Bread

I love bread... however my nutritionist few weeks back told me that key to a good start in weight loss is to cut carbs out as much as possible, or at least the white carbs, like breads, pastas and sugars... I went from about 190 carbs a day to 30-70 max and not only have noticed different in weight but inches as well... im not as hungry all the time as i was when i ate breads and pastas as fillers...

The only thing cutting carbs helps you lose is water weight. Long term, you won't lose any more weight that way, as it balances out.

It's 100% personal preference. If you like bread, eat bread. It won't hinder weight loss at all.

As for "Wheat Belly," that book is a joke. Horribly cherry picked data and sensationalistic tabloid journalism at its finest. The author was way more interested in selling books than in actual facts.

OP:

Looking at your diary, you need to take your typical daily intake, and ADD a Peanut Butter Sandwich, and some bacon. On any kind of bread you want.

Seriously, get a few extra hundred calories in there before you collapse....

I love bread... however my nutritionist few weeks back told me that key to a good start in weight loss is to cut carbs out as much as possible, or at least the white carbs, like breads, pastas and sugars... I went from about 190 carbs a day to 30-70 max and not only have noticed different in weight but inches as well... im not as hungry all the time as i was when i ate breads and pastas as fillers...

The only thing cutting carbs helps you lose is water weight. Long term, you won't lose any more weight that way, as it balances out.

It's 100% personal preference. If you like bread, eat bread. It won't hinder weight loss at all.

As for "Wheat Belly," that book is a joke. Horribly cherry picked data and sensationalistic tabloid journalism at its finest. The author was way more interested in selling books than in actual facts.

I love good bread. But I have to limit it so I disagree with you as some of us do have problems with bread (or carbs in general, not limited to just bread). Yes, I'm diabetic with hypoglycemic tendencies, and bread wreaks havoc with my blood sugar levels unless I'm careful about how/when I consume it. People with insulin resistance, PCOS, and other metabolic disorders that impact insulin levels might have similar problems.

If I eat anything high-carb shortly before or after an intense exercise session, like limiting it to one slice of a whole grain bread, preferably with some seeds, I'm fine. But if I eat more and, especially, if it's not close to an exercise session, I can have blood sugar crashes which then brings on real physical hunger pangs as I need to then raise my blood sugar. And if I over-correct, then another crash, then more hunger, yada yada. Not a good roller-coaster to be on! And it sure makes weight loss difficult because then it's harder to stay within your calorie target. Also leads me to binge eating. While I'm all for planned splurges, binges are not good. I can also get other negative effects if I start OD'ing on high-carb foods, especially bread but I expect that might be the yeast? For example, the only time I ever get heartburn is if I have been eating too much bread.

That said, I agree that IIFYM (if it fits your macros) and those macros are right for you, go ahead and eat the bread. But, if you have problems with bread (or other high-carb foods), you might do better limiting them.

I do best when I get most of my carbs from vegetables and dairy, with limited amounts of grains, beans/pulses, rice, potatoes and such.

Bread...Eat it!

I don't have bread too much. I prefer Rolls, bagels, english muffins to just normal sliced bread. Though put me in front of french bread and I will go to town. Same with hoagie rolls. YUM. I don't NOT eat these things but I try not to have them often because I have control issues with certain types of breads.

I personally am gluten free, but it was by necessity not by choice. Bread is amazing and I miss it. I would think as long as it's whole wheat go for it! And enjoy it for me

All in moderation. I try to have bread/carbs for 2/3 meals. for example, oatmeal at breakfast and a sandwich at lunch, only veggie/soy carbs for dinner.

I don't really eat bread because I just don't like it! I am sort of a low carb eater by default...I am not a huge fan of most grain based stuff (whole wheat pasta and porridge are about my only grain based carbs). It's like anything though...if I liked bread, I'd eat it...no point cutting out stuff you like, this is meant to be a change for life, not a short term fix.

I've done low carb, I've read Wheat Belly, I've read Taubes, et al.

I had 6 slices of bread today.

I think I'll be OK

My boyfriend cut bread out only to loose that stubborn bit of chub underneath his belly button! It worked for him but hasn't worked that well for me.