So apparently I'm a failure????
Replies
-
You rock!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!We set out this last week to do the greenbrier river trail... About 160 miles in five days... Myself and the kids and two friends...
.. Decided to stop ten miles from the end (saving us twenty miles round trip) and did 140...
Slept out four nights...
Rain one of them forcing us to seek shelter in a gazebo instead of sleeping in our hammocksutt
I decided to cut it short
. We didn't finish the trail and I have never seen the last ten miles of it..
You spent 5 days 4 nights with the kids.
Rained during the trip but finished it anyway.
Biked 140 miles.
You" Decided" to cut 20 miles out of the center of the ride. Made a judgment call based on a realistic assessment of physical ability and real life circumstances. While supervising children in a wilderness setting.
Sounds like a great weekend. Wish I could say I did anything that even comes close to this in the year.0 -
For this story you did fail. You were supposed to do 160, but you didn't. You did 140, which is great and really close to your goal, but its not 160, so I'm going to side with your friend on this.0
-
YOU are NOT a failure.
I would call that endeavor a failed attempt at completion though. But then I think walking during a run is failure too... for me.0 -
Who says you were 'supposed to' do the whole 160 miles? You did what you could and what an accomplishment it was! You did not fail, you succeeded marvelously! You need to find a new friend who is more supportive of your journey... IPOU!0
-
DUMP0
-
As far as I am concerned neither of you failed. You biked a great distance and improved yourself while you were at it. I am not sure I could do that bike ride.
For him it may feel as if he failed but that just tells me they need to change their way of thinking. Are you going to fill that glass up or empty it. I choose to fill it and I hope the people closest to me will do that as well.
Bravo for having a good trip.0 -
Please read what I am going to say...
Yes, you are a failure. you set out a goal and you failed to complete that goal.
A failure is defined as an act or instance of failing or proving unsuccessful; lack of success: "His effort ended in failure. The campaign was a failure." (Dictionary.com)
Now, the key to understand all this is the power that you appear to give this word. There is nothing wrong with being a failure, maybe your friend is not exactly the most socially sensitive person (as I have been known not to be) but hear me out.
Yes, you are a failure. Many people fail before they succeed in almost every thing they do. I failed to lose weight this week, I am a failure but guess what? I learned from it, I reevaluated my goals and set new ones and am working to be successful and not a failure. To fail at something is to learn from that something, you learned a lot from this experience so while you technically did fail, you learned from this experience and will contribute this failure to the next time you attempt this goal.
I am sorry but I just dislike this pandering attitude that every one has... "Oh you are not a failure, you accomplished so much !" It is a matter of context and quite frankly you failed, but while that is true it is also very true that you did in fact learn from this failure and either A. will be successful next time or B. Reevaluate your goal and push on.
I would rather be called a failure any day of the week rather than a quitter, a failure has an opportunity to do better next time to get on the horse, a quitter has thrown in the towel and refused to fix their errors.
Living life without being a failure would be pretty boring, imagine how drab life would be to walk around and constantly be perfect !
Get over the word, you failed but the important thing is you did not quit, the only permanent failure is the quitter. Failure is temporary, success is permanent.0 -
Some of the biggest successes in life look like failures on the outside. Did you finish the course? No. Did you make it farther than ever before? Yes! Are you psyched to do it again? Yes! Are you the same person you used to be? No!
So, are you a failure? If we total it up, it is 2 yes & 2 no... I will leave the decision up to you
0 -
We set out this last week to do the greenbrier river trail... About 160 miles in five days... Myself and the kids and two friends...
We didn't make it... Decided to stop ten miles from the end (saving us twenty miles round trip) and did 140... Slept out four nights... Rain one of them forcing us to seek shelter in a gazebo instead of sleeping in our hammocks (pain in the back as it were) butt blister (almost made me stop and hitchhike back to the car at mile forty...)
I decided to cut it short mainly because I have to work tomorrow and I don't want to be dead... I'm already very sore... I'm not sure how the extra twenty miles would have done me...
So my friend says we failed because we didn't "finish" what we set out to do... We didn't finish the trail and I have never seen the last ten miles of it... (we have section biked it before)
I say I am not a failure because I DOUBLED my previous longest bike... I didn't once say "I can't do this it's too hard lets go home I'm finished" (although he claims my cutting it short was saying that)... I say I'm not a failure because I don't know many people who can do 140 miles let alone people my age and weight (I'm still 270#)...
So am I a failure? Is this a guy thing I don't understand? My friend has this thing about "completing" things that feels almost neurotic to me...
You went on with a blister on your butt. Tell your friend to kiss it.0 -
The only person that is a failure is the one who never tries!
You mapped out a goal , you tried and you made it 95% of the way on your first attempt at that distance ! I'd say that's damn good! Next time you'll be wiser ,stronger and will make it the rest of the way ! Life is about practice ! It's not supposed to be perfect the first and every time we try ...yay for you ! You have accomplished something Ive only thought about trying and with 50# more to carry ! I'm actually a little envious that you've done it and I haven't ! ( I just read WILD) keep it up and don't listen to your friend !0 -
The important thing in this story is why your friend said that. If they said it to be rude or to put them above you then they owe you an apology. If they came across as just trying to convince you how important it is to finish what you started and truly care then drop them at your loss.0
-
We set out this last week to do the greenbrier river trail...
So my friend says we failed because we didn't "finish" what we set out to do... We didn't finish the trail and I have never seen the last ten miles of it... (we have section biked it before)
I say I am not a failure because I DOUBLED my previous longest bike... I didn't once say "I can't do this it's too hard lets go home I'm finished" (although he claims my cutting it short was saying that)... I say I'm not a failure because I don't know many people who can do 140 miles let alone people my age and weight (I'm still 270#)...
So am I a failure? Is this a guy thing I don't understand? My friend has this thing about "completing" things that feels almost neurotic to me...
If I'm reading this right, your friend said you (plural) failed to reach your goal. YOU are the one calling yourself "a failure" (or questioning if you are one).
I'd say your friend is correct, technically--you failed to reach the original goal. But you are incorrect--because you're personalizing the fact in a negative way. You're summing yourself up (rather broadly and negatively) by what you DO, not by who you ARE. You are never "a failure" for failing to reach a goal. Goodness, if that were correct, we'd have to call all those Olympians who come home with less than a gold medal "FAILURES."
(ETA: just read gradrun's comment, and thought I ought to add that I'm not male...) 0 -
You are not a failure...know you have a goal to set for the next time to maybe do 5 more miles...then the next trip past that finish those last 5 miles to make it all the way. Good luck and keep at it0
-
Girl, be proud of the 140 miles you did accomplish! I once thought I might die doing an hour of spinning. lol. I can't imagine doing 140 miles, especially with the extra weight. That's an awesome accomplishment...don't let your friend or anyone else on this thread take that from you...and don't take it from yourself. Pat yourself on the back-you deserve it!0
-
Get another friend. That one is bogus.
ETA: All accomplishments are successes. You fail when you don't try.
^^ Said it perfectly. Calling it a failure is pretty harsh and 140 miles is quite the feat. Tell him it was a success for you and maybe stop being such a Negative Ned 0 -
Get another friend. That one is bogus.
No need to drop her friend or get another to replace him. (He was only expressing that they failed to meet their goal.) She needs to instead get another attitude--because one that transforms 'I failed to meet the goal' into "I AM A FAILURE" is bogus.0 -
I would tell your 'friend' to piss off.0
-
The only failure is the one who never tries.
You may have failed to complete the task at hand...........but that does not make YOU a failure0 -
You had a successful through bike (I know of through hikes, you're on a bike, I trust this is the right way of saying it) of a few to several days with family and perhaps some other people you love. (the blame for not adjusting by 60 minutes either way to avoid the rain is laughable on a through hike/bike, by the way and indicates that that guy doesn't know what he's talking about).
In hiking, you say, "I have these days off of work. I'm going to this area. Here's my map. This is how far I can go in optimal conditions. This is where I can ditch the plans if I have a gear problem/weather doesn't cooperate/a bear gets my food pack/someone gets injured/someone gets ill/ran out of water because it was hotter than we thought or I dropped the bottle down the waterfall(I've done that while rappelling down the waterfall)/we figured out the terrain was harder than we thought and we realized we can't be sure we can safely complete the plans". I imagine it is the same four your through bike.
This tells me that you were wildly successful at not being the *kitten* that thinks because he spend $1000 at REI he can go anywhere and do anything even if he's never done anything remotely like that before and ends up needing a wildland rescue. I've never been injured skiing. Nor have any of my family. Mostly because my dad taught me, "stop before your last run. Its when you take the 'one last run' that you are too tired, make mistakes, don't have the best conditions, and get hurt"
Sounds to me like you had a wildly successful trip. 140 with no err minimal problems WAYY beats 160 with injuries and a rescue and a ride to the ER in a helicopter or something.0 -
I think your friend failed, not you, the fact that you tried is a sucess story on its own, shame on your friend0
-
The fact that you were able to do more than you were able to before means that you have more than succeeded. Instead of your friend saying that you failed, they should say that next time you do it you will get even farther. Try and try again and you will reach the end. I've never tried such a feat, so therefore I never failed. According to your friend I guess I'm a huge success, which is nonsense. Stay positive. :flowerforyou:0
-
"Nobody can make you feel inferior without your permission"
Eleanor Roosevelt0 -
Anyone who hikes 140 miles in 5 days is SO FAR FROM BEING A FAILURE!!!! Just because you didn't finish it doesn't make you a failure, it simply means you didn't finish. Forget what your friend said and focus on what you did accomplish.0
-
You are only a failure if you let someone else make you believe that you are.
I'M IN LOVE WITH THIS!0 -
Did you fail to complete the trail?
Yes.
Does that make you a failure?
Up to you!0 -
Get another friend. That one is bogus.
ETA: All accomplishments are successes. You fail when you don't try.
I agree with this poster -- and I'm wanting to join you~! lol0 -
you didn't fail. no, you didn't complete your goal due to some circumstances, but you still accomplished a lot and should be happy.
sometimes a goal is set high, and while we may not reach it on the first try, we can come amazingly close, and give us some gusto for the next time.
Well said! You did great, and you'll complete it next time. Put this one in the win column!0 -
...congratulations on your success! Don't let your friend make you feel like you didn't accomplish something great. People are so different, you are obviously logical and have plenty of common sense. I'm guessing your friend has something along a type A personality...more competitive and work-driven. I have a friend that I walk with, and when we reach the end of our usual route...she has to touch the stop sign, or else it would drive her crazy for the rest of the day. Another example is a long-time family friend that was visiting from Canada...he, his wife and I walked the bridgeway over the Hudson and she and I were looking forward to lunch and were hungry, so we turned around about 200 feet from the end. He said he was okay with it and he teased us for the rest of the day ....but guess what?...the next time they came for a few days, he wanted to do it again and made it a point to go right to the end...it had bothered him all that time that we didn't do the last little bit! (I couldn't have cared less...)0
-
I wanted to reply to everyone... but that would take me hours!!!If I'm reading this right, your friend said you (plural) failed to reach your goal. YOU are the one calling yourself "a failure" (or questioning if you are one).
I'd say your friend is correct, technically--you failed to reach the original goal. But you are incorrect--because you're personalizing the fact in a negative way. You're summing yourself up (rather broadly and negatively) by what you DO, not by who you ARE. You are never "a failure" for failing to reach a goal. Goodness, if that were correct, we'd have to call all those Olympians who come home with less than a gold medal "FAILURES."
(ETA: just read gradrun's comment, and thought I ought to add that I'm not male...)
he did say "we" failed... because of not finishing the bike trailNo need to drop her friend or get another to replace him. (He was only expressing that they failed to meet their goal.) She needs to instead get another attitude--because one that transforms 'I failed to meet the goal' into "I AM A FAILURE" is bogus.
I do have a problem with internalizing things... I am my own worst critic... I have gotten MUCH better... in years past comments like his would have sent me into a fit of depression beating myself up and bingeing on food because I "failed" and I would beat myself up and try to sabotage myself... I would have cried and been miserable for weeks because of a comment like that...
I have gotten to the point where I am not...
I am very proud of myself for how far we went... I think I kicked some serious butt... and I *know* that I can finish the trail... I intend to go again (maybe before the end of this year... when it is cooler ) and maybe with a better seat (I now understand why people pay hundreds of dollars for a bike seat)...
mainly my intent for this post was trying to understand why my friend thinks this trip was a failure... and I understand that from his POV it was... and I am ok with that...
and I need to get over this transition from "we failed" (by which he meant "we didn't accomplish our goal") to "we are failures" (by which I mean "*I* am a failure and worthless and nothing I ever did is worth anything") that kind of thinking is what got me to where I was... and I spent over a year living on my couch in depression because I beat myself (mentally) into a bloody pulp...0 -
I wanted to reply to everyone... but that would take me hours!!!If I'm reading this right, your friend said you (plural) failed to reach your goal. YOU are the one calling yourself "a failure" (or questioning if you are one).
I'd say your friend is correct, technically--you failed to reach the original goal. But you are incorrect--because you're personalizing the fact in a negative way. You're summing yourself up (rather broadly and negatively) by what you DO, not by who you ARE. You are never "a failure" for failing to reach a goal. Goodness, if that were correct, we'd have to call all those Olympians who come home with less than a gold medal "FAILURES."
(ETA: just read gradrun's comment, and thought I ought to add that I'm not male...)
he did say "we" failed... because of not finishing the bike trailNo need to drop her friend or get another to replace him. (He was only expressing that they failed to meet their goal.) She needs to instead get another attitude--because one that transforms 'I failed to meet the goal' into "I AM A FAILURE" is bogus.
I do have a problem with internalizing things... I am my own worst critic... I have gotten MUCH better...
...
mainly my intent for this post was trying to understand why my friend thinks this trip was a failure... and I understand that from his POV it was... and I am ok with that...
and I need to get over this transition from "we failed" (by which he meant "we didn't accomplish our goal") to "we are failures" (by which I mean "*I* am a failure and worthless and nothing I ever did is worth anything") that kind of thinking is what got me to where I was... and I spent over a year living on my couch in depression because I beat myself (mentally) into a bloody pulp...
Sounds like you're well on your way, gal. Keep up with the logical and true self-talk, and firmly resist the internalizing like you resist the foods that would sabotage your diet goals. It'll save you thousands in therapy bills. (Take it from one who battled and beat a serious depression 12 years ago.)0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions
Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!