Overweight fitness instructors
Replies
-
Honestly for me it depends what the instructor is for.
If it was for an Cardio class where a lot of jumping takes place (like Zumba) and I haven't taken one for the longest of time maybe 5 - 6 years now it would matter to me. I would have a pause in my mind for a minute maybe seeing an "overweight" instructor and I mean really overweight.
It won't phase me at all how the instructor's physique is if he/she is for yoga, strength training, running (coach). That's where I search for how much knowledgeable the person is.
Different sports different attitude.0 -
I've done spin & zumba classes with overweight instructors in the past and have not ever really felt like I got a good workout with those instructors vs the more fit instructors.0
-
I don't disagree on lean and appearance, but that has more to do with nutrition (as we in MFP land know) than actual exercise.
Getting fit and getting lean are 2 different things though. A lean person isn't necessarily a fit person.Personally, it says to me that the trainers can't even get fit with their workouts. How do they expect participants to get fit? Nope, no overweight trainers.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
yea but lean or appearance is most peoples goals anyway.
For sure someone could be a very good trainner and be overweight or even not practice what they preach whatsoever.
if they can otherwise prove that they know what they are talking about (degree hanging on wall, lots of satisfied customers, etc), then it might be something worth considering
One could get lean and look better by just eating less with no exercise at all.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
If mildly overweight, but physically fit (endurance etc.) - yes.
If “morbidly obese” – no.
My choice would be someone that was once overweight and out of shape, but has lost the weight etc. and kept it off for 2 years or more. That I personally think is inspirational.0 -
I don't disagree on lean and appearance, but that has more to do with nutrition (as we in MFP land know) than actual exercise.
Getting fit and getting lean are 2 different things though. A lean person isn't necessarily a fit person.Personally, it says to me that the trainers can't even get fit with their workouts. How do they expect participants to get fit? Nope, no overweight trainers.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
yea but lean or appearance is most peoples goals anyway.
For sure someone could be a very good trainner and be overweight or even not practice what they preach whatsoever.
if they can otherwise prove that they know what they are talking about (degree hanging on wall, lots of satisfied customers, etc), then it might be something worth considering
One could get lean and look better by just eating less with no exercise at all.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
thats true, but i'm simply saying its one means of assessing someones level of fitness, flawed tho it maybe.
but thats besides the point. i'm simply saying the instructor should have something to back them up, wether that be thier body as a walking advertisment, word of mouth from happy customers, or maybe even just being that physically impressive in whatever class they are instructing0 -
I have to admit that it does turn me off to see overweight fitness instructors...My BAD...but I cannot trust someone who does not practice what they preach!
Fit instructors Motivate me..and challenge me to do better...0 -
I had a slightly over weight instructor back in the day when I used to do aerobics. He was fit though, high energy and would say hilarious things to motivate people such as, "slim is in and fat is out!"... and when someone was struggling (normally a thin girl), he would say, "You are fat on the inside! let's go!"... Everyone appreciated him because he was obviously fat and saying all this was just hilarious. Another very ripped instructor tried this approach and the members didn't take unto him too kindly... lol. The point of the matter is, if the instructor is fit and know how to energize the class, I'll definitely sign up to join. However, if the instructor is ripped and doesn't engage or motivate the class, I will not join. I prefer a high intensity class, no matter who is teaching.0
-
Kinda like going to a dentist that has bad teeth? Maybe like asking a fat doctor about weight loss?
You live in a town with two dentists.
One has good teeth, the other has bad teeth. Which one do you go to?
I'd find out who was looking after the dentist with good teeth, and go to that person!0 -
I guess it depends on where I am in my goals. I would want a fitness instructor who could keep up with me, at least. I don't have any problems with overweight fitness instructors, but I think they can better help people who are also overweight. But I am talking seriously overweight, like 50+ pounds to lose. Not like, has an extra 5 pounds or whatever.0
-
You're motivated by the "look". Hate to tell you that you could do the same exact workout and look NOTHING like them. You could even eat exactly like they do an look nothing like them.I have to admit that it does turn me off to see overweight fitness instructors...My BAD...but I cannot trust someone who does not practice what they preach!
Fit instructors Motivate me..and challenge me to do better...
Mark Rippetoe is considered a great coach and trainer. Even well versed people in fitness like to attend his seminars. But dude is definitely a bit overweight and looks nothing like an athlete.
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition0 -
I have to admit that it does turn me off to see overweight fitness instructors...My BAD...but I cannot trust someone who does not practice what they preach!
Fit instructors Motivate me..and challenge me to do better...
But you don't know what is going on in their lives. One girl on YouTube that does Zumba routines (and is a LOT of fun) is heavier, but she is only a few months postpartum and is working on losing the baby weight.0 -
Nope, don't worry or give 1 thought if the in instructor is not your typical low body fat/ ripped body type of person.0
-
I want instructors who are knowledgeable. I care about what they can teach me and how they can help me reach my goals. It doesn't matter to me if they are male/female, overweight/underweight/at goal, tall/short, ect. I don't care what an instructor looks like, and it doesn't matter to me if where they are on their fitness journey as long as they can help me on mine.
Let's be honest, someone could have a very healthy looking body that they inherited from mother nature and good genes. They might not have a clue how to help someone loose weight. On the other hand, someone could be overweight and still know exactly what they are talking about. What if that person has recently lost 60 pounds? And they might still have 50 to go, but they also have the experience and skills to show others what to do/not do.0 -
This topic has been discussed a lot here. Being a trainer/instructor myself, I live and love the "lifestyle" and look the part. The thing that makes a good trainer IMO is how passionate they are about what they do. If you're passionate and practice what you preach, you will want to be not only the best trainer for your clients, but one who continually works to make themselves better - through obtaining more and more knowledge that you can pass on to your clients (through reading, research, courses, etc.). I've worked with ripped trainers with <10% body fat who are clueless idiots as well as not so fit looking trainers that are brilliant. Who would you rather have train you?0
-
I'd be more concerned with an overweight nutritionist or dietician than an overweight instructor. One of my friends is (was?) an A.C.E certified group trainer, and is likely a little overweight for her height. She could hand me my *kitten* in spin class though, and she cycles outside of the gym too. She also does stand-up paddle boarding during the summer. She did some classes where we did some balance on a bosu ball mimicking being on a SUP. Then I went on her SUP later in the summer. Almost fell in more than once.0
-
I think it really depends on what you are going for...
My husband went to a trainer at our gym (honestly, the guy is probably 50lbs overweight). The trainer used to compete in power lifting competitions. My husband wanted advice in that area, not nutrition or weight loss. So in this situation, an overweight trainer was fine.
The female instructors for the classes at my gym are all overweight (some more than others); and all lift less weight than I do. I'm not saying that maybe they don't have some knowledge that I don't have...but for me, I don't see the point in taking these classes if I weigh less and lift more than the instructors.0 -
If this was asked a couple years ago, I would have said yes, it is a turn off to see an overweight instructor.
There is a female trainer at my gym who I would say is at least 50+ lbs overweight. I've done a couple of her spin classes though, and let me tell you, she is a machine! I know she's doing high resistance, and has lots of hill climbs & sprints thrown in and never sounds winded. I haven't worked with her one on one, but I think she does power lifting with her clients.
If I walked into a class now and the instructor was overweight, I might be a bit dubious, but I would give him/her a chance. They might really know their stuff and have a good fitness level. Maybe, like me, their diet just isn't where it should be. If I like the class and can push myself to get a good workout, how they look doesn't really matter. I've done other classes with "in shape" instructors and they were awful classes.
^ This!0 -
Lol, the one my insurance covers.:laugh: :laugh:Kinda like going to a dentist that has bad teeth? Maybe like asking a fat doctor about weight loss?
You live in a town with two dentists.
One has good teeth, the other has bad teeth. Which one do you go to?
Truth. :grumble:
Depends what the instructor is teaching. Lifting techniques? I'm game. Cardio? I'd sit in a few classes. If it gets my heart rate up and makes me sore THE RIGHT WAY, I'm in for a try. Eyebrow might raise, but I'll try it.0 -
Lol, the one my insurance covers.:laugh: :laugh:Kinda like going to a dentist that has bad teeth? Maybe like asking a fat doctor about weight loss?
You live in a town with two dentists.
One has good teeth, the other has bad teeth. Which one do you go to?
A.C.E. Certified Personal and Group Fitness Trainer
IDEA Fitness member
Kickboxing Certified Instructor
Been in fitness for 30 years and have studied kinesiology and nutrition
hahaha, that is a different approach to that logic question.
Essentially the answer you be that you go to the dentist with the bad teeth, because in an isolated town, a dentist can't work on himself and has to go to his competitor. Therefore the one with the good teeth is a bad dentist.
I'mma going to go eat a sandwich.0 -
I've had several heavy bellydance dance teachers who were truly gifted dancers and had more endurance and cardio fitness than most of their slender students, and a friend who's on the plump side who climbs mountains and does triathalons. So yeah, I'd give a heavy instructor a chance. You can be "fit" in some ways and still heavy.0
-
This thread is pretty discouraging. I'm getting ready to start studying for my ACE test (personal training) and I'm currently still overweight. However, I was once 80 lbs heavier, I've committed to a healthier lifestyle and my habits and coping skills are BY FAR better than they were 5 years ago. I've run a marathon, 4 half marathons and I can lift.
It makes me really sad that I feel like I'd have to give my entire history in order for someone to give me a chance. I'm human just like everyone else. I'm not perfect. I deal with binge and emotional eating and depression. If anything, I think it makes be BETTER equipped to work with certain types of people. I believe in people feeling strong and capable -- no matter where they are starting.0 -
There are many factors to consider. A person may appear to be overweight but may actually have be healthier and fitter than someone as we like to call "skinny fat." I know how easy it is to come to the conclusion, but we need to really look at the whole picture. I am a lot "bigger" than most of the women I work with. And outwardly it may appear that these women are in better shape than me. The view quickly changes when they see me in fitness clothing and see that my legs are bigger due to muscles quads and calves. I get what you are saying but looks can be deceiving somewhat. I have a aquaintance that is far thinner that me and she constantly wonders how it is that my race times are significantly faster. Yes, my body is bigger but my training is where the work is at. Having said that, I do understand what you are saying and yes it lends to credibility for sure. I think that I would also naturally question things as well, but really the only way to know what that person is about is to take the challenge and test them on it. Because that instructor may be a beast and the skinny super model looking chic in the corner may be deceptively unfit. I for one would not trade my body and what it can do for a much thinner weaker one.0
-
I am more turned off by people who are skinny and don't have any muscle teaching a class or training a client than someone who is overweight. Nothing worse than seeing noodle-arms walk in to teach a class.
For all you know, the overweight person is recovering from an illness or just lost 150 pounds and has 50 more to go and want to share what they've learned...but I can also understand why it's harder for them to get a job. The heaviest trainer at my gym is the busiest so he's doing something right, but personally I laugh at the female trainers at the gym whom I could out-athlete in every way imaginable.0 -
This thread is pretty discouraging. I'm getting ready to start studying for my ACE test (personal training) and I'm currently still overweight. However, I was once 80 lbs heavier, I've committed to a healthier lifestyle and my habits and coping skills are BY FAR better than they were 5 years ago. I've run a marathon, 4 half marathons and I can lift.
It makes me really sad that I feel like I'd have to give my entire history in order for someone to give me a chance. I'm human just like everyone else. I'm not perfect. I deal with binge and emotional eating and depression. If anything, I think it makes be BETTER equipped to work with certain types of people. I believe in people feeling strong and capable -- no matter where they are starting.
I'd sit in with you. As long as you're not full of *kitten* from the start of the course, I'd give ya a shot. :drinker: :flowerforyou:
But if you start telling me about gluten being my worst enemy or sucking toxins out through foot pads, I'm bouncin'. :laugh:0 -
This thread is pretty discouraging. I'm getting ready to start studying for my ACE test (personal training) and I'm currently still overweight. However, I was once 80 lbs heavier, I've committed to a healthier lifestyle and my habits and coping skills are BY FAR better than they were 5 years ago. I've run a marathon, 4 half marathons and I can lift.
It makes me really sad that I feel like I'd have to give my entire history in order for someone to give me a chance. I'm human just like everyone else. I'm not perfect. I deal with binge and emotional eating and depression. If anything, I think it makes be BETTER equipped to work with certain types of people. I believe in people feeling strong and capable -- no matter where they are starting.
Don't get discouraged. I go to a turbo kick class and my instructor is overweight and she shares her weight loss journey with the class. She keeps us informed on her progress, whether she losing or not, and encourages us to stay focused and look to her class for inspiration. We all love her for it. I was skeptical at first, but the class and her instructions are helping me get in shape even though she may not be losing as quickly as she would like to but she's still inspiring because she's trying and sharing her story.0 -
I went to yoga fairly regularly over a summer, and on my last class ( didn't know it would be my last) the gym had a new instructor. When she walked in I thought she was just another student new to yoga, but nope instructor. And she was most definitely obese. I didn't expect much, but she was the most flexible person I had ever seen. She was kind, she was encouraging to everyone, and the had just the right touch to get everyone into proper form, and she moved so quickly into new positions that I was sweating within minutes. I wish I had been able to take her class again, but health issues kept me out of class.
But I can definitely understand how it would be difficult for overweight instructors to get work, people don't expect a whole lot from them0 -
A few years ago I would wonder why the instructor is not thin and svelte from doing their work out etc but now I realise it depends on their personal circumstances. I have an under active thyroid (do not under estimate how serious this can be) and find it hard to lose weight, but I kick *kitten* at Billy Blanks! I exercise everyday with very little weight loss but I'm fit now and want to get fitter.0
-
I "teach" a Zumba class now and then and I'm a good 30 pounds over my goal weight. I also have lost over 40 and kept it off for about 6 years. I live in a teeny town and my class is offered for free through the school district's Adult Education program. There is no one coming to my class that expects to see a stick girl teaching my class. We are all just there to shake our hineys and have some fun.
BUT, if I had to charge for my class or depend on teaching for my income, I would definitely feel the pressure to be in better shape and at a smaller size. "For fun" and "for pay" are big differences. I am paying my $30/mth for my Zumba membership and choreo DVDs and I would probably feel a little ripped off if the instructors on my videos were lardbutts and not dancing at full-on intensity.
To each their own.0 -
I attended a Pilates class on Sunday, and the female trainer was overweight, not obese but carrying a lot of weight in the stomach and booty. She did all the movements in the class no prob, totally poised the whole time and not exhausted, while a lot of the thinner girls were lying down on their mats tired and huffing. I felt that class for sure. I didn't ask because it's not my business but I think she might have reduced her weight through Pilates and got good enough to teach it. It was a great class!0
-
ThanksThis thread is pretty discouraging. I'm getting ready to start studying for my ACE test (personal training) and I'm currently still overweight. However, I was once 80 lbs heavier, I've committed to a healthier lifestyle and my habits and coping skills are BY FAR better than they were 5 years ago. I've run a marathon, 4 half marathons and I can lift.
It makes me really sad that I feel like I'd have to give my entire history in order for someone to give me a chance. I'm human just like everyone else. I'm not perfect. I deal with binge and emotional eating and depression. If anything, I think it makes be BETTER equipped to work with certain types of people. I believe in people feeling strong and capable -- no matter where they are starting.
I'd sit in with you. As long as you're not full of *kitten* from the start of the course, I'd give ya a shot. :drinker: :flowerforyou:
But if you start telling me about gluten being my worst enemy or sucking toxins out through foot pads, I'm bouncin'. :laugh:
And no crazy fads here. However, I have heard about these wraps....:laugh: (j/k)0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions