Skipping Breakfast (on the reg)
noelie365
Posts: 13
I know there are a million studies saying that you should not skip breakfast, but days when I skip breakfast my overall caloric intake is less and I tend to eat better. Days when I load up on breakfast, my stomach is growling 2 hours later and I tend to eat much more. I've been drinking a big glass of water upon waking and doing warm lemon water "tea" afterwards until lunch (at 12) and that seems to be working for me. Does anyone else "cheat" and blow off breakfast? Or drink tea or juice instead? Please share what's working for you!
0
Replies
-
it's fine, you're good. Especially if you're not working out on an empty stomach0
-
Well the first meal of the day is "breaking the fast" so what name you choose is semantics. I fast from 7pm to 11am usually most days and have black coffee first thing in the morning and nothing else. Some people will try to tell you how important eating on waking is but it doesn't matter; do what works for you.
If not eating until lunch works, keep at it.0 -
I know there are a million studies saying that you should not skip breakfast, but days when I skip breakfast my overall caloric intake is less and I tend to eat better.
I would suggest you keep skipping breakfast.0 -
I very rarely skip breaksfast. I normally eat a large amount of protein. I seem to be able to go for hours without being hungry. Everyone is different. This is just works for me. If I eat high carb breakfast I'm hungry in a short time.0
-
a million studies ? show us 10
-
What currently seems to be working for me is bulletproof coffee. basically, I put 1 tbs coconut oil and 1 tbs unsalted grass-fed butter and this morning I added half a scoop of chocolate protein whey isolate. Then I mix it all with a frother until it's foamy and creamy. It keeps me full until about lunch and it's about the same amount of calories I'd normally eat for breakfast anyway, only with much less annoyance.0
-
I skip breakfast and end up doing better the rest of the day too.0
-
"on the Reg" hahaha, let me rephrase my response " aye yo! just do you girl, your on point wit yo goals so don't trip, HOller!"0
-
The only reason breakfast is recommended so strongly is because several studies have shown a correlation between people eating breakfast and people eating less. This doesn't mean all people, just a large group of people. If you don't like it and feel better without it, you don't need to eat it. I'm not a big fan of it, personally.
Oh, and before anyone else says otherwise, breakfast does not "jump start" your metabolism. Skipping breakfast will not put you in starvation mode.0 -
I don't see a problem with skipping breakfast as long as you're still eating well.
I do wonder what it is you've been eating for breakfast, though, that has you hungry a couple hours later simply because I know I felt that way when I didn't have enough protein in mine.0 -
i never eat breakfast0
-
"on the Reg" hahaha, let me rephrase my response " aye yo! just do you girl, your on point wit yo goals so don't trip, HOller!"
lol thanks! Having to eat breakfast must be a mom-ism. I love how supportive you guys are!0 -
Seems like it's working well for you, so keep doing what you're doing. As long as you eat enough calories to fuel your body properly and yet few enough to maintain a small deficit, it doesn't matter what time of day you eat, IMO.
ETA: some days I eat breakfast, some days I just have coffee in the early morning. Depends on whether or not I am hungry. when I just have coffee I have more calories for later in the day, which is always a bonus. I just try to pay attention to my hunger cues and go with those.0 -
I do better with a 300-400 calorie breakfast, about two hours after I wake up, but you should do what works best for you.0
-
It doesn't matter when you eat the calories. If skipping breakfast works for you, keep doing it.0
-
I rarely eat breakfast as cannot face eating until I have been up for at least a couple of hours. Good to know I am not the only one. I shall continue to save my calories for when I am ready for them0
-
If you are that hungry 2 hours after eating breakfast, then I would venture a guess (without looking into it) that you might not be eating all that filling of food for breakfast. I do a protein shake with milk in the morning for breakfast around 7a.m. and that holds me over until around noon at least normally, but everyone is different.
The key to sticking with a diet is finding what works for you, so if not eating breakfast works, then keep at it. You're at a point now, depending on when you stop eating for the day that intermittent fasting could work for you if you wanted to look into it, just sayin...0 -
I know there are a million studies saying that you should not skip breakfast, but days when I skip breakfast my overall caloric intake is less and I tend to eat better. Days when I load up on breakfast, my stomach is growling 2 hours later and I tend to eat much more. I've been drinking a big glass of water upon waking and doing warm lemon water "tea" afterwards until lunch (at 12) and that seems to be working for me. Does anyone else "cheat" and blow off breakfast? Or drink tea or juice instead? Please share what's working for you!
Most studies about skipping breakfast are flawed in their design and base conclusions on correlation, not causation. Skipping breakfast is fine - I've done it for 3 years with nothing but success. I even recommend it to my clients some of whom prefer a 24hr fast once or twice a week - leaner individuals prefer daily 16 hr fasts.0 -
I don't like eating much in the morning. Never have been a big breakfast person (although I like a good weekend brunch sometimes). I have coffee, and if I'm hungry mid-morning, I keep oatmeal & granola bars in my desk. I eat a big lunch & a good dinner with a snack or two during the day. It's what works for me. Do what works for you!0
-
The 10 or so months when I went from near 300 pounds down to the 205 range where I have been holding since last summer I almost never ate until noon time. This was also after my daily workout. I was always happy with my work in the gym and by waiting was still able to have some sizable meals the rest of the day. Everyone is different and finding what works is all that matters in the end.0
-
i do when i am on a fast, works for me.0
-
it's fine, you're good. Especially if you're not working out on an empty stomach
i constantly work out on an empty stomach. i love it.0 -
When you wake up, your half way into a good fat burning fast, if your trying to lose fat instead of burning food all the time doesn't it make sense to keep going? Your body was designed for feast and famine or else you wouldn't be here, so if we live in a world of 24/7 feasting, 5meals a day bla bla, which makes more sense based on what we where built for? What do primitive peoples do, or bushmen or anybody other than westernized peoples? What do they look like? I almost laughed when I saw this chubby faced doctor tell someone that they key to healthy weight was to eat 5 small meals. Whaa? So your always burning food and never burning fat? dumb dumb dumb. Trust exterience and trial not the 'nutrition' communities musings, it's your body not theirs.0
-
I know there are a million studies saying that you should not skip breakfast
None that show that, under conditions where calories are tracked, it makes any difference to weight loss, assuming total calories and macros are the same as when you do.0 -
I LOVE breakfast. I've never been overweight so I'll continue to eat it.0
-
Well if you dont like it dont eat it.
I have never been a breakfast eater, but I find as I lose more weight I am actually starving when I wake up. I see this as a postive change because often my nightly binges would cause severe heart burn and I wouldnt want to eat again till later in the day. If this is not the case with you and your just not a big breakie eater well do what works for you.
Although, if you look at the National Weight Loss Registry the registry that tracks successful weight maintainers over years most of them regularly consumed breakfast. May or may not be related but something to consider.
Listen to your body if its not hungry dont eat.
Note my breakfast is simple hard boiled egg, banana, and peanut butter or sometimes hard boiled egg, fruit, and cheese.0 -
I'm not a breakfast person. If I'm actually hungry in the morning, then I eat. But, that's not often the case. It's never negatively impacted my weight-loss to not eat breakfast.0
-
Type out regular next time haha. I totally thought that title meant something else.0
-
I know there are a million studies saying that you should not skip breakfast, but days when I skip breakfast my overall caloric intake is less and I tend to eat better. Days when I load up on breakfast, my stomach is growling 2 hours later and I tend to eat much more. I've been drinking a big glass of water upon waking and doing warm lemon water "tea" afterwards until lunch (at 12) and that seems to be working for me. Does anyone else "cheat" and blow off breakfast? Or drink tea or juice instead? Please share what's working for you!
I've never eaten breakfast. When I was a kid we were poor and only ate lunch and dinner so I just got use to not eating breakfast. I eat breakfast food for lunch or dinner sometimes though.0 -
Exact same for me! If I eat breakfast, it just kickstarts either a day full of hunger, or a day full of food for me. I almost always skip it, and when I eat it it's usually because I force myself, exactly because everybody tells me that eating breakfast is a MUST.
But without breakfast I eat better (less and healthier) and in general feel better0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions