Gym teacher makes 9th Graders do Insanity Workout
Topsking2010
Posts: 2,245 Member
in Chit-Chat
Just found out that my friend's daughter who is 14 years old had to do an Insanity workout at school this past Friday. Apparently the gym teacher made all the students do this very demanding workout. This is crazy especially since this is a workout program for people 18 years or older. The teacher didn't even ask the parents permission to teach this workout program!!
As you can imagine the kids were struggling after 2 minutes of doing Insanity. Also the teacher plans to do more programs.
Don't get me wrong kids needs physical activity but extreme programs are not appropriate for kids.
My friend is going to meet with the principal of the school to discuss this issue.
Are there any parents out there who kids are doing Insanity or P90X in school?
As you can imagine the kids were struggling after 2 minutes of doing Insanity. Also the teacher plans to do more programs.
Don't get me wrong kids needs physical activity but extreme programs are not appropriate for kids.
My friend is going to meet with the principal of the school to discuss this issue.
Are there any parents out there who kids are doing Insanity or P90X in school?
0
Replies
-
Bump0
-
My son is in 7th grade(13 years old) and does Insanity everyday in P.E.
0 -
Geez, whatever happened to teaching kids how to play basketball, floor hockey, soccer, volleyball, etc.? It seems to me like their PE teachers are slacking in their curriculum design. While not all kids are great at sports and sure, you will get kids that prefer to do as much standing around as possible rather than participating, you can make 'em do laps! That way, your course at least encourages physical activity without falling back on high-intensity mass-marketed workout videos (that aren't really approved for anyone under 18).0
-
I agree P.E. teachers should design a workout program that is suitable for kids. Doing Insanity or P90X is ridiculous especially without the parents contest.0
-
What part of the program do you disagree with?0
-
When I was in middle school, we did Tae-Bo workouts. Not exactly on the same scale as insanity, but still an intense workout non the less for middle schoolers.
Frankly, I'd rather see kids doing Insanity, then I do taking away gym in favor of academics. Plus if kids are in sports, I'm sure they do some form of polymeric training or weight lifting... just not to the extent of Insanity.0 -
I think this is probably more of an exposure to different types of workouts and less an exercise program. I am really hard on teens because they are are hardy bunch. You should definitely complain if they are doing something dangerous not if it a lesson in exposure or as part of series. Most kids are NOT going to push themselves like adult will. They will compete with each other but not really push themselves unless they really have to.
To be honest most 14 year old youths are going to protest most forms of exercise. Most don't even like to change for gym.
To them, sports and normal games may seem childish. Also, student themselves are curious about are different types of alternative workout out there and its the PE teacher job to expose them to wellness they can take with them outside of school.
What if the teacher taught them zumba next week or did swimming after that and your youth hated dancing and did not want to mess up their blowout and so told you how "hard" this class was? I think flag football is quite violent but I am not going to pull my kids out of PE class. It's good to expose them. Fitness and being physically active is something that is NOT normal for today's kids. It's not like it was when I was younger.
I think being exposed to different types of exercise is not bad thing and will not hurt your youth. I am pretty sure that that PE teacher was likely just exposing youth. Usually doing something 3-5 times is really the only way to find out if it works for you.
Jumping to complain right away might only teach your youth that if they wine enough...mommy and daddy will get them out of them pushing themselves. I would make the suggestion to speak to the PE teacher about the rational of doing this type of work out and I also follow up with your youth about why they did not participate or their feelings on it.
If you truly feel you understand the situation and rational and still feel the teacher is truly doing something uncalled for then DEFINITELY take it to principal.
I hope this makes sense....:flowerforyou:0 -
I WISH i could do Insanity at school. It's better than sitting around just goofing off.0
-
They have probably banned team sports in most schools because its not fair for the kids that aren't good at them (stupid rules of parents who's kids are nonathletic) ... So they are forced to try to do something new, and because some states have banned physical fitness testing because its not fair, and running because some kids cant and its not fair, i think this teacher is taking a chance on doing something good for these kids, and soon that will get banned to and PE will turn into social hour with one flat dodge ball that isn't allowed to be thrown because some kid might by chance get hit and think they are being targeted by a bully and the school will have to close down. END RANT sorry I am not a parent yet so I cant fully understand the whole making sure everything is fair for your kid, but I think its also important that kids learn lift isn't fair, and just because one kid isn't good at something doesn't mean every other kid has to miss out on it.0
-
All the kids got fat doing it...Geez, whatever happened to teaching kids how to play basketball, floor hockey, soccer, volleyball, etc.?0 -
My daughter is 13 and runs 7th grade track. They began their conditioning practices with Insanity. I had no problems with it at all. In fact, my daughter was very proud of herself for doing it. I see no problem with kids doing Insanity as long as they are monitored and not made to feel bad if they can't keep up with it at first.0
-
I see nothing wrong with this as long as the kids are closely monitored. I told my principal I would conduct workout for the kids in ISS if he's liked. He declined but he himself does insanity so I have to wonder what he was thinking.
Todays children do not get near the exercise we did when we were kids. I say go for it.0 -
It wouldn't bother me if my son was doing Insanity or some other intense PE class. I don't have firsthand experience with Insanity, so I can't be sure of what the workouts are like, but I doubt it's too much for a teenager to handle.
Like someone else asked, I'm also curious what the problem is, exactly?0 -
I agree P.E. teachers should design a workout program that is suitable for kids. Doing Insanity or P90X is ridiculous especially without the parents contest.
Really? They have weight lifting as a competative sport in High school. Is that not "suitable" for kids. And honestly, I am glad that the P.E. programs are shifting to a more fitness related approach. Honestly, how many kids continue playing kick ball past high school? How many kids do you think would take fitness (weight lifting, cardio, etc...) and continue it on past high school? I am going to think you will have a lot more kids continuing on with the fitness rather than the kick ball. I hope that teacher get P.E. teacher of the year for that. It is obvious that they are taking what they supposed to teach seriously and get the children involved.
And honestly, I would think at school would be the best place to teach it. My P.E. teachers were also physical trainers, meaning they were the PTs at all the games. So you have PTs and nurses at the school in case anything goes wrong.0 -
Considering how little physical exercise kids get nowadays and rampant childhood obesity, they probably need something like Insanity in PE.
Not really sure what the complaint is here. You want to give consent for your kid to do something more than LOLJUMPINGJACKS?
I complained about the jumping jacks and windmills when I was in PE. I complained about field day. I would have complained about Insanity. Hell, I complained about having to sit outside on the bleachers while watching the other kids do crap. Why? Because I was a teenager and complaining about everything it what teenagers do.
Hopefully, your kid will get something out of that program other than your whining.0 -
I think this is probably more of an exposure to different types of workouts and less an exercise program. I am really hard on teens because they are are hardy bunch. You should definitely complain if they are doing something dangerous not if it a lesson in exposure or as part of series. Most kids are NOT going to push themselves like adult will. They will compete with each other but not really push themselves unless they really have to.
To be honest most 14 year old youths are going to protest most forms of exercise. Most don't even like to change for gym.
To them, sports and normal games may seem childish. Also, student themselves are curious about are different types of alternative workout out there and its the PE teacher job to expose them to wellness they can take with them outside of school.
What if the teacher taught them zumba next week or did swimming after that and your youth hated dancing and did not want to mess up their blowout and so told you how "hard" this class was? I think flag football is quite violent but I am not going to pull my kids out of PE class. It's good to expose them. Fitness and being physically active is something that is NOT normal for today's kids. It's not like it was when I was younger.
I think being exposed to different types of exercise is not bad thing and will not hurt your youth. I am pretty sure that that PE teacher was likely just exposing youth. Usually doing something 3-5 times is really the only way to find out if it works for you.
Jumping to complain right away might only teach your youth that if they wine enough...mommy and daddy will get them out of them pushing themselves. I would make the suggestion to speak to the PE teacher about the rational of doing this type of work out and I also follow up with your youth about why they did not participate or their feelings on it.
If you truly feel you understand the situation and rational and still feel the teacher is truly doing something uncalled for then DEFINITELY take it to principal.
I hope this makes sense....:flowerforyou:
this. Except i really hope the kids't don't wine
I hated PE. Hated it, it wasn't fun, it wasn't challenging, I sucked at most of it and I skipped it as often as I possibly could. Except for the times when the class consisted of walking to the donut shop and back. Because, really, that happened.0 -
What part of the program do you disagree with?
I agree kids need a workout program but Insanity is for adults.
The school should have informed the parents about the program and requested permission to participate.0 -
My brothers both did P90X in high school, but they did them after school as part of their JROTC and wrestling workouts. PE class for me in high school 10+ years ago was a joke. I would've loved to do Insanity or at least something that got us to sweat during the class time.0
-
I am so happy to see the general consensus on here supporting the teacher. PE is such a joke today. as much as it was when I was in it 30 yrs ago. The teachers don't want to be there. the kids don't want to be there. My son is spec ed and he sits in the stands and watches the boys play dodgeball while the girls stand around talking. Some days they literally sit on the gym floor the whole time doing nothing. Kudos for a teacher who is actually getting the kids into an active program that they can continue thru HS. Perhaps the obesity rate will go down in that school.0
-
What part of the program do you disagree with?
I agree kids need a workout program but Insanity is for adults.
The school should have informed the parents about the program and requested permission to participate.
Same thing could be said about weight lifting, but they still teach it. It is not -FOR- adults. You have to be an adult to buy it. You seem to think that kids won't be able to do it, or can't do it. I would like to see some kids doing Insanity next to you, would probably show you up.0 -
I hated PE, but we just played sports. I wasn't a sporty kid (I was the fat kid).
My son is in 2nd grade, and they do sit ups, squats, push ups, pull ups, planks... I'm proud to say he's won more than one push up competition.
He isn't just standing around with a floor hockey stick (although, he's crazy active so I'd imagine he wouldn't just stand there).. and he's fit.
There are so many complaints about how overweight everyone is now, but once someone steps up to get kids moving, arms go up. Can't win 'em all!0 -
Considering how little physical exercise kids get nowadays and rampant childhood obesity, they probably need something like Insanity in PE.
Not really sure what the complaint is here. You want to give consent for your kid to do something more than LOLJUMPINGJACKS?
I complained about the jumping jacks and windmills when I was in PE. I complained about field day. I would have complained about Insanity. Hell, I complained about having to sit outside on the bleachers while watching the other kids do crap. Why? Because I was a teenager and complaining about everything it what teenagers do.
Hopefully, your kid will get something out of that program other than your whining.
Exactly!0 -
My kid is on the volleyball team and just did 15 pullups in her PE test.
She also did 25 regular pushups. Fitness is not an issue for her.
Unfortunately most kids are not in good shape but its the parents responsibility to get their child in shape.0 -
In my senior year of high school, my gym teacher had us girls do Tae Bo workouts. I actually preferred that over basketball or any other cruddy sport.0
-
What part of the program do you disagree with?
I agree kids need a workout program but Insanity is for adults.
The school should have informed the parents about the program and requested permission to participate.
Same thing could be said about weight lifting, but they still teach it. It is not -FOR- adults. You have to be an adult to buy it. You seem to think that kids won't be able to do it, or can't do it. I would like to see some kids doing Insanity next to you, would probably show you up.
^This
It's marketed for adults. Kids would find it far, far easier.
Plus:
I more meant what specific aspect/exercise of the program do you think is not appropriate for exercising 9th graders?0 -
when I was a kid, my judo coaches used to make us do things that were basically like crossfit, but without the fancy branding. It was fun. I would have been delighted to do that in PE instead of rounders and netball.
I agree with the person who said about diversity and exposure to different kinds of sports, exercise, workouts etc. One of the big problems with PE in my generation, was that if you weren't good at or didn't enjoy the standard sports (which were gender coded back the, because I would have loved football (soccer), cricket and rugby, but the girls were stuck with netball, rounders and on rare occasions field hockey), then you got the message that sport and exercise was not for you and spent your life skipping PE and getting unfit and seeing yourself as someone that wasn't into sport. I was someone who was into sport and very active, but I hated PE at school, because we never got to play any sports that I actually liked. If even I hated PE, then kids who never got to play much sport outside of school didn't stand much chance of liking PE and getting into any kind of exercise they liked.
A PE programme that includes a whole range of sport and exercise, including competitive and non-competitive, team and individual, is necessary so all kids have a good chance of finding something that they enjoy, and carry on with it outside of school and after leaving school. Additionally, PE should get kids into increasing physical fitness and being active generally.0 -
I say good job to the Coach/P.E. teacher. We need Educators who care about the children. Our Nation today as a whole is overweight and LAZY! I've seen P.E. classes where girls just sit in the bleachers and the guys goof off because some coaches just don't care. So, I give this guy some credit for ,at the minimum, exposing these kids to exercise.0
-
The teacher was wrong not to inform the parents about the program!!
My kid is very fit but the others are not!!!
Are any of you doing Insanity?0 -
What part of the program do you disagree with?
I agree kids need a workout program but Insanity is for adults.
The school should have informed the parents about the program and requested permission to participate.
Why is Insanity for adults? Is there some sort of X rated stuff happening that I'm not aware of?0 -
The teacher was wrong not to inform the parents about the program!!
My kid is very fit but the others are not!!!
Are any of you doing Insanity?
At the begining of the year, you sign permision slips for the children when they go into PE. You also are asked to APPROVE your child's schedule. Sorry, but I don't think "The teacher was wrong" because you knew that they were going to do something physically active in the class.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions