Low carbs diet !
Replies
-
So fat at 9 calories a gram versus protein and carbs at 4 calories each and its the carbs causing calorie density? Go figure. Fruit on average has 50-75 calories per piece (except bananas) verses butter/oil which are typically 100calories a tablespoon. You logic of "calorie dense carbs" holds no logic at all - its the fat content in the product making it calorie dense. Same thing when you get a high fat meat product like bacon or ribs - the calories go through the roof.
It's worth noting that he said calorie dense foods - not calorie dense carbs (which doesn't really make a lot of sense). You're misquoting his post.0 -
A low carb diet is why I am on this site to lose weight. Sure, I got super thin for 2 months, then ate a pink bunny peep and that was that. I will NEVER do one of those again. I have yet to know anyone outside of being a diabetic who was actually able to keep to it for longer than a year.0
-
Can't we all just agree that if you have a medical condition or find diet adherence greater with a low carb diet, that you should do it. There really is no one superior diet plan over another. A calorie deficit is for weight loss, macros support satiety, muscle retention, energy levels, etc...0
-
A low carb diet is why I am on this site to lose weight. Sure, I got super thin for 2 months, then ate a pink bunny peep and that was that. I will NEVER do one of those again. I have yet to know anyone outside of being a diabetic who was actually able to keep to it for longer than a year.
Who says you have to eliminate carbs for more than a year? Do you really think you need to eat the exact same way (caloric intake, macronutrient distribution, etc.) you're eating today for the rest of your life?Can't we all just agree that if you have a medical condition or find diet adherence greater with a low carb diet, that you should do it. There really is no one superior diet plan over another. A calorie deficit is for weight loss, macros support satiety, muscle retention, energy levels, etc...
Sounds reasonable to me. Then again though, I find that reason rarely enters into it.
0 -
Can't we all just agree that if you have a medical condition or find diet adherence greater with a low carb diet, that you should do it. There really is no one superior diet plan over another. A calorie deficit is for weight loss, macros support satiety, muscle retention, energy levels, etc...
If only - totally agree though.
0 -
I have a confession: I FREAKING LOVE CARBS!
They are tasty, make me feel good, aid my low blood pressure... I eat them at every time of the day or week. One of my faves is rice pudding with cinnomon and sugar before bed. I have good whole bread almost every morning, Bananas are awesome.....
I´m here since 5 months and lost almost 20kg (over 40lbs) with a lot of carbs in my diet ;-)
So I wouldn´t take that low carb thing too serious... Just do what works for you. If you ignore cravings for too long they become quite demanding.
Nicely said!
My body needs carbs too and I have successfully lost over 60 pounds in a year with low carbs (and once in a while a nice big carb binge) haha0 -
Haven't read all the responses, I just wanted to interject that paleo does not = low carb. Can a person eat a low carb paleo style diet (even a ketogenic paleo diet)? Yes, but the majority of paleo adherents don't eat very low carb. Many carb cycle, some are moderate carb and still others eat high carb. I tend to fall in moderate carb, about 125 grams per day. For some that would be considered low carb, but really percentage wise it isn't.
No carbs is seriously impossible for long term. VLC is possible, but should be reserved for people with severe metabolic conditions or for special populations like epileptics.0 -
I have a confession: I FREAKING LOVE CARBS!
They are tasty, make me feel good, aid my low blood pressure... I eat them at every time of the day or week. One of my faves is rice pudding with cinnomon and sugar before bed. I have good whole bread almost every morning, Bananas are awesome.....
I´m here since 5 months and lost almost 20kg (over 40lbs) with a lot of carbs in my diet ;-)
So I wouldn´t take that low carb thing too serious... Just do what works for you. If you ignore cravings for too long they become quite demanding.
Love your answer!!!!!!!!!!!!! 20KGS.............. WOW!!! Amazing!!0 -
Worse thing I ever did was low carb. I'll save you from the goriest of the details but I started developing PCOS and other *kitten*.0
-
Worse thing I ever did was low carb. I'll save you from the goriest of the details but I started developing PCOS and other *kitten*.0
-
You dont develop PCOS from low carb dieting. Its a gene defect. You were born with it. Low carb dieting is required for PCOS for a reason.0
-
This odd, given that low carb diets are often prescribed for PCOS. Hope you've found something that works for you now.Worse thing I ever did was low carb. I'll save you from the goriest of the details but I started developing PCOS and other *kitten*.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
This odd, given that low carb diets are often prescribed for PCOS. Hope you've found something that works for you now.Worse thing I ever did was low carb. I'll save you from the goriest of the details but I started developing PCOS and other *kitten*.
Yes, very odd, as PCOS goes hand-in-hand with insulin resistance. You don't "develop" PCOS by partaking in a low-carb diet.0 -
35 How To Become Insulin Resistant (The Paleo Way) 1
Do you want to be insulin resistant? According to the low-carb leaders, you shouldn't. Gary Taubes says, "When you're insulin-resistant, you secrete more insulin and you store more fat" (p.124, WWGF). Mark Sisson wrote, "Here's a quick summary of some of the unpleasant consequences of becoming insulin resistant ... Fat cells get bigger (and fatter), so you gain weight" (p.74, The Primal Blueprint). Loren Cordain informs us that, "It's only recently that scientists have begun expanding the scope of insulin re-sistance. In research worldwide, this condition is being linked to many other chronic diseases and health problems" (p.78. The Paleo Diet). Insulin resistance is associated with obesity, cancer, and heart disease. But what was the evolutionary purpose of insu-lin resistance? And what sort of diets promote it? In this video, I argue that high-protein diets could predispose you to insulin re-sistance. How authentically Paleo do you really want to be? And what sort of body shape was the true Paleolithic ideal?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=prdh62Qklvc&index=35&list=PLv3QDzdxan_JkGX47Rpboyh2oYyAFZDBA 0 -
You don't have to restrict carbs at all (and shouldn't) if you exercise a lot. I love that I can exercise hard every day and burn tons of calories and get to eat pretty much whatever I want as long as the calories fit, still hit my calorie goal, and lose weight!
Plus, low carb diets are VERY hard on your kidneys and digestive system. You can get kidney failure and diverticulitis from them.0 -
You don't have to restrict carbs at all (and shouldn't) if you exercise a lot. I love that I can exercise hard every day and burn tons of calories and get to eat pretty much whatever I want as long as the calories fit, still hit my calorie goal, and lose weight!
Plus, low carb diets are VERY hard on your kidneys and digestive system. You can get kidney failure and diverticulitis from them.
Lowering carbs isn't bad for your kidneys, but eating a diet too high in protein can place additional strain on them. As far as the digestive system, I've only noticed positive effects from not eating as many carbohydrates. There are many people who ascribe to a low-carb diet for medical reasons and do not suffer from digestive or kidney problems.0 -
I've tried low carb a couple times. And every time I go in thinking it will be great and end up hating it. Sometimes I last 3 days, sometimes I last months, but I always hate it. I love carbs. I still don't even eat that many compared to some people (my goal falls in the 100-150 range depending on activity), but that's as low as I want to go.
But that's ME. If you're insulin resistant, have PCOS, are diabetic or pre-diabetic, it might be an effective diet for you. If it helps you stick to your calorie deficit and leaves you satisfied and happy, then it might be an effective diet for you. (I feel like Jeff Foxworthy.) BUT, it's not the only way or the best way or the worst way to do things. Find whatever makes you physically and mentally feel the best along the way, and is something you can easily stick to. IMHO, adherence and happiness and satisfaction during any weight loss/maintenance process (I'd add in bulking but I know NOTHING about it :laugh: ) are far more important than the prospect of a pound or two more or less of lean mass at the end of things (serious lifters notwithstanding, of course).0 -
Who in your PMStimation is being stupid?I have PMS today and the stupidity on this site is testing my patience0 -
You don't have to restrict carbs at all (and shouldn't) if you exercise a lot. I love that I can exercise hard every day and burn tons of calories and get to eat pretty much whatever I want as long as the calories fit, still hit my calorie goal, and lose weight!
Plus, low carb diets are VERY hard on your kidneys and digestive system. You can get kidney failure and diverticulitis from them.
I'm not sure you understand the sort of food you eat on a LCHF diet, but it is not tonnes of protein - plus even if it was there are no studies to suggest that on healthy kidneys a diet high in protein will do any harm to them.
But back to the main point someone on a low carb diet is not eating any more protein (or does not need to) than anyone on a high carb diet.
Low Carb, moderate protein, high fat.0 -
I feel a million times better since eating less carbs. And it is bringing back my passion in the kitchen. I love figuring out how to make my favorite things with no processed ingredients. I am still surprised how many things were making me sick.0
-
Low carb is not for everyone but it does work for those who actually take the time to research the way of eating (NOT DIET) and do it the correct way. Of course any time you treat a new way of eating as temporary you are going to gain it back. People think you can just lose the weight and just eat whatever the hell you want after...and you can't. You WILL gain it back...be it low carb, low cal, or low fat. I've lost 53 pounds on low carb and can just about guarantee I won't gain it back (unless it's caused by something that is completely out of my control). I've never felt more control over food in my life. Carbs cause major cravings for me and make me feel constantly hungry (yes...even complex carbs)...not to mention digestive issues with them. I cannot maintain a caloric deficit that includes any substantial amount of carbs. (that's more than 50 for me...but I stay around 25 or less). I still have berries occasionally and nuts. But I've been on this for six months and am not tired of it at all. I'm a meat eater though and love my veggies so this WOE is very sustainable for me. I think anyone who is making a change to their diet should keep in mind that is needs to be something they can stick to and for me (and many others) that is low carb. Low carb isn't just meat either...you'd be surprised at how much variation you can have with just a little creativity! There's low carb versions of everything these days...and i don't mean low carb products...i mean recipes that have been manipulated to be low carb. I don't trust low carb products. You get some coconut flour or almond flour and you can even have baked goods again! Flax seed meal is another great low carb alternative. Also, you CAN come off of low carb to eat a more moderate carb diet but you have to increase your carb intake slowly to find your carb tolerance level (just like you do with your calories to find your maintenance level) . Most people just go straight from low carb to however many carbs they want and that's why they gain...the same as you would if you come off low cal and don't track calories at all.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
I think I'll go have an Adkins Peanut Butter bar!!!! Thanks for reminding me that I have one.0
-
Hi all - I am a whisker away from being diabetic and am trying to lose weight in a healthy and sustainable way. I am at present trying low carbs as I know I ate too much of them! It is not easy trying to understand all the conflicting stories/ideas and what works for some and not others. I am just trying to eat healthily and sensibly, do more exercise and eat well. I am very confused as to what the "right" regime for me actually is but am trying as my future health is important to me.0
-
Some folks seem to crave the validation that they are doing it right (this time). And as such, they wander around the boards telling others that they're doing it wrong. Seems odd to me, and yes, I agree, it DOES get old.
Who in your PMStimation is being stupid?I have PMS today and the stupidity on this site is testing my patience
he constant bickering over carbs, sugars, and fad diets that occur dailey on this site gets old quick
especially with PMS
truth is its all stupid
all diets work pick one stick to it lose weight.
Why do we need to validate who has the best diet/eating plan/lifestyle change and who is right or wrong?
Gets old quick
note: I'm not low carb, but I get why some folks are.0 -
You don't have to restrict carbs at all (and shouldn't) if you exercise a lot. I love that I can exercise hard every day and burn tons of calories and get to eat pretty much whatever I want as long as the calories fit, still hit my calorie goal, and lose weight!
Plus, low carb diets are VERY hard on your kidneys and digestive system. You can get kidney failure and diverticulitis from them.
This is total misinformation. It is actually high protien diets that hard on your kidneys and digestive system. Low carb diets are low carb/*medium* protien/high fat.0 -
I love low carb because I love to eat fats and veggies. However, I stopped doing it because it meant I could not have a bowl of old fashioned oatmeal or whole wheat pasta on a regular basis.0
-
I would never discourage a healthy adult from trying low carb because it worked very well for me for many pounds, and no, I haven't gained it back.
Same for me. I didn't gain the weight back and the diet worked for me at the time.
These days I occasionally do it for a weekend or odd day when I feel like Im getting back into bad habits (eg too much chocolate/too many bread slices). I find when I go back to eating normal, I tend to make better choices and not want to eat as much junk food. But these days I can't handle more than a weekend because I love eating carbs.0 -
I see that a lot of people don't like my post! But it's correct. There have been many documented cases of people who did Atkins for several years going into kidney failure. And I personally know a guy who got diverticulitis from Atkins. He went septic and everything, was hospitalized for a week, it was really nasty. I'm not misinformed.You don't have to restrict carbs at all (and shouldn't) if you exercise a lot. I love that I can exercise hard every day and burn tons of calories and get to eat pretty much whatever I want as long as the calories fit, still hit my calorie goal, and lose weight!
Plus, low carb diets are VERY hard on your kidneys and digestive system. You can get kidney failure and diverticulitis from them.
This is total misinformation. It is actually high protien diets that hard on your kidneys and digestive system. Low carb diets are low carb/*medium* protien/high fat.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions