Going low sugar/low carb!

Actually I tried both low GI and low carb/ketogenic diet so I can tell you a little bit about my experience trying to maintian my weight and hormones. When I was eating low GI, I found that white rice, refined carbs spiked my blood sugar levels and made me tired and moody. I switched to whole grain (brown rice) and oats after listening to the advice that whole grains are good for you, but I actually fall asleep after oats. They say oats are low GI, it certainly never acted that way on my body. It has never kept my blood sugar steady. I feel giant brain fog after oats. I used to eat lots of bananas, but this plus all the whole grain, made me gain 22lbs in a very short time. The paleo people do have a point, our ancestors did not eat grain all the time, so why are we so into grain instead of healthy fats and protein?

I've found that eating a big bowl of low starchy vegetables, like broccoli, kale, lettuce, cauliflower, green beans, zucchini, a tiny amount of pumpkin, etc, with a spoon of coconut oil, and a piece of protein, really helped me feel full and melted my weight off. I went from a Low GI eater to a Ketogenic eater. The major difference is that my fat intake is much higher on keto, so I feel the added benefits of soft smoother skin, additional fat burning, more energy, more satisfying delicious food to eat.

I say it depends on your goals and severity, but I would respectfully disagree that eating "whole grain" is a health food for people with Insulin resistance and PCOS. Stay away from sugar, bread, pasta, oats, white rice, eat only a small amount of brown rice and potatoes. You can do a lot of research about the effect of carbohydrate on blood sugar, and a cup of brown rice contains over 50g of carbs. So if your body can handle it, I say go for it, otherwise, try to go without it and see how you feel

When I was eating low GI, I found that white rice, refined carbs spiked my blood sugar levels and made me tired and moody.

These are med-high GI foods, and on the GI diet should be largely avoided (unless paired with a source of protein and fat).

The truth is that aiming for complex carbs over refined carbs is simply more sating (white bread is still a complex carb, as is white rice), all foods are insulinogenic (spike insulin) to some degree, high sat-fat diets have been shown to possibly promote IR, and you can manage - even improve - IR with exercise and losing weight (in a much more effective way than Metformin will).

For us women with PCOS, the same principles of counting calories apply... you don't need to low-carb/keto to lose weight. Whole grains are recommended for controlling IR, but again you don't need to only consume low-GI whole grains to lose weight, either. I have had a heck of a lot of success without it... ultimately you just find what works for you. Psychology is a big part of sticking to and enjoying a method of eating.

The most overlooked thing in the management of PCOS is exercise. Lifting weights is essential, particularly if paired with light-moderate cardio.

Whole grain reduces insulins rise that's why it works. Low carb or no grain would also do that, but in spades, so no you probably don't have to go low carb but it would control the problem more efficiently and that's why it's prescribed.

I go "paleo" except for the occasional serving (1/2 cup dried) of whole grain pasta and near-daily serving of greek yogurt. No dairy, no grains, no added sugars. Got diagnosed with polycystic ovaries, but don't suffer from other signs of PCOS (like insulin resistance or extra body hair). I am completely fine, and actually prefer, having very unadulterated foods or simple meals to eat, like eggs scrambled with veggies, fruit mixed with nuts, plain boneless/skinless chicken with steamed veggies on the side. I may not have the energy boosts eating all those grains usually gives us, but I find I don't have the crashes, energy swings, or cravings that my friends do, too.

For breakfast, instead of coffee or an energy drink and some kind of crap snack, I am going to have some hardboiled eggs that I keep at work and bring a banana or apple and peanut butter

Banana is the highest sugar fruit, I would lose that altogether.

Yes I know. Low carb is less circulating glucose which by default increases insulin sensitivity. Like I said your way is fine, but low carb works just as well and better for these conditions.

Edit, wrong study... I will be back.

It really doesn't matter, low carb is an effective strategy for people that have PCOS, other stategies work too, never said they didn't..

It does matter if you're talking about increased efficacy.

Low-carb/keto diets are not more effective for weight loss than diets with an adequate or high amount of carbs for women with PCOS and IR.

Do vegetarians with PCOS & IR lose weight more or less effectively than a female with PCOS & IR on a low-carb diet?

Eh, low-GI can be a good reminder to make good choices. The underlying "science" is extremely questionable, but it can create a mental marker for those who find it difficult to make decent food choices most of the time.

If you are not a doctor, then why are you posting with authority, especially for someone who has a medical condition?

Either quote from a source that has medical credentials, or....don't post at all.

If you MUST post, at least write out your disclaimer with real words instead of using the first letters.

And you MIGHT tell us the credentials that you do have.

Helpful.

I haven't posted "with authority" I've simply said that low-carb is not necessary for weight loss with PCOS/IR. I have not said that it doesn't work, though I have said that it is no more/less effective than a simple calorie-controlled, balanced diet and I have said that low-GI principles are the same as any other healthy eating principles.

If you'll notice my first few posts I've mentioned I have PCOS ("us women with PCOS") . I also have IR. I've spent a long, long time losing a lot of weight on diet that has not restricted carbs - refined or otherwise - in any sense. I suppose those are my "credentials".

If you have nothing of note to add, why are you posting?

If you are not a doctor, then why are you posting with authority, especially for someone who has a medical condition?

Either quote from a source that has medical credentials, or....don't post at all.

If you MUST post, at least write out your disclaimer with real words instead of using the first letters.

And you MIGHT tell us the credentials that you do have.

Helpful.

I haven't posted "with authority" I've simply said that low-carb is not necessary for weight loss with PCOS/IR. I have not said that it doesn't work, though I have said that it is no more/less effective than a simple calorie-controlled, balanced diet and I have said that low-GI principles are the same as any other healthy eating principles.

If you'll notice my first few posts I've mentioned I have PCOS ("us women with PCOS") . I also have IR. I've spent a long, long time losing a lot of weight on diet that has not restricted carbs - refined or otherwise - in any sense. I suppose those are my "credentials".

If you have nothing of note to add, why are you posting?

Many interventions can effect an outcome for sure, but I just don't understand your stance on low GI foods. Low carb is by default a low GI diet, but then you go on and say that low carb and ones with high carbs is no more effective for weight loss, so basically your contradicting yourself by trying to instill the fact that's its about glucose and lower GI is more effective. And you seem to confuse insulin with glucose when you said that protein increase insulin, which is true but it doesn't effect or blood sugar levels because of the absence of sugars in protein. Anyway, if what's working for you is effective, that's great. I also just want to mention that refined carbs for the most part are complex carbs, you seem to think they're different.

Many interventions can effect an outcome for sure, but I just don't understand your stance on low GI foods. Low carb is by default a low GI diet, but then you go on and say that low carb and ones with high carbs is no more effective for weight loss, so basically your contradicting yourself by trying to instill the fact that's its about glucose and lower GI is more effective. And you seem to confuse insulin with glucose when you said that protein increase insulin, which is true but it doesn't effect or blood sugar levels because of the absence of sugars in protein. Anyway, if what's working for you is effective, that's great. I also just want to mention that refined carbs for the most part are complex carbs, you seem to think they're different.

I think you need to re-read a lot of what I've posted. Particularly my second post and your first post, but all of them in general.

Low-carb is not by default low-GI, either, by the way. The grammage of carbs consumed does not matter in low-GI eating. As another poster said, it matters to GL... but a food's GI is not the same as its GL.

It's the GL that needs to be addressed not the GI. Any yes, if someone is consuming the carbs prescribed in most low carb diet, they are low GI.

I personally don't have PCOS but I do know of people that have cut down their carbs and had success.

I eat low carb but I do agree...a banana is one of the highest sugar content fruits there are. On the other hand....I ate one nearly everyday when I was doing low carb the first go round but i did low carb to lose weight not for anything specific for medical reasons. If youre trying to avoid the higher amount of sugar I would avoid it for your medical issues. Berries would be a better choice. Also, check your sugar content on your peanut butter.

I would check to out some of the low carb groups or if their is a group just for those with PCOS.

Yes, I agree with MeIRC. Bananas can really spike your insulin levels and send your body into anabolism (storing mode) and pair that with grains, then you're putting yourself in a longer storing window than you are burning. Correct me if I'm wrong, but the human body can't burn and store at the same time. Your body needs some time to actually process what you're eating, and a window of time where insulin is low so you can tap into your fat stores. If you keep your insulin levels sustained at a high/moderate level all the day (by eating "healthy" wheat products) then you are constantly in a storing mode where you can be at risk of crashing into a low.

Ketoers aim to give themselves more windows of catabolism where they have very little insulin, high levels of leptin and plenty of ketones to fuel their body. But please, don't just take my word for it, do some reading or a search on Google or Youtube on low carb and ketogenic diet, you will find a rich foundation of lectures to listen to.

There is a lot of prejudice against low carb, mainly because people confused ketosis with ketoacidosis, and mistake it for "Fad" or "extreme" when its actually a diet used around the world for hundreds of thousands of years. If anything, a high wheat, gluten and processed diet would be more recent and thus would be more of the fad than low carb.

It's still daily caloric balance that dictates fat loss or gain, but there are advantages to low carb with people with "broken" metabolisms like the OP, or satiety reasons for dietary compliance, which is why I consume fewer carbs , but not the very low regime that would initiate ketosis.

People that are insulin resistant and with PCOS really need to reduce glucose from the blood, and while more complex carbs like grain helps with the insulin spike, it increases the transit time and actually prolongs the insulin response. Anytime we eat carbs and we get what's called an initial insulin response that is basically a duplication of the previous meals response and if that response doesn't remove the glucose fast enough or low enough, we get a secondary insulin response, normally about 1/2 hour later........removing carbs lowers the insulin response going forward because of the lower glycemic load on the body and future events are reduced. Basically it speeds up the repair of receptors making the cells more insulin sensitive......and that's why low carb is beneficial to people with these problems, others, not so much.

Bananas have potassium (good for B/P) and Vit B6. And Schauzers love them. Edited to mention I am no Dr.

There are plenty of potassium and b vitamins in other low carb food sources too. You don't need to eat a particular food that is bad for your blood sugar just to just a certain vitamin that can be found elsewhere.

neanderthin - Thanks for that info. Very informative. Yes, caloric balance is still an important factor, but calories are not the entire picture for people with hormonal and metabolic imbalances, that is why I'm trying to say that low carb is better than eating grains and bananas in the attempt of calling it healthy for those with insulin resistance and PCOS.

I have a banana almost every day. You can eat them. Really.