having hard time meeting calorie goal
Replies
-
[/quote]You were eating too much if you are 244 lb. not exercising does not make you gain, eating too many cals does. I can easily eat 1200 cals and don't buy it that people are "too full" to reach 1200
Wow thanks for the no-help comment. sad when people feel the need to comment simply to be argumentative ... everyone else that was great info thank you very much
[/quote]
I'm not going to debate her comment as I didn't say it. It just wasn't a helpful comment. In no way did she answer any question I asked. If I say I'm full I'm full how is it for her to judge if I am or not?
i believe the person is just stating a common sense question …which is, how can it be hard to eat 1300 when to get obese you/us/everyone was eating a lot more than that …?
[/quote]
[/quote]
I believe the point that we are trying to make is that how can you be full on less than 1300 calories when you were obviously eating more than that to get to 244 pounds? If you address this question then it will help you to understand what is going on ….
[/quote]
I will try to answer that the best i can. I dont like breakfast i would wake up kinda sort full? So i would go all day then at supper eat like i was starving cuz i was then wash rinse and repeat. So I'm used to that if u read my comment at the top I said over eating wasn't my big problem moving is. I didnt eat all day long none stop was eating prolly 1500-2000 at one shot good? Not at all! And I have changed that. I'm not used to drinking water like a fish and eating 5 times a day and with this new diet I do want something for breakfast and I want lunch and I want dinner now. Its all the rest that just seems to be so much I feel like I'm always eating. I simply wanted to know if I should be getting more calories or not. I didn't know that I would be picked apart about how I ate before I changed my habits and started working out!
[/quote]
OK…meal timing has nothing to do with metabolism….so you can eat three meals a day, six meals a day, or one meal a day and there is zero impact on metabolism.
My suggestion would be to eat three meals a day of about 450 calories each, which would put you at 1350 a day and you will then be hitting your calories goal….0 -
You were eating too much if you are 244 lb. not exercising does not make you gain, eating too many cals does. I can easily eat 1200 cals and don't buy it that people are "too full" to reach 1200
Wow thanks for the no-help comment. sad when people feel the need to comment simply to be argumentative ... everyone else that was great info thank you very much
[/quote]
I'm not going to debate her comment as I didn't say it. It just wasn't a helpful comment. In no way did she answer any question I asked. If I say I'm full I'm full how is it for her to judge if I am or not?
i believe the person is just stating a common sense question …which is, how can it be hard to eat 1300 when to get obese you/us/everyone was eating a lot more than that …?
[/quote]
[/quote]
I believe the point that we are trying to make is that how can you be full on less than 1300 calories when you were obviously eating more than that to get to 244 pounds? If you address this question then it will help you to understand what is going on ….
[/quote]
I will try to answer that the best i can. I dont like breakfast i would wake up kinda sort full? So i would go all day then at supper eat like i was starving cuz i was then wash rinse and repeat. So I'm used to that if u read my comment at the top I said over eating wasn't my big problem moving is. I didnt eat all day long none stop was eating prolly 1500-2000 at one shot good? Not at all! And I have changed that. I'm not used to drinking water like a fish and eating 5 times a day and with this new diet I do want something for breakfast and I want lunch and I want dinner now. Its all the rest that just seems to be so much I feel like I'm always eating. I simply wanted to know if I should be getting more calories or not. I didn't know that I would be picked apart about how I ate before I changed my habits and started working out!
[/quote]
OK…meal timing has nothing to do with metabolism….so you can eat three meals a day, six meals a day, or one meal a day and there is zero impact on metabolism.
My suggestion would be to eat three meals a day of about 450 calories each, which would put you at 1350 a day and you will then be hitting your calories goal….
[/quote]
Thank you that was helpful and I think I'm going to try it for a few days and see how it goes0 -
It does not matter if you were eating 1,500 calories a day, at 9pm every single day of your life, you still wouldn't gain. Most people have BMRs (the number of caloires a body burns with basic, life supporting functions only -- a coma state, essentially) that are AT LEAST 1,200. I assume since you are a SAHM, you don't lay in bed all day -- the amount of caloires you burn in a normal day (basic functions + activity = TDEE) would have to be at least 1,800, probably more but we will estimate LOW. To become 244 pounds, you would have to be consuming more than 1,800 calories regularly. The point is, 1,300 should'nt be "hard" to reach, you HAD to be eating AT LEAST 500 calories more per day (likley more!).0
-
I don't understand the question.
If you are having a hard time reaching your calorie goal, eat more calorie dense food. Add oil when you cook. Avocados, full fat cheese, nuts, full fat dairy, red meat. All of those are pretty calorie dense. You shouldn't be eating just lean meat and fat free dairy with veggies. That WILL fill you up without meeting your calorie needs.0 -
It does not matter if you were eating 1,500 calories a day, at 9pm every single day of your life, you still wouldn't gain. Most people have BMRs (the number of caloires a body burns with basic, life supporting functions only -- a coma state, essentially) that are AT LEAST 1,200. I assume since you are a SAHM, you don't lay in bed all day -- the amount of caloires you burn in a normal day (basic functions + activity = TDEE) would have to be at least 1,800, probably more but we will estimate LOW. To become 244 pounds, you would have to be consuming more than 1,800 calories regularly. The point is, 1,300 should'nt be "hard" to reach, you HAD to be eating AT LEAST 500 calories more per day (likley more!).
Lady I don't know who peed in ur diet shake this morning but what I did BEFORE I started working out has nothing to do with my question about calories Now. I a grown woman and so should you be so leave the trolling a cyber bullying to the kids thanks have a great new year
0 -
Sara- I sent you a friend request. I would leave much of the negativity of this thread behind.
Why people choose to be so snarky when someone asks for help is beyond me.0 -
I dont understand….we did not get obese by underrating so how is it hard to get to 1300 calories…I mean, you did not get obese by underrating all the time, so hitting 1300 should be easy ...
I don't understand either ... i eat between 1700 and 1600 a day and i would be happy to eat more even though i never eat out (home cooked meals only) and i have only a few pounds to loose nothing major ... if i were to eat 1200 i might literally not be able to move0 -
Just because people are being honest and real doesn't mean they are bullying you. None of us would be here if we had trouble eating 1300 cals.0
-
I dont understand….we did not get obese by underrating so how is it hard to get to 1300 calories…I mean, you did not get obese by underrating all the time, so hitting 1300 should be easy ...
I don't understand either ... i eat between 1700 and 1600 a day and i would be happy to eat more even though i never eat out (home cooked meals only) and i have only a few pounds to loose nothing major ... if i were to eat 1200 i might literally not be able to move
Been eating less then 1200 for almost 3 weeks I feel great0 -
Sara- I sent you a friend request. I would leave much of the negativity of this thread behind.
Why people choose to be so snarky when someone asks for help is beyond me.
Agreed
0 -
OK…meal timing has nothing to do with metabolism….so you can eat three meals a day, six meals a day, or one meal a day and there is zero impact on metabolism.
My suggestion would be to eat three meals a day of about 450 calories each, which would put you at 1350 a day and you will then be hitting your calories goal….
The OP never said a word about her metabolism. She just said she used to be in the habit of only eating one meal a day, and that trying to eat three times a day leaves her feeling fuller and she has a hard time reaching 1350 calories.
sara5788, you should try to get close to your 1350 goal most days, and eat back at least some of your exercise calories, to keep your body fueled. There's been some good advice in this thread about using calorie-dense foods like peanut butter, avocados, and olive oil to boost your calorie intake if you feel too full to reach your goal with other foods.0 -
When I first started losing weight, I cut out sugars and a lot of processed foods. After a very short while I did realize I didn't feel hungry when it was time to have a snack or even a meal. But I ate something even if it was just a piece of fruit or some nuts. You have to feed and hydrate the machine if you want it to work properly.
I think mine wasn't as much that I wasn't hungry as it was that my body's blood sugars weren't longer spiking and crashing so I didn't feel that physical discomfort I'd come to call hunger.0 -
If you can try to eat 3 meals a day consisting of about 400 calories per meal then you will nail it! i had the same problem when i first started but it all comes down to trial and error, just keep logging every single thing in you diary and you will begin to understand hoiw your body works..
Before MFP i though i was eating around 1000 calories per day but what i wasnt realizing was how much i was being eating once a week and that would be what stopped me from loosing but now that i can see everything in my diary im much more aware of what i was doing wrong and finally seeing small results
sorry if i have made this more confusing lol0 -
I might be going to extreme with the calories. That is why I asked if it really that important to meet the calorie goal that mfp sets for you. I just find it hard after sweating my butt off at the gym every day to not notice calories everywhere on everthing.
I feel that some days I'm not that hungry and don't make the 1300cal goal I have.
Don't sweat it. You'll have days when you want to eat more.
MFP estimation of calories burned is grossly inaccurate so get accurate measuring if you think you should eat your cals back.
I doubt we'll starve.
Since I've been eating nutritionally well, I get full quite frequently.
My appetite goes crazy when I am tired. So good sleeping is necessary (nightshift worker).0 -
It does not matter if you were eating 1,500 calories a day, at 9pm every single day of your life, you still wouldn't gain. Most people have BMRs (the number of caloires a body burns with basic, life supporting functions only -- a coma state, essentially) that are AT LEAST 1,200. I assume since you are a SAHM, you don't lay in bed all day -- the amount of caloires you burn in a normal day (basic functions + activity = TDEE) would have to be at least 1,800, probably more but we will estimate LOW. To become 244 pounds, you would have to be consuming more than 1,800 calories regularly. The point is, 1,300 should'nt be "hard" to reach, you HAD to be eating AT LEAST 500 calories more per day (likley more!).
This person is right, you know. You didn't gain all that weight eating 1500 calories a day, that'd be impossible, except maybe if you laid in a comatose state all day.
Icecream or peanut butter or chocolate are great for upping calories. :drinker:0 -
Because when you switch from high calorie foods (like a average burrito has 1200 calories in it) to low calorie foods (salads, fruit for snacks etc) It CAN be hard to get 1300 calories in. If you exercise too, it's hard.
That being said try to hit your calorie goal. Women shouldn't eat under 1200 calories for several reasons. One, you'll stall your weight loss because your body will think it's starving and conserve. Two, You won't be building muscle, and muscle burns 5 more calories per hour/per pound than fat. Also, if you stay under 1200 calories for long enough you can disrupt your cycle and endanger your health.
I agree with the people here that you should add avocado, nuts and the like to your food. Don't be afraid of fat!0 -
I'm a 6ft 300lb male, when I first started attempting to lose weight I did very high protein extremely low carbs for a while. I ate 6 times a day easily and was ALWAYS full, however I was struggling to hit even 1300-1500 calories a day. I switched my plan to include more carbs and calorie dense foods and I'm comfortably hitting my 1900 a day with exercise. Hope this helps you in some way and good luck!0
-
I agree with everyone else who suggested adding more calorie dense foods such as avocado, nuts, red meat, peanut butter, full fat dairy, etc. I sometimes have difficulty making my calorie goals thanks to one of the medications I take which is basically pharmaceutical grade legal speed and if I'm not hungry I have a hard time eating. I personally love almonds and I like to have a protein shake after workouts both of which are fairly calorie dense and easy to put down even if my appetite is in the toilet. Also, make sure you're getting enough protein and fat in your diet. Good luck, feel free to add if you want.0
-
It does not matter if you were eating 1,500 calories a day, at 9pm every single day of your life, you still wouldn't gain. Most people have BMRs (the number of caloires a body burns with basic, life supporting functions only -- a coma state, essentially) that are AT LEAST 1,200. I assume since you are a SAHM, you don't lay in bed all day -- the amount of caloires you burn in a normal day (basic functions + activity = TDEE) would have to be at least 1,800, probably more but we will estimate LOW. To become 244 pounds, you would have to be consuming more than 1,800 calories regularly. The point is, 1,300 should'nt be "hard" to reach, you HAD to be eating AT LEAST 500 calories more per day (likley more!).
Lady I don't know who peed in ur diet shake this morning but what I did BEFORE I started working out has nothing to do with my question about calories Now. I a grown woman and so should you be so leave the trolling a cyber bullying to the kids thanks have a great new year
She's not trolling. She's actually trying to help you and you're throwing a tantrum over it. And actually the amount you ate before you started dieting has A LOT to do with it, because you were more than likely eating way more than you are now. You gain weight by eating MORE than you burn. That's an indisputable fact. It's hard to believe that you would be having an issue eating 1200-1300.0 -
I really think you should try to eat your daily allotment while losing. So aim for the 1300.
You may have what I can only explain as a dieters "high". I sometimes get this in the beginning of starting a new program , where it's easy to eat less or exercise more. That's hard to sustain and even harder to maintain.
I personally never eat back the calories I earn from exercise...Actually I'll try to bank some for a night out, unless I burn more than 10,000 calories in a day then I'll use half.
Good luck and add me if you'd like.
Thank you and I will
So you take advice from someone who has only loss 2 pounds and not from people who lost a lot of weight. Ok. Out.
Her post indicates she has been on VLC diets before and has regained the weight. If you added together all the weight I've lost on VLC diets, you could say I've lost somewhere between 480 and 560 pounds. So that makes me an EXPERT on LOSING. The point is keeping it off. VLC diets: They aren't sustainable.0 -
You were eating too much if you are 244 lb. not exercising does not make you gain, eating too many cals does. I can easily eat 1200 cals and don't buy it that people are "too full" to reach 1200
Wow thanks for the no-help comment. sad when people feel the need to comment simply to be argumentative ... everyone else that was great info thank you very much
It's also a load of rubbish! You can easily be overweight from eating too little for too long, and not moving, especially if what you're eating is the wrong foods. Not everyone is the same. I don't lose weight unless I exercise, or I practically starve myself.
I have 2 young kids though, so I don't understand how you weren't active as a SAHM. That's the bit that confuses me. My 2 don't stop moving. My son is at school now, and i work part time, but on my days off we do not stop moving! When I was on maternity leave with my youngest we were out every single day on the seafront, in the park, at soft play etc.
I started off losing weight after my 2nd child was born, and I started off at 1200 calories and struggled to meet that some days, and I was working out 5 times a week, plus taking my kids out. Then I joined MFP and increased my calories, and now I don't find it hard to hit 1500 calories. I'm pregnant now and aiming for 1800 and even that is now doable.
I did lose weight at 1200 calories, because I was so active, but when I increased to 1500 I lost more, and it made all the strength training I was doing more effective I think.
My diary is open so you're welcome to look. Things like peanut butter for example can easily increase your calories, or a couple of pieces of fruit.0 -
I would definitely recommend eating at least your goal now. You may be feeling great at the moment but in a couple of months when you've lost weight it's not going to be great. If you're not eating enough calories and protein at least half of what you lose is going to be lean body mass. The less LBM you have the lower your metabolism/BMR/TDEE will be which will mean in a couple months you're going to have to lower your calories even more to lose weight. I know I wouldn't want to do that, it's not sustainable.
Eat your goal and eat back your exercise calories. A lot of people have made great suggestions on how to do it. Stick away from 'diet' foods and eat fuller fat dairy, nuts, avocados, olive oil, etc.
I've lost all my weight eating at least 1600 calories. It's coming off slow but it's the right way. You can add me as a friend if you'd like to see what I eat.0 -
I can appreciate that you just feel full, You've eaten one meal a day for a long time and that is how your body has adjusted. It's the same with people not feeling the need to eat breakfast.
I would suggest you try slowly introducing small healthy snacks and meals through the day. A light breakfast before or after your workout and then slowly increase the quantity. Your body will adjust.
I agree with what some people have said; there is a possibility that you are over and underestimating your calories. I always take the higher calorie measurement on food and the lower on exercise because I know it is not precise (but I have the issue of going over my goal not under)0 -
OK…meal timing has nothing to do with metabolism….so you can eat three meals a day, six meals a day, or one meal a day and there is zero impact on metabolism.
My suggestion would be to eat three meals a day of about 450 calories each, which would put you at 1350 a day and you will then be hitting your calories goal….
The OP never said a word about her metabolism. She just said she used to be in the habit of only eating one meal a day, and that trying to eat three times a day leaves her feeling fuller and she has a hard time reaching 1350 calories.
sara5788, you should try to get close to your 1350 goal most days, and eat back at least some of your exercise calories, to keep your body fueled. There's been some good advice in this thread about using calorie-dense foods like peanut butter, avocados, and olive oil to boost your calorie intake if you feel too full to reach your goal with other foods.
Yes, I know she never said she did it for metabolism, but i was just sharing a little knowledge.. .I was just elaborating that there is no metabolic need to eat five times a day…geez…
to your second point,actually, she said that she has a hard time eating 5 times a day and drinking water because it makes her feel "full"…so my suggestion was that she can reduce that to three meals, or two meals, or even one meal if she wants to.0 -
Sara- I sent you a friend request. I would leave much of the negativity of this thread behind.
Why people choose to be so snarky when someone asks for help is beyond me.
