STARVATION MODE?
todsho
Posts: 9
I have been using MFP for a while but this is my first post. I just have a question about "starvation mode". I have been under my calorie count quite often. Sometimes by as much as 300 calories. I get the warning about "starvation mode". I have lost 11lbs in about two months. My last weigh in I gained a pound. It kind of startled me! My question is, What happens when your body goes into "starvation mode"? Could this be why I started gaining? I feel just fine. I have been under my calories because I am satisfied with what I ate, meaning not hungry. I am afraid that if I eat more I will not reach my goal. Any advice?
0
Replies
-
I have been using MFP for a while but this is my first post. I just have a question about "starvation mode". I have been under my calorie count quite often. Sometimes by as much as 300 calories. I get the warning about "starvation mode". I have lost 11lbs in about two months. My last weigh in I gained a pound. It kind of startled me! My question is, What happens when your body goes into "starvation mode"? Could this be why I started gaining? I feel just fine. I have been under my calories because I am satisfied with what I ate, meaning not hungry. I am afraid that if I eat more I will not reach my goal. Any advice?
If you go well under what you need for a good amount of time you can get into starvation mode, but by losing 11 pounds in 8-9 weeks it doesnt seem as if you are eating at that huge of a deficit.
and gaining 1 pound can be anything0 -
This content has been removed.
-
If you are getting that message you are too much under and need to eat more food.
Starvation mode as thought of is a myth.
But if you eat too little for a long period of time your metabolism slows..which makes it harder to lose weight at an appropriate deficet.0 -
thavoice,
300 under daily 1360 goal. Sorry, I should give more info..Thanx for the reply0 -
1000 calories will not make you gain weight. Starving won't make you gain weight. Sorry.0
-
Starvation mode is largely a myth. While your metabolism will slow from starving, "starving" doesn't mean eating 300 calories less than you were supposed to. It means literally starving for a few days.0
-
Starvation mode is largely a myth. While your metabolism will slow from starving, "starving" doesn't mean eating 300 calories less than you were supposed to. It means literally starving for a few days.
I agree, if your eating 1000 you arent getting near it. Most likely just water, fluctuations, or eating more than what you had been thinking.
1 lb isnt much to worry about.....heck...could be the scale! I know digital scales, if used on a cold floor/room will be off by up to 3 lbs to the bad! (and I have seen thast first hand with mine)0 -
While "starvation mode" has a lot of hype that surrounds it that is completely unnecessary, I have to diverge from the crowd here. There's a reason you get that warning, and it's because you're eating too little. That's probably not the reason you gained a pound - that is most likely water - but you should definitely be meeting your goal, especially a goal that low.
Eating significantly below your BMR for a sustained period of time can cause metabolic slowdown. It's not starvation mode; it's more like adaptation. Your body doesn't have the energy it needs, so it sort of reworks itself to be able to run on the number of calories you've been giving it. I don't see that happening in the beginning of a journey, but as you continue to lose weight it may pose a problem.0 -
Thank you all for the replies...I guess I'm just paranoid about going backward instead of reaching my goal. So would 300 cal under slow matabolism? Or should I really try to be at my aloted 1360?0
-
While "starvation mode" has a lot of hype that surrounds it that is completely unnecessary, I have to diverge from the crowd here. There's a reason you get that warning, and it's because you're eating too little. That's probably not the reason you gained a pound - that is most likely water - but you should definitely be meeting your goal, especially a goal that low.
Eating significantly below your BMR for a sustained period of time can cause metabolic slowdown. It's not starvation mode; it's more like adaptation. Your body doesn't have the energy it needs, so it sort of reworks itself to be able to run on the number of calories you've been giving it. I don't see that happening in the beginning of a journey, but as you continue to lose weight it may pose a problem.
That's all correct and well, but some people think it will make them GAIN weight. Their metabolism would only slow from starvation after the fat reserves were used up. I've never seen fat, starving people, and that's why starvation mode is widely frowned upon here.0 -
Thank you all for the replies...I guess I'm just paranoid about going backward instead of reaching my goal. So would 300 cal under slow matabolism? Or should I really try to be at my aloted 1360?
You should eat your 1360 because your body needs the nutrients and fuel. Consider your long term health.0 -
I have been eating a lot more fruits and vegitables which tend to fill me up which is why I think I am often under the 1360. I always had a problem with "moderation" in the past. Now, since I started eating differently, I feel very full most of the time after eating.0
-
I have been eating a lot more fruits and vegitables which tend to fill me up which is why I think I am often under the 1360. I always had a problem with "moderation" in the past. Now, since I started eating differently, I feel very full most of the time after eating.
but your body still needs the calories for fuel.
there are ways to get calories in without treats.
Full fat milk, olive oil, avocadoes, bananas, ice cream, butter, peanut butter....eat a good marbled steak....0 -
Dont worry about going under you calories not a big deal; what is a big deal is nutrition. Look at your daily nutrition in your MFP if you are getting enough vitamins and minerals then you will be fine. If you aren't try adding a supplement shack or multi vit0
-
If you are getting that message you are too much under and need to eat more food.
Starvation mode as thought of is a myth.
But if you eat too little for a long period of time your metabolism slows..which makes it harder to lose weight at an appropriate deficet.
THIS. If you eat more than 1200 calories I bet you will still lose weight. I don't mean more than your TDEE!0 -
I need to find an animated .gif of a transformer transforming into a skinnier transformer with the tagline "Starvation mode, activate!". I think it would come in handy at times like this.
I'm sorry but I can't take people who think that somehow they will gain weight by eating less than an amount where they were already losing weight. That is just so blatantly illogical I don't even know what to say.0 -
I was just worried about my metabolism slowing down due to not enough calories..thats all0
-
I was just worried about my metabolism slowing down due to not enough calories..thats all
Yes, you can make your metabolism slow by eating less which means that you might not lose as much as you would have expected based on your intake and your previous loss rate. But you will never, ever, gain weight as a result of eating less.
That one pound you gained is most likely water weight due to you starting exercise. When you exercise your muscles retain water.
The idea that you can put on fat by eating to little is a laughable fallacy and it doesn't take thinking about it very long to see why.
That said its a bad idea to eat that little and you probably should eat more than you are if you are only netting 800 calories.0 -
I had been eating 1200 calories with the same work out for over a year only lost 25 pounds the first 4 months, and haven't lost since I first started 2 years ago and have plateaued ever since. I was hungry, tired, had headaches and my hair was falling out. Then I upped my calories as I burned more and start lifting heavier- I've lost 4 pounds in 2 weeks. My body is more defined, I've lost inches and I way upped my protein to hit my macros. This matters. Same thing as gassing up your car, the further you go, the more fuel the body needs. Always changing your routine, the body does get use to it and stops responding, you have to switch it up, now maintaining is a different story. Starvation mode is real. Your metabolism gets all messed up0
-
Starvation mode is real.
No, no its really not. You cannot gain fat by eating at huge deficits. You can lower your metabolism but you cannot lower your metabolism so low that 800 calories becomes an amount that you put fat on.
If you eat slightly below your maintenance level you can lose fat healthily. If you eat way below your maintenance level you will lose both fat and some muscle. If you eat drastically below your maintenance level you will lose fat and muscle and your metabolism will lower in an attempt to compensate. At no point during this process do you stop losing weight and you most certainly do not start to put fat back on.
This reminds me of a post from someone who seriously believed that proof of starvation mode was starving malnourished children in Africa who had large engorged bellies. She thought they were fat because of it. Not kidding, she was serious.0 -
I am very new to this nutrition thing, so, I'm sorry if I ask dumb questions that have been beat to death before or make comments that some may think is common knowledge, but everyone has been at the same stage of the game as I am at one time or another..0
-
I am very new to this nutrition thing, so, I'm sorry if I ask dumb questions that have been beat to death before or make comments that some may think is common knowledge, but everyone has been at the same stage of the game as I am at one time or another..
Sorry yeah you are correct it is a topic that has been beaten to death in these forums numerous times so it carries a lot of baggage with it.
Short answer is no you are not in "starvation mode". What you experienced is a gain in water weight due to water retention in your muscles from starting to exercise. What you will do however eating as little as you are is lose muscle along with fat and your metabolism will lower meaning your body will naturally burn less and less calories. This is not healthy. You really need to eat more than you are, that part is true. The idea that you will put on fat though is false.0 -
I am very new to this nutrition thing, so, I'm sorry if I ask dumb questions that have been beat to death before or make comments that some may think is common knowledge, but everyone has been at the same stage of the game as I am at one time or another..
Sorry yeah you are correct it is a topic that has been beaten to death in these forums numerous times so it carries a lot of baggage with it.
Short answer is no you are not in "starvation mode". What you experienced is a gain in water weight due to water retention in your muscles from starting to exercise. What you will do however eating as little as you are is lose muscle along with fat and your metabolism will lower meaning your body will naturally burn less and less calories. This is not healthy. You really need to eat more than you are, that part is true. The idea that you will put on fat though is false.
Thanx..That's an answer that I can understand...makes sense now.
Now I know that I shoul'nt be afraid to up my calories.0 -
While "starvation mode" has a lot of hype that surrounds it that is completely unnecessary, I have to diverge from the crowd here. There's a reason you get that warning, and it's because you're eating too little. That's probably not the reason you gained a pound - that is most likely water - but you should definitely be meeting your goal, especially a goal that low.
Eating significantly below your BMR for a sustained period of time can cause metabolic slowdown. It's not starvation mode; it's more like adaptation. Your body doesn't have the energy it needs, so it sort of reworks itself to be able to run on the number of calories you've been giving it. I don't see that happening in the beginning of a journey, but as you continue to lose weight it may pose a problem.
I've read the responses, and this is the most comprehensive one I'd emphasize; if you eat another 100-150 calories a day you probably won't get that message and it won't hurt. You may also want to consult with your doctor if you're coming that far under a calorie goal that low to make sure it's safe and your nutritional needs are being met.0 -
This is all great info for someone just starting out like myself. I always thought that less calories...more weight loss.. I now know that's not always true.
I don't deliberately go under my calories but I will now try harder to come closer to at least 12000 -
Starvation mode is real.
No, no its really not. You cannot gain fat by eating at huge deficits. You can lower your metabolism but you cannot lower your metabolism so low that 800 calories becomes an amount that you put fat on.
who said starvation mode made you gain weight? I did not say that. So next time, you should take the time to read before you comment. Thank you. Moving on.
Starvation mode is real, it simply means eating to little netting below 1200 calories after working out or eating below 1200 calories. You can lose weight, but eventually you will plateau and eating too little can mess up your metabolism. You can YouTube that.
You become lethargic, low energy, headaches , hair falling out, even increased hunger. Because your not eating enough your body begins to pull nutrients from your muscles. And that's not a good thing, especially when your trying to tone up.
For example: If your exercising and burning 500 calories and only eating 1200 calories your only netting 700 calories: no bueno. You need more fuel. But I don't know what your stats are or what your goal is, to just lose weight or build muscle, but the pound thing can be water weight and it will fluctuate. Not much to worry about. If you are still not sure I would say look for helloitsmedan. He has a great road map that can help you. He's helped thousands of people on here.0 -
who said starvation mode made you gain weight? I did not say that. So next time, you should take the time to read before you comment. Thank you. Moving on.
The OP said that. They said they gained a pound and was wondering if it was because of starvation mode. Therefore the OP's definition of starvation mode is eating so little that you gain fat. That was the "starvation mode" I was addressing because it is the OPs thread.Starvation mode is real, it simply means eating to little netting below 1200 calories after working out or eating below 1200 calories.
You seem to be confusing adaptive thermogenesis, a real thing (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20935667) with "starvation mode", a total myth http://www.nowloss.com/starvation-mode-myth.htm. Adaptive thermogenesis is what you are describing and yes that exists. "Starvation mode" is a commonly propogated myth that if you eat too few calories you will actually put on fat. This is the myth that the OP was wondering if she should believe given her original post. If you read it again you will see she is wondering if "starvation mode" was the reason she gained a pound.You can lose weight, but eventually you will plateau and eating too little can mess up your metabolism.
Right, but that is adaptive thermogenesis not "starvation mode". I think we might be just talking past eachother but I'm addressing what the OP was talking about and you seem to be talking about something else.You can YouTube that.
You become lethargic, low energy, headaches , hair falling out, even increased hunger. Because your not eating enough your body begins to pull nutrients from your muscles.
Again, adaptive thermogenesis.And that's not a good thing, especially when your trying to tone up.
For example: If your exercising and burning 500 calories and only eating 1200 calories your only netting 700 calories: no bueno. You need more fuel. But I don't know what your stats are or what your goal is, to just lose weight or build muscle, but the pound thing can be water weight and it will fluctuate. Not much to worry about. If you are still not sure I would say look for helloitsmedan. He has a great road map that can help you. He's helped thousands of people on here.
OP this here is good info. She is not wrong, eating that low will cause you to lose muscle, become lethargic and slow your metabolism down through adaptive thermogenesis which is not what you want. The idea of "starvation mode" whereby your body actually holds onto and ADDS fat under starvation conditions is a total myth.0 -
Dude!! Where are you getting your information from? My trainer NEVER told me that starvation mode was the body putting on fat. Wtf are you talking about, seriously. ????. And I was answering post above me, once again you should read.
OP: If you really want some good info here's a helpful site:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/974889-in-place-of-a-road-map-short-n-sweet
Dan is amazing and helped me learn a lot. And thousands of others, he really knows his stuff. I hope this helps. He's helped thousands of people on my fitness pal.0 -
Dude!! Where are you getting your information from? My trainer NEVER told me that starvation mode was the body putting on fat. Wtf are you talking about, seriously. ????. And I was answering post above me, once again you should read.
OP: If you really want some good info here's a helpful site:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/974889-in-place-of-a-road-map-short-n-sweet
Dan is amazing and helped me learn a lot. And thousands of others, he really knows his stuff. I hope this helps. He's helped thousands of people on my fitness pal.
I am talking about the myth of a "starvation mode" whereby you eat so little you put on fat. I know its absolutely ridiculous but this IS a myth that is propogated out there and believe it or not people DO buy into it including people on these forums. This is the exact myth the OP was referring to. Read her first post. again she was asking if she PUT ON ONE POUND because of STARVATION MODE. I'm addressing what the OP said and what the OP is talking about not what you thought starvation mode was which is apparently adaptive thermogenesis in your mind and what your personal trainer told you.
But seriously, google adaptive thermogenesis and find the scientific studies and descriptions of the causes and effects in an intelligent manner then google "starvation mode" and be in awe of the crazy or read the descriptions of the myth. Words have meanings and "starvation mode" refers to something different than adaptive thermogenesis.0 -
My trainer explained to me that " starvation mode" was , not fueling the body enough and causing plateaus. That's probably his way of simplifying it. I have never heard of gaining weight ... That sounds absolutely retarded to me. Well good thing you told me that, I had no ideal people thought that-that was starvation mode SMH. Well I don't spread that ignorant disease lol good lord.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions