Yay or Nay on Fruit?
RaspberryTickleChicken
Posts: 629 Member
I'm always tweaking my maintenance eating in hopes to beating the statistical odds of regaining.
And as I have incorporated more and more veggies, I've found myself eating less & less fruit. After some research, I'm contemplating if there is even a reason to consume fruit if I'm getting the comparable vitamins & nutrients from veggies but at a fraction of the calories, carbs, & sugar of fruit.
Thoughts?
And as I have incorporated more and more veggies, I've found myself eating less & less fruit. After some research, I'm contemplating if there is even a reason to consume fruit if I'm getting the comparable vitamins & nutrients from veggies but at a fraction of the calories, carbs, & sugar of fruit.
Thoughts?
0
Replies
-
If you like fruit, eat it.
If you don't, don't.
Life shouldn't have any "hands off" foods.
Eat what you like. Eat at a deficit. Exercise.
ENJOY LIFE0 -
You don't 'have' to eat fruit, but if you do, try to eat it before 1pm or so. Stick it in a shake for sweetness or in yogurt. I have about 2-3 cups a day of fruit max. I eat a lot of veggies myself.0
-
Moderation. HealthFirst (Hirsch) says 3-4 portions a day, with a portion being what will fit in the palm of your hand. An apple is one, banana is two, only enough grapes to fit in your cupped hand. I like to eat an apple half an hour before dinner. I find it helps me with portion control because I am not as hungry when I sit down to the meal.-1
-
A while back, someone posted a picture of a giant bowl of fruit with the caption "nature's Skittles." While I didn't really agree with the person posting it, I did like the picture, and it's stuck in my head ever since. I think it's a fitting description of what fruit basically is -- a great, wholesome treat.
As you discovered, you can get the same nutrients from vegetables without the sugar load. On that account, fruit is not necessary as long as you're getting the nutrients from elsewhere (fun fact - certain cuts of meat have more nutrients than even the "powerhouse" vegetables, so it's actually possible to thrive without plant matter altogether, given the right dietary execution).
Now, that doesn't mean you have to avoid fruits, especially since you're at maintenance, but if sugar is something you want/have to monitor for whatever reason, you don't have to feel guilty for choosing the spinach salad (or even the pate) over the fruit salad.
You can also be discerning about the fruits you do eat. Berries, for example, have a higher fiber and nutrient content for their sugar load than most other fruits, making them a great choice for when you want some fruit.0 -
Fruit is great for vitamins, nutrients, and fiber. Plus, they taste great. You don't have to have them, but they make for great healthy treats (if you want to think about them this way). As long as you are within your calorie and macro goals for the day, I wouldn't worry about the sugar (if that is a concern). I've never seen anyone get overweight from eating too many apples.
Allan0 -
Fruit has nutrients and fiber, just treat like a dessert.0
-
F1tnessCh1ck wrote: »You don't 'have' to eat fruit, but if you do, try to eat it before 1pm or so. Stick it in a shake for sweetness or in yogurt. I have about 2-3 cups a day of fruit max. I eat a lot of veggies myself.
The only part that you should follow is the bolded. Timing makes no difference as long as you brush your teeth well before going to bed, especially after eating fruit because of the acids and sugar and the potential effect on teeth.
Seriously though, fruit is yummy but not essential as long as you are getting the micronutrients and fiber from other foods.
-1 -
Funny, I'm reading this as I'm noshing on a big bowl of grapes.
If you're satisfied with just veggies then I guess there's no reason you HAVE to include fruit in your diet, but you should also be cautious about getting too restrictive with food.
0 -
I like fruit in the morning to sweeten my plain yogurt and not very sweet granola or muesli. I like it on salad to perk up the flavor of greens dressed in balsamic vinegar and lemon juice.
One thing many fruits give you is fiber, which isn't as frequent in veggies. If you don't really want fruit - and it's expensive and often sprayed with pesticides - there's lots of other ways of getting that.
Personally, I often need those calories, because I tend towards being too low.0 -
Mmmm... I'm not sure. Seems like it would be good to have fruit at least once a week but I have no basis for that. I have heard it's better to eat more veggies than fruit though.0
-
I love fruit. Fruit is healthy for you0
-
F1tnessCh1ck wrote: »You don't 'have' to eat fruit, but if you do, try to eat it before 1pm or so. Stick it in a shake for sweetness or in yogurt. I have about 2-3 cups a day of fruit max. I eat a lot of veggies myself.
The only part that you should follow is the bolded. Timing makes no difference as long as you brush your teeth well before going to bed, especially after eating fruit because of the acids and sugar and the potential effect on teeth.
Seriously though, fruit is yummy but not essential as long as you are getting the micronutrients and fiber from other foods.
+1 Food timing has no scientific basis, although some people can have indigestion if they eat too late at night.
If fruit doesn't grab you, you can certainly get all your vitamins and minerals (and less sugar) with just veggies. Oh, and I'm happy to eat your fruit.
0 -
I don't have a sweet tooth, really, so I pick more vegetables than fruit. That said, I try and get one a day at least. Vitamin C is a little harder to find in vegetables.0
-
F1tnessCh1ck wrote: »You don't 'have' to eat fruit, but if you do, try to eat it before 1pm or so. Stick it in a shake for sweetness or in yogurt. I have about 2-3 cups a day of fruit max. I eat a lot of veggies myself.
Why must you eat fruit before 1 pm?0 -
FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »F1tnessCh1ck wrote: »You don't 'have' to eat fruit, but if you do, try to eat it before 1pm or so. Stick it in a shake for sweetness or in yogurt. I have about 2-3 cups a day of fruit max. I eat a lot of veggies myself.
Why must you eat fruit before 1 pm?
If you have to ask. . . . .uh oh.
0 -
The only organisms that have to worry about food timing are called Mogwai.
They definitely shouldn't eat after midnight.
Bad stuff happens.
0 -
_Terrapin_ wrote: »FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »F1tnessCh1ck wrote: »You don't 'have' to eat fruit, but if you do, try to eat it before 1pm or so. Stick it in a shake for sweetness or in yogurt. I have about 2-3 cups a day of fruit max. I eat a lot of veggies myself.
Why must you eat fruit before 1 pm?
If you have to ask. . . . .uh oh.
Apparently I missed this memo as well. I missed a lot of memos from the 1990's though Consequently, I enjoy lots of fruit after 1pm. It goes well with my protein and fats. 0 -
I have fruit occasionally, typically with Greek yogurt, or an apple chopped in oatmeal, but I don't find it filling at all.0
-
I love fruit, so I eat lots of it! If you like fruit, eat it. Simple as that, we don't need to complicate things 0
-
Eat it. Especially bananas, blueberries, raspberries, blackberries and apples.0
-
nay
0 -
-
If you like fruit, eat it.
If you don't, don't.
Life shouldn't have any "hands off" foods.
Eat what you like. Eat at a deficit. Exercise.
ENJOY LIFE
^^ this.
Don't over think it.
I don't like most fruits. Therefore, I would naturally choose vegetables over fruit. But that's my choice.
0 -
I almost always have some fruit with breakfast mmm
0 -
I love fruit!0
-
This content has been removed.
-
F1tnessCh1ck wrote: »You don't 'have' to eat fruit, but if you do, try to eat it before 1pm or so. Stick it in a shake for sweetness or in yogurt. I have about 2-3 cups a day of fruit max. I eat a lot of veggies myself.
The only part that you should follow is the bolded. Timing makes no difference as long as you brush your teeth well before going to bed, especially after eating fruit because of the acids and sugar and the potential effect on teeth.
Seriously though, fruit is yummy but not essential as long as you are getting the micronutrients and fiber from other foods.
Agree
But to add, please do NOT brush your teeth within half hour of eating anything, if you must eat a lump of cheese first
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
If anyone tried to tell me I couldn't eat bananas, blueberries and avocados - I'd eat their face instead.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions