Dr. Oz - 75 grams of protein?
Replies
-
I eat at least 100g a day. MFP protein goals are set really low.
But...I just can't bring myself to agree with anything Dr. Oz says, so....75 GRAMS IS TOO LOW RAWR.0 -
I strive for at least 100 grams per day, but this week I've been averaging 112 grams per day. Protein not only helps fill you, but it curbs your cravings as well. Took my trainer months to drill this into my head.0
-
Can you eat bulky protein instead?0
-
I have 25% of my calories as protein which for my daily 1530 cals gives me over 90g.
There is some good evidence that higher protein helps with satiety and may help with maintenance of weight loss. There was a large study called Diogenes which looked at weight loss and maintenance on different diets, mainly focussing on protein and GI. The higher protein 25% and lower GI was the most successful.
Here's a good summary article in Science Daily. http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2010/11/101124171536.htm0 -
Pfffffffffffffft...so basically get skinny fat by creating a protein deficit...wow...."lean protein"(low fat) preferably unprocessed(chicken breast vs whey protein isolate). The TEF for the chickbreast is 30% so your losing 15 grams out of every 50gr as heat! Go ahead of skinny fat and undermuscled is whats up....horrible advice.0
-
I aim for 120-140g daily. My lean mass is hovering just shy of 120 lbs.0
-
The protein goals on MFP should be considered minimums (and even at that, the default setting is too low).0
-
You should aim for 1g of protein per pound of body weight. If you're obese then you can use your BMI. There is no way you can have a blanket statement of 75g for everyone.0
-
I do. I get about 125g a day. Protein is more thermogenic. Your metabolism is going to burn harder from it.0
-
My trainer had me set my goals to 40% carbs, 30% fat, 30% protein and that brought the protein goal up. If that helps anybody who is complaining about the protein goals on here being too low. I will try to figure out how I did that and post the directions.
Edit: Go to goals, click change goals, then mark the circle for custom and click continue. On the next page there will be drop down boxes for you to go through and change the carbs and stuff. When I chose 40% carbs, the fat and protein automatically changed to 30% and I saved it.0 -
I have roughly 190lbs lean body mass, my macro for protein is set to 240g though.0
-
I do 1 gram of protein per 1 lb of body weight
Actually, it is supposed to be 1 gram of protein per 1 lb. of LBM, not body weight.0 -
Agree that some of what Dr. Oz is now recommending is starting to remind me more of an infomercial, than actual medical advice. It seems it shouldn't be a set amount of protein, but a percentage based on your calorie intake & current weight. I have mine custom set at 25%, based on the latest nutritional recommendations. If you get too much protein, although I think the opposite is more of a problem, then it can leech the calcium from your body (if you don't get enough calcium) & could cause osteoporosis, especially in women.
Forks over Knives talks about how increasing protein content of food in both rats and populations of humans whose food is supplemented through the UN directly correlates to cancer in the rats and "Western" diseases in humans.
The China Study is also fascinating - people living in the areas in China that have traditionally used meat for flavour rather than a macronutrient have 4000 times less risk of developing cancer than those living in populations in China where meat is eaten frequently.
PCRM advocates 15% of total calories be protein in humans.
Editing to add: Dr. Oz is a fame-hungry media addict. I don't place much value in most of what he says.0 -
Please stop watching Dr. Oz and go find some real books. At one time he was credible, but alas, the money has led to flogging what people want to hear or what his sponsors want him to talk about. Here is a vlog from a Bodybuilder that happens to have a PHd in nutritional science and his research thesis focused on protein use in the body.
http://www.biolayne.com/uncategorized/biolayne-video-log-4-myths-about-protein/
You need to estimate your lean body mass and decide on a goal for your physique to determine what is a good nutrition plan. Here is a simple calculator that might help.
http://iifym.com/IIFYM-calculator/0 -
Generally the western diet includes far too much protein. Protein is great and your body needs it but in balance with carbs and fats.People get obsessed with high protein. Has anyone ever known anyone with a protein deficiency? The answer will be no because in the western world it doesn't happen.
I know the you need to eat silly amounts of protein brigade will disagree with this. Just remember carbs are the bodies main source of energy.Carbs give you the energy to work those muscles so they can get bigger. If you haven't eaten enough carbs you will lose energy and your body will use your protein for energy rather than muscle building.
I await this POV to be leaped upon with gusto.0 -
The mention of Dr Oz should be banned in all forums0
-
Well you should generally stop listening to Dr. Oz, but yes, more protein is a good thing. I aim for at least 100g a day. 1g per pound of lean body mass.0
-
Nothing Dr. Oz says is credible.
**bubbleburst**
Agreed. He let a podiatrist tell the world to spray their flip flops with HAIRSPRAY in the summer to keep them from slipping. Hahaha.
BUT.. to get more protein just try the powder's I used to make a coffee drink and mix it in there. It was Yummy
I don't know about flip flops, but hairspray on the soles of shoes to keep from slipping is an old dancers' trick. We used to do it all the time back in the day. It's legit.
Who knew, apparently Dr. Oz has actually had one legit thing on his show. I wouldn't have believed it if you hadn't posted it. Then again, it wasn't about dieting, so, there you go. ^^0 -
I fall short of my protein goals every day and it's very frustrating. Usually it's because I've exhausted my fat calories and I don't eat fat-free dairy. I know I can eat more egg whites but I'd love some ideas on very low fat sources of protein.
Oh...I should note that this has been a challenging week food wise because of a Mother's Day brunch and a horrible dinner that my sister prepared for her son's birthday. Just in case anyone looks at my diary0 -
Generally the western diet includes far too much protein. Protein is great and your body needs it but in balance with carbs and fats.People get obsessed with high protein. Has anyone ever known anyone with a protein deficiency? The answer will be no because in the western world it doesn't happen.
I know the you need to eat silly amounts of protein brigade will disagree with this. Just remember carbs are the bodies main source of energy.Carbs give you the energy to work those muscles so they can get bigger. If you haven't eaten enough carbs you will lose energy and your body will use your protein for energy rather than muscle building.
I await this POV to be leaped upon with gusto.
Typical defense when asked how to get more protein; "you don't need much!"0 -
I fall short of my protein goals every day and it's very frustrating. Usually it's because I've exhausted my fat calories and I don't eat fat-free dairy. I know I can eat more egg whites but I'd love some ideas on very low fat sources of protein.
What's your fat goal?0 -
http://agro-food-industry.teknoscienze.com/pdf/norton_AF2_09.PDF
http://www.wannabebig.com/diet-and-nutrition/is-there-a-limit-to-how-much-protein-the-body-can-use-in-a-single-meal/
http://www.humanengine.com/index.php/articles/item/protein-how-much-and-how-often-layne-norton-bs-biochemistry-phd-nutritional-sciences0 -
Watched Dr. Oz today and he recommended 75 grams of protein over the course of 3 meals, looked at my reports, and the highest I have ever had, is 66. Of course he recommends lean protein, but just checking to see if others do this? If so, any meal suggestions. Thanks
I don't give a crap what Dr. Oz says in general...but I think this time he got it close to right. I eat over 140 grams every day0 -
I do 1 gram of protein per 1 lb of body weight0
-
Generally the western diet includes far too much protein. Protein is great and your body needs it but in balance with carbs and fats.People get obsessed with high protein. Has anyone ever known anyone with a protein deficiency? The answer will be no because in the western world it doesn't happen.
I know the you need to eat silly amounts of protein brigade will disagree with this. Just remember carbs are the bodies main source of energy.Carbs give you the energy to work those muscles so they can get bigger. If you haven't eaten enough carbs you will lose energy and your body will use your protein for energy rather than muscle building.
I await this POV to be leaped upon with gusto.
I'll stand over here with you for a little bit. While the MFP guidelines are too low, the protein recommendations I see around here do seem on the high side. There are 150 pound women on here that are being told to eat more protein than I ate when I was a 26 year old, 240 pound mountain of muscle. I used to giggle about the "Magical Proteins" of MFP when I joined the site last year. Sore? Pile on the protein! Want to run 5 miles a day on a bulk? No problem at all, just have more protein all your muscle will be spared! And yeah, the main difference between bulking and cutting for me is the carbs. My protein and fat stay relatively high during either cycle.
While I don't believe there's an inherent danger to high protein diets, I'm starting to suspect some of the super high recommendations have been secretly coming from the supplement industry. You know, sort of how people will say breakfast is a conspiracy started by cereal manufacturers.
As with most things, the answer probably lies somewhere in middle.0 -
That formula isn't right. It's 1 g for each pound of lean body weight, not total body weight.0
-
I fall short of my protein goals every day and it's very frustrating. Usually it's because I've exhausted my fat calories and I don't eat fat-free dairy. I know I can eat more egg whites but I'd love some ideas on very low fat sources of protein.
What's your fat goal?
30% but I try and get the bulk of my fat from things like avocados, olive oil, coconut oil, nuts, nut butter, etc...0 -
I shoot for at least 200 grams of protein per day.0
-
Personally, I am beginning to just understand my body and find when I consume between 80-110 grams of protien per day, my other macro counts are tracking well also and have had a pretty balanced day. I like balance.0
-
I fall short of my protein goals every day and it's very frustrating. Usually it's because I've exhausted my fat calories and I don't eat fat-free dairy. I know I can eat more egg whites but I'd love some ideas on very low fat sources of protein.
What's your fat goal?
30% but I try and get the bulk of my fat from things like avocados, olive oil, coconut oil, nuts, nut butter, etc...
I'm not sure what mine is in terms of percentage but it's 48 grams per day, which is close to the minimum recommended by this post:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/819055-setting-your-calorie-and-macro-targets
It recommends .35 grams per pound of body weight (or per pound of LBM if you are obese I think).
Anyway I'm regularly right at my limit. I do 2% on most dairy, but that's because of the calories not the fat.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions