So I went to a nutritionist
malavika413
Posts: 474 Member
I went to see a nutritionist last week to discuss my lack of weight loss and my constant fatigue/exhaustion. She told me to send her my food diary for a week, so I did.
Today, she told me the following things
--my calorie level was fine (which surprised me, since I haven't lost any weight since placing my calories at 1740)
--my protein level was fine (I eat on average 50g per day, sometimes more sometimes less. I rarely meet my goal for protein as suggested by MFP)
--I eat too many carbs (understandable)
--I don't eat enough vegetables/fruits (also understandable, I guess I'll have to get used to bland, American-style vegetables)
Instead of suggesting exercise to help with my tiredness (she understood that I don't really have time) she told me to take an herbal supplement called Rhodiola. I've never heard of this herb and I'm a little skeptical.
What do you think? Should I go by what the nutritionist is saying?
Today, she told me the following things
--my calorie level was fine (which surprised me, since I haven't lost any weight since placing my calories at 1740)
--my protein level was fine (I eat on average 50g per day, sometimes more sometimes less. I rarely meet my goal for protein as suggested by MFP)
--I eat too many carbs (understandable)
--I don't eat enough vegetables/fruits (also understandable, I guess I'll have to get used to bland, American-style vegetables)
Instead of suggesting exercise to help with my tiredness (she understood that I don't really have time) she told me to take an herbal supplement called Rhodiola. I've never heard of this herb and I'm a little skeptical.
What do you think? Should I go by what the nutritionist is saying?
0
Replies
-
Did you see a nutritionist or a registered dietitian? Pretty different training requirements.0
-
Vitamin B 12% 6 help with constant tiredness. Nutritionist wants you to buy so product I have never heard of.0
-
Uh no.
Hard to say why you're not losing weight. More often than not, I think stalls are due to people not being accurate with food logging, particularly when it comes to weighing their food.
Your goal goal seems ok from what I see in your diary.
As to your macros, I'd suggest thinking of the MFP default protein level as a minimum. I know nothing of that supplement, but I suspect it's entirely unnecessary. And depending on the severity of the fatigue and exhaustion, I might suggest seeing a doctor. Who knows, you may have a condition that's both making you tired and hindering calorie burns.0 -
My personal experience when I eat too many carbs is that I find it makes me sluggish, tired, and I feel like I'm dragging it by mid afternoon. I really "crash" hard.
What's helped for me is to up my protein and fat a little to an approximate 40% (c) 30% (p), 30% (f) ratio.....more importantly for me though is to ensure that I have more than 110 grams of protein per day. Not an easy task but I do my best. I let the rest fall where it may.0 -
Did you see a nutritionist or a registered dietitian? Pretty different training requirements.
My bad, she's a registered dietitian employed by my university.0 -
Why would you spend the money and time to see a nutritionist and then not follow their advice? Do you have reason to distrust her? Was she licensed?
Rhodiola is just the root of a vegetable that has medicinal uses. -- http://www.webmd.com/vitamins-supplements/ingredientmono-883-rhodiola (roseroot).aspx?activeingredientid=883&activeingredientname=rhodiola (roseroot)
What are these bland, American style vegetables to which you refer, and why must you eat them? Vegetables are as bland or spicy or savory or whatever, as you make them.0 -
My inability to move weight and extreme fatigue has turned out to be a pretty much dead thyroid. If you know you're tracking is correct, numbers are right, and nothing is changing, I would see a doc to check for this sort of thing. As I get more correct in my levels, the weight is starting to move.0
-
That was going to be my question. It sounds a little shady to me.Did you see a nutritionist or a registered dietitian? Pretty different training requirements.I don't eat enough vegetables/fruits (also understandable, I guess I'll have to get used to bland, American-style vegetables)
Learn how to cook.0 -
Herbal supplements can help with energy but I wouldn't take one without checking with a dr. Lowering carbs and especially sugars has helped my energy levels a lot. So that may help you too.
You say that you have to get used to bland American vegetables. Are you away from your family? Is this your first time away from home? Are you from another country? Could you be depressed?0 -
Okay, number one thing for energy = sleep. Are you getting a good regular 8-9 hours per night? Also, do you get regular sun and exercise?
Re vegetables, there's so many ways to have them. I like to steam them and put spice on them. Nothing wrong with sauteing or baking them with some olive oil as well.0 -
Why would you spend the money and time to see a nutritionist and then not follow their advice? Do you have reason to distrust her? Was she licensed?
Rhodiola is just the root of a vegetable that has medicinal uses. -- http://www.webmd.com/vitamins-supplements/ingredientmono-883-rhodiola (roseroot).aspx?activeingredientid=883&activeingredientname=rhodiola (roseroot)
What are these bland, American style vegetables to which you refer, and why must you eat them? Vegetables are as bland or spicy or savory or whatever, as you make them.
Appointments were free, she's employed by my university. I just find that what she was telling me seems contrary to what others have been telling me both on MFP and elsewhere.
The bland vegetables are what my dining hall offers. I eat exclusively what they offer, I'm on a college meal plan. I have no transportation and therefore cannot buy my own food.0 -
I always think I’ll turn purple like George Costanza if I take herbal supplements…
0 -
Herbal supplements can help with energy but I wouldn't take one without checking with a dr. Lowering carbs and especially sugars has helped my energy levels a lot. So that may help you too.
You say that you have to get used to bland American vegetables. Are you away from your family? Is this your first time away from home? Are you from another country? Could you be depressed?
I agree with you on the carbs/sugar. I'm from the US but I'm of Indian origin and eat almost exclusively Indian food at home. I live relatively close to home but can only go home once a month. I am depressed, yes.0 -
Okay, number one thing for energy = sleep. Are you getting a good regular 8-9 hours per night? Also, do you get regular sun and exercise?
Re vegetables, there's so many ways to have them. I like to steam them and put spice on them. Nothing wrong with sauteing or baking them with some olive oil as well.
Can't cook my own vegetables, unfortunately. I'm at college. I get about 7 hours of sleep per night, I have a busy class schedule. I have been told 7 hours is fine. No exercise, and I get sun while walking to classes.0 -
The nutritional counselor that I see did not suggest any sort of medicine, herbal or otherwise. She suggested that I reduce my carb intake, eat more veggies ("American" vegetable are neither bland or boring, add some herbs and spices) and increase my activity. Withing two weeks of eating fresh, natural foods, I could tell a huge difference in my energy level. It concerns my that she would recommend a supplement other than a multi-vitamin. That is unusual.0
-
A lot of your diary entries are by the cup or the bowlful. Unless you're weighing your food, you're probably eating quite a bit more than you think you are. Give this and the links in here a read:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1080242-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants
And find a way to get your protein in.0 -
Do you have a refrigerator with a freezer? If not, buy a small freezer. Ask your mom to cook you different sabzis in large quantities and pack it in single/double portion sized packets the next time you visit home. Freeze them all! If you can't cook or get to a grocery store, this might be your best option. American vegetables aren't bland, you only think so because it isn't in cooked sabzi/curry form.
When my mom visits me in the US from India, I make her do this for me, not because I don't cook but because I miss her cooking and like to have a couple of packets in the freezer for whenever I miss home. I know how hard being away from home is. Good food makes a lot of difference. Hope you feel better soon! :flowerforyou:0 -
I...I guess I'll have to get used to bland, American-style vegetables ...
Yes, we can produce some pretty boring vegetables here in the US as can other parts of the world. But there's no reason for veggies to be bland and the herbs and spices you can use to add spark to veggies don't usually add too many calories -- unless you are hitting the butter or oil.
Since you are on a college meal plan and eating those veggies to save money, carry herbs and spices in your pocket. No one says you can't whip out a good lemon-pepper grinder (Alessi is my favorite brand) and give a lift to those green beans. Also, I'm sure you buy snacks for your room -- remember veggies are good snacks, too.0 -
Do you have a refrigerator with a freezer? If not, buy one. Ask your mom to cook you different sabzis in large quantities and pack it in single/double portion sized packets the next time you visit home. Freeze them all! If you can't cook or get to a grocery store, this might be your best option.
When my mom visits me in the US from India, I make her do this for me, not because I don't cook but because I miss her cooking and like to have a couple of packets in the freezer for whenever I miss home. I know how hard being away from home is. Good food makes a lot of difference. Hope you feel better soon! :flowerforyou:
Nice to hear from a fellow desi. I have my mom make me food for a few days whenever I go home, but because the dining hall meal plan costs a good deal of money, my parents are insistent I eat the food from it as often as I can. It's bearable, I guess, but it makes me miss home even more.0 -
Is there a communal fridge in your dorm? Or better yet, can you get a mini fridge/microwave combo for your dorm room? You can get a ride to the grocery store every couple of weeks and buy some fresh food. My resident advisors and sophomore advisors used to ferry people to the grocery store when I was a freshman. Or make friends with upperclassmen in clubs or classes!0
-
A lot of your diary entries are by the cup or the bowlful. Unless you're weighing your food, you're probably eating quite a bit more than you think you are. Give this and the links in here a read:
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1080242-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants
And find a way to get your protein in.
Agree. And maybe take a liquid vitamin D supplement, just walking between classes isn't enough sun.0 -
I think the poster mentioning depression may have hit the nail on the head. It's very common for new college students to experience that and one of the most common symptoms of depression is unexplained lack of energy. Take advantage of a few free therapy sessions at your college. :-)
As for the bland cafeteria veggies, I hear you on that one! Maybe when you get a chance to go the store, stock up on some spices and hot sauces that you can bring with you to the cafeteria to add to the bland veggies. (You can put them in little travel bottles so you can bring them inconspicuously in your bag.) I keep a couple bottles of hot sauce in my office drawer to spice up bland cafeteria food and frozen meals and it makes all the difference in flavor!
Good luck!0 -
Check with the doctor first.
Never take supplements the doctor doesn't recommend (and if you need them, he will tell you.)
Trust me - they never shy away from telling you take something if you need it. I despise swallowing all my supplements all the time, but they worked. If you can live life without ever taking a pill, enjoy that!!!
Tap, tap, tap, "It'll be at the pharmacy!" Get this,take that, do this, don't do that. Some medical schools mustn't allow them to say: "No swimming. Risk of infection," so they spend the rest of their lives saying it as much as possible. It's their favorite damn thing to say.
Good luck!0 -
OP - have a read of this thread.
http://www.myfitnesspal.com/topics/show/1080242-a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants?page=7
Also you have time to exercise if you want to. You need to make time, get up early in the morning and go for a run or just jump about your lounge - or replace something that isn't exercise with something that is - Instead of driving to work, get on your bike or walk - or park your car at a distance and bike, walk. Speed walk or jog at lunchtime If you don't work walk to where you are going instead of using so much transport. Its all about choice and I am in despair at your dietician for not pointing this out to you.
Regarding your dietary advice, I would replace everything that was said with everything on the sexypants link.0 -
I really recommend trying to get some exercise in. It will help with energy, deperession, and weight. You're busy but that will always be the case. Best to learn to make that time for yourself now and form good, healthy habits for the long term.0
-
A few months ago my doctor ordered a battery of blood tests due to me feeling fatigued, sluggish, depressed, and gaining weight. She thought it might be my thyroid but checked multiple fronts. Well my thyroid was good but I had a severe vitamin D deficiency. Vit D is fat soluble and stored in the fat cells. Well since I wasn't burning fat I wasn't getting the vitamin. So she has me taking 4K IUD. I feel so much better and I am losing the weight. You might try upping your vitamin D intake, if you don't already take it.0
-
Can't cook my own vegetables, unfortunately. I'm at college. I get about 7 hours of sleep per night, I have a busy class schedule. I have been told 7 hours is fine. No exercise, and I get sun while walking to classes.
You probably need more than 7 hours. Some people only need 7 hours, it's true, but you are learning a lot and young. A few ways to get an idea if you are getting enough sleep: is it easy to get up in the morning? do you feel rested in the morning? can you wake without an alarm clock? If you close your eyes in a dark room in the middle of the day will you be able to stay awake? If you answer no to these questions it indicates you are sleep deprived. That will mess up your energy, your mood, and make it harder to lose weight.0 -
I really recommend trying to get some exercise in. It will help with energy, deperession, and weight. You're busy but that will always be the case. Best to learn to make that time for yourself now and form good, healthy habits for the long term.
I guess so, but right now it's going to be a stretch. My grades aren't where they need to be and any spare time I have is spent there. Exercise would mean compromising sleep, and I don't really want to go less than 6-7 hours.0 -
OP there're a lot of 15-25 min workouts that need no equipment and can be done in your room. If you have 15 mins, you can do them. I cannot tell you how much of a mood-upper it is just to see your improving body shape in the mirror. I guarantee that you will feel better and forget about the food being tasteless. I think that is more in your head than your tongue. I went through something similar when I first came to the US.
Try one of these videos: https://www.youtube.com/user/FitnessBlender There are over 200 to choose from. All the workouts are amazing in terms of results.0 -
Is there a grocery store (even a convenience store?) in walking distance? You should at least be able to get some fruit.Do you have a refrigerator with a freezer? If not, buy one. Ask your mom to cook you different sabzis in large quantities and pack it in single/double portion sized packets the next time you visit home. Freeze them all! If you can't cook or get to a grocery store, this might be your best option.
When my mom visits me in the US from India, I make her do this for me, not because I don't cook but because I miss her cooking and like to have a couple of packets in the freezer for whenever I miss home. I know how hard being away from home is. Good food makes a lot of difference. Hope you feel better soon! :flowerforyou:
Nice to hear from a fellow desi. I have my mom make me food for a few days whenever I go home, but because the dining hall meal plan costs a good deal of money, my parents are insistent I eat the food from it as often as I can. It's bearable, I guess, but it makes me miss home even more.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions