Any way around eating exercise calories back?!?!

2»

Replies

  • nicolemontagna22
    nicolemontagna22 Posts: 229 Member
    @ OP: Really? 900 cals on WW? NO way!!! I've lost 40 lbs 6 years ago following that program and I still do, and I always ate the WP ( that you are suppose/encourage to) + my AP (optional) best part I've been maintaining for 6 years... If fruits/veggies are 0 pts + GHG's (protein, dairy, oil, etc, etc) how can you keep it under 1,000? I track my cals also and consume more like 1,600 + or -exercise included! WW is NOT a diet ;)

    Weight watchers gave me 21 lbs to start (old plan) and eventually got me down to 19. When tracking them side by side with mfp a few months ago I'd be at my 19 points but mfp would only show 950 calories-1000
  • bfanny
    bfanny Posts: 440 Member
    Yeah 21/19 + 35 WP + AP back then...
  • bfanny
    bfanny Posts: 440 Member
    But 900 cals? I don't think so...that would not be healthy, not then not now :)
  • brianpperkins
    brianpperkins Posts: 6,124 Member
    You're probably netting less than half of your estimated walking burns.

    http://www.runnersworld.com/weight-loss/how-many-calories-are-you-really-burning?page=single

    .30 x your weight x miles .... so 13 miles comes out to about 540 calories burned.
  • nicolemontagna22
    nicolemontagna22 Posts: 229 Member
    You're probably netting less than half of your estimated walking burns.

    http://www.runnersworld.com/weight-loss/how-many-calories-are-you-really-burning?page=single

    .30 x your weight x miles .... so 13 miles comes out to about 540 calories burned.

    Thanks for the equations. I trust myself more than calculators and apps so I like equations haha. That will be very helpful
  • nicolemontagna22
    nicolemontagna22 Posts: 229 Member
    So if I up it to 1500 I will be eating closer to the right amount?
  • blonditz
    blonditz Posts: 83 Member
    Yeah 21/19 + 35 WP + AP back then...

    The way I remember WW (old plan).....
    20pts at around 50 cal a point (roughly). +5 wp (35 divided by 7 is 5 per day average), most fruit was 1pt, veggies free, so add 50 cal for veggies
    So 1000cal daily + 250 in WP +50cal in free veggies +AP (which were half what you burned)

    MFP- 1620cal (my current number)+ workout calories

    Let say a I have a day where I burn 300 cal. WW gives me roughly 1450cal, MFP gives me 1920. Almost a 500 calorie difference!
  • sarainiowa
    sarainiowa Posts: 287 Member
    First of all, STOP using MFP to calculate your workouts. How much a workout burn is varies greatly from person to person. You need to invest in a heart rate monitor or at the vary least use a fitness calculator that takes into account your current weight and other information.

    Once you are accurately recording your workout burns, then you can decide how many calories you should be eating.

    I eat very few, if any of my workout calories back. It appears to be working well for my body. Every body is different but accurate information is key to success.
  • laurenawolf
    laurenawolf Posts: 262 Member
    I am one of the tiny ones.... It's funny - I did all the TDEE stuff etc.... and you know what the result was? 1200 calories.... :grumble:
    You know what maintenance is? 1260 calories..... :grumble: You know what I am? HUNGRY!!!! Hahahahahahaha! You have to just laugh sometimes! All the best to all of us!!!! We are all trying our best!

    :noway: :noway: :noway: :noway:
  • izzy0113
    izzy0113 Posts: 7 Member
    MFP says I should eat 1220 calories per day to lose approximately 2lbs / week.

    BMR = 1583

    TDEE = 1899

    I am SO confused now??? Do I consume 1220 calories daily? Or between BMR and TDEE? (i.e. something like 1600 calories?)

    I have a desk job and put in sedentary for activity level. As much as I tell myself I'm going to walk 3x / week it just doesnt' happen.
  • corgicake
    corgicake Posts: 846 Member
    Instead of eating half of them back, try eating them all back. Even though your calorie budget looks high, you're still shorting your body 650 calories, which if done every day is trying to get your body to drop more than a pound a week on top of what you're already set to lose. It makes all too much sense that you're getting backlash.

    Exercising heavily with a sensible calorie deficit creates numbers that don't look anything like a diet of the month. That's the entire point of doing it.
  • ksy1969
    ksy1969 Posts: 700 Member
    @ OP: Really? 900 cals on WW? NO way!!! I've lost 40 lbs 6 years ago following that program and I still do, and I always ate the WP ( that you are suppose/encourage to) + my AP (optional) best part I've been maintaining for 6 years... If fruits/veggies are 0 pts + GHG's (protein, dairy, oil, etc, etc) how can you keep it under 1,000? I track my cals also and consume more like 1,600 + or -exercise included! WW is NOT a diet ;)

    Weight watchers gave me 21 lbs to start (old plan) and eventually got me down to 19. When tracking them side by side with mfp a few months ago I'd be at my 19 points but mfp would only show 950 calories-1000

    I call BS on the OP as well. I did WW for 18 months before I decided I wanted to understand the calorie and macro nutrients better, plus I didn't want to keep paying the monthly fee. Your initial points may have equated out to 950 calories but you also had approximately 1800 to 2250 calories worth of what they called Weekly Points (WP) to use, depending on who you talked to, and you were encouraged to use them. You were also supposed to eat at least 5 servings of fruit and vegetables a day that they called 0 points but they were calorie laden as well. A single banana or apple can easily be 100 calories. So lets say, conservatively, if you ate all 5 servings and at least two of them were fruit, you could easily have another 250-300 calories of fruit and vegetables a day. Then divide that weekly point allowance by 7 days, that is approximately 285 calories a day. By my calculations that is 1500 calories a day. And that is if you don't eat a lot of high calorie fruit. If you eat a lot of green vegetables then I guess, maybe you could be around 1300 to 1400 calories a day.

    None of that calculation factored in Activitiy Points or AP's. You earned these AP's based on your exercise. Just like MFP wants you to eat back your exercise calories burned WW did as well.

    And that is the lowest a female could get. So you were not following the program properly.
  • nicolemontagna22
    nicolemontagna22 Posts: 229 Member
    @ OP: Really? 900 cals on WW? NO way!!! I've lost 40 lbs 6 years ago following that program and I still do, and I always ate the WP ( that you are suppose/encourage to) + my AP (optional) best part I've been maintaining for 6 years... If fruits/veggies are 0 pts + GHG's (protein, dairy, oil, etc, etc) how can you keep it under 1,000? I track my cals also and consume more like 1,600 + or -exercise included! WW is NOT a diet ;)

    Weight watchers gave me 21 lbs to start (old plan) and eventually got me down to 19. When tracking them side by side with mfp a few months ago I'd be at my 19 points but mfp would only show 950 calories-1000

    I call BS on the OP as well. I did WW for 18 months before I decided I wanted to understand the calorie and macro nutrients better, plus I didn't want to keep paying the monthly fee. Your initial points may have equated out to 950 calories but you also had approximately 1800 to 2250 calories worth of what they called Weekly Points (WP) to use, depending on who you talked to, and you were encouraged to use them. You were also supposed to eat at least 5 servings of fruit and vegetables a day that they called 0 points but they were calorie laden as well. A single banana or apple can easily be 100 calories. So lets say, conservatively, if you ate all 5 servings and at least two of them were fruit, you could easily have another 250-300 calories of fruit and vegetables a day. Then divide that weekly point allowance by 7 days, that is approximately 285 calories a day. By my calculations that is 1500 calories a day. And that is if you don't eat a lot of high calorie fruit. If you eat a lot of green vegetables then I guess, maybe you could be around 1300 to 1400 calories a day.

    None of that calculation factored in Activitiy Points or AP's. You earned these AP's based on your exercise. Just like MFP wants you to eat back your exercise calories burned WW did as well.

    And that is the lowest a female could get. So you were not following the program properly.

    When I signed up It was still the old plan. I didn't go to meeting just did it online. Probably should have went to meeting because the people online were telling me eating the weekly an activity points was optional and you'd lose less weight if you did. The way your explaining it makes a lot more sense. Too bad I didn't realize that before putting my body through hell all that time :/
  • RedRider230
    RedRider230 Posts: 89 Member
    Simply put- if you're eating above your BMR and below your TDEE, you should NOT eat back exercise calories. So find those out - here's a link iifym.com/tdee-calculator/ - and adjust your daily calories accordingly.

    That is giving me Bmr of 1397 (87 higher than the 1310 I've been doing and tdee of 2043. I'd probably be sick if I ate that much lol. At 1310 I was trying hard to make it to that number each day.

    If you do it, it'll work better than what you're doing now (which isn't working for you which is why you started this thread) So, either you try it for at LEAST 4 weeks to see if you get any positive results, or you keep doing what you're doing and know for a fact you will continue to stall on your weight loss. The decision is yours, we're just giving you helpful ways that work for us and many others here on MFP.

    Good day :flowerforyou:

    I agree! I was stalled too and after research and reading these forums I upped my calories to 1440 per day. Depending on the day I may or may not eat part of the exercise calories back. I've been losing weight every since and I find it much easier to manage!

Categories