Not losing weight!

I'm just wondering if I'm eating the correct amount of calories. I'm a 34 year old female, weigh 171 and I'm 5'7". My BMR is 1548 and my TDEE is 2128. I'm currently eating 1635 calories a day. I walk 4 times a week at a moderate pace and do zumba 2x a week.
«1

Replies

  • AmyRhubarb
    AmyRhubarb Posts: 6,890 Member
    According to your ticker you've lost 15 lbs.... :smile:

    How long have you been trying to lose, and has the current calorie goal a recent change, or have you been eating at this level the whole time?
  • I've lost 15 pounds since December 30th when I started. I've been stuck with the same 1-2 pound variance for almost a month.
  • _Zardoz_
    _Zardoz_ Posts: 3,987 Member
    If your not losing weight you're eating at maintenance. So you're either not being accurate with your counting or not logging everything. Over estimating your exercise calories or your figures are off. Go back to basics make sure you are weighing and measuring everything accurately and that you are using accurate entries on the database. Then double check your BMR/TDEE figures but remember what ever calculator you use to determine those it's an estimate. Good luck
  • I measure everything and count everything I eat. My BMR and TDEE are accurate from the calculator I used today.
  • kgeyser
    kgeyser Posts: 22,505 Member
    You may be overestimating your calorie burn. You've lost 15 lbs, it takes less energy to simply move your body around now, and your body has probably adapted to your exercise routine, meaning it takes fewer calories to simply do the exercises. Keep up with the weighing/measuring of food and switch up your exercise routine. Add intervals to your walks, take an extra zumba class instead of a walk, or try a new workout all together. See if that gets the scale moving.
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    I measure everything and count everything I eat. My BMR and TDEE are accurate from the calculator I used today.

    If you don't weight your food (solids) you have a large chance you are underestimating the intake along with probably over estimating burns.
  • I'll try to switch up my workouts. Thanks!
  • Well, the first thing that comes to mind is to shake things up a bit. If you've been eating and exercising at the same level for quite a while, your body may adjust to that level of intake and activity. Maybe throw some higher intensity workouts in throughout the week. How long have you been eating that reduced calorie level? It takes quite some time for adaptation to happen, but it could potentially be responsible for your weight stall. Eating at maintenance levels for a while (slightly increased caloric intake from your current level) can help increase metabolism, but honestly you're not that far in deficit to begin with. A leptin reset can sometimes pop people out of a plateau as well, but the necessary diet changes can be kind of extreme. Intermittent fasting is something else to look into, and would be a bit easier with lots of health benefits. Check out the Fast Diet.

    IF study:
    http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/23582559

    Here's an excerpt from Wikipedia on leptins:
    Dieters who lose weight experience a drop in levels of circulating leptin. This drop causes reversible decreases in thyroid activity, sympathetic tone, and energy expenditure in skeletal muscle, and increases in muscle efficiency and parasympathetic tone. The result is that a person who has lost weight has a lower basal metabolic rate than an individual at the same weight who has never lost weight; these changes are leptin-mediated, homeostatic responses meant to reduce energy expenditure and promote weight regain.

    Some leptin reset stuff.
    http://jackkruse.com/my-leptin-prescription/
    http://jackkruse.com/the-leptin-rx-faqs/
  • Anniebotnen
    Anniebotnen Posts: 332 Member
    Based on your post, you do not appear to do any strength training. Is that is the case, I highly recommend you start a good strength program. This will help fire up your metabolism and help maintain lean body mass while you are losing weight. Good luck!
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    I'll try to switch up my workouts. Thanks!

    Exercise changes doesn't mean weight loss...switching stuff up will give you a bit more calorie burn but not much.
  • Based on your post, you do not appear to do any strength training. Is that is the case, I highly recommend you start a good strength program. This will help fire up your metabolism and help maintain lean body mass while you are losing weight. Good luck!

    This! Putting on a bit of muscle boosts your metabolism a lot. It's difficult/impossible to put on muscle while cutting calories unless you've got plenty of body fat, but as this guy mentioned it'll help maintain lean body mass which is important for burning calories and which tends to waste on long term diet programs with no lifting/resistance training.
  • I'll try to switch up my workouts. Thanks!

    Exercise changes doesn't mean weight loss...switching stuff up will give you a bit more calorie burn but not much.

    I already weigh/measure/calculate everything I eat. And log my exercise. I have a fitbit and use run keeper and MFP. I like to think I'm headed in the right direction.....
  • hannaawh
    hannaawh Posts: 51
    It might be that your body is just slow in losing weight.
    (People can be ignorant sometimes - "oh when I lose 1 lbs a week by eating 1800 calories then EVERYBODY must and obviously you're just not logging everything and cheating on yourself"-People, sigh)

    Does your diet bother you, is it hard for you to eat that little or did it become normal for you?
    If you're comfortable with it, just stick with it. Not losing motivation is key, and even if it goes a little slower for you than for some other people, I am confident you will be able to get it off!
  • Thank you!
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    I'll try to switch up my workouts. Thanks!

    Exercise changes doesn't mean weight loss...switching stuff up will give you a bit more calorie burn but not much.

    I already weigh/measure/calculate everything I eat. And log my exercise. I have a fitbit and use run keeper and MFP. I like to think I'm headed in the right direction.....

    You are headed in the right direction..you have lost some weight and seem to be fluctuating 1-2lbs..which is actually quite normal.

    I have gone 4 weeks without weight loss...sometimes fluctuating as well...it's not linear...

    I guess my point was "changing up" your exercise doesn't do much if anything at all...I have been doing the same exercise for 6months...weight lifting and yes I lift heavier almost every workout but it is the same exercise...if I changed my exercise up everytime I flucuated I would be going nuts..

    and not to belabour this point but logging accurately is key and you measure/weigh everything ...there is one more thing...choosing the correct entries...it can be a pain sometimes but that is also important.

    Your diary is closed so it's hard to say for sure about that but I find lots (even vetrans) sometimes have to go back and readjust because they realize the entries they used weren't right...
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    It might be that your body is just slow in losing weight.
    (People can be ignorant sometimes - "oh when I lose 1 lbs a week by eating 1800 calories then EVERYBODY must and obviously you're just not logging everything and cheating on yourself"-People, sigh)

    Does your diet bother you, is it hard for you to eat that little or did it become normal for you?
    If you're comfortable with it, just stick with it. Not losing motivation is key, and even if it goes a little slower for you than for some other people, I am confident you will be able to get it off!

    I don't see that anywhere in this thread...

    am I missing something?
  • hannaawh
    hannaawh Posts: 51
    If your not losing weight you're eating at maintenance. So you're either not being accurate with your counting or not logging everything. Over estimating your exercise calories or your figures are off. Go back to basics make sure you are weighing and measuring everything accurately

    edit: @SezxyStef not angelabenderz
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    If your not losing weight you're eating at maintenance. So you're either not being accurate with your counting or not logging everything. Over estimating your exercise calories or your figures are off. Go back to basics make sure you are weighing and measuring everything accurately

    edit: @SezxyStef not angelabenderz

    This quote has nothing about what you said earlier...I see no reference to I eat this and lose this so you should be able to as well...

    It was standard advice given to those with a closed diary who are saying they aren't losing weight...and don't let people know in advance that they do weigh/measure etc.
  • hannaawh
    hannaawh Posts: 51
    If your not losing weight you're eating at maintenance. So you're either not being accurate with your counting or not logging everything. Over estimating your exercise calories or your figures are off. Go back to basics make sure you are weighing and measuring everything accurately

    edit: @SezxyStef not angelabenderz

    This quote has nothing about what you said earlier...I see no reference to I eat this and lose this so you should be able to as well...

    It was standard advice given to those with a closed diary who are saying they aren't losing weight...and don't let people know in advance that they do weigh/measure etc.

    It is rude and something I do not just notice on this thread.
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    If your not losing weight you're eating at maintenance. So you're either not being accurate with your counting or not logging everything. Over estimating your exercise calories or your figures are off. Go back to basics make sure you are weighing and measuring everything accurately

    edit: @SezxyStef not angelabenderz

    This quote has nothing about what you said earlier...I see no reference to I eat this and lose this so you should be able to as well...

    It was standard advice given to those with a closed diary who are saying they aren't losing weight...and don't let people know in advance that they do weigh/measure etc.

    It is rude and something I do not just notice on this thread.

    your new here aren't you....
  • I'll try to switch up my workouts. Thanks!

    Exercise changes doesn't mean weight loss...switching stuff up will give you a bit more calorie burn but not much.

    I suggested switching up workouts as well. Upon looking into it further, I think Stef is right. Periodic cycling of workouts is supposed to speed up lean mass gains a bit, but I don't see anything about it affecting weight loss. Sorry about that.

    Stef, do you have any opinions on the leptin reset? The whole biochemical side seems solid, but I don't know if that program actually increases leptin sensitivity. Can't find any actual research.
  • wtw0n
    wtw0n Posts: 1,083 Member
    I guess my point was "changing up" your exercise doesn't do much if anything at all...I have been doing the same exercise for 6months...weight lifting and yes I lift heavier almost every workout but it is the same exercise...if I changed my exercise up everytime I flucuated I would be going nuts..

    Actually, switching up your workouts once in a while does do a lot. Why? Because once you get used to a type of exercise, it becomes less challenging and therefore less effective.

    When it comes to lifting you (most likely) increase weights, do different kinds of exercises, change the number of sets and/or repeats and so on. That is mixing it up. However, doing the same kind of cardio all the time (like the same workout DVDs, or using a stationary bike), that becomes less effective. Changing a workout routine about once a month is definitely not a bad idea.
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    I guess my point was "changing up" your exercise doesn't do much if anything at all...I have been doing the same exercise for 6months...weight lifting and yes I lift heavier almost every workout but it is the same exercise...if I changed my exercise up everytime I flucuated I would be going nuts..

    Actually, switching up your workouts once in a while does do a lot. Why? Because once you get used to a type of exercise, it becomes less challenging and therefore less effective.

    When it comes to lifting you (most likely) increase weights, do different kinds of exercises, change the number of sets and/or repeats and so on. That is mixing it up. However, doing the same kind of cardio all the time (like the same workout DVDs, or using a stationary bike), that becomes less effective. Changing a workout routine about once a month is definitely not a bad idea.

    Actually I do the same exercises same # of reps and sets...there are two different workouts and I do squats for every workout...

    I only mix it up by adding weight when I succeed at one...but that doesn't always happen.

    Your body getting "used to exercise" = you are getting fitter

    Increase intensity that is that is required...

    Muscle confusion is a marketing scheme.
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    I'll try to switch up my workouts. Thanks!

    Exercise changes doesn't mean weight loss...switching stuff up will give you a bit more calorie burn but not much.

    I suggested switching up workouts as well. Upon looking into it further, I think Stef is right. Periodic cycling of workouts is supposed to speed up lean mass gains a bit, but I don't see anything about it affecting weight loss. Sorry about that.

    Stef, do you have any opinions on the leptin reset? The whole biochemical side seems solid, but I don't know if that program actually increases leptin sensitivity. Can't find any actual research.

    nope...anything I have seen has to do with going paleo or HCG or some other restrictive diet which I don't subscribe too...so to me it's a null.
  • Muscle confusion is a marketing scheme.

    I don't know if I agree with this. Obviously you can make great gains and never have to switch your exercise routine up, but there are whole of of people who swear by muscle confusion for faster gains. That doesn't mean it's true necessarily--they could all be brainwashed--but it makes sense from a theoretical standpoint. Is there a reason you're so sure it's a worthless concept?
  • SezxyStef
    SezxyStef Posts: 15,267 Member
    Muscle confusion is a marketing scheme.

    I don't know if I agree with this. Obviously you can make great gains and never have to switch your exercise routine up, but there are whole of of people who swear by muscle confusion for faster gains. That doesn't mean it's true necessarily--they could all be brainwashed--but it makes sense from a theoretical standpoint. Is there a reason you're so sure it's a worthless concept?

    there are no studies to prove or disprove this...so my reasons are behind the fitness industry constantly using this term in their advertisments...specifically P90X which is a beachbody workout and for me anything to do with beachbody is a gimmick...
  • Haha, that's fair. That being said, periodization has been around since the 50's and long predates P90x. Keeping it simple can be a good move either way, I just don't think it should be written off entirely.
  • Anniebotnen
    Anniebotnen Posts: 332 Member
    I don't think it's a marketing scheme, although some companies may use it in their marketing. When you keep doing the same thing for any length of time, the body adapts and becomes more efficient at that particular exercise. More efficient = less calorie burn and less benefit. And yes, it does also mean that you have become more "fit" at performing that particular movement. This adaptation is what causes the body to lay down more muscle tissue as a result of lifting weights, for example. To maximize calorie burn and build more muscle or increase fitness, you need to periodically change and do something new that your body is not yet efficient at doing. I believe there have been studies on this although I cannot cite one right this minute.
  • Sreneesa
    Sreneesa Posts: 1,170 Member
    I don't know.

    I lost and always have lost a lot of weight just running for 45mins to one hour on the treadmill and eating at a deficit. I did at the beginning of this fitness "journey" and in the past when I didn't log.

    I only stopped running on treadmill because now I strength train instead.

    The intensity of your cardio will help you lose weight with a calorie deficit.

    It has always amazed me when people have several months and years plateau with no weight loss and say they are logging, eating at a calorie deficit, and exercising.

    I guess everyone's body and metabolism are different because I never had several months or years plateaus in the past even when I didn't log calories or exercise.

    I will say just like the other woman said above that I have went 3 weeks not losing anything but all of a sudden will lose a few lbs. Honestly, this has only been since I have started strength training...if I continued to run I know my weight loss would be steady. But I'm not complaining because my legs are looking oh so great from strength training! lol.. I'm content and patient because I'm at a good weight now..just want to lose more and look better and reveal my muscles. lol

    My comment above about not losing weight and being stuck at a plateau for several months or years wasn't aimed at the OP just something that I have always wondered and been amazed by when I hear other people say this.
  • SLLRunner
    SLLRunner Posts: 12,942 Member
    I've lost 15 pounds since December 30th when I started. I've been stuck with the same 1-2 pound variance for almost a month.
    So, that means you have lost 15 pounds in 11 weeks, which averages out to about 1.3 pounds a week.

    Did you set up your goals to lose 1 pound a week or 1.5? If so, it seems to me you are in the ball park and doing just fine. If you are not in the ballpark, look into your logging habits for both food and exercise. Often we underestimate calories consumed and overestimate calories burned.