I Don't Believe in Counting Calories on Thanksgiving

2

Replies

  • Mindful_Trent
    Mindful_Trent Posts: 3,954 Member
    While one day of overindulging wouldn't do much harm in the long run, I'd rather eat reasonably (including using some healthy recipes), enjoy my day with my family and NOT feel stuffed silly at the end of the day. The focus of the day is the company I'm keeping, not the food - so I refuse to feel guilty for tracking my calories and applying my habit changes to Thanksgiving just like any other day.

    Edited to add: my opinion on why I *should* track on Thanksgiving, is that part of why I got here in the first place is mindless eating. I don't want to allow myself to eat mindlessly for any occasion - by tracking what I eat for Thanksgiving, I'm more likely to stick to reasonable portions and not make myself feel sick by the end of the day.
  • jamie1888
    jamie1888 Posts: 1,704 Member
    Do whatever YOU think is best for YOU. What works for one, may not work for another. That's the beauty of this life; we can all do whatever the hell we want and nobody can (or atleast they shouldn't) tell us we are wrong for doing it!

    mjtwomail - I like your outlook/attitude on threads! :wink:
  • buggaboo73
    buggaboo73 Posts: 169
    I don't think you should feel guilty for counting calories if that's what you want to do.

    Nor do I think I should feel guilty for choosing one or two days to not count them.

    Nor do I think Loseittoo should feel guilty for doing his lifestyle change in the way that suits him.

    At the end of the day we all need to do what works for us.

    When I said my lifestyle change was moderation, I was NOT attacking anyone who said their lifestyle change was 100% healthy all the time.

    I was ONLY stating how I like to do things.

    I don't think my way is superior, nor do I think yours is.

    I only know ME and that I do not tend to feel black and white about ANY topic. Not religion, not child rearing, not sexuality, none of it. FOR ME it is reasonable to say that I want to extend that moderation to my diet. Considering in the past that I have been a binge eater, moderation FOR ME is a good plan.

    Talking about me here, again, nobody else. Not judging anyone else's choices. Not attacking anyone. Just saying this is what works for me. Period.
  • buggaboo73
    buggaboo73 Posts: 169
    Do whatever YOU think is best for YOU. What works for one, may not work for another. That's the beauty of this life; we can all do whatever the hell we want and nobody can (or atleast they shouldn't) tell us we are wrong for doing it!

    mjtwomail - I like your outlook/attitude on threads! :wink:

    Agreed! On both statements!
  • elainegsd
    elainegsd Posts: 459 Member
    And for goodness sakes, one day isn't going to "sabotage" anyone's weight loss.

    It certainly can, it depends on the person.
  • TaneeisFitforLife
    TaneeisFitforLife Posts: 433
    I will do what I do at any event. Eat lighter during the day, get a good work out in and eat sensible. I will not go all out and eat what ever I like.

    I have family over every week. I smoke some meat on the smoker and we have a big feast. I always stay with in my goals. Thanksgiving is no different.

    I have made a lifestyle change. I am not on a diet. After being 400lbs and losing most of it you see food differently. And my holiday will not be about stuffing myself full of bad foods. It will be about sharing a day of thanks with those that mean so much to me.

    And FOOTBALL!!!!!

    Yes! This is how I view Thanksgiving eating. We are visiting in-laws so what they make is beyond my control so I'll eat a nice salad (I do bring my own dressing lol) and then eat sensibly. :) it's not an excuse to gorge myself.
  • buggaboo73
    buggaboo73 Posts: 169
    And for goodness sakes, one day isn't going to "sabotage" anyone's weight loss.

    It certainly can, it depends on the person.

    Fine, I apologize. Eat salad on Thanksgiving or you will wake up 100 lbs heavier. This is the last straw for me on these boards. Too many extremists, too many judgmental people. This board is supposed to be about support but every time I come here I leave more stressed than when I came.

    If you all need rigid rules and all or nothing mindsets to feel cozy and snug at night then do what you gotta do. I'm off to find a forum where people can think outside the box and be rational.
  • Mkserpa
    Mkserpa Posts: 136
    So true! It's just too bad we have to celebrate it FIVE times since, now that we're married, everyone wants us over and everyone gets offended if we can't make it :P salad please!
  • Mkserpa
    Mkserpa Posts: 136
    And for goodness sakes, one day isn't going to "sabotage" anyone's weight loss.

    It certainly can, it depends on the person.

    Fine, I apologize. Eat salad on Thanksgiving or you will wake up 100 lbs heavier. This is the last straw for me on these boards. Too many extremists, too many judgmental people. This board is supposed to be about support but every time I come here I leave more stressed than when I came.

    If you all need rigid rules and all or nothing mindsets to feel cozy and snug at night then do what you gotta do. I'm off to find a forum where people can think outside the box and be rational.

    I agree buggaboo! One day will not hurt! It's called willpower and the ability to say no to overeating AFTER that one day!
  • Loseittoo
    Loseittoo Posts: 74 Member
    And for goodness sakes, one day isn't going to "sabotage" anyone's weight loss.

    It certainly can, it depends on the person.

    Fine, I apologize. Eat salad on Thanksgiving or you will wake up 100 lbs heavier. This is the last straw for me on these boards. Too many extremists, too many judgmental people. This board is supposed to be about support but every time I come here I leave more stressed than when I came.

    If you all need rigid rules and all or nothing mindsets to feel cozy and snug at night then do what you gotta do. I'm off to find a forum where people can think outside the box and be rational.

    Wow. She deactivated her account over this discussion? Her ticker says 0 lbs lost and she has been here since last year. Maybe she doesn't update it or she is still battling her relationship with food. Her reaction to this topic is way over the top.

    Either way I wish her the best.
  • elainegsd
    elainegsd Posts: 459 Member
    And for goodness sakes, one day isn't going to "sabotage" anyone's weight loss.

    It certainly can, it depends on the person.

    Fine, I apologize. Eat salad on Thanksgiving or you will wake up 100 lbs heavier. This is the last straw for me on these boards. Too many extremists, too many judgmental people. This board is supposed to be about support but every time I come here I leave more stressed than when I came.

    If you all need rigid rules and all or nothing mindsets to feel cozy and snug at night then do what you gotta do. I'm off to find a forum where people can think outside the box and be rational.

    Wow. She deactivated her account over this discussion? Her ticker says 0 lbs lost and she has been here since last year. Maybe she doesn't update it or she is still battling her relationship with food. Her reaction to this topic is way over the top.

    Either way I wish her the best.

    I wish her the best too. I wasn't trying to get her to do things my way, just attempting to give my alternative view. The OP took it all in stride and saw my point (and I agree that we are actually quite aligned in our views, just using slightly different methods to get there.) I've just spent way too many Thanksgivings where I regretted eating certain things. I don't want to repeat that this year!
  • MisdemeanorM
    MisdemeanorM Posts: 3,493 Member
    So true! It's just too bad we have to celebrate it FIVE times since, now that we're married, everyone wants us over and everyone gets offended if we can't make it :P salad please!

    LOL! This could be a problem! I remember when I was younger we did lunch at one and dinner at another! Yes, if I still did that I would be counting at least one of those meals to the calorie!!

    Side note, personally, I have no problem with people who won't budge from what they think. They don't have to. It's what THEY think. I find very few people telling me what to do (at least, not in a hostile way). I have very opinionated views myself, though somewhat flexible (sometimes depending on how hungry I am :laugh:). It won't make me gain or lose one pound if you count your thanksgiving calories, if you go over by 2000, if you enjoy the day, or if you hate it because of the food stress. I'm doing it my way, and I might tell you what that is, and maybe even suggest you do it my way, but in the end, I don't "care" what you do. (i mean, I "care" about everyone, and wish everyone health and the best... but you get the point.)
  • Neuroticwench
    Neuroticwench Posts: 115 Member
    I don't even have to worry about this since I have to work Thanksgiving and my family is 50 miles away. Makes it easy! :grumble:
  • lkm111
    lkm111 Posts: 629 Member
    I agree with you! I do think, though, that there are plenty of things that will be on my family's table that are considered healthy. Besides turkey we always have raw vegetables, olives, pickles, and cooked vegetable dishes. I also think that pumpkin pie isn't the worst thing to eat as long as you don't add whipped cream.

    I plan on eating but limiting the really bad culprits: carbs. I will go easy on the mashed potatoes, homemade noodles and rolls.

    Have a great Thanksgiving Day! :smile:
  • janemartin02
    janemartin02 Posts: 2,653 Member
    I agree~!Holidays do`nt have to stress everyone out.Eating healthier choices and eating smaller portions of the more calories.I think for me if I deprive myself,I`m more prone to eat more later in the day .
    The holidays are about spending time with loved ones.It doesn`t have to be all about the food.
    Happy thanksgiving to all!
    Jane
  • Sharont213
    Sharont213 Posts: 323 Member
    As my WW leader used to say - it's okay to enjoy yourself but remember, it's a HoliDAY not a HoliWEEK :wink:
  • selbyhutch
    selbyhutch Posts: 531 Member
    I agree. I haven't had a "cheat" day in 2 weeks & won't until Thanksgiving. There may be some collateral damage but I plan on logging it & offsetting it with exercise.
  • SJSchwartz
    SJSchwartz Posts: 131
    And for goodness sakes, one day isn't going to "sabotage" anyone's weight loss.


    lol agreed!
  • EmpressB
    EmpressB Posts: 36 Member
    I want to be educated and conscious about what I am eating, but obsessing over it is another thing.

    I'd like to lose weight and be healthy and live a "normal" just more healthy life.

    Balance is the key. With my new mentality, I will make sure not to go overboard on Thanksgiving like I normally would. I can have a great thanksgiving, enjoy my family and food without eating 10 times the serving size.My family has these HUUUUGE plates that are like platters for individuals to put food on, and in times gone by I sure would pile it on high with 5 different meats, 8 different sides, seconds and then throughout the night and the rest of the week continue eating the left overs. Needless to say, this Thanksgiving, that won't be happening.

    You can plan your Thanksgiving week calories around the actual day so you can eat more. I think that will be my only meal that day so I will save all my 1600 odd calories for that meal lol, but I also don't feel the need to pack it all on, THANK GOD! I wondered how I would manage, but now thinking about it, it's not a big deal, I don't live to eat anymore (wow, can't believe I'm saying this) so I will enjoy myself within reason.

    Food was often the first and last thing on my mind...and while I am a foodie and will continue to love and appreciate food...I am quickly learning that I can enjoy food without being gluttonous...which I will be the first to admit, I would be on holidays. My world doesn't revolve around food or being able to eat anymore, food is a nice part of my world but not at the center and on Thanksgiving it won't be the center either.
  • megteg
    megteg Posts: 97 Member
    And for goodness sakes, one day isn't going to "sabotage" anyone's weight loss.

    It certainly can, it depends on the person.

    Fine, I apologize. Eat salad on Thanksgiving or you will wake up 100 lbs heavier. This is the last straw for me on these boards. Too many extremists, too many judgmental people. This board is supposed to be about support but every time I come here I leave more stressed than when I came.

    If you all need rigid rules and all or nothing mindsets to feel cozy and snug at night then do what you gotta do. I'm off to find a forum where people can think outside the box and be rational.

    Huh. Not that I agree with a strict mindset with dieting, but I know that support doesn't mean people pat you on the back constantly and tell you what you WANT to hear. Support is about people telling you what you might NEED to hear! And I didn't realize anyone was being mean about it...

    Anyway, I wish her the best, and I think this is a really good discussion.
  • fefe1979
    fefe1979 Posts: 3
    I can't wait for Thanksgiving! I'm eating less calories now (1200 calories/day) so I can pig out Thursday. I'm eating in moderation but will eat whatever I want. :bigsmile:
  • JStarnes
    JStarnes Posts: 5,576 Member
    I'm gonna eat until I can't walk. :glasses: Happy Thanksgiving!
  • superwmn
    superwmn Posts: 936
    Here, here! I second this notion :)

    Charmagne
  • Gogo76
    Gogo76 Posts: 581
    I'm gonna eat until I can't walk. :glasses: Happy Thanksgiving!

    BWAHAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHA!!!!! You crack me up! I too am going to eat any and everything I want. It is only one day a year!!! Plus, if I tell myself I can have whatever I want, I probably won't want half the stuff anyways. Gotta love reverse psychology!
  • firedragon064
    firedragon064 Posts: 1,082 Member
    Yup, I'm going to eat whatever I want on xgiving but I will eat seafood soup and salad first.
  • SlipperySlope
    SlipperySlope Posts: 34
    I love the reverse psychology idea...it's funny how when I give myself PERMISSION to eat things I love, I eat some--and really enjoy it--but I don't go crazy. It's when I feel I "shouldn't" that it's harder to stop...Propensity to misbehave! :D

    -Carrie

    PS I like this thread, too. Thoughtful ideas from all. Thanks!
  • ashleyinthestars
    ashleyinthestars Posts: 107 Member
    AMEN!! My mantra is this: "I didn't lose 100 lbs over night and I certainly wont gain it back overnight!" It is indeed ONE day. Go for a walk once the food settles, workout in the morning, workout the next day (or power walk through the mall to catch all the black friday sales!), and get right back onto your regular routine. No sense in denying yourself!
  • shawnnshinta
    shawnnshinta Posts: 37 Member
    I give myself a free day every week anyways, so I'll just use Thanksgiving as my weekly free day. easy!
  • ActionJackson
    ActionJackson Posts: 31
    I am going to enjoy my TG as well!! I am satisfied with my progress. I do like that term "free-day" opposed to falling off the wagon or some other self-defeatist phrase. For me long term weight-loss will always be a lifetime goal. Some days will be others, some weeks will be better than others, but all years from here on out will be good.
  • misslizz6958
    misslizz6958 Posts: 124 Member
    nahhh.. I don't even want thanksgiving dinner this year, I'm going stay home n let hubby and baby go to our friends house. Ill be at home with healthy choice n football. Way better imo
This discussion has been closed.

Categories