Question about BMI, Body Shape and Short Girls
TaraMaria
Posts: 1,975
Where should a short girl stop with her weight loss and her BMI? Today while on MFP I was reading and discovering that many of us shorties go to the far left and loose as much weight as possible. With my body shape, I don't know if I could actually lose any more weight! Or am I just using my body shape as a crutch?
How do you know where to stop as a short gal loosing weight? I'm curious as I'm trying to decide for myself what to do!
) My BMI Range is 141-104 and I can't even IMAGINE getting down to 104...What are your thoughts? How did you pick your goal?
How do you know where to stop as a short gal loosing weight? I'm curious as I'm trying to decide for myself what to do!
) My BMI Range is 141-104 and I can't even IMAGINE getting down to 104...What are your thoughts? How did you pick your goal? 0
Replies
-
I'm 5'4" and I think my ideal healthy weight according to that is 117-145, and I'll be happy to hit 145 cause there's NO WAY I'd ever get to 117, and I'd look pretty weird at that weight. I think as long as you feel comfortable and you're in the healthy range, that should be your goal.0
-
Just try to stay on the lesser side of the healthy range0
-
I don't know if there's a technical way to answer this question...for me (I'm 5'2" with a small frame), I picked the weight 130 because I feel like that's where I look best. Not so skinny as to be unhealthy, but plenty thin for me. Get to a nice low pant size that you're excited about, and stay there! :glasses:0
-
I am 5 feet tall and my range, is 97-127... give or take on the lower end, thats from memory, my goal is 125.... because I know thats attainable, I picked a goal *I* knew I could stick with and be proud of, I've had 3 kids and was 115 when I got pregnant with the first, so Ill take 10 lbs after 3 kids!! That is how I chose my goal, if you are comfortable and within a healthy BMI, and it works for you, and you feel its a reachable goal, then thats where you set yours, everyone is different... do what makes you feel best and you may even surprise yourself in the end!!!!0
-
My BMI range is 148 to 110 and I don't think I could be under 120 and healthy! I am 5ft 3 and my goal is to be around 145ish. Just in that healthy BMI. I do not want to weigh less than my 13yr old who is 5ft 2 and weighs 128lbs and is a size 1!0
-
I'm 5'5" and according to the BMI calculator on this site, my "healthy range" is 111 to 150. My personal goal is 125 based on my past weight. I got down to 120 before my wedding, and while I felt skinny, it still wasn't good enough for me. I look back at pictures now, though, and I think I was WAY too thin at 120. I can't imagine 111 being healthy for me and my body type. So my goals are based on past experience.0
-
I'm 5'4" and I'm currently 144.5 lbs. When I started MFP I was 149.5 which according to my height is in the upper portion of my BMI index. Although I was normal, I couldn't fit into any of my clothes anymore. My goal is to try to get down to 127 which is a little higher than midway in my range. I'm not certain if I could get down that far anymore (I used to weigh that when I was dancing everyday) as my body has changed since I turned 30, but I would be happy with even something close to 135.0
-
DON'T USE BMI. BMI is one of the worst things out there for indicating where people should be. So a body builder who is 5'9 and 250 would be overweight and yet only have a 9% body fat. This is why BMI doesn't work. When I lost tons of weight I kept measuring the scale and getting so frustrated. I know at my smallest I have been 145 (my smallest BMI is 135-I would look like a skeleton). So I couldn't get below 160 and when I saw the doc and told him I can't lose any more weight-he said-you don't need to. I was doing so much strength training that when I was 160 I fit into a 10 and I usually cannot fit that size unless I am around 145. So unless you have someone who can measure your body fat, go by measurements with a tape or just by how your clothes fit. This is the BEST indicator.0
-
I think it always shocks me to find out how many people may be the same height as me and around the same weight but could be a completely different pant size. I don't quite get that! http://www.mybodygallery.com/ is a website that you can put in your height and weight and see people at your same size (or future size!) I put in people at my height and weight and get a completely different pant size. I'm extremely happy where I am...I was just reading a lot of girls today who planned on getting down to the 100 pound mark at around my height and my jaw dropped. I don't even know HOW I would do that, or what pants I would wear! Maybe I'm already too old! LOL!) 0
-
I'm aiming for being "fat" by BMI standards. I'm 5'6" and want to be in the 160-ish pounds range. When I get too slim (been there before) - I get lightheaded if I don't eat regularly - and I get cold easily. Since I enjoy winter sports and water sports - having some "insulation" is a good thing. A few years ago, I went through the ice rescuing my daughter's dog out on our frozen lake - I was wet for approx 45 minutes in 25-degree weather. In THAT case, I was glad for the fat....LOL!0
-
I wonder this too, but....
I'm 5"2 (and a half!) and felt pretty good being below 130lbs. ie: 127-129 lbs. Then I was watching Dr. Oz and he has his lose 10 pounds challenge. I had just started on my 'lose the baby weight' goal and thought, what the h*ll, I'll make my goal 118 instead of 128.
I really didn't think I could do it but...
I'm pretty much there and feel fantastic! My BMI is 21 or so and I'm no longer pear shaped. I had accepted 'pear' as my shape about 10 years ago. I haven't been below 120lbs. for about 15 years.
I don't think I want to lose anymore though because my boobs (sorry for the description) are starting to shrink and I really don't want that. Although it is coming off easier now after I got past the 127 plateau... I think it's because of the muscle to fat ratio.
That extra ten pounds that I was happy with carrying is no longer acceptable for me, and I'm very happy I tried!0 -
DON'T USE BMI. BMI is one of the worst things out there for indicating where people should be. So a body builder who is 5'9 and 250 would be overweight and yet only have a 9% body fat. This is why BMI doesn't work. When I lost tons of weight I kept measuring the scale and getting so frustrated. I know at my smallest I have been 145 (my smallest BMI is 135-I would look like a skeleton). So I couldn't get below 160 and when I saw the doc and told him I can't lose any more weight-he said-you don't need to. I was doing so much strength training that when I was 160 I fit into a 10 and I usually cannot fit that size unless I am around 145. So unless you have someone who can measure your body fat, go by measurements with a tape or just by how your clothes fit. This is the BEST indicator.
Interesting! Thank you so much! I have been wanting to get this done but a little nervous of the actual results! I have to figure this has to apply to me. I cannot possibly loose any more weight...I think I would look unhealthy. And I wouldn't have any more pants to wear. I think I will just continue with my fitness goals and go from there. I thought that BMI was a load of crap...haha!0 -
According to my BMI, I am healthy between 154 and 108 lbs. I'd feel too heavy at 154 and way to small at 108! A few years ago, I was 125lbs and I think that is a good weight for me (I'm 5'6"). Maybe you should just focus on how you'd like to look and not worry so much about your weight, because I'm sure you'll know what a good size for you is when you get to it! good luck!0
-
I'm 5'4" and my goal weight was originally 125. It still sort of is. I'd love to be under 125.
As I start to lose fat and gain muscle, I'll check in and see where my body fat % is. I'd like it to remain around 15% or less (over 12%) which would put me between 115 and 124 somewhere.
That's how I'm determining it. I did all of this with a body comp test.0 -
Tara, I am on the taller side! I am 5"6' and my healthy BMI is 115- 154, I want to be 15 pounds below my top number that way I have wriggle room, you know as a mommy ( who has a lot going on) that you can't always get those workouts in, and instead of pushing myself to have a maintenance number I want a flex number, a low and a high that I feel comfortable with, mine is 140.0
-
I'm 5'2" and my healthy range is supposed to be 103-136. Yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh right. I mean, I'm sure that makes sense, but I have no idea how on earth I would ever get to the point of weighing 136. And that would be the fat end of the normal range! I am aiming for 145. Although I'm not happy with my body yet, I am amazed at my current weight. If you would have asked me a year ago if I thought I could lose 35 lbs successfully I would have said yeah right I WISH! But here I am. So maybe 135ish is doable... we'll see!0
-
It's funny - I'm 5'4.5" and since losing weight now I think going lower than my goal weight will still be healthy for me. I thought "I will NEVER be able to get down to 130! And I'll be so skinny then!" Well guess what? I'm at 131 right now and I feel I still have a way to go. My new goal weight is 125 and when I get there we'll see...
My range is supposedly 111-146. At 111 I think I would be skin and bones...
You gotta remember though - along with BMI (which isn't the best indicator because you CAN have a lot of muscle, be fit, and be "overweight" to the BMI standards), there is also body FRAME you have to take into account. Google "women frame size" and you can take various measurements of your wrist and elbow to see what "frame" you are. I am a medium frame, so I shouldn't get to that low-end of BMI like a super-tiny boned girl could. It just won't work for my frame/body type.
Go to this site, its pretty cool: http://www.halls.md/ideal-weight/body.htm. Here you can see your weight in different aspects and even select your "Frame" size and recalculate.
Hope this helps! Keep it up chica you're awesome!0 -
I'm 5'2" with a medium to large frame and my goal weight is currently 130. I've never been at a normal weight as an adult, so I don't know exactly what weight I should be at, but it seems to be a reasonable goal -- healthy, but not too aggressive.
And can I just say how relieved I am to see so many other women near my height aiming for the 130s and 140s instead of 115, 110, or 98! :laugh: Clearly the lower weights are healthy and doable for certain people, and I mean NO disrespect towards anyone who has that as their goal -- I'm just glad not to be the only shorty not looking to go that low! :flowerforyou:0 -
I think it always shocks me to find out how many people may be the same height as me and around the same weight but could be a completely different pant size. I don't quite get that! http://www.mybodygallery.com/ is a website that you can put in your height and weight and see people at your same size (or future size!) I put in people at my height and weight and get a completely different pant size. I'm extremely happy where I am...I was just reading a lot of girls today who planned on getting down to the 100 pound mark at around my height and my jaw dropped. I don't even know HOW I would do that, or what pants I would wear! Maybe I'm already too old! LOL!)
I put in 5'2" and 130 lbs....no pictures
0 -
I feel the same way about bmi!! It does not take into account your muscle mass or anything.... I am supposed to lose another 45 lbs according to bmi! I am muscular and even at 190 I am in a size 12. I have a personal goal of 160's (another 25lbs probably)and or size 8 then reevaluate because I would be pretty.interesting looking at 145 if even possible! Lol go by body fat if you can, or the way you feel and how happy you are.DON'T USE BMI. BMI is one of the worst things out there for indicating where people should be. So a body builder who is 5'9 and 250 would be overweight and yet only have a 9% body fat. This is why BMI doesn't work. When I lost tons of weight I kept measuring the scale and getting so frustrated. I know at my smallest I have been 145 (my smallest BMI is 135-I would look like a skeleton). So I couldn't get below 160 and when I saw the doc and told him I can't lose any more weight-he said-you don't need to. I was doing so much strength training that when I was 160 I fit into a 10 and I usually cannot fit that size unless I am around 145. So unless you have someone who can measure your body fat, go by measurements with a tape or just by how your clothes fit. This is the BEST indicator.0 -
I am with you on that. I am almost 5'3" and my goal is 140 for now.0
-
I am 5'2". I am shaped like a woman, but with a girl height! In fact I got down to 115 once due to huge stress and weight loss and my ribs were showing. It was really on the too thin edge! I know my body would rather be 125-130 where i was in high school when I was very athletic and lived on a farm. In high school I was always size 8 or 10 pants. I'm much older, though, at 49 and I tend to think I'll be lighter and good. I'm going to shoot for 130, but 120 might be my true bottom. I'll see, but I would never be able to be a mini-woman like a girl when I have hips big 'nuff to have large babies and carry around these D 'girls'. The frame counts, too, not just height. So does muscle mass.0
-
I think it really depends on your frame size.
I know there's ways to determine your frame based on your wrist circumference...I'm sure if you google it you'll find tons.
My Bff and I are the exact same height. However she can easily weigh more than me and still look SO much thinner than I do. She also had larger wrists than I do. And she would look way too thin at a weight that I would look thin at.
I say you do whatever makes you feel happy, healthy, and comfortable!0 -
I agree Im 5'4 too and 117 is way too small fr me Im tryna keep my curves lol !!0
-
That's cool. I looked it up and I have a medium frame, I didn't even know that you could measure that! Also, the "people's choice" ideal weight (from the website you posted) was 127, which is only 2lbs over my goal weight! lolIt's funny - I'm 5'4.5" and since losing weight now I think going lower than my goal weight will still be healthy for me. I thought "I will NEVER be able to get down to 130! And I'll be so skinny then!" Well guess what? I'm at 131 right now and I feel I still have a way to go. My new goal weight is 125 and when I get there we'll see...
My range is supposedly 111-146. At 111 I think I would be skin and bones...
You gotta remember though - along with BMI (which isn't the best indicator because you CAN have a lot of muscle, be fit, and be "overweight" to the BMI standards), there is also body FRAME you have to take into account. Google "women frame size" and you can take various measurements of your wrist and elbow to see what "frame" you are. I am a medium frame, so I shouldn't get to that low-end of BMI like a super-tiny boned girl could. It just won't work for my frame/body type.
Go to this site, its pretty cool: http://www.halls.md/ideal-weight/body.htm. Here you can see your weight in different aspects and even select your "Frame" size and recalculate.
Hope this helps! Keep it up chica you're awesome!0 -
I'm 5ft 5 and I'm hoping to get down to 133. That will put me lower middle of my 'healthy' BMI so I'm more than happy with that. I've been many sizes over the years (at one point 118 which I now know was WAY too tiny for me) and I've been at the high end of overweight. As long as I look healthy I'll be happy. No point in using wrist measurements to work out my frame though - I'm Marfanoid and so my wrists are super super tiny no matter what kind of a frame I have, lol. I did that with a website once, (before I knew I had Ehlers Danlos Syndrome with Marfanoid Habitus) and it logged me as 'petite'. Well I knew I sure as heck wasn't petite! I'm at least medium anyway.0
-
I'm 5'4 and a little bit and currently weigh 146lbs. My goal at 136lbs at the moment. I don't think I could go any lower then this.. i have a butt and boobs and have always been curvey. I like my curves and I don't really want to loose them.
I had a look at myself in the mirror the other day and its really just my hips and upper thighs i want to trim down a bit more. but thats always the last to go for me..and I'm pretty sure there isn't more then 10 lbs worth of stuff there to get rid of. LOL0 -
This frame thing for me, is rubbish lol It's Not even close!
0 -
BMI is worthless. In pretty much all my photos I'm around 200-210 (except maybe 1) and I had a 6 pack. But BMI says I'm overweight in that range.0
-
UGH, the dreaded BMI
I personally hate the BMI chart. It does not take into account one's frame, muscle mass, etc. I am 4'11" and have a large to very large frame. According to the BMI chart, I am morbidly obese. Yeah right!!! Way back in the dark ages of college, I weighed 120lbs and was skin and bones. I have pics of me on my 21st birthday and I looked like I should have been hooked up to an IV drip and in a hospital bed. All of my bones were sticking out, eyes were sunk in, and super thin hair. Yeah, it was nice to wear a size 4 jeans, but yuck!!!
My personal goal is 140lbs. Even that is pushing it for me. If I make it to 160 (which is what I look like I weigh now), I will be stoked. My chesticles are already disappearing, however, I carry most of my weight stomach and hips.
Personally, I think one should strive for a goal that they know they can achieve without harming themselves; a goal that is comfortable and maintainable. That is healthy.
On a side note.....the stupid BMI scale will stay in existance as long as we have health insurance companies. It is a tool for said companies to charge higher premiums to people they consider "high-risk". Yeah, don't get me started about those @$$holes right now :explode:0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions