People that drink whey protein gain weight???!!!

2»

Replies

  • stubbysticks
    stubbysticks Posts: 1,275 Member
    Whey protein is food. Like all food in the universe, it will make you gain fat if your intake exceeds your requirements.
    Well said. Consumption of whey protein in itself won't make you gain, it's the calorie surplus that does it.
  • veromancha
    veromancha Posts: 158 Member
    LMAO. that "personal trainer" has much to learn. You can tell him that this is me BEFORE at 232.2 lbs MArch3rd 2011, then AFTER on January 10th, 2012 42lbs lost, drinking WHEY protein EVERY SINGLE DAY. LOL.

    Before-AfterP90X.jpg


    This next set is from April 30th 2012 thru May 26th 2012 part of my current 90 day challenge.

    Day1-Day27Progress-60.jpg


    DSCN1261-email.jpg

    [img]http://i1069.photobucket.com/albums/u474/teamFit2Day/DSCN1255-email.jpg[/ Great job!!! You've done amazing work!![/img]
  • veromancha
    veromancha Posts: 158 Member
    It's hard to quote on my old iPad!! But you guys all look amazing!! Thanks for the support! I'm taking my wieght loss journey slow and steady the healthy way, because it's a life style change, not a quick fix!!
  • Michellerawrrr
    Michellerawrrr Posts: 310 Member
    That trainer was clearly trying to sell some crap product and doesn't really care about people. I am living proof that whey protein is a good thing and will not cause you to gain weight.
  • Bridget1908
    Bridget1908 Posts: 2
    So what brand do you use? Thanks for sharing your story; I'm interested in trying anything to get my weight loss jump started.

    Thanks
  • iamlaprell
    iamlaprell Posts: 71 Member
    I use whey protein the same as you (after a heavy workout) and I have not saw any gain from it. I have hit plateaus but definitely not gained anything back!
  • johnp1732
    johnp1732 Posts: 32 Member
    The trainer was feeling a little threatened by someone so informed...



    I tried a protein mix one morning (was lucky to get a sample from GNC the night before) and I felt like I was going to hurl for about 4 hours afterwards. :sick:

    Of course, I was at my desk job when I took it, but I felt so ill that I don't think any activity would have done me any good.

    I will admit I don't have any protein drinks after doing my c25k runs or other lite strength movements (just starting out), but the glass of chocolate milk or peanut butter on an english muffin does taste pretty good.
  • workout_fish
    workout_fish Posts: 67 Member
    That trainer sounds like an idiot!! I drink a Whey Protein shake EVERY MORNING with my breakfast, in part to help muscle recovery and also becasue it's a good way to make sure i reach my protein goal everyday (I can sometimes fall short). I lost over 60 pounds doing this every day. Shame on him for saying this to you in front of a bunch of people!
  • albertabeefy
    albertabeefy Posts: 1,169 Member
    I wonder what he'd think of my shakes then: Not only do I drink 2 whey shakes a day (sometimes 3) I also add 1/2 cup of heavy cream (400 calories, 44g of fat) to also make them into a calorie-laden meal for me.

    I've been drinking those same shakes for over 2 years now, had about 900 of them I'd estimate. And I lost well-over 100lbs in well-under a year while consuming them. :smile:
  • grover0ca
    grover0ca Posts: 568 Member
    Whey does not make me gain.
    I also think that was very unprofessional of him to speak to you that way at all never mind in front of a group!
  • lself0924
    lself0924 Posts: 113 Member
    I've lost 30+ pound in 90 days, I use a whey protein supplement. Love 'em.
  • juliapeter47
    juliapeter47 Posts: 10 Member
    I want to complement other styles regarding proteins, not only whey.

    The whey would not lead to gain weight. Any kind of weight obtain can be from not necessarily reaching appropriate macros at all hours, furthermore i may want to alter ones routines.

    I propose ingesting 6 small foods each day (about 3: 3 hours apart). That retains ones metabolic process working.
    Incorporate entire amino acids in what you eat, similar to rooster, ground slim animal meat, egg cell white wines.
    Increase sluggish running crab supply, similar to oats along with sweet spud. Consume these types of inside your 1st 3 food of the morning. They will keep the entire body total along with energy way up.
    Increase extra fat, similar to almonds, organic olive oil, and avocado. Employ these types of modestly.
    A lot of clean up, entire vegetables.

    I'd furthermore adjust ones physical exercises in order to something such as this kind of:
    Mon: Friday: half-hour fasted aerobic (empty stomach) very first thing every day. Evenings, accomplish 20-30 min aerobic furthermore lifting using a unique lean muscle class.
    Weekend or maybe Sunday: Perform HIIT aerobic every day. This really is substantial power time period education.
  • yogayug
    yogayug Posts: 15
    Recall, individual mentors and bunch exercise educators don't have much if any sustenance training. Afterward, ask him where he got his degree in dietetics in light of the fact that I surety you he doesn't have one. Individuals in all callings, http://www.yogayug.com/
  • EricJonrosh
    EricJonrosh Posts: 823 Member
    What he meant to say was: "I have no sales skills and my product sucks, so I have to lie."
  • mj428
    mj428 Posts: 5
    Protein helps gain muscle!! But if your feeling all fat, bloated, chk your protein. If you paid 15 bucks for it there is your answer.. Just like everything else there is a quality.
  • Elleinnz
    Elleinnz Posts: 1,661 Member
    115 lbs lost drinking two whey protein shakes on workout days - which can be from 3 to 6 days a week!!
    And obviously eating at a deficit most of the time ;-)
  • heatherbrosigyaskow
    heatherbrosigyaskow Posts: 28 Member
    My personal trainer has me drink protein before and after my appt with her. She said that it will help with muscle and weight lose. So far I've gone down one size.
  • Unknown
    Unknown
    This content has been removed.
This discussion has been closed.

Categories

Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!