Does anyone have any tips or advice on EATING CLEAN???

24

Replies

  • CoachReddy
    CoachReddy Posts: 3,949 Member
    The whole idea of a "clean" food makes no sense. Only calories and macros make any difference for weight loss/gain.

    The whole idea of clean eating is a fitness industry exercise in make-believe.

    Hopefully it'll go the way of other gems such as "fat makes you fat" and die a quick painless death.....

    nope. and nope.

    and if it makes no sense, you might wanna rethink your reasoning skills.

    eat nutritious whole foods instead of processed pre-packaged foods. yeah man that's crazy.

    I get that eating nutritious foods and exercise helps you lose weight. I want to accomplish more than that, I just want to be healthy and minimize all the pesticides, additives, preservatives, etc. They cannot be good for you! but thank you both for your advice :)))

    absolutely! it's great that you're deciding to make that change. your body will thank you in the long run. :)

    feel free to check my diary for some ideas - doing 4000 cals almost entirely clean.
  • auddii
    auddii Posts: 15,357 Member
    The whole idea of a "clean" food makes no sense. Only calories and macros make any difference for weight loss/gain.

    The whole idea of clean eating is a fitness industry exercise in make-believe.

    Hopefully it'll go the way of other gems such as "fat makes you fat" and die a quick painless death.....

    nope. and nope.

    and if it makes no sense, you might wanna rethink your reasoning skills.

    eat nutritious whole foods instead of processed pre-packaged foods. yeah man that's crazy.

    I get that eating nutritious foods and exercise helps you lose weight. I want to accomplish more than that, I just want to be healthy and minimize all the pesticides, additives, preservatives, etc. They cannot be good for you! but thank you both for your advice :)))

    I remember watching a show on the History channel (before they started only showing reality tv) about different kinds of mummies. Apparently there was a sect of monks somewhere in Asia who would eat small amounts of the herbs used to preserve bodies throughout their lives, and when they felt closer to death, they'd start eating them in larger quantities. Then when it was "time" they'd go to their resting place (it was actually a kind of pedestal thing), and start meditating. Low and behold, when they died, they were essentially already mummified and their bodies were preserved (granted their resting places were in a cool, dry cave, which also helps prevent degradation of the body).

    You sure you don't want to give that a try?! :laugh:
  • toaster6
    toaster6 Posts: 703 Member
    I am new to the whole eating clean idea. I get the concept of not eating processed foods and staying away from the whites (sugar, flour, & salt) but how do YOU do it? Any tips for a newbie? Thanks! =)

    Frankly that concept is silly, eat foods you like, create a deficit (if you're looking to lose weight), get in adequate protein and fats and try to eat mostly whole nutrient dense foods

    ^ If you're only goal is weight loss, that. But if you are set on clean eating for different reasons, I find that cooking your own meals from scratch and with fresh produce makes clean eating pretty easy. The more I cook, the less processed foods I consume and I don't have to even think about it.
  • WendyTerry420
    WendyTerry420 Posts: 13,274 Member
    Best thing I've read on eating clean....

    Quote from Layne Norton

    "I find the whole idea of ‘clean eating’ pretentious. What exactly defines a food as ‘clean’? Do you spray windex on it? Rub soap on it? I find it a bit preposterous. I’ve been in debates with people promoting ‘clean eating’ but when I ask for a specific scientific definition of what makes a food ‘clean’ they are silent. I think the restrictive diets where you can only eat a half dozen or so foods are not only unhealthy because they don’t give you a diverse intake of nutrients but I believe they promote eating disorders and binging. I see people who ‘eat clean’ during most of the week and then binge on cheesecake, ice cream, and donuts because it’s a ‘cheat’ meal. Oh yea… that is way healthier than eating ‘unclean’ foods in moderation to a hit a specific macronutrient target. *rolleyes* Now that said, I do believe that many IIFYMers (I find it funny that something myself and others been promoting for years gets an acronym attached to it and is now this ‘new’ way of eating LOL) actually go too far in one direction. Most people who origionally promoted targeting macronutrient intakes instead of obsessing about food choices actually eat ‘clean’ foods 95% of the time, we just don’t agonize over having a homemade burrito with a low carb wrap or some reduced calorie ice cream. We see the value of a controlled intake in order to prevent uncontrolled binging. But I do see IIFYM followers who eat as much sugary, high fat foods as they can and wear it like a badge of honor. That is not the point. If you are following a macronutrient intake that is friendly for body composition you will be eating a lot of ‘clean’ foods by default because you will not be able to hit a protein, carb, fat, and fiber intake conducive to body composition improvement if all you eat are high sugar/fat foods. The point is it’s ok to have these foods in small amounts if you are still hitting your goal macronutrient intake."

    http://www.shreddedknowledge.com/home/a-talk-with-the-doc-dr-layne-norton/

    ^^^ Awesome! :drinker: :heart:
  • CoachReddy
    CoachReddy Posts: 3,949 Member
    Best thing I've read on eating clean....

    Quote from Layne Norton

    "I find the whole idea of ‘clean eating’ pretentious. What exactly defines a food as ‘clean’? Do you spray windex on it? Rub soap on it? I find it a bit preposterous. I’ve been in debates with people promoting ‘clean eating’ but when I ask for a specific scientific definition of what makes a food ‘clean’ they are silent. I think the restrictive diets where you can only eat a half dozen or so foods are not only unhealthy because they don’t give you a diverse intake of nutrients but I believe they promote eating disorders and binging. I see people who ‘eat clean’ during most of the week and then binge on cheesecake, ice cream, and donuts because it’s a ‘cheat’ meal. Oh yea… that is way healthier than eating ‘unclean’ foods in moderation to a hit a specific macronutrient target. *rolleyes* Now that said, I do believe that many IIFYMers (I find it funny that something myself and others been promoting for years gets an acronym attached to it and is now this ‘new’ way of eating LOL) actually go too far in one direction. Most people who origionally promoted targeting macronutrient intakes instead of obsessing about food choices actually eat ‘clean’ foods 95% of the time, we just don’t agonize over having a homemade burrito with a low carb wrap or some reduced calorie ice cream. We see the value of a controlled intake in order to prevent uncontrolled binging. But I do see IIFYM followers who eat as much sugary, high fat foods as they can and wear it like a badge of honor. That is not the point. If you are following a macronutrient intake that is friendly for body composition you will be eating a lot of ‘clean’ foods by default because you will not be able to hit a protein, carb, fat, and fiber intake conducive to body composition improvement if all you eat are high sugar/fat foods. The point is it’s ok to have these foods in small amounts if you are still hitting your goal macronutrient intake."

    http://www.shreddedknowledge.com/home/a-talk-with-the-doc-dr-layne-norton/

    ^^^ Awesome! :drinker: :heart:

    I agree with that whole-heartedly as well.
  • dewsmom78
    dewsmom78 Posts: 498 Member
    Buffalo, elk, venison, all wonderful lean red meats - I rarely eat beef. :happy:
  • Confuzzled4ever
    Confuzzled4ever Posts: 2,860 Member
    Tips and advice::
    Learn to cook - you can always add veggies to almost any recipe to make it healthier, less caloies and more filling. (and usually more visually appeasing)

    Read labels/ingredient lists - shorter is better
    Look up what you don't know listed on the ingredient list. The whole "if you can't pronounce it" thing is over rated. If it end is "ose" it's sugar.

    Don't discount a food simply because it is white. (Regular sugar is better then artifical sweetners, even better is honey.)

    Don't be afraid to try new things.

    Farmers markets and co-ops are great way to get more veggies.. don't be afraid to ask them how the method they use at thier farm (ie do they practice organic farming?, what pesticides do they use etc.. if they won't answer buy from someone else)

    Just do it! Nothing worth it is easy.. remember this and don't give up!

    Someone at some point is going to tell you it's unnecessary or your missing out on something. I have just learned to smile and nod, more often then not those are the people who lack energy and are less healthy then I am. So while I bounce out of the gym ready for the rest of the day (lol i more like prance or bound really lol), they are still home trying to wake up. While I can hike all the way to the top of Cheyenne Canyon and do the Incline, they can't even fathom the first step. While they eat thier snickers or ice cream (that I am missing out on apparently) and then are still hungry, I eat double the amount my homemade chocolate banana frozen yogurt ice cream and feel full, happy and satiated. (sp?) and I've consumed less calories and fat then them.

    Clean eating has to do with nutrition and health moreso then weight loss. However, if you cut out or severly reduce added sugars, salts and checmicals, you are going to lose weight, provided you don't replace those things with other non-healthy items. You can get fat while eating clean. All you have to do is over do it there are plenty of organic/natural food items that are high calorie. ps.s Natural is not the same as organic.

    If your worried about pesticides you might want to look at the "monsanto protection law" just signed last week. Not looking for a debate here, just giving information. Eating certified organic is going to be the only way to avoid it soon.

    Remember, jars and cans usually have added chemicals and salt and lots of time you can get the same food fresh and chop it up yourself (esp veggies!!) and they will taste better. Time will be your greatest advasary with this. EVen sauerkraut is easy to make yourself.

    Oh yes.. and you don't have to eat 100% clean all the time. I don't worry about it in resturants.. Cause eating out is fun :)
  • jennaworksout
    jennaworksout Posts: 1,739 Member
    Best thing I've read on eating clean....

    Quote from Layne Norton

    "I find the whole idea of ‘clean eating’ pretentious. What exactly defines a food as ‘clean’? Do you spray windex on it? Rub soap on it? I find it a bit preposterous. I’ve been in debates with people promoting ‘clean eating’ but when I ask for a specific scientific definition of what makes a food ‘clean’ they are silent. I think the restrictive diets where you can only eat a half dozen or so foods are not only unhealthy because they don’t give you a diverse intake of nutrients but I believe they promote eating disorders and binging. I see people who ‘eat clean’ during most of the week and then binge on cheesecake, ice cream, and donuts because it’s a ‘cheat’ meal. Oh yea… that is way healthier than eating ‘unclean’ foods in moderation to a hit a specific macronutrient target. *rolleyes* Now that said, I do believe that many IIFYMers (I find it funny that something myself and others been promoting for years gets an acronym attached to it and is now this ‘new’ way of eating LOL) actually go too far in one direction. Most people who origionally promoted targeting macronutrient intakes instead of obsessing about food choices actually eat ‘clean’ foods 95% of the time, we just don’t agonize over having a homemade burrito with a low carb wrap or some reduced calorie ice cream. We see the value of a controlled intake in order to prevent uncontrolled binging. But I do see IIFYM followers who eat as much sugary, high fat foods as they can and wear it like a badge of honor. That is not the point. If you are following a macronutrient intake that is friendly for body composition you will be eating a lot of ‘clean’ foods by default because you will not be able to hit a protein, carb, fat, and fiber intake conducive to body composition improvement if all you eat are high sugar/fat foods. The point is it’s ok to have these foods in small amounts if you are still hitting your goal macronutrient intake."

    http://www.shreddedknowledge.com/home/a-talk-with-the-doc-dr-layne-norton/

    ^^^ Awesome! :drinker: :heart:

    I agree with that whole-heartedly as well.

    I thought clean eating , was "clean" of additives, chemicals, preservatives.etc... not "clean " like clean laundry lmao :laugh:
  • Clynnsky
    Clynnsky Posts: 2 Member
    I cook with salsa all the time!! I love salsa so much that I don't dread boring plain meals! A great meal that my fiance who is a picky eater and I both love is lean turkey meat cooked with a little salsa, a salad and a splash of salsa as the dressing! Crockpot chicken with low-sodium chicken broth and a little water with cabage carrots and green peppers is really good and easy too!! Once you start eating clean you'll find it's easier than you think!! You'll do great! Good luck!!
  • graceylou222
    graceylou222 Posts: 198 Member
    If it spoils, put it in. If it has a shelf life of anything more than a week, pass.



    bump! i need to remember this
  • holothuroidea
    holothuroidea Posts: 772 Member
    My staple foods, the foods I rely on every day, are whole foods. Rice, beans, fruits, veggies, nuts.

    I still eat processed food. Snacks maybe twice a day or so, but they're not my main source of nutrition.

    Unless you have or are at risk for medical conditions or nutrient deficiencies, there's really no legitimate health reason to eat "clean." And even then, you'd be avoiding specific things like sodium not something as vague as "dirty food."

    I see a lot of healthy people here that have ready-made foods for breakfast, lunch and dinner. They still loose weight, they're still fit.

    There are some pretty convincing ethical reasons to avoid foods that are the product of the agriculture industry, but this isn't the forum for those issues. :)
  • dym123
    dym123 Posts: 1,670 Member
    Actually I don't eat "clean" to lose weight, I was losing weight doing the whole calorie deficit thing before I decided to clean up my eating. Reading about all the chemicals and artificial things that are put into foods had me a little concerned and though I am not 100%, I can tell there is a definite change in my well-being, I have more energy, my skin cleared up and my pre-menopausal symptoms have subsided. I don't judge people who chose to eat whatever they want, so please don't feel you have the right to tell me what I am doing is "silly". I believe that the quality of calories are just as important, if not more important than quantity.

    There may not be science behind it, but I know for ME, I am better for it.
  • alexveksler
    alexveksler Posts: 409 Member
    I have been on a clean food diet for several week and found that best to do what others already said: bulk prepare your foods.

    I pre-wash and dry my base foods. I use deep part of my kitchen sink to mix all of my foods. You are welcome to see the list in my food diary, but most of them are high-density phytochemicals. I store it in large container and when ready to eat, only add "wet" foods (cucumbers, mushrooms, tomatoes, avocados, cilantro, parsley, and fruits)

    It takes me an hour to prepare my foods and I don't have to do anything for the next 5 days, but eat them.
  • katy_trail
    katy_trail Posts: 1,992 Member
    wash your produce and it will be clean.
  • JeneticTraining
    JeneticTraining Posts: 663 Member
    Well, I assume you mean eating whole foods. Invest in vegetables - frozen and fresh. Carrots, spinach, kale, broccoli, etc. Avoid highly processed foods - read the ingredients and nutrition facts. Take your time shopping - I tend to spend an hour comparing products. Do a lot of research. Prep your foods on Sundays or whichever day you have free. I love chocolate, I buy 80%+ cacao. I eat 1-2 pieces every other day - it satisfies me. I have more tips/advice if you'd like.
  • WendyTerry420
    WendyTerry420 Posts: 13,274 Member
    If it spoils, put it in. If it has a shelf life of anything more than a week, pass.

    So true!!!!

    Not true. That would mean that you can't eat anything that's been canned or frozen. You would be pretty nutrient-deprived in the winter doing that. Also, many people grow their own food and preserve them. There's absulutely nothing unhealthy about it. And what about buying meat in bulk and freezing it?
  • CoachReddy
    CoachReddy Posts: 3,949 Member
    If it spoils, put it in. If it has a shelf life of anything more than a week, pass.

    So true!!!!

    Not true. That would mean that you can't eat anything that's been canned or frozen. You would be pretty nutrient-deprived in the winter doing that. Also, many people grow their own food and preserve them. There's absulutely nothing unhealthy about it. And what about buying meat in bulk and freezing it?

    If you put frozen veggies on the shelf they will spoil.
  • jimmmer
    jimmmer Posts: 3,515 Member
    The whole idea of a "clean" food makes no sense. Only calories and macros make any difference for weight loss/gain.

    The whole idea of clean eating is a fitness industry exercise in make-believe.

    Hopefully it'll go the way of other gems such as "fat makes you fat" and die a quick painless death.....

    nope. and nope.

    and if it makes no sense, you might wanna rethink your reasoning skills.

    eat nutritious whole foods instead of processed pre-packaged foods. yeah man that's crazy.

    Alright tighten up the categories of 'clean' and 'unclean' for me. Show the properties of an item that it must/must not possess to be included in these categories. Then show me how these properties are intrinsically bad/good for me.

    Then you will have shown your reasoning to me. Perhaps you will help me to 'make sense' of it....

    As others have pointed out, humans have been making preserves, pickles, Chutneys, smoked meats, cured meats, cheeses, curds, etc, etc...... these are all processes carried out on raw materials. These foods are all 'processed' in some manner to allow them to be stored for lean times and cold seasons.

    If your food colourant or preservative in a pre-packaged item is derrived from a beetle's shell or rainforrest plant is it more 'natural' and acceptable than then same substance made in a lab which has the same chemical composition?

    I think you'll find my reasoning skills capable of picking apart nebulous and foggy concepts, thank you very much.......
  • RunHardBeStrong
    RunHardBeStrong Posts: 33,069 Member
    Thanks for all the great advice!!! A couple more questions...
    What do you think about red meats?
    Frozen Veggies?

    I use them all the time. Most frozen veggies actually have more nutrients than fresh. I don't get too hung up on it. Just try to keep boxed/processed items to a minimum.
  • I'm hoping the notion that "only carlories and macros matter" dies a quick and painless death.

    I certainly agree that for most Americans, weight loss should be their number one priority in terms of improving their health. To do that, calories and macros are key.

    For people whose dietary amibitions have graduated from weight loss to overall health, there's certainly a lot more to it than calories and macros. You can hit your calorie / macro goals by eating turkey and cheese sandwiches all day every day, but vital nutrients required to fight infection, improve immune function, sustain brain function, improve bone density, fight chronic illness, improve digestion, and much more would be seriously lacking.

    It's analogous to learning to play a sport. Start with the basics: passing, catching, blocking, basic play mechanics. Once you've reached a certain level of comfort and competence, if you want to be great, you add-in some of the advanced skills (without forgetting the basics).
  • zillah73
    zillah73 Posts: 505 Member
    bump
  • AnJulNZ
    AnJulNZ Posts: 186 Member
    I avoid overly processed food where possible. The purpose of food is to fuel my body, not to fill it up with chemicals and additives and who knows what else. I don't look at it as eating clean, I look at it as eating healthy. I don't want my kids filling up on artificial crap.

    I'm really lucky because we have a huge vege garden, and the long hot summer we have just had made it go crazy - our freezer is packed chockablock of veges. We also have our own chooks, so a ready supply of delicious 100% free range eggs. It also saves a lot of money at the supermarket. We try to shop at the local farmers market for meat, and we find it tastes so much better than what you get at the supermarket (seems to be less fatty as well). I also cook all of our meals at home. We go out for dinner or lunch once in a while, but not often.

    I tend to not buy biscuits/cake/etc, because I love to bake so there is always a ready supply of goodies in the pantry (I think this is my biggest downfall because I love to eat it too).

    In saying all of this, I do still buy stuff from the middle of the supermarket which has been processed but I try to be careful with reading the label.
  • CoachReddy
    CoachReddy Posts: 3,949 Member
    I'm hoping the notion that "only carlories and macros matter" dies a quick and painless death.

    I certainly agree that for most Americans, weight loss should be their number one priority in terms of improving their health. To do that, calories and macros are key.

    For people whose dietary amibitions have graduated from weight loss to overall health, there's certainly a lot more to it than calories and macros. You can hit your calorie / macro goals by eating turkey and cheese sandwiches all day every day, but vital nutrients required to fight infection, improve immune function, sustain brain function, improve bone density, fight chronic illness, improve digestion, and much more would be seriously lacking.

    It's analogous to learning to play a sport. Start with the basics: passing, catching, blocking, basic play mechanics. Once you've reached a certain level of comfort and competence, if you want to be great, you add-in some of the advanced skills (without forgetting the basics).

    :drinker: this. So much.
  • endoftheside
    endoftheside Posts: 568 Member
    I try to build my meals around protein and low-carb veggies. When I do this, the quality of my meals increases dramatically. Instead of making nachos based around massive quantities of chips, I would make spicy grass-fed ground beef with a large salad and guacamole, and maybe crunch a few chips on top. Instead of mounds of spaghetti, mounds of spaghetti squash. It's letting the nutritious stuff in, so it naturally crowds out the junk to a certain extent (not completely, I decided when I started this that nothing is absolutely off limits because that just makes me crave-zy :tongue: ). For ease, batch cooking and the crock pot are the most-used tools I have, that and easy meaty salads.
  • jimmmer
    jimmmer Posts: 3,515 Member
    I'm hoping the notion that "only carlories and macros matter" dies a quick and painless death.

    I certainly agree that for most Americans, weight loss should be their number one priority in terms of improving their health. To do that, calories and macros are key.

    For people whose dietary amibitions have graduated from weight loss to overall health, there's certainly a lot more to it than calories and macros. You can hit your calorie / macro goals by eating turkey and cheese sandwiches all day every day, but vital nutrients required to fight infection, improve immune function, sustain brain function, improve bone density, fight chronic illness, improve digestion, and much more would be seriously lacking.

    It's analogous to learning to play a sport. Start with the basics: passing, catching, blocking, basic play mechanics. Once you've reached a certain level of comfort and competence, if you want to be great, you add-in some of the advanced skills (without forgetting the basics).

    :drinker: this. So much.

    But the micros you are talking about can be had from processed foods too. I'm not saying don't get your daily allowance of vitamins and minerals, just that if you got them all from processed foods your body wouldn't know the difference. You're imbibing chemicals with good or bad properties based on what foodstuff they came out of. Calcium from ice cream is the same as calcium from a vitamin tablet or a slice of Cheddar. Your body can't tell the difference because every calcium atom is identical on a sub-atomic level regardless of it's source.

    Plus, still waiting for a response about my reasoning skills......
  • CoachReddy
    CoachReddy Posts: 3,949 Member
    I'm hoping the notion that "only carlories and macros matter" dies a quick and painless death.

    I certainly agree that for most Americans, weight loss should be their number one priority in terms of improving their health. To do that, calories and macros are key.

    For people whose dietary amibitions have graduated from weight loss to overall health, there's certainly a lot more to it than calories and macros. You can hit your calorie / macro goals by eating turkey and cheese sandwiches all day every day, but vital nutrients required to fight infection, improve immune function, sustain brain function, improve bone density, fight chronic illness, improve digestion, and much more would be seriously lacking.

    It's analogous to learning to play a sport. Start with the basics: passing, catching, blocking, basic play mechanics. Once you've reached a certain level of comfort and competence, if you want to be great, you add-in some of the advanced skills (without forgetting the basics).

    :drinker: this. So much.

    But the micros you are talking about can be had from processed foods too. I'm not saying don't get your daily allowance of vitamins and minerals, just that if you got them all from processed foods your body wouldn't know the difference. You're imbibing chemicals with good or bad properties based on what foodstuff they came out of. Calcium from ice cream is the same as calcium from a vitamin tablet or a slice of Cheddar. Your body can't tell the difference because every calcium atom is identical on a sub-atomic level regardless of it's source.

    Plus, still waiting for a response about my reasoning skills......

    I know, and ill oblige when im no longer on a tablet. Hard to type longwinded explanations. ;)
  • Feisty_Red
    Feisty_Red Posts: 982 Member
    I always shower while eating..
  • Jxnsmma
    Jxnsmma Posts: 919 Member
    Alright tighten up the categories of 'clean' and 'unclean' for me. Show the properties of an item that it must/must not possess to be included in these categories. Then show me how these properties are intrinsically bad/good for me.

    Then you will have shown your reasoning to me. Perhaps you will help me to 'make sense' of it....

    As others have pointed out, humans have been making preserves, pickles, Chutneys, smoked meats, cured meats, cheeses, curds, etc, etc...... these are all processes carried out on raw materials. These foods are all 'processed' in some manner to allow them to be stored for lean times and cold seasons.

    If your food colourant or preservative in a pre-packaged item is derrived from a beetle's shell or rainforrest plant is it more 'natural' and acceptable than then same substance made in a lab which has the same chemical composition?

    I think you'll find my reasoning skills capable of picking apart nebulous and foggy concepts, thank you very much.......

    If you and I ever end up trapped together on a desert island with 100 cases of kraft dinner and an unlimited supply of fresh meats, fruits and vegetables, you can have my share of the kraft dinner and we'll see in a year who has what vitamin and mineral deficiencies and who still has all their teeth.....
    :flowerforyou:
  • holothuroidea
    holothuroidea Posts: 772 Member
    Alright tighten up the categories of 'clean' and 'unclean' for me. Show the properties of an item that it must/must not possess to be included in these categories. Then show me how these properties are intrinsically bad/good for me.

    Then you will have shown your reasoning to me. Perhaps you will help me to 'make sense' of it....

    As others have pointed out, humans have been making preserves, pickles, Chutneys, smoked meats, cured meats, cheeses, curds, etc, etc...... these are all processes carried out on raw materials. These foods are all 'processed' in some manner to allow them to be stored for lean times and cold seasons.

    If your food colourant or preservative in a pre-packaged item is derrived from a beetle's shell or rainforrest plant is it more 'natural' and acceptable than then same substance made in a lab which has the same chemical composition?

    I think you'll find my reasoning skills capable of picking apart nebulous and foggy concepts, thank you very much.......

    If you and I ever end up trapped together on a desert island with 100 cases of kraft dinner and an unlimited supply of fresh meats, fruits and vegetables, you can have my share of the kraft dinner and we'll see in a year who has what vitamin and mineral deficiencies and who still has all their teeth.....
    :flowerforyou:

    Nope. You gave the choice of one food versus a variety of food. Your analogy doesn't work.

    If you gave me the option of only lean meat vs. only mac and cheese, I'd choose the mac and cheese and live longer than you.
  • jimmmer
    jimmmer Posts: 3,515 Member
    Alright tighten up the categories of 'clean' and 'unclean' for me. Show the properties of an item that it must/must not possess to be included in these categories. Then show me how these properties are intrinsically bad/good for me.

    Then you will have shown your reasoning to me. Perhaps you will help me to 'make sense' of it....

    As others have pointed out, humans have been making preserves, pickles, Chutneys, smoked meats, cured meats, cheeses, curds, etc, etc...... these are all processes carried out on raw materials. These foods are all 'processed' in some manner to allow them to be stored for lean times and cold seasons.

    If your food colourant or preservative in a pre-packaged item is derrived from a beetle's shell or rainforrest plant is it more 'natural' and acceptable than then same substance made in a lab which has the same chemical composition?

    I think you'll find my reasoning skills capable of picking apart nebulous and foggy concepts, thank you very much.......

    If you and I ever end up trapped together on a desert island with 100 cases of kraft dinner and an unlimited supply of fresh meats, fruits and vegetables, you can have my share of the kraft dinner and we'll see in a year who has what vitamin and mineral deficiencies and who still has all their teeth.....
    :flowerforyou:

    Does the Kraft dinner selection have the same amounts of macros/micros/calories as the food supply you're eating? If it does, then you will/will not suffer the same deficiencies as me. If not then it's not really a comparison.....