I do not see what is negative about trying to understand someone's eating habits so that we can provide advice, about said eating habits. I also do not see how it is negative to question how someone who is recently obese is now having a problem eating 1300 calories a day ….0 -
I would definitely recommend eating at least your goal now. You may be feeling great at the moment but in a couple of months when you've lost weight it's not going to be great. If you're not eating enough calories and protein at least half of what you lose is going to be lean body mass. The less LBM you have the lower your metabolism/BMR/TDEE will be which will mean in a couple months you're going to have to lower your calories even more to lose weight. I know I wouldn't want to do that, it's not sustainable.
Eat your goal and eat back your exercise calories. A lot of people have made great suggestions on how to do it. Stick away from 'diet' foods and eat fuller fat dairy, nuts, avocados, olive oil, etc.
I've lost all my weight eating at least 1600 calories. It's coming off slow but it's the right way. You can add me as a friend if you'd like to see what I eat.
How do you define lean body mass?
Adults only need about 50 grams of protein a day to remain in balance. That is 2 ounces or a tenth of a pound. Not much at all.
The reason it is tougher for formerly-obese people to lose those final pounds is that just the loss of weight means they have to work less in accomplishing the same level of activity.
If someone drops fifty pounds, that's like losing a 50 pound weight you have been lugging around. Your muscles have to work less.
what?
50 grams a day of protein to remain in balance?
this makes no sense…Yea, I guess your muscles will have to work less but if you do not use them then you will lose LBM and you will be "skinny fat"0 -
^^^ This (Although even if I went zero fat I would struggle to hit 1200 :-) )You are likely underestimating your intake. 1300 calories is nothing...hell, a typical meal out is close to 1,000 +.
If indeed you can't meet such paltry calorie goals it is likely you've cut far too much dietary fat out...dietary fat is an essential nutrient...eat nuts, avocados, cook with olive oil, etc. One tiny ounce of nuts...a very small handful has 150 calories plus. Half of an avocado is around 120....cooking with just a Tbsp of olive oil will add a good 110 calories to anything.
Perhaps when you start moving a bit your appitite will get stronger :-)
good luck, you can do it. Make sure this is'nt a January diet but one that lasts for life. Sticking around here and making friends will help ensure that this happens :-)0 -
My mind boggles when I see people saying "I can't reach my 1300 daily calorie goal"
I usually have between 1000 - 1300 calories just for my dinner.
You probably can't reach your 1300, because you're that malnourished you can barely be bothered to feed yourself!0 -
I understand what you are saying, I used to have the same issue. I think it's a combination of a couple things for you to consider. The first (for me) was the mental part of it. Food used to be the "enemy" for me instead of viewing it as fuel/a tool to help me reach my goals. Therefore, when I ate - no matter what it was - I felt guilty/ashamed. Even if it was veggies! This is from a damaged self esteem. I'm not saying that is part of your problem but you really need to view food as an essential tool to reaching your goals. I think we can all agree we at least have some days where we don't really feel like working out but we push ourselves because we know what the end result will be. You need to get in that same mindset for food.
The second is absolutely planning. I hate planning my meals, dread it. But I know if I don't plan my meals and what time I will eat them, I will make bad choices. So, I eat a lot of the same food - because it's easy for me. And I set an alarm on my phone to tell me when it's time to eat. After time it will become a habit.
I'm eating between 1700-1800 a day now with ease after I got past those couple things.
Good luck with your journey!0 -
I understand what you are saying, I used to have the same issue. I think it's a combination of a couple things for you to consider. The first (for me) was the mental part of it. Food used to be the "enemy" for me instead of viewing it as fuel/a tool to help me reach my goals. Therefore, when I ate - no matter what it was - I felt guilty/ashamed. Even if it was veggies! This is from a damaged self esteem. I'm not saying that is part of your problem but you really need to view food as an essential tool to reaching your goals. I think we can all agree we at least have some days where we don't really feel like working out but we push ourselves because we know what the end result will be. You need to get in that same mindset for food.
The second is absolutely planning. I hate planning my meals, dread it. But I know if I don't plan my meals and what time I will eat them, I will make bad choices. So, I eat a lot of the same food - because it's easy for me. And I set an alarm on my phone to tell me when it's time to eat. After time it will become a habit.
I'm eating between 1700-1800 a day now with ease after I got past those couple things.
Good luck with your journey!
Thank you and I think your right a lot of u are I need to just "eat" like when some morning when I don't want to work out I "just do it" an up side I guess I can food that taste better then what I'm currently eating thanks everyone it also makes me feel better to see people who eat 1500-1700 a day and have lost a lot of weight 0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions