We are pleased to announce that as of March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor has been introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

Are you about to ask the forums why you aren't losing weight?! Read This First!

Posts: 216 Member
These are the most common reasons I hear people say they gained weight:

A ) I blame yoga pants, leggings etc, I wear them all of the time so I didn't notice how much I gained.
B ) I must not have a metabolism.
C ) I have no idea how I gained weight?! I only eat 1200 calories a day!

Now here's the truth:

A ) Unless you were EATING your yoga pants/leggings (not sure the calories in those) they did not MAKE you gain weight. I get that fabric is stretchy, But a 200 lb person is not going to wear the same size as 160 lb person. If you gained 5 lbs, maaaybe even 10, I can let it slide, but when you've gained 30+ pounds, you noticed they were too tight, you were in denial.

B ) Thanks to this really awesome guy named Empedocles (should out to Thales as well, you were almost there little buddy) we know that energy is neither created nor destroyed, it is just transferred. That means when you eat that 1500 calorie cheeseburger 2 things are going to happen: You burn off as much of it as your body needs and then you body stores the rest of the calories (energy) in your fat cells. This is why people workout, so they can burn off the excess energy before it makes it's way to their thighs.

C ) You did not eat 1200 calories a day. Period. End of Story. Did you know that in order to gain weight on a 1200 calorie diet a 25 year old woman would have to be 3'5" and weigh 50 pounds?! She'd also have to be bed ridden as well.
Maybe it was the alcohol on the weekends with friends, maybe it was the Mcdonalds you got on the way to little Johnny's soccer practice. If you aren't weighing/measuring your food, it's extremely easy to over eat.
Stop trying to eyeball portions and at LEAST use a measuring cup! Make sure you're logging your drinks, make sure you're logging your condiments, sauces, toppings etc.
Make sure you're logging the crap that you eat as well, don't lie to your journal, because no matter what you put in there, your mirror will always be honest with you. At least if you're honest in your journal, you can look back and say "oh hey, I ate an entire pint of ice cream that day, so that's why I'm up a pound this week."

I know I'm probably going to get *kitten* on for this, but this question is asked about a thousand times per day. I'm sorry, you are not a special snowflake. There is no magical reason to why you got fat.

There are legitimate reasons for weight gain in the first place. Maybe you started a new relationship and cut into your exercise time to go out with them. Maybe it's all those dates you guys have been on, or maybe you just got comfortable. Undiagnosed, untreated, and/or un-monitored medical diseases. (Do not WebMD every disease that causes weight gain and make your doctor run a full panel, this isn't as common as you'd think) Depression is another one. Until you admit the real reason WHY you gained weight, you aren't ready for weight loss. Maybe you'll lose some weight, but without treating the Cause prepare for the Effect to come right back.

Welcome!

It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
«134

Replies

  • Posts: 4 Member
    excellent post
  • Posts: 3,987 Member
    excellent post

    It wont end well though
  • Posts: 6,993 Member
    _Zardoz_ wrote: »

    It wont end well though

    ha ha.
  • Posts: 46 Member
    Man, I wish we were able to "like" posts. Nicely said. Thumbs up to you!
  • Posts: 2,925 Member
    _Zardoz_ wrote: »

    It wont end well though

    Sadly this ^^^^
  • Posts: 216 Member
    _Zardoz_ wrote: »

    It wont end well though

    If they're too weak to handle a little tough love, they're too weak to change their entire lifestyle to becoming happy and healthy. Just sayin'
  • Posts: 26 Member
    Thank you!
  • Posts: 2,113 Member
    Very nice.

    Surprised that you haven't been flagged as being 'abusive' yet (because, you know, the truth hurts sometimes).
  • Posts: 276 Member
    Yep...totally hear everything in this post. I understand that there are other factors. When I hear someone say that they are eating 1200 calories and gaining weight, I tell them that they need to see a doctor. If they are legitimately having this problem, then something is wrong and they need a doctor, not a forum.
  • Posts: 216 Member
    MrsKGrady wrote: »
    Yep...totally hear everything in this post. I understand that there are other factors. When I hear someone say that they are eating 1200 calories and gaining weight, I tell them that they need to see a doctor. If they are legitimately having this problem, then something is wrong and they need a doctor, not a forum.

    I agree! Same with if they're struggling with depression!
  • Posts: 414 Member
    Great post!! I want to paste a smiley with flowers thingy but don't know how :)
  • Posts: 15,151 Member
    eric_sg61 wrote: »

    Sadly this ^^^^
    Yep
  • Posts: 216 Member
    mitch16 wrote: »
    Very nice.

    Surprised that you haven't been flagged as being 'abusive' yet (because, you know, the truth hurts sometimes).

    45 minutes in and I'm still safe! For now anyways.
  • Posts: 216 Member
    Great post!! I want to paste a smiley with flowers thingy but don't know how :)

    Hahaha cutest thing I've read all day.
  • This content has been removed.
  • Posts: 373 Member
    Like!
  • Posts: 414 Member
    Tbaby1514 wrote: »

    Hahaha cutest thing I've read all day.

    Thank you :)
  • Posts: 4,585 Member
    I like you.
  • Posts: 22,505 Member
    It's too early for this.
  • Posts: 258 Member
    Very nice!
  • Posts: 35,719 Member
    Tbaby1514 wrote: »

    45 minutes in and I'm still safe! For now anyways.

    i just got flagged for swearing in a chit chat thread so give it time!
  • Posts: 906 Member
    Hey! I am a special snowflake! *stomps feet and storms away*
  • Posts: 8,399 Member
    I is sad
    because I'm not special! :'(
  • Posts: 133 Member
    love this so much I'm bookmarking it! just had a convo with a friend this weekend who said she couldn't lose on 1,000 calories a day ummm...stoppppit
  • Posts: 17,562 Member
    *contemplates flagging anyway*

    Nah, this is good. Too bad the people who need to see it probably won't.
  • Posts: 1,018 Member
    200.gif
  • Posts: 326 Member
    Agreed. Truth hurts. Calories do not sneak into your foodhole without your knowledge. There's a ton of factors about *why* you stuck the calories in your foodhole, but you can't change it without acknowledging what is really going on so you can tackle it head-on. For 99% of the population, calories in<calories out does not lie.
  • Posts: 2,561 Member
    I_Love_You_Patrick.gif
  • Posts: 15,267 Member
    Tbaby1514 wrote: »

    45 minutes in and I'm still safe! For now anyways.

    In before the flags start dropping...
  • Posts: 65 Member
    Tbaby1514 wrote: »
    I agree! Same with if they're struggling with depression!

    Not everyone is looking for an antidote in the forums.. just advice or a tip! That's all. I agree, people can be really in denial about weight gain, and hey I wear yoga pants all the time, I practically live in them.. but I do know that they went from XL to XXL, and that wasnt from the pants, that was by me.

    For the depression, sometimes people just need some encouragement. I know myself, could not even begin to afford anything to help it due to no benefits.. but that's just me!

    Your post is eye opening, and the truth for sure! But some people just enjoy having people to talk to, and maybe need a few people to point out the denial (in a nice way).

    I hope people understand that you mean well!
This discussion has been closed.