The Ketosis Diet - Any opinions?
Caseyann2501
Posts: 43 Member
I've recently heard about the ketosis diet (a friend of a friend's apparently lost 30 lbs on it in 4 months).
The basic idea is that you cut out almost all carbs (50gram daily allowance maximum) and focus on protein and good fats. This is supposed to put your body into a state of ketosis, where your body stops burning carbs for energy (because there is none) and starts burning fat while not reducing muscle at all.
Has anybody been on this diet, or know anyone who has been on it? If you have, please give your experiences on it:
Did it work for you?
Were you able to exercise while on it?
I am thinking of trying it out and I am curious to hear from someone who has first hand knowledge
The basic idea is that you cut out almost all carbs (50gram daily allowance maximum) and focus on protein and good fats. This is supposed to put your body into a state of ketosis, where your body stops burning carbs for energy (because there is none) and starts burning fat while not reducing muscle at all.
Has anybody been on this diet, or know anyone who has been on it? If you have, please give your experiences on it:
Did it work for you?
Were you able to exercise while on it?
I am thinking of trying it out and I am curious to hear from someone who has first hand knowledge
0
Replies
-
I don't think this is a very good idea if you plan on exercising.
I have never tried it myself, so I can't speak from experience or anything, but if you plan on doing this I think you should be really careful! At the first sign of anything negative, take a step back. And good luck.
Whatever works for you is what you should do.0 -
I have lost a lot of weight, but find my weight stalls if my carbs creep up. I find 100 carbs to 120 is fine. Don't think you necessarily need to go to 50 or less. Try around 100. More balanced and if it works you haven't had to go too extreme. I I'm also zigzagging between 1300 to 1500 calories, with one day at 1600. I shoot for 120g protein. 4.1lbs gone just in the last 3 days. Know this will be lot if water but I'm always successful when I stick around this ball park. The good luck x0
-
First hand experience here, it's pretty easy to stay on because you feel full. But don't get into the habit of not eating vegetables. You'll also want to read all labels, stay away from trans fats.
Fats from meat aren't necessarily bad, they help with raising HDL and lowering LDL, given that you eat them in moderation. I'm sure there are a ton of keto-ers here that could help explain it in more depth and along with working out.0 -
The ketosis diet puts the body in an acidic state. Acidic states not only take the body out of it's natural balance, they have been linked to inflammation and cancer. I would not recommend it as a long term option.0
-
Also I'm fine working out at this level... And I work out hard!!! X0
-
Been doing keto since May! It's working! I was too lazy to exercise for most of it, but I thought I'd try to do C25K and it's been lots of fun!
Lots of good advice in this thread already for OP. Eat veggies, drink water, and try to stay away from processed foods (like Atkins bars...*shudder*)... just like any other healthy dietary change!
Best of luck, and if you need a keto buddy, feel free to add me!0 -
It doesnt provide better results long term than just eating a basic calorie deficit. Just eat a high protein, moderate carb and fat diet.0
-
Morbidly obese friend of mine was on this diet recently. He sung its praises and did appear to be losing a lot of weight. However, he ended up in intensive care with heart and lung failure (came close to dying), which the doctors attributed to his diet. He is now out of hospital and is no longer following this "diet".
Read up on it yourself (via proper websites and not "health websites") and decide for yourself if you think its a good idea. On this website you will get a lot of differing opinions from people, most of whom have no qualifications or in depth knowledge of the subject (myself included). Also, speak to your doctor... those people actually ARE experts on the human body.0 -
Lighter Life focus on this.....as a result there have been people who have had to have gall bladders removed due to following it. I think I'd steer clear.....0
-
Read up on it yourself (via proper websites and not "health websites") and decide for yourself if you think its a good idea. On this website you will get a lot of differing opinions from people, most of whom have no qualifications or in depth knowledge of the subject (myself included). Also, speak to your doctor... those people actually ARE experts on the human body.
^This^ If you're diabetic or have thyroid issues, keto (and the quick initial weight drop that sometimes comes along with it) can exacerbate underlying health issues. Always make sure you run it by him/her, that way you can also get initial blood work to see how well it improves if he/she gives you the OK to start your new lifestyle.0 -
The ketosis diet puts the body in an acidic state. Acidic states not only take the body out of it's natural balance, they have been linked to inflammation and cancer. I would not recommend it as a long term option.
Not entirely true. There's ketosis and there's ketoacidosis (this is dangerous).0 -
Read up on it yourself (via proper websites and not "health websites") and decide for yourself if you think its a good idea. On this website you will get a lot of differing opinions from people, most of whom have no qualifications or in depth knowledge of the subject (myself included). Also, speak to your doctor... those people actually ARE experts on the human body.
^This^ If you're diabetic or have thyroid issues, keto (and the quick initial weight drop that sometimes comes along with it) can exacerbate underlying health issues. Always make sure you run it by him/her, that way you can also get initial blood work to see how well it improves if he/she gives you the OK to start your new lifestyle.
I'd recommend talking to a nutritionist and a doctor.
However, there are peer reviewed medical journals concerning the issue with low carbohydrate diets and patients who are type 2 diabetics. It is a viable option for dieting, as it can result in better glycemic control.0 -
Also known as the Atkins diet. And "tricking" your body into losing weight is never a good way to lose weight and keep it off. Unfortunately, I know this from experience. If you want to eat low carb, then set your own personal goals on MFP, and keep the carb goal low.
Ask yourself: Do you want to lose weight or do you want to be healthy? Because being healthy is about balance. And tricking your body isn't balanced.
And talk to your doctor, as previously suggested.0 -
Read up on it yourself (via proper websites and not "health websites") and decide for yourself if you think its a good idea. On this website you will get a lot of differing opinions from people, most of whom have no qualifications or in depth knowledge of the subject (myself included). Also, speak to your doctor... those people actually ARE experts on the human body.
^This^ If you're diabetic or have thyroid issues, keto (and the quick initial weight drop that sometimes comes along with it) can exacerbate underlying health issues. Always make sure you run it by him/her, that way you can also get initial blood work to see how well it improves if he/she gives you the OK to start your new lifestyle.
I'd recommend talking to a nutritionist and a doctor.
However, there are peer reviewed medical journals concerning the issue with low carbohydrate diets and patients who are type 2 diabetics. It is a viable option for dieting, as it can result in better glycemic control.
Yup! There are lots of stories of how those with type 2 are doing so well on a ketogenic diet. It may not completely reverse it, but it can help immensely!
ETA:
And another thing, OP. It may not work for you. Give it a few weeks, though. It took me two to get in my stride and then make the decision to stay or try something else.
If it works, fantastic! If it doesn't, I wish you the best of luck in finding something that does.0 -
Also known as the Atkins diet. And "tricking" your body into losing weight is never a good way to lose weight and keep it off. Unfortunately, I know this from experience. If you want to eat low carb, then set your own personal goals on MFP, and keep the carb goal low.
Ask yourself: Do you want to lose weight or do you want to be healthy? Because being healthy is about balance. And tricking your body isn't balanced.
And talk to your doctor, as previously suggested.
No, sorry, this is not entirely correct.
It is NOT the Atkin's diet, it is similar, but it is NOT the Atkin's diet. Keto is based on proportions of eating more fats, moderate protein, and low carbohydrates. Your body ISN'T tricked, it seeks out usable energy, since there are less carbohydrates floating around, the body goes into lipolysis, hence, ketogenesis, as ketones are the waste products of lipolysis.
Is it a healthy balance? It's still undetermined. What we do know is that it can help with lipid profiles, it will raise HDLs and should lower LDLs. A Low-Fat diet does not do this, it will keep the ratio of HDL/LDL the same.
Edit: forgot to add, EAT YOUR VEGETABLES, seriously. Or else you'll become constipated.0 -
There are many people on this forum who are not informed on ketosis. I recommend it for weight loss, heart health, diabetes control and avoidance and most of all - you just feel better and can stick to it long term. Please please please do some serious research. it is very healthy and involves eating high fat, moderate protein and very low carbs. You will have greater appetite management and will have greatly reduced insulin levels. As we all know insulin is the fat hormone (you guys know this, right?) and insulin comes from carbs.
Ketosis doesn't trick your body into anything. other than restoring it to what it was always meant to be. think about how long we have been eating refined carbs and how the levels of obesity have increased. the connection is not an accident. even unrefined carbs have only been eaten for a relatively short period of time.
I have been eating this way for many months and have never gone back to sugar or carbs. I feel relaxed around food, free from all cravings and my diet is easy to stick to. I lost 50 pounds and have maintained it for six months.0 -
Lighter Life focus on this.....as a result there have been people who have had to have gall bladders removed due to following it. I think I'd steer clear.....
gallbladder disease is caused by a lack of fat in the diet - leading to the gallbladder not being stimulated often enough to produce enough bile to wash away cholesterol deposits (which are perfectly normal and healthy).
Anyone on a low fat diet and loses weight is chancing gall bladder disease (I know because I had mine out after a long period of time on a low fat diet).
I like Lighter Life, but it is low fat (as well as being ketogenic) and this is the likely reason it could lead to increased chance of gall bladder disease. but most diets are low fat and could result in this outcome - choose a high fat diet and you won't have this issue. Our bodies are designed to exist on a diet high in saturated fats.
Once again - gall bladder disease is new and started to become prevalent when low fat diets were introduced in the 1970's.0 -
Ketosis and the Paleo diet are pretty similar I think....Lots of protein and healthy fat and low carb and nothing processed or man-made. So like- if the cavemen wouldn't have eaten it ( bread, dairy, sugars) you don't eat it either. That's God's original diet for the human body....He didn't make bread man did....we really shouldn't eat it. Etc...0
-
Ketosis and the Paleo diet are pretty similar I think....Lots of protein and healthy fat and low carb and nothing processed or man-made. So like- if the cavemen wouldn't have eaten it ( bread, dairy, sugars) you don't eat it either. That's God's original diet for the human body....He didn't make bread man did....we really shouldn't eat it. Etc...
In my opinion, I would not consider Paleo low carb. You can easily get over 30-40% of your carbs from fruits and veggies.0 -
I have been in ketosis for 10 months now, lost almost 100 pounds, and have had a host of non-weight related improvements. For me, it's been a godsend.
I do gentle exercise 4-5 days a week, and have had no issues. I have more energy than ever.0 -
you could not be further from the truth.The ketosis diet puts the body in an acidic state. Acidic states not only take the body out of it's natural balance, they have been linked to inflammation and cancer. I would not recommend it as a long term option.0 -
I wouldn't start any diet that sounds like a disease. Just sayin'!
:laugh: :laugh: 0 -
The ketosis diet puts the body in an acidic state. Acidic states not only take the body out of it's natural balance, they have been linked to inflammation and cancer. I would not recommend it as a long term option.
False.
This last focus point is the danger of ketoacidosis. This occurs when the level of ketones in the blood gets out of control, this happens because ketones are acidic only as long as they are floating around waiting to be burned. If the level of ketones in the blood rises out of control it would lower the pH of the blood and this could result in death. BUT, this is not a concern for the non-diabetic whatsoever because for the non-diabetic blood sugar levels are kept low by our bodies and it will only allow so many ketones to be manufactured at one time. In the diabetic person blood sugar can rise as high as 300-2000mg/dl, where as normal being around 80-120. Also when this happens the low insulin to glucagon ratio causes ketogenesis to be stimulated, this is where the person can run into ketoacidosis.0 -
Hold protein and cals constant and keto diets show no advantage in fat loss0
-
I love the keto diet. I am full, my skin has cleared up and I have more energy than ever. I am not highly overweight, but has a few lbs to lose. I drink a ton more water and eat way healthier, more natural foods than on a 'low-fat' diet. It focuses on natural foods. You NEED fats in your diet, as well as proteins. I get all the carbs (VERY little) I need from veggies. Fruit is a treat. I know it sounds crazy, but it has helped my GERD as well as my allergies. It is hard to get your head around, so read up on it. Try it yourself. It works for me - and I'll continue to live this way. Doc confirms I am healthy. :-)
EDIT: Also, I zumba 3-4 times a week and lift heavy 3x a week. I have so much more energy and my body loves it!0 -
Once you start eating carbs again all that weight you lost will come back with a vengance! So unless you plan on eating like that for the rest of your life calorie deficit is the only way to go.0
-
not only will you gain weight back when you stop the diet, there have been studies done with people who did atkins and people who lost weight old fashioned way (calorie defecit and exercise) and at the end of a year they all lost the same amount of weight. The atkins just lost it faster but had same end result as the ones who still ate carbs.0
-
Once you start eating carbs again all that weight you lost will come back with a vengance! So unless you plan on eating like that for the rest of your life calorie deficit is the only way to go.
no it won't if you keep to the same calorie level, you will regain some water weight once you add in carbohydrates again but that's irrelevant. Fat loss =/= weight loss.
I'm not even a fan of low carb dieting but statements like this are nonsense.0 -
:noway:
Sorry but I have to advise you that Ketosis is a natural body function. It's how the body fuels the Brain and CNS when there are no carbs available to use. We are designed to run this way when needed. When carbs are not available, we use fat to run most of the body's functions and ketones to run the dependent organs.0 -
Got to be honest, ketosis is not a great thing. When your body is lacking carbs it eats itself to replace. I was on a no carb diet for a while (bit like atkins) and went to the doctors for an unrelated issue, had a urine test and he commented on the "keytones" in my sample.
It does have great effects but puts extreme pressure on the kidneys.
I am a typical yo-yo dieter and unfortunately it comes back to the same old thing - you have to change your life style, quick dfixes never last.
Hopefully the detail available on this site will highlight visually my transgressins and where I need to show some restraint.
Anyway good luck whatever you decide.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions