What do you think of fat people after losing weight?
Replies
-
The biggest issue that I've personally seen is that some become "snobs" to others that haven't lost weight. That because they lost weight, that they on a "higher level" than those that didn't. They'll criticize how others eat, when a few months ago they were eating the same way.
A.C.E. Certified Personal/Group FitnessTrainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
^^^^Agreed.
Yes it is very true a lot of people out there can be lazy, but to blanket everyone with that statement is not ok. You say people use medical conditions as excuses, but unless you have one you have no idea how difficult some conditions make losing weight.
I have PCOS and it is very difficult to lose weight. I have to eat very low carb to see any kind of movement on the scale, and do get bashed quite a bit from people who don't understand that not everyone can just eat what they want to lose or just base things off cals in vs cals out. Medical conditions do mess with your body and the one size fits all approach does not work a lot of times for people with these problems.
And you have no idea either where some are in the journey, I have been stalled out for months, is it as easy to stay completely motivated and hardcore when all your efforts aren't showing results? Definitely not. Not everyone loses with the effort they put in. I say all the time, with the amount of effort and determination I have, I should be skinny by now, but im not. There are a lot of people that put effort in and don't reap the benefits the same as someone else. Does that mean they are lazy and aren't trying because they haven't lost the same as you? Don't think so. Some people can just alter a few things and stick to it and lose. There are many others who make drastic changes and don't lose, definitely wouldn't say they are lazy.
Just because some may not look like they try doesn't mean they are not. Some activity is better than none for people who are completely sedentary, making gradual changes is what brings success for a lot of people.
Sorry maybe I read this post wrong, but it came off quite judgemental. There are alot of people that have mental issues when it comes to food, some have ailments that have prevented them from turning things up, there are a lot of things. But I wouldn't make a statement saying that the majority are just lazy, maybe you were and think others are all the same. Don't know but losing weight is not easy for everyone and shouldn't be looked at as so either.0 -
For me, I never realized what my actual calorie intake was. I assumed I was not eating much. After I started counting and having to see what all this stuff adds up to, it opened my eyes. Now I see WHY I got so big. It wasn't ;laziness, it was ignorance.0
-
I have a long way to go. What I didn't know for decades is that it is easy to lose weight. I don't have (m)any problems keeping in my calorie limits and I like walking and doing things. At this point I would wonder what was holding me back. I would, but I happen to know what was holding me back and it wasn't just one little thing I had a boat load of problems and stresses, it would take at least a small pamphlet to explain all of the problems. At the moment I have some health issues that make things difficult and there are a lot of activities I am just not in any kind of shape to do. But, I have lost a chunk of weight. And I don't think well if I can do it anyone can do it and the reason is simple, they haven't figured out what works for them.
People that aren't losing weight have simply succeeded at losing weight exactly one less time than I have. And that was true for me as well. I have never been on a losing streak this long. I have never ever been on a losing streak where I wasn't feeling like I was starving all the time. And I have never ever been on a losing streak where I was actually eating a better diet, I simply at a lot less and that is exactly why it never worked.0 -
I try not to criticize because I have been there, I've made bad choices and I've been lazy... I also know that there isn't much anyone can say to make anyone lose weight. They have to be ready and motivated or else they probably wont have much success anyway. I was obese for a long time and I knew I was doing it to myself and I knew that I had noone to blame but myself. I also knew that I HAD to do something about it... but it wasn't until something clicked in my head and I was suddenly READY that I was finally able to do it.
But even though I know all this, I do still find it difficult to see people I know and care about eat themselves into an early grave. I would never say anything to them because I've been there and would've been insulted and hurt if someone had told me I needed to lose weight... but I do find it incredibly difficult to just sit back and watch them because I know it can be done... I just hope that in time, they will find the motivation they need to help themselves...0 -
I have a long way to go. What I didn't know for decades is that it is easy to lose weight. I don't have (m)any problems keeping in my calorie limits and I like walking and doing things. At this point I would wonder what was holding me back. I would, but I happen to know what was holding me back and it wasn't just one little thing I had a boat load of problems and stresses, it would take at least a small pamphlet to explain all of the problems. At the moment I have some health issues that make things difficult and there are a lot of activities I am just not in any kind of shape to do. But, I have lost a chunk of weight. And I don't think well if I can do it anyone can do it and the reason is simple, they haven't figured out what works for them.
People that aren't losing weight have simply succeeded at losing weight exactly one less time than I have. And that was true for me as well. I have never been on a losing streak this long. I have never ever been on a losing streak where I wasn't feeling like I was starving all the time. And I have never ever been on a losing streak where I was actually eating a better diet, I simply at a lot less and that is exactly why it never worked.
I completely agree with this. The reason why people's eyes glaze over when you tell them "portion control and exercise" is because they think that they've tried it and failed. What they've probably tried is exercising like mad and not eating anything, but there's so much mis-information out there that it's hard to get people to hear you.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
i think they lack discipline, which could translate to being lazy. but primarily they lack the skill, knowledge, and drive to execute what they want out of life.
i was flat out lazy. i didn't like sweating, so i didn't work out, or exert myself. and i love food.0 -
I can't read through this topic, too frustrating. I'd like to believe that most people who WERE overweight would have some compassion for those who ARE overweight. I personally know that I never want to be like the people that made fun of me. I don't judge people by their pants size.0
-
This. 100% this.I think you can't tar everyone with the same brush! You have to look at each person individually and can't make a sweeping statement like "everyone who is fat is just lazy"
not everyone who is fat is lazy. I for one do have a thyroid that likes to kick my *kitten* everynow and then so I know its still there, still taunting me and still making this *kitten* harder for me than for others. It also contributed to my weight gain... aside from other factors in my life.
Laziness is not always just the case, in some people sure but a health issue like PCOS or Thyroid issues are NOT imaginary.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
As you well know, we all find motivation in different ways and at different times. Everyone knows to lose weight you have to eat less and move more. If it was a simple as that, we'd be a nation of fit and fabulous folks! But we're not. It's so much more than all of that, and people have to work through their own emotional attachments to food and fatness and come to the conclusion to do something about it, on their own terms and in their own way. Like anything else, you can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him put down that Big Mac and Fries, until he's ready.0
-
Culture/society and family play a big role too ..someone who is raised by a sedentary family eating pizza and burgers for launch in a culture/society that doesn't know ANYTHING about nutrition ( Countries like this exist ) is never going to grow up like someone who is raised by a athletic/ active family with a good nutrition background .0
-
When I see a fellow obese person, I don't think anything really. Maybe if they are EXTREMELY overweight like I was, I feel sadness and hope that one day they can figure out their way to a healthy lifestyle. What I DON'T do is judge them and assume they're lazy. There are a lot of factors that come into play, most of them being psychological. You don't know what life that person has lived. You haven't walked in their shoes. You don't know what role food plays in their lives. You're not doing anyone a favor by offering your spare bike and then judging them for their decision to decline.
Oh and you are also assuming every adult knows how to ride a bike. MAYBE they don't know HOW to ride a bike and are too embarrassed to admit it to you? lol
Moral of the story: Stop passing judgment on people's lives when you haven't walked a day in their shoes. :drinker:0 -
Ex Fat people are a lot like ex-smokers! All of the sudden they are superior and wonder why everyone else doesn't "Just stop smoking" (or overeating), because it's just so simple to do!I can't read through this topic, too frustrating. I'd like to believe that most people who WERE overweight would have some compassion for those who ARE overweight. I personally know that I never want to be like the people that made fun of me. I don't judge people by their pants size.0
-
I think everyone fights their own battles on their own timeline and for their own reasons.
^^ This times a million.
But I can't help but feeling a bit sorry for them. I feel like I wasted many years being fat and miserable so it kind of pains me to watch other people be fat and miserable when they can change it.0 -
I don't judge, when someone asks how I did it, I tell them, ate less, move more. I don't get into clean eating or my workout regime. I also let them know that something within me finally "clicked" and I was able to get focused, I guess I don't want them to think that just because I did it, they should be able to do it. What has started to happen, now my overweight friends and family feel the need to explain their choices to me, even though I never asked, never make comments on what they're eating. I just want to say I don't give a crap.0
-
excuses are easier than results..0
-
For some people its a confidence issue. Making the decision to lose weight also has a lot to do with living a balanced life and so many people don't which is why they feel they can't do it. Self-development is very important. However, I want to be careful because I don't want to generalize any group of people as we're all different. Keep encouraging them because you never know when they will join you.0
-
I can't read through this topic, too frustrating. I'd like to believe that most people who WERE overweight would have some compassion for those who ARE overweight. I personally know that I never want to be like the people that made fun of me. I don't judge people by their pants size.
I have many overweight people in my family so I know everyone's situation is different.0 -
I just want them to know how much better it can be... that they deserve to have every chance to live a happy, healthy, active life only constrained by what they desire...not by their size or self esteem.... but they have to choose to make it happen for themselves.0
-
I think everyone fights their own battles on their own timeline and for their own reasons.
This.
I got a lot of judgement when my activity plummeted and my weight increased after my twins were born. I was told repeatedly that I needed to make exercise a priority when in reality, I was barely hanging on with just a few hours of sleep for almost two solid years. I couldn't afford to get help. I did the best I could. And it ticked me off when people that had no idea the hell I was going through, just trying to take care of my family, told me I wasn't trying hard enough.
I understand what you are saying. I haven't slept for more than 3 hours before one of my girls gets me up. So tired =no energy=no desire to get off my but and do something about it. This week I made that change but the road is long0 -
,0
-
This!I think everyone fights their own battles on their own timeline and for their own reasons.0
-
The whole thyroid thing is a real thing you know... Some people actually do suffer from it. I gained 80+ lbs from not being diagnosed in time and doctor error. That's not my fault. I'm fat because of that. However, I don't go around making excuses, I simply just tell people that it is a real thing and people do gain because of it, and when you're not being treated, you don't lose no matter how hard you try, at least I didn't. I just kept gaining.
I won't feel any differently toward fat people when I lose this weight. I feel sorry for the people that aren't motivated enough to actually try to better themselves, but I feel that way now.0 -
EXACTLY!! I have lost 109 lbs and STILL morbidly obese! I was one of the most active fat people at 400 lbs I walked a mile every day and did dishes laundry etc and did not loose weight till I found this life saving site! I swim 3 days a week I walk 3 days a week plus normal house chores so any way Fat does not mean lazy I just needed help still do! THANKS to MFP and my Friends!0
-
My biggest problem was that when I was a teenager I starved myself down to 110 pounds without realizing the drastic effects this would have on my body later down the line. Once I got to, what I thought, was a "perfect" size, I started eating again. After a while I had gained all the weight back PLUS more. I was so distraught and disgusted with myself that I couldn't even look in a mirror. After I realized what I had done, I tried to starve myself again but it didn't work so well this time. I lost barely anything. After that failed to work, I gave up. I didn't have access to healthy food; I was a teenager living with my parents, no money, no job, my parents were flat out BROKE and they only bought crap food because it was cheap. My Dad weighed over 400 pounds and I thought I had no chance to ever be as skinny as I would like.
I still have trouble with my weight even though I have moved in with my boyfriends family. They buy good food but also buy junk food. I try not to be tempted but sometimes it's hard when I get really depressed (which is sometimes, a lot). I've been working really hard over the last 3 weeks, going to the gym 3 or 4 times a week, trying very hard to eat LOTS of veggies and fruits through-out the day instead of junk, but it's just so hard when six other people are sitting there drinking Cokes and eating potato chips. It's hard when they offer me donuts or muffins from Tim Hortons and even after I say no several times, they keep insisting. I know I don't have to eat it, but I am a people pleaser at heart. I have such a hard time saying no to people and I try so hard to give everyone what they want that it's not always best for me. I am getting better, I am trying hard, I know I am my own worst enemy.
I am by no means making excuses for myself. I know that only I can put the food down my throat and that is something I am dealing with. It really isn't a diet, it really is a LIFE style choice that you must be prepared to stick with forever and just like quitting smoking is difficult, quitting your life style is difficult too. You really have to be prepared for it and really, really want it for it too stick. When you talk to "obese" people and they give you excuses, I guarantee you that many of them know where you're coming from and agree with you, but aren't ready to take the plunge into that drastic life-style change. Some of them never will.0 -
"Lazy" is one of those blanket terms I find annoying when applying to people and their inability to produce results other people think are the best. It's completely inaccurate, not to mention demeaning judgmental, and doesn't get the big picture in.
I work in healthcare, and yes, a majority of people that come in technically do not have anything that's physically stopping them from eating better, prioritizing, and getting some physical exercise in. What ends up stopping them are their mental and psychosocial issues.
And no, it's not psychotic illnesses like bipolar disorder or schizophrenia. It's the little things, like anxiety/depression that isn't treated or diagnosed because they don't have insurance or a good PCP. Most have other physical co-morbidities or illnesses, many self-medicate with alcohol and cigarettes, most have lower levels of education, many are in poverty or just above, and many have children and families and struggle just to survive. Things like lack of sleeping, lack of access to proper nutrition, and lack of social support from family are HUGE in the success of any person, and many, many people struggle with those things daily.
The fewer resources people have, like education, support, and money, the less likely they are to succeed. That's true in ANY aspect of healthcare, but it is certainly true with weight struggles, because it's such a socially-driven habit that requires so many factors to be successful.
For many people, it's not simply choosing not to do something; it's lacking the coping skills and psychosocial health to be able to choose to do something. It's a lot more complex than people realize, and it a lot more than people just choosing to be "lazy".0 -
With age comes wisdom, thank god! I don't judge, I mind my own business. I am more concerned with behavior, and how people treat others. If you treat others poorly, you are not a successful person, no matter how fit and body beautiful you are.0
-
I think everyone fights their own battles on their own timeline and for their own reasons.
This. Unfair to judge people because you got it. Until the head is ready nothing will work for them.0 -
My concern is that society can work diligently to create programs try to recover people with all types of disorders that effect their health and the health of families and communities but that over-eating disorders are defendable and have this attitude of being something that you just mind your own business about because it hurts people's feelings. Obesity is just as detrimental to health and costly to treat complications as under-eating or smoking. Regardless of the reason, it is a health condition that can causes harm to others. Prevention and education are key. Society is going to stay this way or get worse if people continuously refuse to participate or make excuses that keep from improving their health and the health of their families. People should care about this. It is a huge deal. This cardiac ICU nurse watches obese people suffer and die from directly related complications daily and they just keep getting bigger and bigger.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.2K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.1K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 420 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 152.9K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.5K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions