your eating habits if you keep them consistent. Be Consistent! Be healthy! hope this helps
HAH! Here is another NO!
You don’t start your metabolism by eating. You are more hungry later because your levels are higher in the morning and it causes your body to react to food differently. It actually freaks out my system and makes me eat more usually if I eat breakfast. It doesn’t magically make you burn more because it magically jump starts your metabolism!! We are not cars! Unicorns don't make are metabolism get jump started either! Shesh people. It takes 60 hours to go into starvation mode! 60 hours not 12 not even 24 hours! 60!!! You can eat 1 meal a day or 10! Do what you want and you like!
Here is the info about your levels and what it does to your body and why you are hungrier if you eat breakfast. If it works for you to eat breakfast then great! But stop telling people it "jump starts" your metabolism!
http://www.leangains.com/2012/06/why-does-breakfast-make-me-hungry.html0 -
Dont force yourself to eat breakfast. There is no reason to eat when you first get up. I never feel like eating before I have been up for hours. Just get your calories in and try to meet your macro and micro nutrient needs when you do eat.0
-
I think in your particular case you should not eat breakfast.
Your meal timing and frequency should be dictated by personal preference and gym performance. Since not eating breakfast makes it easier for you to stick to your calorie goal (at least that's what I'm getting from your post), you should do that.
Ditto... and I usually I don't eat it either. Unless by some miracle I am actually hungry. Which today I was so I did. Usually if I eat too early it makes me over eat later too. Ikk. Do what you feel your body needs.
I'm the exact same way. If I eat a big breakfast, even if it's healthy, I actually find myself eating more throughout the day. If I do eat I stick to something small like a hard boiled egg or piece of fruit.0 -
I usually have a piece of fruit for breakfast on the go at work. If I have anything bigger I am absolutely starving all morning!0
-
received wisdom says that you should eat breakfast, largest meal,
and then eat small meals during the day - you do not have to be tied to breakfast, lunch and dinner. 4,5,6,8 meals of small size are just fine.
Then I have seen diets that like you to fast from going to bed till about 3 hours before going to bed again - for me that would be
eat at 7pm everyday. No more than 300 calories during the day. I haven't tried it, goes against everything that you are supposed to believe but I believe hunter gatherers used to eat but once a day and that was just before sunset.
Uh no and no and NO! Who is this the wisdom of a 2 year old named Received?????
good grief, with the power of google two people demonstrate inability to look up - received wisdom as an idiom.
Hilarious, with such research ability one should really trust their advise.
I will be laughing all the way to the Gore Vidal bank.
http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/the+received+wisdom
Now you two, go and try to belittle someone else.0 -
Thanks for the responses going to read the articles posted and decide what is best for me, eating breakfast just doesn't feel natural to me.0
-
You have to remember that everyone is different. I have to eat breakfast or else I turn into the Hulk. If you weren't eating breakfast and were overweight you may want to consider that being part of your problem. It is WAY better to eat the bulk of your calories in the first half of the day. So if you eat at 7:30am and a snack at 10am then lunch at noon you probably won't need to eat again until dinner.
Long story short...If whatever you were doing before led you to being overweight then don't do it now... Just my 2 centsI have never been one for breakfast normally because I am running late but have been trying to make sure I have something in the morning recently.
The problem is when I eat breakfast say around 7:30am by the time it gets to lunch I am really hungry to the point I think about snacking. When I didn't eat breakfast I could go all day without eating but I would normally eat loads between dinner and bed.
Is anyone else like this or just me lol, I know eating in the morning makes sence but food seems to be on my mind all day after it.0 -
received wisdom says that you should eat breakfast, largest meal,
and then eat small meals during the day - you do not have to be tied to breakfast, lunch and dinner. 4,5,6,8 meals of small size are just fine.
Then I have seen diets that like you to fast from going to bed till about 3 hours before going to bed again - for me that would be
eat at 7pm everyday. No more than 300 calories during the day. I haven't tried it, goes against everything that you are supposed to believe but I believe hunter gatherers used to eat but once a day and that was just before sunset.
Uh no and no and NO! Who is this the wisdom of a 2 year old named Received?????
good grief, with the power of google two people demonstrate inability to look up - received wisdom as an idiom.
Hilarious, with such research ability one should really trust their advise.
I will be laughing all the way to the Gore Vidal bank.
http://idioms.thefreedictionary.com/the+received+wisdom
Now you two, go and try to belittle someone else.
*snicker* you're fun :flowerforyou:0 -
I've never been one much for eating breakfast. I tend to skip it or have it very late in the morning. It's all calories in vs. calories out and the timing of meals doesn't play a role. I'm living proof this works. 113 down in one year.0
-
It is WAY better to eat the bulk of your calories in the first half of the day.
Based on what?0 -
I'm totally with you and I eat breakfast, usually with a lot of protein in it such as egg beaters, cheese, and toast. Then, I eat a snack a few hours later, often after working out or after some hours at work. Otherwise, I tend to not be hungry and then, several hours later, it's like "BAM!!!! I'm starving!!" and I spend the rest of the day eating more than had I just eaten breakfast and had a snack later on in the day (pre-lunch). Eating at regular intervals tends to help me a lot!
All the best to you,
Abi :flowerforyou:
PS I'm following the advice of my nutritionist at a doctor and nutritionist-supervised medical weight loss program at Cedars Sinai in LA. http://www.cedars-sinai.edu/Patients/Programs-and-Services/Weight-Loss-Center/Weight-Management-Program.aspx
Please help me conquer my goal of $1,001 for the SD AIDS Walk. (Hope it's ok to put this here.) Every bit helps. http://events.thecentersd.org/site/TR/Events/General?px=1037155&pg=personal&fr_id=10500 -
It is WAY better to eat the bulk of your calories in the first half of the day.
Based on what?
Based on the fact that he admitted to eating late in the day after not eating all day long and now he's overweight. I'm just suggesting he do what is opposite of what he's been doing. If it doesn't work it doesn't work but obviously he needs to change something.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions