Side Effect of Vegetarianism?

FredDoyle

Side Effect of Vegetarianism = being less responsible for the death of thousands of animals.

:flowerforyou:

Those animals wouldn't have been alive without meat eaters. We raised them for meat and milk...
They only exist for us to use them. You can take issue with that if you want, but your point is silly.

mushroomcup

lack of healthy fat in the diet can make existing psychiatric problems worse and I've seen one study that links insufficient healthy fat to an increased risk of suicide (not read the actual journal article though, just seen it referenced in something else)

Healthy fat certainly has a role in the brain, and lack of it can affect how your brain functions, so that *may* be an explanation as to why introducing fish into your diet caused the nightmares to stop... *if* they were caused by a deficiency in healthy fats... fish is a very good source of healthy fat. Note: this is just a suggestion, no idea if it was that or not, but it's theoretically possible. The brain is a highly complex organ and if it's not functioning at its best due to a dietary deficiency, then nightmares *may* be one way that manifests itself. this kind of thing would vary from individual to individual, and sometimes things that would not have any noticeable affect on one person's brain might trigger something another person is more susceptible to (nightmares in your case)

Also, even if the above is true, the vegetarian diet itself is not to blame. There are plenty of vegetarian sources of healthy fat such as cold pressed vegetable and seed oils, and nuts, and flax seed is supposed to be really good. The vegetarian diet isn't automatically healthier than a meat eating diet. Either a vegetarian or non-vegetarian diet could be deficient in some nutrients if you don't pay enough attention to them.

And if you were sure you were getting adequate fat and other nutrients in your diet then just ignore my suggestion. There are other likely causes, including pure co-incidence.

Thanks for the response. I'll definitely look into that. I know that sometimes I've neglected fat in my diet. It wasn't on purpose, I just tend to really like carb-heavy foods.

mushroomcup

I had the opposite, actually. Since I stopped eating meat, I die a lot less frequently in my dreams. I used to have nightmare nearly every night, but the lack of meat (and the addition of a melatonin supplement for my Asperger's) has helped me sleep more soundly. I have not heard of any similar thing from any of my other vegetarian/vegan friends.

That's really interesting. Why do you take melatonin for Asperger's?

I've never been tested by a psychiatrist, but I've taken the Asperger's Quotient (I think that's what it's called) online and it put me well within the Asperger's range and suggested that I test for it with a professional to see for certain.

happydaze71

Good lord!!! I've never heard of anything so crazy in my life.
Nightmares would more likely be caused by stress, and perhaps if you at a diet loaded with crap like ALOT of sugar and caffeine (but this isn't restricted to vegetarians)
Stress stress stress or a manic condition that needs medication yes, caused by vegetarianism.... Um no!

DesireeLovesOrganic

I'm vegan and don't have this problem either. I sleep good. I eat lots of healthy fats though (and get enough b12.)

courtneyparsons

I'm a vegetarian and I DO have crazy dreams as well.

I doubt vegetarianism is linked to the dreams, but in my case I think if I go to bed too hungry, then my body will wake me up in the middle of the night and the dream will seem more real. I eat a handful of nuts or a few crackers, then I go back to bed just fine.

missssminky

hmmm... dont know about nightmares but being vego has certainly helped with my depression and anxiety.

I believe its partly because i am not ingesting all the misery that shoots through the animals blood before they slaughter them.

megan1869

I became a vegetarian around age 3-5 (I'm now 26) and I can honestly say that I have nightmares A LOT.... I dont know if its connected, but if it is I'd sure as heck like the cure!

billsica

I was a veg from 1993 to 2006. I don't dream very often. The ones I have had were horrific. from being torn in half to being choked by the devil. The later haunts me to this day because I woke up unable to breath.

I haven't had any lately that I know of. That is so weird. I'm going to have to think about when they started and stopped.

what helped me. was to say my prayers at night. I think mostly it was a relaxing mantra to de-stress myself.

mushroomcup

I was a veg from 1993 to 2006. I don't dream very often. The ones I have had were horrific. from being torn in half to being choked by the devil. The later haunts me to this day because I woke up unable to breath.

I haven't had any lately that I know of. That is so weird. I'm going to have to think about when they started and stopped.

what helped me. was to say my prayers at night. I think mostly it was a relaxing mantra to de-stress myself.

That's awful. >.< They sound similar to mine.

I don't pray but I did try relaxation techniques. Unfortunately, they didn't seem to help much. There were times that I went to bed content and stress-free and still had my night terrors. This is part of why I think that maybe they have a physical cause.

billsica

I was a veg from 1993 to 2006. I don't dream very often. The ones I have had were horrific. from being torn in half to being choked by the devil. The later haunts me to this day because I woke up unable to breath.

I haven't had any lately that I know of. That is so weird. I'm going to have to think about when they started and stopped.

what helped me. was to say my prayers at night. I think mostly it was a relaxing mantra to de-stress myself.

That's awful. >.< They sound similar to mine.

I don't pray but I did try relaxation techniques. Unfortunately, they didn't seem to help much. There were times that I went to bed content and stress-free and still had my night terrors. This is part of why I think that maybe they have a physical cause.

I ended up going to a sleep lab. Maybe you should look into that? If its every night, that is horrible. At least mine are not that often, so its just any dream I can remember is a night terror. the rest are just empty black sleep.

mushroomcup

I was a veg from 1993 to 2006. I don't dream very often. The ones I have had were horrific. from being torn in half to being choked by the devil. The later haunts me to this day because I woke up unable to breath.

I haven't had any lately that I know of. That is so weird. I'm going to have to think about when they started and stopped.

what helped me. was to say my prayers at night. I think mostly it was a relaxing mantra to de-stress myself.

That's awful. >.< They sound similar to mine.

I don't pray but I did try relaxation techniques. Unfortunately, they didn't seem to help much. There were times that I went to bed content and stress-free and still had my night terrors. This is part of why I think that maybe they have a physical cause.

I ended up going to a sleep lab. Maybe you should look into that? If its every night, that is horrible. At least mine are not that often, so its just any dream I can remember is a night terror. the rest are just empty black sleep.

I have only had one in the last 5 months or so (since I went pescetarian) and even when I had them before, it was sporadic. I would go weeks without a night terror, then I'd go a week where I'd have one every night. Then maybe another week would go by and I'd have one, etc. If they come back, I might do a sleep study.

mushroomcup

So for anyone who's interested, I mentioned all this stuff to my mother today and she told me that if it was a B12 deficiency, it might have been exacerbated by my birth control pills. I hadn't realized, but apparently they can lower the absorption of B12 by your body?

I found an article (I don't know how credible it is, but it does have a list of references for anyone who likes fact-checking) which talks about B12 deficiency:

http://articles.mercola.com/sites/articles/archive/2009/05/19/warning-potentially-life-threatening-vitamin-deficiency-affects-25-percent-of-adults.aspx

One part of the article which may be related to my nightmare issue was the following:

Sleep Problems

If you have trouble sleeping, it could be due to a lack of melatonin in your system. If you’re a regular reader of my newsletter you know the importance I place on adequate good quality sleep for optimum health.

Melatonin is known as the “sleep hormone” and as you age, your body becomes less efficient at producing this chemical.

B12 plays a crucial role in melatonin production, which is another reason it is important to make sure you’re receiving an adequate amount of this vitamin into your blood.

...

Vitamin B12 deficiency has also been linked to psychiatric disorders, which are grouped into the following methods of expression:

Mood disturbances ... apathy, depression, eating abnormalities, and behavior disturbances which occur specifically at night
Hyperactivity ... agitation, euphoria, irritability, lack of inhibition, and motor disturbances
Psychosis ... hallucinations and delusions

geebusuk

Remember that just because it doesn't happen to YOU or people you know, doesn't mean it doesn't exist.

toddis

Around these parts mercola isn't in high regard. Might be around most parts but...

B12 tests are easy to have done at the doc as far as I know. See your family physician and get checked maybe, then try sleep studies?

AbbsyBabbsy

So for anyone who's interested, I mentioned all this stuff to my mother today and she told me that if it was a B12 deficiency, it might have been exacerbated by my birth control pills.

Did you by any chance go on the pills right around the time you started having these nightmares? The hormones in the pill started giving me very vivid dreams when I started on them. I really doubt it's the lack of meat or even b12, which is found in eggs and dairy so most veg aren't deficient anyway.

mushroomcup

So for anyone who's interested, I mentioned all this stuff to my mother today and she told me that if it was a B12 deficiency, it might have been exacerbated by my birth control pills.

Did you by any chance go on the pills right around the time you started having these nightmares? The hormones in the pill started giving me very vivid dreams when I started on them. I really doubt it's the lack of meat or even b12, which is found in eggs and dairy so most veg aren't deficient anyway.

I went on BC pills in 2007 and have been on them since. My nightmares started in 2009. Though, I'm still on the pills and no longer have the nightmares.

It could be that my diet would have been fine if not for the added effect of the pill blocking the absorption of B12. But then, that's assuming that a B12 deficiency was the underlying issue, which of course I'm not sure about.

mockchoc

About the only time I have nightmares is when I'm hot in bed.

albertabeefy

The only thing I would be aware of being deficient in a veggie diet is B12 (without supplementation). Deficiency in B12 does cause neural issues. I'm not sure it's directly related to nightmares though.

^ This is the only thing I can suggest. B12 deficiency can manifest in many ways, including anxiety/panic/nightmares but more commonly is associated with weakness, rapid pulse/breathing, pale skin, gastro-intestinal issues and others. If unchecked it progresses to the possible mood symptoms, affective disorders/anxiety/etc., and even dementia-like symptoms.

If you don't have a B12 deficiency (it's more common in veganism than vegetarianism, but either way can take 3 full years after adopting the diet to manifest) then it's likely unrelated to diet.

laurynwithawhy

OP you are not crazy! I am a pescatarian (was vegetarian for years also) and I find that if I am not eating well balanced diet I have trouble sleeping (not nightmares, but you'll see where I'm going in a minute). When I was in college getting my psych degree we studied the effects of serotonin on sleep, and basically if you don't have enough serotonin, you're gonna have a bad time. Your body produces serotonin naturally by synthesizing tryptophan. Tryptophan is very common in meat, and also common in non-meat foods but in lower doses. If you weren't eating enough of the right tryptophan containing foods, then you could have had low serotonin and that could have been the cause of your sleep issues. As the other posters have stated this is NOT an effect of vegetarianism, more like lack of a balanced diet.

You can find more info on foods with tryptophan here: http://www.3fatchicks.com/9-foods-with-tryptophan/. For more info on serotonin you can go here: http://www.livestrong.com/article/157020-serotonin-effects/.