Sugar, sugar-HELP!
Terpnista84
Posts: 517 Member
I am really struggling with my sugar intake. I always go over. I'm making the effort to cut it down- no more added sugar and using a lot of splenda substitute. But I like my SlimFast as a meal replacement/snack/post-workout meal and my low-fat Edy's ice-cream occasionally to keep me sane and to reach my calorie goal on some days. And of course adding fruit puts me over my limit though I have heard not to count the sugar in fruits.
If I focus on a calorie deficit, do I need to worry if my sugar intake is still over what MFP recommends.
If I focus on a calorie deficit, do I need to worry if my sugar intake is still over what MFP recommends.
0
Replies
-
Do you have a medical condition that requires you to limit your sugar intake?
If you answered yes - then you should watch your sugar intake (according to your doctor's recommendations).
If you answered no - then you just need to worry about a calorie deficit for weight loss.0 -
Lora, you have made my day!
I don't have any medical condition to my knowledge. But I do worry when I hear about people who struggled to lose weight despite their calorie deficit because of the TYPES of food they ate.0 -
If you don't have a medical reason to watch your sugar I wouldn't worry about it provided most of your sugar is coming from fruits. I regularly go over my sugar before breakfast is done due to fruit.
For slimfast, they are not very nutritous (at least the ones I've seen). I used to keep one in my purse to drink as opposed to stopping for fast food if I was out and was hungry. What about making your own shake that gives you better nutrients? You could make a fruit flavoured on with some water, yogurt, and some fruit. Blended up makes a great smoothie. If you prefer the chocolate one a great shake is some cocoa powder, milk, and maybe some greek yogurt for protein. I personally wouldn't use slimfast after a workout since they don't have much protein (again, at least the ones I've seen around me). A regular protein shake might be better and you can get lower sugar varieties.0 -
I am ALWAYS over but its all natural i stopped tracking sugar and just made sure its from healthy places0
-
Hi,
I removed fruit from my sugar count. I eat blueberries [1/8 cup] and an apple every day. I think the benefits outweigh the negatives--all other sugar counts in my daily tab and I work hard to try to keep within my goals. It is a challenge but worth it.
Good luck!0 -
i struggle with the same, but im not yet ready to try anything to stop it lol im a stubborn person. i will say one thing. it may take longer to lose the weight if you consume too many sugars ( at least thats how my body reacts.) and if you really like your slim fasts, try finding a low sugar protien power. and make it with fat free milk or almond milk. you get more protien fron the powder and you also get less sugars, :-) good luck0
-
Sugar is just a carb. As long as you're eating enough fats and protein, your carbs/sugar aren't important unless you have a medical issue that requires carbs/sugar to be monitored. As long as you're under your calorie goal, you'll lose weight. Some people find that sugar (even from fruit) causes them to have more sugar/carb cravings. If this isn't the case for you there's no need to limit sugar.0
-
I use up a lot of my carbs, and sugar, w/my slightly sweetened tea. I can't use non-sugar sweeteners, because they give me migraines. What I don't like is that I'm using up carb calories with processed sugar, that I could be replacing with healthy carbs...veggies, fruits, whole grains. So I'm slowly cutting down my tea & increasing water. Another reason to cut back..."scientists now know that sugar is almost as big a culprit in heart disease as dietary fat. Sugar raises levels of blood fats & LDL (bad) cholesterol. Also damages the linings of blood vessels, raising the risk for stroke, heart attack, high blood pressure, & triglyceride levels." Just because you don't have medical issues now, doesn't mean you couldn't develop them, or just try to be healthy anyway.
Try to make little changes, that bring your sugar down gradually. Maybe try to find a meal replacement that has less sugar, just buy one of each at the store to give them a try. Same thing w/the ice cream, read the labels & try the brands that have less sugar to see if you might like them even better than the Edy's.
KEEP Looking for Little Changes That Can Make a Big Difference...I eat yogurt for breakfast. Used to only like Yoplait Original (170 calories/5 g protein/2g fat), kept trying new Greek yogurts as they came out & finally found one I liked, Oikos Traditional (160 calories/11g protein/5g fat). Saw a new Greek yogurt & decided to give it a try & really like it...Fage Total 0% w/Raspberry (120 calories/13g protein/0g fat). So w/gradual changes, I've cut 50 mostly fat calories from my breakfast, but more than doubled my protein intake. Everyone has different tastes, find something YOU like, but don't close the door to a healthy upgrade as new products come out.0 -
No Sugar Added icecream sucks. BUT!!!! No Sugar Added Icecream treats (Icecream sandwiches, fudgepops, etc) have been my sanity saver. I need to at least 'think' I am eating chocolate occasionally. At 3-6 g of suger they are a nice occasional treat.0
-
I took a peek at your diary and it looks like the majority of your sugar is coming from whole sources. (Fruits, etc.). So I wouldn't worry too much about it.0
-
Thanks so much everyone!
I wish I hadn't gotten the Slim Fast but I bought a 20 count case from Sam's Club so I am stuck with them lol. I wanted to make my own protein shakes but I'm not a fan of the taste and they aren't as convenient. Oh well.
I am definitely going to try to monitor my sugar intake but I won't be hard on myself if I go over. I've done a good job eliminating added sugar and adjusting to splenda. I don't eat any granulated sugar or white flour so some fruit and low-fat ice-cream shouldn't hurt me too bad.0 -
I definately don't think sugar in it's natural form found in God given whole foods is an issue. I agree with the others, the benefits (fiber) far outways the sugar.0
-
I use up a lot of my carbs, and sugar, w/my slightly sweetened tea. I can't use non-sugar sweeteners, because they give me migraines. What I don't like is that I'm using up carb calories with processed sugar, that I could be replacing with healthy carbs...veggies, fruits, whole grains. So I'm slowly cutting down my tea & increasing water. Another reason to cut back..."scientists now know that sugar is almost as big a culprit in heart disease as dietary fat. Sugar raises levels of blood fats & LDL (bad) cholesterol. Also damages the linings of blood vessels, raising the risk for stroke, heart attack, high blood pressure, & triglyceride levels." Just because you don't have medical issues now, doesn't mean you couldn't develop them, or just try to be healthy anyway.
Try to make little changes, that bring your sugar down gradually. Maybe try to find a meal replacement that has less sugar, just buy one of each at the store to give them a try. Same thing w/the ice cream, read the labels & try the brands that have less sugar to see if you might like them even better than the Edy's.
KEEP Looking for Little Changes That Can Make a Big Difference...I eat yogurt for breakfast. Used to only like Yoplait Original (170 calories/5 g protein/2g fat), kept trying new Greek yogurts as they came out & finally found one I liked, Oikos Traditional (160 calories/11g protein/5g fat). Saw a new Greek yogurt & decided to give it a try & really like it...Fage Total 0% w/Raspberry (120 calories/13g protein/0g fat). So w/gradual changes, I've cut 50 mostly fat calories from my breakfast, but more than doubled my protein intake. Everyone has different tastes, find something YOU like, but don't close the door to a healthy upgrade as new products come out.
I'm definitely conscious of my yogurt so I bought one container of plain greek and add splenda to it. I also have low-fat dannon vanilla. Eventually I'll eliminate that and try to stick with the greek (it is so bitter though).
I'll look into finding another ice-cream replacement. Right now the Edy's is pretty good for ice-cream, it has about 4grams of fat. But I am always looking to do better.0 -
It doesn't need to alwyas be plain, I LOVE the vanilla. I got used to the differant texture and taste pretty fast. When I was pregnant with the twins I got gestational diabetes and my dietician got me hooked on it. Haven't switched back once.0
-
I was finding on other boards too that MFP standards can be low. I just changed my % to 40-30-30 (which when you select 40 it changed the others to 30-30 automatically). Only been a day but does seem more reasonable.0
-
I was finding on other boards too that MFP standards can be low. I just changed my % to 40-30-30 (which when you select 40 it changed the others to 30-30 automatically). Only been a day but does seem more reasonable.
I manually changed my % to 50-25-25 based on more current recommendations than MFP seems to be using.
OP...you might also want to try switching your artificial sweetener from Splenda to stevia (Truvia). It's more natural, doesn't seem to have the negative health effects like some report w/Splenda, & still 0 calories.0 -
MFP is harsh on the sugar and sodium intakes. It seems that if you eat 4 servings of fruit and 1 serving of carbs you are at double your intake already. Don't measure it Life should be more sweet than that...0
-
Do you have a medical condition that requires you to limit your sugar intake?
If you answered yes - then you should watch your sugar intake (according to your doctor's recommendations).
If you answered no - then you just need to worry about a calorie deficit for weight loss.
Even if a person doesn't have a medical condition now, that doesn't mean that taking in too much sugar in the present cannot cause one in the future. I think it's very important for a person's health to limit refined sugar intake, even too much fruit intake can cause problems. I would try to reduce your sugar and artificial sweetener intake, it may not be what you want to hear, but processed foods aren't the road to healthiness.0 -
I eat mostly clean- hardly eat any processed foods.0
-
Do you have a medical condition that requires you to limit your sugar intake?
If you answered yes - then you should watch your sugar intake (according to your doctor's recommendations).
If you answered no - then you just need to worry about a calorie deficit for weight loss.
Even if a person doesn't have a medical condition now, that doesn't mean that taking in too much sugar in the present cannot cause one in the future. I think it's very important for a person's health to limit refined sugar intake, even too much fruit intake can cause problems. I would try to reduce your sugar and artificial sweetener intake, it may not be what you want to hear, but processed foods aren't the road to healthiness.
Care to enlighten us to the conditions we will get sweet cheeks?0 -
I cut out sugar a couple or years ago and found that I had to cut out the artificial sweeteners as well. they are much sweeter than natural sugar & actually increased my cravings. I lost 50 lbs in 6 months when I did this. I started eating sweets again last year after a stressful time and have now gained most of that back. I honestly believe keeping sugar low is the key, at least FOR ME.
ps I don't include fruit in my sugar intake, but limit them to berries, or low glycemic fruit.0 -
MFP is harsh on the sugar and sodium intakes. It seems that if you eat 4 servings of fruit and 1 serving of carbs you are at double your intake already. Don't measure it Life should be more sweet than that...0
-
I cut out sugar a couple or years ago and found that I had to cut out the artificial sweeteners as well. they are much sweeter than natural sugar & actually increased my cravings. I lost 50 lbs in 6 months when I did this. I started eating sweets again last year after a stressful time and have now gained most of that back. I honestly believe keeping sugar low is the key, at least FOR ME.
ps I don't include fruit in my sugar intake, but limit them to berries, or low glycemic fruit.0 -
I do try to make healthy choices as far as sugars are concerned... but recently, I made the decision to hide my sugar intake on MFP. It's enough that I am trying to stay within my Carbs/Protein/Fats, I don't need the extra stress of seeing the sugars in red everyday.0
-
I do try to make healthy choices as far as sugars are concerned... but recently, I made the decision to hide my sugar intake on MFP. It's enough that I am trying to stay within my Carbs/Protein/Fats, I don't need the extra stress of seeing the sugars in red everyday.
My thoughts exactly!! LOL I just removed it too.0 -
Even milk was sending me over my limit. I knew then that these settings were ridiculous lol0
-
Lora, you have made my day!
I don't have any medical condition to my knowledge. But I do worry when I hear about people who struggled to lose weight despite their calorie deficit because of the TYPES of food they ate.
No, a calorie IS a calorie but eating sugar tends to increase appetite and is heavily involved with "food addiction". http://www.foodaddictionsummit.org/presenters-johnson.htm
As sugar is metabolized, the body is drained of important nutrients--minerals in particular, like magnesium which can make it more difficult to use body fat for energy. Because women have 2 to 3 times the blood levels of leptin (a hormone put out by body fat that tells you when to quit eating) than men (even at the same level of body fat) leptin resistance is much more of a problem for women than men. Eating simple sugars and starch tend to increase leptin-resistance. And most or all obese women have leptin resistance. Leptin resistance precedes and predicts insulin resistance in later years. You would be better off without sugar, if you can do it.0 -
Even milk was sending me over my limit. I knew then that these settings were ridiculous lol
Milk has galactose and contributes to blood glucose levels but you don't take the metabolic hit with galactose that you do with sucrose or fructose. If you OD'd on galactose, you might get diarrhea but that's about it. Sugar (sucrose) is a whole different kettle of fish. Most of the fructose that we take in, comes from our sugar habit (sucrose is 50% fructose and 50% glucose). Fructose in the small amounts that we take in through a couple of servings of fruit is not a problem. But sugar consumption (the average American takes in 500 calories a day in added sucrose or high fructose corn syrup per day) is a real problem. Virtually all processed food contains some added sugar and a LOT of salt (I suppose they add it to cover up the too sweet taste from the added sugar). One of the problems with the "total sugar" approach that they use at MFP is that it doesn't distinguish the types of sugar. It is sucrose and fructose that must be watched. Obesity researchers suggest that obese persons (or persons trying to lose body fat) limit their fructose consumption to 15 grams or less per day. You can calculate it by hand--that's what I do. I ignore galactose or dextrose (the industry name for glucose). I generally eat lower carb anyway so high blood glucose isn't a problem for me. Interestingly, researchers have recently noted that obese folk seem to be able to efficiently convert high blood glucose into fructose! So watching total carbs is important too--especially if one is experiencing higher blood glucose levels than in the past.0 -
Even milk was sending me over my limit. I knew then that these settings were ridiculous lol
Milk has galactose and contributes to blood glucose levels but you don't take the metabolic hit with galactose that you do with sucrose or fructose. If you OD'd on galactose, you might get diarrhea but that's about it. Sugar (sucrose) is a whole different kettle of fish. Most of the fructose that we take in, comes from our sugar habit (sucrose is 50% fructose and 50% glucose). Fructose in the small amounts that we take in through a couple of servings of fruit is not a problem. But sugar consumption (the average American takes in 500 calories a day in added sucrose or high fructose corn syrup per day) is a real problem. Virtually all processed food contains some added sugar and a LOT of salt (I suppose they add it to cover up the too sweet taste from the added sugar). One of the problems with the "total sugar" approach that they use at MFP is that it doesn't distinguish the types of sugar. It is sucrose and fructose that must be watched. Obesity researchers suggest that obese persons (or persons trying to lose body fat) limit their fructose consumption to 15 grams or less per day. You can calculate it by hand--that's what I do. I ignore galactose or dextrose (the industry name for glucose). I generally eat lower carb anyway so high blood glucose isn't a problem for me. Interestingly, researchers have recently noted that obese folk seem to be able to efficiently convert high blood glucose into fructose! So watching total carbs is important too--especially if one is experiencing higher blood glucose levels than in the past.
Pero... hablas ingles?
I like Almond Breeze Almond Milk... I think it only has like 1g of sugar.0 -
Even milk was sending me over my limit. I knew then that these settings were ridiculous lol
Milk has galactose and contributes to blood glucose levels but you don't take the metabolic hit with galactose that you do with sucrose or fructose. If you OD'd on galactose, you might get diarrhea but that's about it. Sugar (sucrose) is a whole different kettle of fish. Most of the fructose that we take in, comes from our sugar habit (sucrose is 50% fructose and 50% glucose). Fructose in the small amounts that we take in through a couple of servings of fruit is not a problem. But sugar consumption (the average American takes in 500 calories a day in added sucrose or high fructose corn syrup per day) is a real problem. Virtually all processed food contains some added sugar and a LOT of salt (I suppose they add it to cover up the too sweet taste from the added sugar). One of the problems with the "total sugar" approach that they use at MFP is that it doesn't distinguish the types of sugar. It is sucrose and fructose that must be watched. Obesity researchers suggest that obese persons (or persons trying to lose body fat) limit their fructose consumption to 15 grams or less per day. You can calculate it by hand--that's what I do. I ignore galactose or dextrose (the industry name for glucose). I generally eat lower carb anyway so high blood glucose isn't a problem for me. Interestingly, researchers have recently noted that obese folk seem to be able to efficiently convert high blood glucose into fructose! So watching total carbs is important too--especially if one is experiencing higher blood glucose levels than in the past.
I consume daily high amounts of sugar due to the amount of fruit I consume. My breakfast alone sends me skyrockting over the sugar amounts here on MFP. Regularly I am twice or triple the suggested amount here yet I lose weight perfectly fine. Fruitarians lose weight fine most times and consume incredibly large amounts of fruit everyday.
Sugar is sugar. Fructose, or sugar coming from fruit obviously comes with a lot more nutrients than refined or added sugar. I fail to see how limiting your fruit sugars will cause you to lose more weight... or gain if you are consuming a lot of fruit. I lose better now that most of my intake is fruit than I did before.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions