soup diet??

kara1990
kara1990 Posts: 34 Member
in Health and Weight Loss
so iv been doin research and it says to eat nothing but soup for 7-10 days.... has anyone actually tried this??? also does anyone have some good simple soup recipies for a slow cooker??? (crockpot) as i dont want to eat just canned stuff lol
«13

Replies

  • ay1978pa
    ay1978pa Posts: 142 Member
    Soup is all I have for lunch most days. It works wonders. It fills you up but you can fit as many or as few calories as you need in it.

    Here's a good recipe my partner makes (it has a ridiculously low caloric value):
    http://www.billandalex.us/recipe.php?name=Vegetable Soup (Low Calorie)
  • rumplesnat
    rumplesnat Posts: 372
    Are you talking the hokey 80's cabbage soup diet or a real soup with actual protein, maybe some whole grains tossed in and vegetables?
  • melsinct
    melsinct Posts: 3,512 Member
    Eating soup is fine but why would you want to eat it for two weeks straight when you can eat all sorts of foods, keep within your calories, and still lose weight? Gimmicky diets tend not to work, as after you are done with your soup diet, you still have to figure out how to eat like a normal person.

    However, I do love homemade soup and eat it for lunch at work all of the time!
  • prium01
    prium01 Posts: 306 Member
    Eating just soups for 7-8 days will give you remarkable weight loss, but you will gain half of the pounds back , the pounds mostly you lose will be water and muscle,when you return to normal food.I have done that, but could not keep doing it for long, also became very weak...I don't know much but others might be able to help.This doesn't seem to be a healthy approach..
  • gracielynn1011
    gracielynn1011 Posts: 726 Member
    Are you talking cabbage soup? Or healthy soup?

    My mom did the cabbage soup diet in the late 90's, of course she had great results because she had nothing but the runs for 2 weeks.

    But I love a good chicken noodle soup with whole grain pasta noodles and fresh veggies, simmered in the crock pot for a few hours. I also love a good venison stew with fresh veggies and tomato paste. Delicious and nutritious!
  • kara1990
    kara1990 Posts: 34 Member
    actual soups with veg n meat in , lol not the cabbage one , dont think i could have that much cabbage lol xx
  • Redgal56
    Redgal56 Posts: 73 Member
    I love soup! It helps fill you up!
  • ZHawk1123
    ZHawk1123 Posts: 215
    Dat ain't sustainable yo... You be gainin' all dat weight back once you stop eatin' dat soup
  • stephdeeable
    stephdeeable Posts: 1,407 Member
    I feel like all this would accomplish is making me hate soup.
  • kara1990
    kara1990 Posts: 34 Member
    i have no trouble keeping the weight off once its off , i struggle with the loosing of it , and i plan to incorprate exercise too , and then return to healthy eating after the 7-10 days xx
  • AmyMgetsfit
    AmyMgetsfit Posts: 636 Member
    That sounds like the "poop soup" diet from the 80's. You may lose a few lbs, but you gain it all back, once you go back to your regular eating habits.
  • quirkytizzy
    quirkytizzy Posts: 4,052 Member
    i have no trouble keeping the weight off once its off , i struggle with the loosing of it , and i plan to incorprate exercise too , and then return to healthy eating after the 7-10 days xx

    If you plan on returning to eating healthy in a week and a half, you'd do better to just start that today. Doing otherwise will only prolong the development of healthy food choices.
  • KilikiMom
    KilikiMom Posts: 237 Member
    diets do NOT WORK!!!! eating right and healthy DOES!!! ohh and exercising too...eating one thing for 7-10 days is only gonna mess you up IMO....you go from eating nothing to eating normally and its gonna screw with your system big time....do not fall into these "fad diets" they do not work....and if they do its only short term....think of long term....
  • gvheintz
    gvheintz Posts: 138 Member
    I love soup. Search for a good butternut squash recipe... Nummy. I also like my lentil soup. 1 can rinsed washed lentils, 1 can tomato soup and 2 tins of water. 1 can Aylmers tomatoes with celery, onion and green pepper. 1 beef bouillon cube. Then go to town adding other veg (I use 1 large onion, bunch of celery, carrots, red pepper, cabbage, and whatever else is in the fridge). And then some pepper to taste, some minced garlic, a couple bay leaves, and parsley. The great thing about soup is you can experiment with flavourful pairings... It helped me learn how I liked to cook... Including things other than soup too.

    Other soups I like... Split pea, taco soup, meatball soup, chicken rice, mushroom barley, cream of broccoli, and last week's tortellini soup I made for Lenten service at church. Mmmmm Mmmmm mmmmmm good.
  • tjphelps73
    tjphelps73 Posts: 171 Member
    I make low calorie chili, taco soup, chicken and noodles, tomato spinach brown rice soup, and chicken in rice soup in crockpot. We eat soup at least once a week in my household. I have a cookbook that is nothing but crockpot recipes. I review the recipe and then make a few changes to make the macros better.

    Chili - Can of tomato juice(low sodium), a small can of tomato sauce, one can of dark red kidney beans, 1/2 lb of ground turkey cooked with spicy chili seasoning (you can make your own or buy a packet), and all goes into the crock to cook. This pretty basic because my hubby likes peanut butter sandwiches with his chili BUT you can change it up.
  • trogalicious
    trogalicious Posts: 4,584 Member
    i have no trouble keeping the weight off once its off , i struggle with the loosing of it , and i plan to incorprate exercise too , and then return to healthy eating after the 7-10 days xx

    If you plan on returning to eating healthy in a week and a half, you'd do better to just start that today. Doing otherwise will only prolong the development of healthy food choices.
    exactly this.
  • now_or_never13
    now_or_never13 Posts: 1,575 Member
    The only way this will make you lose weight is due to calorie lowering. Why would you want to do this? You can't live off soup for a week or more.

    Don't look for quick fixes. The only reason to consume only soup is if you are sick or can't eat regular foods.

    When you stop eating soup after those 7-10 days you will gain some if not all of the weight back. You will not be losing much fat during those days you only consume soup. Eat healthy now.
  • LishieFruit89
    LishieFruit89 Posts: 1,956 Member
    i have no trouble keeping the weight off once its off , i struggle with the loosing of it , and i plan to incorprate exercise too , and then return to healthy eating after the 7-10 days xx

    If you plan on returning to eating healthy in a week and a half, you'd do better to just start that today. Doing otherwise will only prolong the development of healthy food choices.

    This!

    But you'd like to incorporate some soup into your healthy lifestyle, skinnytaste.com has a lot of soups & many that are crockpot recipes (or have suggestions how to make it in a crockpot)
  • llaskoske
    llaskoske Posts: 21 Member
    Weight Watchers was promoting the soup idea in the 90s. It was a cabbage based soup and you put in any kind of non-starchy vegetable you like (green beans, beets, carrots, etc.). You'd eat that for one or two meals a day. For variation, you could add potatoes or chicken and still have a relatively low calorie soup. I loved it and would vary the vegetables in it (peppers one week, spinach another, etc) to keep it interesting. I'd make a stock pot of it and freeze portions for the rest of the week. The downside, was that even using a small cabbage, it made so much that my freezer was full of frozen soup all the time.

    You could eat this soup cold, hot or warm and it was still good, I'd recommend it as a kickstarter when you hit a plateau in dieting. You can even strain off the broth and use that as part of your liquids for the day in place of a fruit or vegetable juice.
  • gvheintz
    gvheintz Posts: 138 Member
    Oh ya... Don't just do a soup diet... It's a fad diet. I just like soup as a way to get my veg in me and it can be part of a nutritious healthy well rounded meal plan. Just eat healthy under your needed calories and the weight will come off slowly but for the long term.
  • vim_n_vigor
    vim_n_vigor Posts: 4,089 Member
    I could maybe do it for a few days if my jaw is wired shut. Why can't you just eat the healthy foods that you are putting into the soup instead? Eating nothing but soup for that long sounds miserable, even if it is good, hearty soup.
  • EvelynBfly78
    EvelynBfly78 Posts: 240 Member
    It sounds very much like the Cabbage Soup Diet I was on over 30 years ago. It was only a temporary fix. Just to satisfy your curiosity, try it if you think it will work.
    Me? I wouldn't waste my time & effort on it again.
  • GastricJoy
    GastricJoy Posts: 17
    I like the Scared Heart Soup. Not for the DIET but because it taste good. I make the soup like one a week and my family loves it.
  • SteveJWatson
    SteveJWatson Posts: 1,225 Member
    Hey!

    I hear you can lose weight by only eating a stale crust of bread and drinking a pint of water a day. Its called the 'third world prisoner diet'.....
  • chocl8girl
    chocl8girl Posts: 1,968 Member
    I wouldn't think it was a very good idea at all. Maybe soup every day for lunch or something, HEALTHY, filling soup. But your body NEEDS solid foods to function correctly. Eating only liquids/mushy things for extended periods of time causes your internal organ muscles to weaken, and then when you reintroduce solid food, not only will you probably gain weight back, but you may very well suffer gastrointestinal issues as your body struggles to get used to digesting solid foods again.

    How about just eat reasonably and healthily with sensible portions?
  • kara1990
    kara1990 Posts: 34 Member
    o dear me... obviously i eat healthy , hence why i would be returning to a healthy diet after , not "starting" it fresh lol , and i reckon i`ll be able to keep the weigh off once the 7-10 days are finished , i`ll just up my exercise reguim (cant spell lol) and portion control , i`ve been ill latley so iv put weight on as i`v not been able to exercise and my hips have been in a bad way too ( i have CHD) ..... cheers for the advice from ppl who gave it tho!!
  • kara1990
    kara1990 Posts: 34 Member
    also the soup i`m on about eating would have big chunky bits in it , like beef and veg , big chunks of beef.... carrot ... broccili ect
  • Hiskhaleesi
    Hiskhaleesi Posts: 53 Member
    Ugh. My boyfriends cousin keeps telling me I "need" to do this cabbage soup diet. Her exact words were "I tried it and lost 15 pounds! But I gained them all back when I started eating like regular again" well no ****. And I don't want to just lose 25 pounds for a week, I want them gone for life!
  • kara1990
    kara1990 Posts: 34 Member
    Hey!

    I hear you can lose weight by only eating a stale crust of bread and drinking a pint of water a day. Its called the 'third world prisoner diet'.....


    lol literally!! you can survive on less so long as you drink water , i had issues when i was younger and was daft and didnt eat for days on end , only drinkin water , i ended up really ill obvs ... so cheers for the sarcasm there dude
  • trogalicious
    trogalicious Posts: 4,584 Member
    Hey!

    I hear you can lose weight by only eating a stale crust of bread and drinking a pint of water a day. Its called the 'third world prisoner diet'.....


    lol literally!! you can survive on less so long as you drink water , i had issues when i was younger and was daft and didnt eat for days on end , only drinkin water , i ended up really ill obvs ... so cheers for the sarcasm there dude
    his recommendation was no less silly than a "I want to eat soup for 7-10 days just lose weight and then expect it to stay off when I go back to eating real food again" diet.

    but hey, cheers!

Categories