To many people concerned with accuracy of everything

Options
CelticWarrior
CelticWarrior Posts: 117
in Health and Weight Loss
I have seen many people posting for accuracy, in calories,bmi,body fat,you name it they wanna have accurate readings.

I personally find it gratifying not to be so accurate because this can hurt your progress at times.

Say you just did 60 minutes of running and calories burned says 300, how would that make you feel ?

I suggest not to worry about the accuracy as much as just doing it ,instead just put in what you find on MFP, say is 450 for 60 minutes of running, maybe your off by 150 calories that you burned, but you will continue to do it seeing these numbers opposed to seeing 300 and you will build confidence and you will still lose weight and get healthy.

I have based my exercises like this the whole time and it has kept me encouraged and this is what you need more than accuracy .

GL and HF ,stay healthy
«1

Replies

  • Barelmy
    Barelmy Posts: 590 Member
    Options
    I think most people gain confidence based on seeing results, not grossly exaggerated numbers.
  • MelissaL582
    MelissaL582 Posts: 1,422 Member
    Options
    I agree Celtic!
  • SheliaN1960
    SheliaN1960 Posts: 454 Member
    Options
    Well said! I do not put my trust in these computers anyway. It is all about how you feel! I hope many of our peeps on here read this! Best wishes!
  • ajbeans
    ajbeans Posts: 2,857 Member
    Options
    I agree -- I like some degree of accuracy, but if I'm off by a little bit, it's not going to hurt me as long as I'm still staying within my goal range. I don't want to measure every little thing. I do measure some things, like my morning cereal, because I know I'd dump a whole bowl full and it would be too much. But mostly I eyeball it, and I know I'm getting close.

    I do think it's important for some people to be precise because sometimes they're drastically underestimating what they're eating or overestimating what they're burning, and that can stall progress. So in cases like that, I think it's ok to shift the other way and try to be super-accurate for a while to get you back on track. I don't think it's *wrong* to try to be accurate down to the calorie. As long as it doesn't become an obsession (which it probably would for me), it's ok if that's the route someone wants to take.
  • skinimin
    skinimin Posts: 252 Member
    Options
    I'm afraid of underestimation calorie worth and over estimating on calories burned. These inaccuracies would not be good.
  • wewon
    wewon Posts: 838 Member
    Options
    For a lot of people (myself) the reason for coming to mfp was to get some accuracy, both in their diets and exercise. So much of my past frustrations was that the results that I thought that I should get were not in alignment with what I felt that I was doing.

    After making some progress and experience it becomes easier to loosen up on some of the strictness since you have a "feel" for how things are working. But that's the way it is with most things in life.
  • tmaksparkie
    tmaksparkie Posts: 279
    Options
    I agree, I don't even now what I burn during exercise I have a bodybugg and could wear it but I decided that I am not going to logg my exercise I am just going to do it, just like I don't logg calories, I do put in what I eat but the only numbers I look at are my macros.
  • acknan
    acknan Posts: 261 Member
    Options
    I totally agree! I often try to overestimate my food so that the error goes in a direction that helps me lose... I use a HRM, so I'd like to think that my calories burned are accurate, but even if they are not, I assume I am making a consistent mistake. Either direction will still help me see what is and isn't working. It's up to me to make changes based on patterns, not hard and fast numbers!

    Thanks for posting! :)
  • EbonyGemstoneHealth
    EbonyGemstoneHealth Posts: 249 Member
    Options
    This is true! BUMP
  • cgipson165
    cgipson165 Posts: 11
    Options
    This is exactly why I stopped entering my workouts on here. I think it may be a good tool for someone to have a guideline maybe? But if they are depending on the accuracy of these tools... they will be disappointed.
  • Mairgheal
    Mairgheal Posts: 385 Member
    Options
    I do try to be as accurate as possible (my GPS tracker gives way lower calories than MFP and I prefer to go by the lower ones to be on the safe side), but at the same time, I try not to obsess about it all too much.

    No way I'll be measuring out a tablespoon of peanutbutter or half a cup of broccoli. At the end of the day a gramme more or less are not going to make a difference.
  • ybba12490
    ybba12490 Posts: 252
    Options
    Agree! I posted a topic last night where I was wondering how often people weigh themselves. I don't weigh myself often, maybe every 2 weeks or so, because I feel like having numbers in my head would put pressure on. With food, I eyeball my portions and watch what I eat. I don't even use the food diary of MFP but I do write down what I eat on a log on my computer. For exercise, I don't really trust the machines giving accurate numbers because some don't even ask for your age, weight, etc, and don't account for your body type. So I look at how many calories I'm "burning" on those machines but it doesn't really bother me if I only burn 300 cals in one session. I'm starting to focus more on just feeling and looking better, but I do understand why some people want to be as accurate as possible, especially if you have set goals. For someone like me, I'm just going with the flow, and while I have "target numbers" I'm not stressing over them. Thanks for this post!
  • jenbusick
    jenbusick Posts: 528 Member
    Options
    For some of us, accuracy really matters. The closer I get to my goal, the more my body wants to hang onto its remaining weight, and accurate measures of calories in/calories burned become more critical than they were when I was 40 lb overweight.

    There's really no reason to dump on other people who are just trying to hit their goal and need an accurate tool to do it.
  • Hinto
    Hinto Posts: 52
    Options
    Well, I'm mainly looking for consistency rather than accuracy I guess. I always tend to 'round' up for food and 'round' down for excercise, I figure this way is the safest for me as I try to lose weight. I do like all of the good information I get from logging what I eat, and I do put EVERYTHING in there, even when I'm binging. I do think keeping that food journal is very helpful because it helps me see what works and what doesn't. In terms of exercise, I log everything I do. I use a HRM, even if it's not 100% accurate, it's at least consistent and it helps me judge a 'good' workout versus a 'bad' one. I do find that the calories reported from my HRM is lower than what MFP spits out.
  • CelticWarrior
    CelticWarrior Posts: 117
    Options
    I think most people gain confidence based on seeing results, not grossly exaggerated numbers.


    yes that is true , but you take exercising 1 day at time and visual has a big impact on how you see an impact. I don't know about others but for me ,exercise was and is a fragile thing that can be broken easily if Im not seeing a daily result and you cant see daily results based off weight lose. But you can see progress in calories burned vs calories consumed and that visual progress or failure has an impact on you getting up the next day and wanting to perform your exercise duties. That is the most important part of exercising to me. The confidence from results still will come the same whether your exaggerating numbers or not ,but the motivation that doing this can produce by far outweighs the accuracy of what your doing.
  • CelticWarrior
    CelticWarrior Posts: 117
    Options
    For some of us, accuracy really matters. The closer I get to my goal, the more my body wants to hang onto its remaining weight, and accurate measures of calories in/calories burned become more critical than they were when I was 40 lb overweight.

    There's really no reason to dump on other people who are just trying to hit their goal and need an accurate tool to do it.

    Dumping on people that want to be accurate ? no way . Im simply saying ( mostly for the benefit of those that get discouraged easily , Like myself) accuracy doesn't really matter as much as staying motivated to keep going. I was basically passing on what I learned, that worked to keep me motivated to get up every morning and keep doing what I did.
  • JeanneTops
    JeanneTops Posts: 2,619 Member
    Options
    The key is to only do what you are sure you can do for the rest of your life. Some folks are great at being precise in everything, others can be comfortable eyeballing it all.

    But it won't do you any good to be very precise about it all until you hit goal and then stop, figuring you've learned new ways. It won't do you any good thinking of measuring, exercising, logging, refusing treats etc. as "hard work" and that you won't have to work so hard when you reach goal.

    The reports I've read about people who successfully don't gain the weight back are those who continue doing what they did while they lost the weight. So if you are the kind of person who needs to be accurate about everything in your life, then you are probably right to be accurate about calories and exercise while you're losing weight.

    But if you see it as a pain to do now, then you're not likely to continue when you reach goal and you will be at great risk for gaining the weight back. It's best to find the middle ground where what you're doing feels comfortable for you and you're still losing weight.
  • JennDoesKeto
    JennDoesKeto Posts: 244 Member
    Options
    i log everything food wise i mainly make sure im under my calorie goals for the day. i don't pay too close attention to the other columns. i really dont track all my water as i get over 100oz a day. i measure everything i eat unless i go out to eat then i eyeball it and preplan what i am going to have so i can prep beforehand. i log my exercise but i don't eat those calories ive gained from them as i just look it at is as bonus loss. and i weigh in the am and pm. i love seeing the scale go up and down. im a scale a holic. it works for me. it always has. i know what ive had to eat and i can see where the scale is. i log my weight every morning. i want to be able if i need to go back and see what worked one day and know what i ate that helped me lose. i have a long journey so these habits will probably change over time and i will be more lax but for now im doing what works for me. you do what works for you.
  • CelticWarrior
    CelticWarrior Posts: 117
    Options
    i log everything food wise i mainly make sure im under my calorie goals for the day. i don't pay too close attention to the other columns. i really dont track all my water as i get over 100oz a day. i measure everything i eat unless i go out to eat then i eyeball it and preplan what i am going to have so i can prep beforehand. i log my exercise but i don't eat those calories ive gained from them as i just look it at is as bonus loss. and i weigh in the am and pm. i love seeing the scale go up and down. im a scale a holic. it works for me. it always has. i know what ive had to eat and i can see where the scale is. i log my weight every morning. i want to be able if i need to go back and see what worked one day and know what i ate that helped me lose. i have a long journey so these habits will probably change over time and i will be more lax but for now im doing what works for me. you do what works for you.

    your goals will always change with progress I think, mine did . I started my goal with wanting to get to 235 pounds, around 250 my goal changed to getting to 220, then 210, now 200, Im not sure if that goal will change to I get there ,or closer to it. My exercises evolved and changed over time. I always challenged my body to push a little harder once I got to a place where I felt comfortable at doing the exercises I did.
  • sunshine79
    sunshine79 Posts: 758 Member
    Options
    Totally agree. At a point I became so obsessed with the minutiae of every morsel that entered my mouth and every calorie burned through work out almost to the point of obsession.

    I stopped wearing my HRM for workouts for a while and I also stopped entering calories burned and just logged my exercise in the notes section and doing this was mentally, such a release.

    I also stopped weighing myself and just measured instead :happy:

    What has now become more important for me is just getting on with it. Making the wises food choices, eating a balanced diet and being active for the sake of being active and not to clock up a number on my HRM as this is now a life style for me and not something I'm 'doing' for a while.

    The outcome has been that I am able to maintain my weight (which is a huge achievement for me), without micro managing every aspect of my life. I do still have 9lbs left to go but I'm confident I WILL get there.

    Great post.

Categories