Will squats make my thighs bigger?
Replies
-
I'm loving the legs in this thread!! I would MUCH RATHER have thighs a little bit bigger but firmer. I am a firm believer in lifting heavy, I've seen the results.
In my case, my genetics gave me flabby thighs. My mom has them, my sister has them, her mother before her, etc..
As someone else said, mostly it is diet - but diet can't reshape your body like lifting can - it has to be used in conjunction with a good lifting plan. When I was eating like a bird and weighed nothing I was just a flabby mess.
I was 103-105 pounds here and HATED my legs. Even though I was a skinny minny, my legs were still flabby. All I did back then were some light weights (DVDs) and the elliptical trainer, and my diet was low calorie/1000-1200 daily. See pic below. My legs were small by measurements, 19 inches at biggest part of thigh. And by the way, this was 7 years ago.
Now, I hardly do any cardio, only a couple sessions of HIIT per week, I lift heavy 3x a week, squats, deadlifts, you name it. Very little cellulite, and I eat WAY more. I weigh 6-7 pounds more, wear the same size clothing, and my measurements are 19.5 inches now. And now I wear short dresses, shorts, etc and I'm confident in them! I wish I could go back to the old me and tell me to lift weights! I spent years being dissatisfied. I wasted all of my 20's and early 30's away! :sad:
You look great! This post is so motivating. I was starting to give up on getting rid of cellulite but you ladies just encouraged me to keep working at it.0 -
there are ways to elongate muscle, instead of bulking muscle (weight / rep range combos, different resistant / impact levels, amt of work on a particular muscle group, etc). And these are definately ideas someone should look it to.
Muscles cannot be "elongated." We aren't Gumby.0 -
Stealing this!0 -
Great Job Jen!0
-
I'm loving the legs in this thread!! I would MUCH RATHER have thighs a little bit bigger but firmer. I am a firm believer in lifting heavy, I've seen the results.
In my case, my genetics gave me flabby thighs. My mom has them, my sister has them, her mother before her, etc..
As someone else said, mostly it is diet - but diet can't reshape your body like lifting can - it has to be used in conjunction with a good lifting plan. When I was eating like a bird and weighed nothing I was just a flabby mess.
I was 103-105 pounds here and HATED my legs. Even though I was a skinny minny, my legs were still flabby. All I did back then were some light weights (DVDs) and the elliptical trainer, and my diet was low calorie/1000-1200 daily. See pic below. My legs were small by measurements, 19 inches at biggest part of thigh. And by the way, this was 7 years ago.
Now, I hardly do any cardio, only a couple sessions of HIIT per week, I lift heavy 3x a week, squats, deadlifts, you name it. Very little cellulite, and I eat WAY more. I weigh 6-7 pounds more, wear the same size clothing, and my measurements are 19.5 inches now. And now I wear short dresses, shorts, etc and I'm confident in them! I wish I could go back to the old me and tell me to lift weights! I spent years being dissatisfied. I wasted all of my 20's and early 30's away! :sad:
best exemple ever0 -
I'm loving the legs in this thread!! I would MUCH RATHER have thighs a little bit bigger but firmer. I am a firm believer in lifting heavy, I've seen the results.
In my case, my genetics gave me flabby thighs. My mom has them, my sister has them, her mother before her, etc..
As someone else said, mostly it is diet - but diet can't reshape your body like lifting can - it has to be used in conjunction with a good lifting plan. When I was eating like a bird and weighed nothing I was just a flabby mess.
I was 103-105 pounds here and HATED my legs. Even though I was a skinny minny, my legs were still flabby. All I did back then were some light weights (DVDs) and the elliptical trainer, and my diet was low calorie/1000-1200 daily. See pic below. My legs were small by measurements, 19 inches at biggest part of thigh. And by the way, this was 7 years ago.
Now, I hardly do any cardio, only a couple sessions of HIIT per week, I lift heavy 3x a week, squats, deadlifts, you name it. Very little cellulite, and I eat WAY more. I weigh 6-7 pounds more, wear the same size clothing, and my measurements are 19.5 inches now. And now I wear short dresses, shorts, etc and I'm confident in them! I wish I could go back to the old me and tell me to lift weights! I spent years being dissatisfied. I wasted all of my 20's and early 30's away! :sad:
You look fantastic!!!0 -
I've been lifting for almost a year, and I like looking and feeling strong. However, it's ridiculous to say that people that don't want my type of muscle definition are stupid or misinformed. Some people (women in particular) would rather be and look a little soft, even if that means they have a little more wiggle in their walk. As long as they're healthy, why do you care? You don't want to look like them, and they don't want to look like you. The end.
Way to miss the entire point of the thread, beginning to end.
The point was that lifting will make your legs (thighs in particular) firmer and smaller, rather than "big and bulky".
"Looking soft" has to do with your body fat percentage. I lift heavy weights and look "soft", as my BF% isn't low enough to look hard or ripped at this point. I wiggle!
Nobody seems offended by this, and I'm certainly not offended by anyone who has a harder, tighter body than me, just as I'm not offended by someone with more body fat than I have, who is even wigglier and jigglier.
What bothers me are comments suggesting women who lift weights are "masculine", "bulky", and generally undesirable. I'm bothered by women jumping up to object to the MANY positive benefits of lifting weights, and the (YES) misinformed women who will discourage others from lifting by telling them they'll get big and bulky, masculine, etc. They are indeed misinformed if that's what they believe. There's no two ways about that, sorry.0 -
Your legs are fabulous. Great work to all of you that have changed your bodies for the better by lifting. Sounds great to me....I just don't know where to start.0
-
I've been lifting for almost a year, and I like looking and feeling strong. However, it's ridiculous to say that people that don't want my type of muscle definition are stupid or misinformed. Some people (women in particular) would rather be and look a little soft, even if that means they have a little more wiggle in their walk. As long as they're healthy, why do you care? You don't want to look like them, and they don't want to look like you. The end.
Way to miss the entire point of the thread, beginning to end.
The point was that lifting will make your legs (thighs in particular) firmer and smaller, rather than "big and bulky".
"Looking soft" has to do with your body fat percentage. I lift heavy weights and look "soft", as my BF% isn't low enough to look hard or ripped at this point. I wiggle!
Nobody seems offended by this, and I'm certainly not offended by anyone who has a harder, tighter body than me, just as I'm not offended by someone with more body fat than I have, who is even wigglier and jigglier.
What bothers me are comments suggesting women who lift weights are "masculine", "bulky", and generally undesirable. I'm bothered by women jumping up to object to the MANY positive benefits of lifting weights, and the (YES) misinformed women who will discourage others from lifting by telling them they'll get big and bulky, masculine, etc. They are indeed misinformed if that's what they believe. There's no two ways about that, sorry.
I understand your point. But to some people the OP would probably be considered "bulky", and might serve as an example for women who do not want that aesthetic to not lift heavy. It's nothing personal, I'm a heavy squatter and tend to have "big thighs" but I get it that some women/men don't like that.0 -
Strong legs are awesome and you look great, OP.0
-
Out of all the B/A pictures, as a thunder thigh owner myself, these are the progress pics that inspire me most (along with the rest of the OP and all of her awesomeness)
I saw a picture of a woman on tumblr who started heavy lifting and the difference in her thigh/butt cellulite was insane despite her GAINING weight, blew me away since we're all told that "cellulite never goes away" I love it. I'd post the pic here but that would be creeperish of me.0 -
love this reminds me of a conversation I had a work yesterday. A girl was complaining of all the "muscle" she gained on her thighs from running a mile everyday.
It is SO annoying when people complain about something fitness related and they have NO idea what they are talking about!!!!
OMG this ^^^^ Especially when they complain that they never lose any weight and work out so much and you never them break a sweat on cardio or lift anything other than barbie pink dumbbells... Sorry for the rant but this hit a nerve after going to the gym this morning!0 -
I can attest. When I added in squats, jumps, all kinds of lunges & dead lifts blah blah, and I started losing fat on my thighs within a week!
YES my quads are bigger but umm I want the fat to go away and it is! I lost an inch already!
Slowly but surely. Plus Leg muscle is sexy. (I'm not a teenager, I don't want chicken legs, Thx)
I HATE HATE HATE HATE my fat thighs. They looks worse than the OP's original, but I'm sure I can make a difference in them now if I keep it up!
Thanks for this post. I did know it was working, but it motivates me even more to stick with it. I enjoy the workouts like this and I want so badly for my stupid thigh fat to go away.
yay! <3<30 -
I've been lifting for almost a year, and I like looking and feeling strong. However, it's ridiculous to say that people that don't want my type of muscle definition are stupid or misinformed. Some people (women in particular) would rather be and look a little soft, even if that means they have a little more wiggle in their walk. As long as they're healthy, why do you care? You don't want to look like them, and they don't want to look like you. The end.
Way to miss the entire point of the thread, beginning to end.
The point was that lifting will make your legs (thighs in particular) firmer and smaller, rather than "big and bulky".
"Looking soft" has to do with your body fat percentage. I lift heavy weights and look "soft", as my BF% isn't low enough to look hard or ripped at this point. I wiggle!
Nobody seems offended by this, and I'm certainly not offended by anyone who has a harder, tighter body than me, just as I'm not offended by someone with more body fat than I have, who is even wigglier and jigglier.
What bothers me are comments suggesting women who lift weights are "masculine", "bulky", and generally undesirable. I'm bothered by women jumping up to object to the MANY positive benefits of lifting weights, and the (YES) misinformed women who will discourage others from lifting by telling them they'll get big and bulky, masculine, etc. They are indeed misinformed if that's what they believe. There's no two ways about that, sorry.
I understand your point. But to some people the OP would probably be considered "bulky", and might serve as an example for women who do not want that aesthetic to not lift heavy. It's nothing personal, I'm a heavy squatter and tend to have "big thighs" but I get it that some women/men don't like that.
If the OP is "bulky" I don't want to live in this world anymore.0 -
Just wanted to contribute my experience on how shocked I was that squats didn't make my thighs bigger.
I'd always had proportionally bigger legs even when I was thin. I'd wear a size 2 top, but a size 6 jeans. (I know size 6 isn't big, the point is I was two sizes bigger on the bottom.) So I NEVER strength trained my legs in fear that they'd, well, get bigger.
Then I gained weight--all over--no longer a size 2 top, nor a size 6 bottom. When I tried to lose weight, I got on the heavy-lifting bandwagon (squats, deads, bench) after seeing all the MFP women's tremendous results.
And now? My husband married a woman who was fairly slender, but it is only NOW that he comments on how small my legs are.
Thank you, squat rack.0 -
Nice legs OP
It's women like you who have inspired me to begin lifting
I look forward to every session
Congratulations and Thank You!0 -
My apologies for the blanket post - but thank you guys so much for all your love! I appreciate it. I've received a ton of new friend requests and sadly I cannot accept anymore as I can't keep up with my list as it is. But I wanted to put this group link out here for anyone interested in lifting to transform their bodies - a group of like-minded people over here (if you aren't lifting yet, you betta start if you join! LOL) http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/12919-girls-who-lift-the-guys-who-spot-them
I'd love to support all of you but there are only so many hours in a day and I get limited time to myself these days. Also, for those asking how to get started - I highly recommend Mark Rippetoe's Starting Strength program. You start with the barbell and progressively add weight as you get stronger (or each workout). Google it! It covers the compound lifts that will help transform your body the most efficiently as a beginner. Stronglifts is similar but it's a couple more sets for each lift and if you are eating in a deficit, you may hit walls/stalls sooner (which leads to frustration, so I push Starting Strength more for women just starting out).0 -
very late bump for a very good thread0
-
My apologies for the blanket post - but thank you guys so much for all your love! I appreciate it. I've received a ton of new friend requests and sadly I cannot accept anymore as I can't keep up with my list as it is. But I wanted to put this group link out here for anyone interested in lifting to transform their bodies - a group of like-minded people over here (if you aren't lifting yet, you betta start if you join! LOL) http://www.myfitnesspal.com/groups/home/12919-girls-who-lift-the-guys-who-spot-them
I'd love to support all of you but there are only so many hours in a day and I get limited time to myself these days. Also, for those asking how to get started - I highly recommend Mark Rippetoe's Starting Strength program. You start with the barbell and progressively add weight as you get stronger (or each workout). Google it! It covers the compound lifts that will help transform your body the most efficiently as a beginner. Stronglifts is similar but it's a couple more sets for each lift and if you are eating in a deficit, you may hit walls/stalls sooner (which leads to frustration, so I push Starting Strength more for women just starting out).
this this this^^^0 -
It really depends on what you like. If you want to look strong as the OP does, then squats are ok, but if you're more into the lean long look, then avoid them and go running.
I'm sorry Casy. This is wrong. My wife runs, does not squat, and has strong, muscular legs. Her legs look great. But, they are strong.
Legs are going to look better whatever you do, if you do something. But you cannot worry about getting big legs by using them. A woman either has bigger, strong legs or she doesn't. They're not going to change much.0 -
I will add to this. Firs off to avoid being screamed at, OP your legs look great. I think strong legs look amazing, HOWEVER comma dot dot dot I prefer the lean ( not long) "scrawny" leg look ON MYSELF. I currently do not lift heavy but want to eventually! here comes the point of my post. I have been all over the weight chart throughout my life, I was 5'2 117 lbs quite a few years back, I squat, I love squatting. I think no matter what look you are going for squatting is essential. It gives you legs definition no matter who you are and what look you're trying to achieve. It works out your *kitten* too!0
-
Two things to add:
-OP, your legs look freaking amazing.
-If one more person says this is bulky, I'm going to kick you in the shins.
That is all.0 -
I honestly don't care how big or small my legs get as long as they're strong like tree trunks and the jiggle wiggle is gone! I used to want the thigh gap...but have learned better from all you heavy lifters Now lets squat!
totally agree. I don't care if my thighs forever stay at 25 inches as long as they become a firm 25 inches rather than soft and jiggly :P0 -
I've been lifting for almost a year, and I like looking and feeling strong. However, it's ridiculous to say that people that don't want my type of muscle definition are stupid or misinformed. Some people (women in particular) would rather be and look a little soft, even if that means they have a little more wiggle in their walk. As long as they're healthy, why do you care? You don't want to look like them, and they don't want to look like you. The end.
Way to miss the entire point of the thread, beginning to end.
The point was that lifting will make your legs (thighs in particular) firmer and smaller, rather than "big and bulky".
"Looking soft" has to do with your body fat percentage. I lift heavy weights and look "soft", as my BF% isn't low enough to look hard or ripped at this point. I wiggle!
Nobody seems offended by this, and I'm certainly not offended by anyone who has a harder, tighter body than me, just as I'm not offended by someone with more body fat than I have, who is even wigglier and jigglier.
What bothers me are comments suggesting women who lift weights are "masculine", "bulky", and generally undesirable. I'm bothered by women jumping up to object to the MANY positive benefits of lifting weights, and the (YES) misinformed women who will discourage others from lifting by telling them they'll get big and bulky, masculine, etc. They are indeed misinformed if that's what they believe. There's no two ways about that, sorry.
I understand your point. But to some people the OP would probably be considered "bulky", and might serve as an example for women who do not want that aesthetic to not lift heavy. It's nothing personal, I'm a heavy squatter and tend to have "big thighs" but I get it that some women/men don't like that.
You absolutely do not understand my point, or the point the OP made to you earlier in this thread when you said the same thing to her directly.
The point is that your genetics determine how your legs look, ultimately.
My legs don't look like the OPs. My legs don't really look like any of the legs posted in this thread. They look like my legs, just like your legs look like however your legs look. I can't transform my legs into long skinny things, no matter what I do. However, I CAN make them into the best legs they can be by strengthening my leg muscles and losing as much fat as I find desirable/sustainable. The amount of body fat one has is what will either cover the muscles (giving the appearance of softness) or show them off (lower amounts of body fat) as I said in my previous post.
Look at the other photos posted in this thread by women who squat! I think you'll note that there isn't just one sort of "look" a woman's legs develop from squatting. Nobody can say "squats make women's legs bulky". There is no evidence of that! There's a great variety of squatter's legs posted to this thread, and there is no way anyone could point to all of them and say that squats make legs bulky, because they simply DO NOT. Squats do make your legs firmer and smaller, though.0 -
Your legs look fantastic a inspiration . Thanks for sharing.0
-
I would also just like to point out that the media often skews how most celebrities get those fit, "long" and "lean" bodies that you see. No, most of them aren't the product of yoga and running. At the very least they are doing bodyweight workouts and most of them are lifting in some fashion.
For so long women have been brainwashed into thinking that touching anything heavier than a 5lb pink dumbbell is going to make them instantly into a bodybuilder. Most women are dieting... so like the OP mentioned, she wasn't gaining any mass while she was lifting... she was in a deficit, she was shedding fat. The lifting made her maintain muscle to look "toned"... or what apparently some of you think is "bulky". Two words I despise.
And another thing, you know why muscles are sexy? They are the product of busting *kitten* in the gym and discipline. A person's body and composition says so much more than just how they look, it says a lot about their character and work ethic too.0 -
Love this post!0
-
I know I'm late to the party but I absolutely love this whole topic :-) you ladies have some beautiful legs out there! Wonderful inspiration to us all!0
-
In for Awesome quads!:flowerforyou: :drinker:0
-
I know this is an older thread, but I have to say to the original poster, your thighs, after squatting, look great! I used to think that squats would make my thighs bulky since I'm short. That didn't happen at all when I started squats, lunges and deadlifts. My thighs now look better at age 40 than they did when I was 20 and skinny.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions