Carbs and Pain...is there a connection?
narrowdoor
Posts: 28 Member
I was wondering if anyone knows of a connectionbetween carb intake and increased pain. I have a considerable amount of pain all the time, mostly joints...knees, hips, ankles, and such. I have been cutting back on carbs, with yesterday being very low and I felt pretty good all day and slept pain free last night. I do get fairly regular exercise by pushing through the pain but am tired of living on ibuprofin & tylenol....it is so bad for a body. Help please!!
0
Replies
-
Have you talked to your doctor about this?1
-
Have you talked to your doctor about this?
That's what I was thinking.0 -
I don't know about carbs but I saw something about gluten and sugar and since my body is filled with pain as well, I'm seriously thinking about it.0
-
I had heard something about processed carbs causing an inflammatory response in the body. Inflammation = pain. Or, in my case, edema. I digress... I'm not sure about whole grains. I can get by with eating small amounts of whole grains as well as legumes, yogurt, and fruit. It's certainly worth looking into.Research it. In the mean time, if cutting carbs helps, I say go for it. No sense in hurting.2
-
I agree that you should probably talk to your dr. BUT, yes, excess carbs can cause inflammation in many parts of your body. I'm not an expert but I have been seeing a nutritionist and have followed a primal eating plan for 6 months and feel I have learned alot. Primal is low-carb by default b/c you cut out all things processed, including bread and pasta and refined sugars... low-carb, clean foods, high healthy fat and lean protein and lots of fruits and veggies, nuts and no chemicals. I have never felt better and I'm down over 50 lbs! Last winter I had a bad bout of tendonitis in my foot and underwent 4 months of therapy. I also had headaches and other pain, all of which are gone now. Good luck to you!2
-
Yep, Humans were never designed to run on carbs as a main fuel that is why you get the inflamatory bloated feeling after eating carbs... Read "The Primal Blueprint" for more info.1
-
Great feedback ~ Thank you!!1
-
And yes I have spoken with docs about it, have been suffering with pain for years (10+) and their suggestion is always physical therapy, which even after about 4 months I feel worse. I had one doc scribe a pain med that made me completely sick...I don't have a lot of faith in medical advice any more...Back to the basics, we are designed a certain way and our current lifestyles and eating habits are not part of the original design. For now I just do research ( my new best friend), chiropractic care, and exercise...as much as I can stand0
-
yes! when i eat too many carbs (over 120 or so grams), my body is in pain. if i keep my carbs reasonable (around 100 grams), i am pain-free. good luck experimenting with what will make you feel the best!0
-
YOu might want to look at the book UltraMetabolism by Dr. Mark Hyman and look into the issue of processed carbohydrates and inflammation.0
-
Have you talked to your doctor about this?
That's what I was thinking.
The problem is that most doctors will try to prescribe something She should look for a naturopath or a doctor who specializes in functional medicine0 -
Have you talked to your doctor about this?
That's what I was thinking.
The problem is that most doctors will try to prescribe something She should look for a naturopath or a doctor who specializes in functional medicine
Agree that she needs to be a strong advocate for herself with the doc to make sure unnecessary meds are not prescribed. The symptoms she describes could be many things, some of which she might want to get treated for immediately (e.g. rheumatoid arthritis, fibromyalgia, etc.) Since she has been working with a doctor, these hopefully have been ruled out and it is safe for her to try going low-carb to see if that helps. The level of pain she is describing is decidedly not normal (not even for me, and I have rheumatoid arthritis), and it isn't something that should ONLY have the attention of a group of strangers on the internet. Sounds like she is covered.1 -
Without knowing how many carbs you are getting per day. It could be your body getting ready to go into ketosis which is the mild fat burning stage in which your body burns fat. My carbs are under between 80-85 gm a day the first 5 days of getting there are tough, but after that it in an energy blast off.. And the first week I lost 9 lbs. During that first 5 days headaches and fatigue and general aches and pains are expected.. If you not sure I would see a physcian Medications ie anti inflammatories can actually cause you to retain fluid as well.. Drink at a minumum of 4 extra 8 oz cup of H20 when taking those medicaions. Hope you find some answers but more importanly some relief.
Laurie0 -
If your carbs are wheat based or have gluten in them there could definitely be a connection. Have you been tested for celiac disease? Celiac has many indicators of inflammation on the same scale as lupus and rhumatoid arthritis. When my so gets wheat exposed, we notice it first in his leg cramps and bones/body aching.
You may also try a yeast or parasite cleanse.1 -
Thanks again all....Great info here!!0
-
I cut gluten out 2 weeks ago..my chronic joint pain is better!! And I switched hubby's diet and he just commented on it the other day his neck doesnt hurt as bad. My stomach pains are gone too and i'm more regular..if you catch my drift. All that gluten and carb cant be good for us...its in everything..sometimes ketchup etc..to thicken things.1
-
I was wondering if anyone knows of a connectionbetween carb intake and increased pain. I have a considerable amount of pain all the time, mostly joints...knees, hips, ankles, and such. I have been cutting back on carbs, with yesterday being very low and I felt pretty good all day and slept pain free last night. I do get fairly regular exercise by pushing through the pain but am tired of living on ibuprofin & tylenol....it is so bad for a body. Help please!!
I have significant joint pain when I eat a lot of wheat.
Maybe it's not carbs in general (which you do need.), but the types of carbs being ingested.0 -
Have you talked to your doctor about this?
That's what I was thinking.
The problem is that most doctors will try to prescribe something She should look for a naturopath or a doctor who specializes in functional medicine
LMAO, naturopaths? Why not go for something evidence based vs naturopathic voodoo?0 -
Processed carbs yes.. msg causes joint pain. You could have a gluten intolerance as well, I've heard people with gluten intolerance of pain.. so breads, pasta's, etc. Anything with wheat. High acid foods can cause joint pain as well.. like red meat, pork, even chicken at times.0
-
I agree that not carbs themselves are the problem, but possibly you have gluten problems or problems with certain sugars. It's worth a trip to the doctor to see if there's something to it.0
-
I was wondering if anyone knows of a connectionbetween carb intake and increased pain. I have a considerable amount of pain all the time, mostly joints...knees, hips, ankles, and such. I have been cutting back on carbs, with yesterday being very low and I felt pretty good all day and slept pain free last night. I do get fairly regular exercise by pushing through the pain but am tired of living on ibuprofin & tylenol....it is so bad for a body. Help please!!
I discovered the same thing a few months ago. I stopped eating gluten and my joint pain went away. I've had 5 knee surgeries from sports injuries and my doctors all said my pain was just normal, I have arthritis, deal with it or take pain killers all the time. Ugh.
I had been totally grain free for a while but then had a few days where I ate something with gluten and my knees swelled up visibly and all the pain came back in my knees and hips. Cut the gluten out again and it's gone in a few days.
Needless to say, I'm off the gluten permanently now. I had no idea that it would cause joint inflammation - I figured that if I was sensitive to gluten it would give me gastro-intestinal symptoms, which I've never had. But it can affect you in different ways.
Right now I'm in the middle of an anti-inflammatory diet where we cut out most potential allergens/things that would cause sensitivities and I'm adding things back one at a time to see what else bothers me. So far just gluten and quinoa (which just makes me bloat).
Anyway, for me it's not the carbs - I can eat boatloads of veggies and even a good amount of fruit - it's grains/gluten that cause the joint pain.0 -
It depends... people say because I have a pain disorder (Fibromyalgia) I should have no sugar and no carbs... ha! I've done low carb and no processed sugar and I felt the same -
please check with a doctor. Test for celiacs (gluten allergy). I just had mine done and am negative.
ETA: Also if it's only in the joints get you AN titer tested - it may be rhumatory arthritis, or some sort of arthritis. Just an idea, if you're going to get blood work done anyways!0 -
Over the last 9-10 years, I have learned that msg, sugars, and gluten increase my experience of pain. Sugar is an inflammatory agent so it would stand to reason that it would exacerbate any arthritis that you may have.
But I still eat lots of carbs! I would not advocate cutting all carbs out. Try taking out one thing at a time so that you can ID the real culrpit(s)0 -
Have you talked to your doctor about this?
That's what I was thinking.
The problem is that most doctors will try to prescribe something She should look for a naturopath or a doctor who specializes in functional medicine
Dafuq?0 -
Have you been tested for celiac disease? I am celiac, and my body reacted in horrible ways to gluten (which is in most processed carbs) once I eradicated gluten the joint pain and fatigue vanished. I now eat a lot of complex carbs and never suffer with the previous issues I had when I ate processed carbs.1
-
It depends... people say because I have a pain disorder (Fibromyalgia) I should have no sugar and no carbs... ha! I've done low carb and no processed sugar and I felt the same -
please check with a doctor. Test for celiacs (gluten allergy). I just had mine done and am negative.
ETA: Also if it's only in the joints get you AN titer tested - it may be rhumatory arthritis, or some sort of arthritis. Just an idea, if you're going to get blood work done anyways!
Just because you do not have an allergy to gluten, does not mean you would not benefit from trying gluten free. What have you got to lose? Gluten isn't a necessary nutritional source.1 -
I'm all for going to the doctor if you can't figure out the joint pain and think you have an injury or something that needs to be treated.... but if you can change your diet and the pain goes away... what do you need the doctor for exactly?
Every time I go to the regular doctor/ortho for my joints they just tell me to take more pain killers to control inflammation. Which in turn, destroys my stomach and then I just have stomach pain instead of joint pain. Gee thanks. When I complained about that I was offered more medicine to control the stomach pain. No one ever suggested that I could benefit from changing my diet.1 -
I second all the posts that suggest that it's likely a certain category of carbs, with gluten being most likely. But it could also be white flour, processed sugars, anything really.0
-
Have you thought about what you ate in lieu of carbs when you felt better? Like more veggies? Perhaps it was the increase in whatever else you were eating that helped with the inflammation as well. I find that the more greens I eat, the less pain I'm in. Just food for thought.0
-
I just did a carb load and my body hurts every muscle hurts so there is some truth to it. I have been under 100 grams of carbs for a long time and ate about 300 grams yesturday with an extra 1000 calories,0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions