Why is Healthy Eating So Expensive?

24

Replies

  • AZDizzy
    AZDizzy Posts: 434 Member
    I get 3/4 of my groceries from the 99 cent only store!
  • amanda_ataraxia
    amanda_ataraxia Posts: 400 Member
    I am in the same school of thought. I think it is more expensive to eat unhealthily. And it is certainly more costly in the long run to keep living that lifestyle if you anticipate what your medical bills might be.

    I look at food as an investment in my health and I really spare no expense. It is worth it to me.
  • StinkyWinkies
    StinkyWinkies Posts: 603 Member
    A 3# bag of apples here is ~$3.99, get 9-12 apples depending on size (I eat macintoshes) a bag of chips (any sort) is also $3.99 for ~11 servings...this comparison alone helped me realize eating healthier is not more expensive either $-wish or health-wise. An apple, I find, satisfies me more than chips, which is perhaps why I eat less of them!

    I also started, once again, to shop all three grocery stores here for the best prices I can get. One of them gets in mostly locally grown fresh veggies, this is a huge plus. I love to cook and recommend a crock-pot as an investment, it makes some wonderful meals, and can be 'done ahead' to be ready when you get home.
  • endlesoul
    endlesoul Posts: 98 Member
    Its not..

    its just an excuse for people who dont want to eat healthy


    ^ this too lazy to make an effort to make good meals

    Define eating healthy? I think you need the parameters to gauge if it costs more. I cook everything from scratch, I cook Ketogenics for one person (who also lifts weights), low carb for another, one person has an eating disorder and one that has dietary issues. We are all in the same household. For example since our change in eating habits ( and exercise) we went through 2 gallons of milk a week average $5.00. Now we drink almond and or coconut milk. It costs about $3.69 a half gallon we go through 2 1/2 gallons a week. that's $18.45 just for that. Whey protein powder even at Costco is an added expense................. Yes we have eliminated junk food but add healthy foods and other products that can be costly.

    It may depend on where you live and what your diet is. Lazy I am not and more like a short order cook. LOL I shop sales, Costco, and utilize online club card savings. So if asked if eating healthy is more expensive I say it depends on what your "healthy foods are". Since it can be subjective as to what is healthy.
  • It's not. You have to know where to shop, when to shop and plan. If you ease up on meat and dairy, like only have it a few times a week. You'll save money from that. Find a local farmers market. Most of them, if not all, are seasonal. But you can find other stores that are reasonable. It took me a couple tries to find the places I go to when the market is closed. Also, if you plan your meals either a week at a time or a month that will save you from buying extra groceries. Always stick to your shopping list. Don't stray. That's where you start to spend the money. If there's different things you want to try shop around. And there's always coupons.
  • dawndw
    dawndw Posts: 203
    Not expensive at all. You save tons of $$$ by not getting prepared boxed over processed unhealthy foods. And even more if you make it yourself and not do the dining out thing. I love preparing my meals now. :-)
  • endlesoul
    endlesoul Posts: 98 Member
    I think people are seeing through blinders, posting in regards to what they eat and use that as a reference. Some people eat low carb and meat and dairy is an important place in their diet, some are vegetarian etc.
    So for some their diet change has cost less, some more. And both can be correct since there is endless dietary changes for the good that can affect the wallet..
  • msbunnie68
    msbunnie68 Posts: 1,894 Member
    I do think it is dependent on where you live.

    Here in Western Australia

    white bread and grain breads = same price
    greek yogurt vs flavoured yogurts = same price
    chicken comes in around $9-$10 per kilo for breast or thigh fillets and anywhere from $3-$6 per kilo for wings or legs
    lean heartsmart mince is more expensive than regular but looks a billion times nicer.
    fresh produce is usually cheaper than frozen *except* when there has been a massive storm wiping out crops (cyclone in Queensland wiped out banana plantations and they went from $2-$3 per kilo to around $18-$20 per kilo for a while there!!
    Tins of beans/lentils/chickpeas 99c to $2 depending on brand.

    I CAN make you a nicer and much healthier meal for your $5-$6 you spend at McDonalds that won't make you feel like you are about to throw an artery.

    Buy in season. Buy meats in bulk and separate them into portion sizes then freeze.
  • Mokey41
    Mokey41 Posts: 5,769 Member
    You don't have to buy fresh fruit and veg either. Frozen has just as much goodness because it's usually flash frozen within hours of being picked while fresh may have traveled around the country for days before it gets to you. Greek yogurt isn't a necessity, regular yogurt is just as healthy. Bulk foods are usually cheaper for things like rice, beans, etc.
  • Gallowmere1984
    Gallowmere1984 Posts: 6,626 Member
    I don't eat plants at all anymore, so for me, yeah it's a bit more expensive. I typically go through about $30 per day, but almost all of my food is meats, protein shakes, bars, and supplements. There are much cheaper ways to do things, but to me, plants are what food eats.

    There are definitely cheap ways to eat decently, it just takes this little thing that so few people are willing to put forth anymore: effort.
  • angiechimpanzee
    angiechimpanzee Posts: 536 Member
    Its not..

    its just an excuse for people who dont want to eat healthy
    This. This. This.

    Thread over.
  • msbunnie68
    msbunnie68 Posts: 1,894 Member
    I don't eat plants at all anymore, so for me, yeah it's a bit more expensive. I typically go through about $30 per day, but almost all of my food is meats, protein shakes, bars, and supplements. There are much cheaper ways to do things, but to me, plants are what food eats.

    There are definitely cheap ways to eat decently, it just takes this little thing that so few people are willing to put forth anymore: effort.

    Plants are what food eats??

    I am picturing you as about 20 feet tall with little forearms, poor eyesight, long tail, powerful legs and great big teeth...
  • Gallowmere1984
    Gallowmere1984 Posts: 6,626 Member
    I don't eat plants at all anymore, so for me, yeah it's a bit more expensive. I typically go through about $30 per day, but almost all of my food is meats, protein shakes, bars, and supplements. There are much cheaper ways to do things, but to me, plants are what food eats.

    There are definitely cheap ways to eat decently, it just takes this little thing that so few people are willing to put forth anymore: effort.

    Plants are what food eats??

    I am picturing you as about 20 feet tall with little forearms, poor eyesight, long tail, powerful legs and great big teeth...

    So that's why I have little chicken claws for hands that make me have to use straps for heavy shrugging and deadlifts...now it all make sense. O_O
  • acf860
    acf860 Posts: 5
    It may seem more expensive but just think of the money you will save on doctor visits and medicines that you won't need because you are eating healthy!!!
  • Gallowmere1984
    Gallowmere1984 Posts: 6,626 Member
    It may seem more expensive but just think of the money you will save on doctor visits and medicines that you won't need because you are eating healthy!!!

    You may have just inadvertently derailed this thread, but here I go.

    I think this very thing you mentioned has a lot to do with why people don't take care of their bodies as much anymore. Everyone just thinks "no matter how bad I **** myself up, modern medicine can fix me", and this is only exacerbated by the whole "medical care is a right" mentality. No one feels that they should have to suffer for their ****ty decisions anymore, basically.
  • jennaworksout
    jennaworksout Posts: 1,739 Member
    Its not..

    its just an excuse for people who dont want to eat healthy


    ^ this too lazy to make an effort to make good meals

    Define eating healthy? I think you need the parameters to gauge if it costs more. I cook everything from scratch, I cook Ketogenics for one person (who also lifts weights), low carb for another, one person has an eating disorder and one that has dietary issues. We are all in the same household. For example since our change in eating habits ( and exercise) we went through 2 gallons of milk a week average $5.00. Now we drink almond and or coconut milk. It costs about $3.69 a half gallon we go through 2 1/2 gallons a week. that's $18.45 just for that. Whey protein powder even at Costco is an added expense................. Yes we have eliminated junk food but add healthy foods and other products that can be costly.

    It may depend on where you live and what your diet is. Lazy I am not and more like a short order cook. LOL I shop sales, Costco, and utilize online club card savings. So if asked if eating healthy is more expensive I say it depends on what your "healthy foods are". Since it can be subjective as to what is healthy.

    ??????? I eat healthy and its not expensive. the end.
  • jennaworksout
    jennaworksout Posts: 1,739 Member
    Its not..

    its just an excuse for people who dont want to eat healthy
    This. This. This.

    Thread over.

    thank you!! .
  • misskerouac
    misskerouac Posts: 2,242 Member
    I find it cheaper.

    The only time my grocery bill is high is when my husband wants chips or pop or frozen premade crap.
  • Madholm
    Madholm Posts: 167
    It can be extremely expensive. I have some friends in boston that eat local organic food. It costs them around $1100 per month for an active family of 3. Far too pricey for me to ever consider, but there are certainly plenty of ways to eat healthy for a lot less.
  • magj0y
    magj0y Posts: 1,911 Member
    Cost-co, 10lb bag of frozen chicken breasts run about $15. They also have a good selection on other things.
    Unprocessed rice, beans quinoa, pastas (costco) , potatoes in bulk, all cheap.

    If you rethink your menu and where you buy your stuff, it's not more expensive.
    Most Mexican, italian, chili, none of these are expensive.
  • kimmeyjo
    kimmeyjo Posts: 57 Member
    I feel that way sometimes too, but I try to remember I'm buying for a whole family and the rest of the family can have "not so healthy" food whereas I have to have healthy food. It still is cheaper because we are not eating out as much and I eat leftovers. Yes I pay over $5 a pound for 96/4 hamburger meat, but I can get two to three meals out of one pound. Where before I wouldn't eat my leftovers and buy fast food. My grocery bill is higher, but my food cost in total is much lower since we don't eat out and I'm not eating junkfood.
  • survivor1952
    survivor1952 Posts: 250 Member
    Nobody seems to care when they spend $3.99 for a bag of chips or $10.00 for a box of candy but good grief ask for $4.00 for veggies & people scream. I don't think eating healthy costs any more than eating junk (unless you count fast food dollar menus-uck!)
    Anyhow, I'd rather pay for good, healthy food than pay the hospital bill for a heart attack.
  • betancourta229
    betancourta229 Posts: 171 Member
    The way I look at it I may be spending a little extra now but it will be worth it to live a longer life hopefully with no or less medications later in life.

    I find that I am eating less food then I did before so it is about quality vs quantity and I save more money simply because I am buying less.
  • fit_librarian
    fit_librarian Posts: 242 Member
    It really shouldn't be. Buy fruits and veggies that are in season, shop around, you'll find you can actually eat healthily for a lot less. good luck x

    This!
  • survivor1952
    survivor1952 Posts: 250 Member
    Its not..

    its just an excuse for people who dont want to eat healthy
    Amen to that!
  • Nina2503
    Nina2503 Posts: 172 Member
    I dont find it more expensive, admittedly food is getting more expensive and I have to be more creative in the ktichen but I do plan menu's in advance, buy on offer, eat cheaper cuts of meat, eat seasonal veg, batch cook. It does take time and planning perhaps but much tastier than prepacked junk
  • Kaydana123
    Kaydana123 Posts: 71 Member
    It really depends what you're buying. People who say it's more expensive have usually gone from cooking unhealthy meals, to cooking meals with mostly fresh veg and fresh meat. People who say it's cheaper have usually gone from eating takeaways and snacks to cooking healthy meals.

    Eating healthily doesn't have to be expensive, but you do need to ignore all the people (and I mean ALL of them!) who insist that you should eat lots of fresh this and fresh that. Dried beans and lentils are practically given away, and frozen meat, fruit and veg are ridiculously cheap compared to their fresh equivalents. As a general rule when it comes to fruit and veg, I only buy fresh when I'm going to eat it raw or can't buy it any other way.
  • contingencyplan
    contingencyplan Posts: 3,639 Member
    Value. Healthy. Convenience.

    Pick two.

    In my experience, the only time "healthy" foods are more expensive is when you're one of those "EVERYTHING MUST BE ORGANIC!" nuts or if you're trying to stick to things that don't require much effort to prepare as they come mostly pre-prepared. Well, sorry, but part of eating healthy means being willing to spend time in the kitchen. Yeah, if you're not willing to do THAT, then it can get expensive. Stupidly expensive. But if you care about your health AND saving money, you'll attempt to learn what you need to in order to resurrect the arcane arts of combining basic ingredients over heat in a process the ancient ones referred to as "cooking."
  • juliec33
    juliec33 Posts: 238 Member
    I just joined a co-op. for $15 a week you get a huge basket of veggies and a huge basket of fruit(think medium round laundry basket size). One of the ladies fingered it out and it would be approximately $40 to buy the same stuff in the store. They use as local as possible and what's in season. I have to split it with a friend because it's so much I couldn't use everything in a week (single).

    The co-op is called bountiful baskets and they have locations throughout the country. Check it out. Or find a similar group in your local area. So far it's been great.
  • lynn1982
    lynn1982 Posts: 1,439 Member
    To reiterate what others have said - it doesn't have to be. I spend less on groceries each week because I'm not buying junk food on top of healthy food and I'm portioning everything out. So in that case, no, it's not more expensive. (Although sometimes, especially in the winter, fresh fruits and veggies are more expensive, so that's when I turn to frozen veggies, but always as a last resort.) That being said, it is NOT a myth that healthy food is more expensive than unhealthy food. A pound of broccoli at my grocery store costs more than a bag of chips. (Of course in the long run, that pound of broccoli will keep you healthier than that bag of chips, so it's sort of like an investment in your health.) Also, it depends on your definition of healthy. Non-GMO versions of corn and soy and grass fed, hormone-free meats are definitely way more expensive than their GMO corn (which is in almost everything in some form and allows for cheap production of processed foods) and corn-fed beef, for example, are less expensive. They're also government subsidized (depending on where you live), as is wheat, for example. So yes, it is definitely more expensive to eat super healthy, but there are ways around it and alternatives.
This discussion has been closed.