Bread - how to get over it?
Replies
-
I'm 48 too. Stop it! It is an awesome age.0
-
OP - noting wrong with bread. You can eat it, be in a calorie deficit, and lose weight. It sounds like you need to analyze what you are eating and then find a way to moderate all of your foods into a 500 per day calorie deficit. I highly doubt that 100% of your diet is bread, or even 75% of it is bread….
If you break it down you would probably have some bread in the morning, some with lunch for sandwich, and maybe some with dinner or a carb like rice, vegetables, etc…
oh, and get a food scale and weigh/log/measure everything that you eat.0 -
Unless you have celiac disease or a wheat allergy, whole wheat bread is healthier to eat than a rice cake. I have a wheat allergy, so I eat either Udi Whole Grain bread made from rice, or Paleo bread made from almonds, or german 100% rye bread. So, enjoy!0
-
Hello you lovely people....
I will start to attack my surplus weight today.
I am 48 and the menopause has hit. Getting old is depressing, but I know there is a glorious older woman in here somewhere.
Trying to analyse my bad habits and bread is one of the major sources of calories for me. I guess I should look at WHY I need it rather than HOW to not need it.
Nobody needs bed things in their life; it tastes good, but it is bad. Rice cakes are more than capable of holding up any foodstuff. So why do I go to the breadbin and look for a comfoting, doughey, squidgy, tasty loaf?
I have the occasional sandwich...maybe once per week and I like toast on Sunday with my breakfast. Other than that, I don't eat much in the way of bread...when i do, it's usually either a whole multi-grain variety or sour dough so that at least there's some nutrition involved.
that's not to say bread is inherently "bad"...it isn't...but it tends to be calorie dense and many breads do not offer much in the way of nutritional value, some more than others though.0 -
Raises hand... 53. Nothing wrong with having just about any food. I still love bread, but I don't eat much of it. Weight loss is about the calorie deficit. As long as you fit bread into your calorie count, you can lose weight while still having bread. For instance, I have been having a bagel or banana bread for breakfast every day this week. Therefore, enjoy what you like in moderation.0
-
Nothing wrong with bread. It's your calorie total you need to watch -- and you are only going to be miserable if you make your cuts in the areas that give you the most pleasure. So, rather than avoiding bread altogether, I would recommend only eating REALLY GOOD BREAD.
Like, buy from an artisan baker, or, better yet, bake your own! Don't waste calories on stupid spongy factory bread, rather include in each day a sensibly sized piece of well-made, delicious, chewy, crusty BREEEEEEAD. Eat it slowly and without distraction. Enjoy every bite. Refuse to feel guilty, you planned for it!
weigh your food and log everything...I bet you'll find a daily treat of deliciously crafted bread can fit in to most days if you're willing to cut elsewhere.0 -
Eat bread, eat at a deficit. Be happy.0
-
How much bread do you really eat though? Is it every meal? Snacks? I can't see even the highest of calorie breads being a major issue provided you're not overeating it. I'm guessing there's more to this equation than bread.
Exactly. Plus, you have to read the labels on your bread. Some carry a lot of added sugar and sodium. It may not just be the fat and/or calories that cause a dietary problem. Reading labels and comparing is very important to fit bread into your daily goals.0 -
Um. I'm almost 45, just had a hysterectomy, and have lost almost 80 pounds. Guess what? I did it eating bread, and potatoes, and rice, and pasta.
Wait, WHAT? Isn't that going against everything that the universe is telling us???
No, it's not. It's not about denying yourself the foods. It's about learning to eat the right amounts of those foods as well as other healthy ones. It's about finding a balance that works for you. I would look for healthier versions of the foods you like and occasionally allow yourself the less healthy versions as long as it fits into you daily range. Do that and you'll lose weight while eating the foods you love.
Good luck to you! You can do this and live too.
0 -
I'd also like to say that typing out my previous post made me want bread IN MY MOUTH RIGHT NOW.0
-
For me , bread is a bit of a treat now. I dont find it very filling and at 120-140 calories a sclice then a 2 slice sandwich is a calorie investment. Every week I throw most of a loaf away, which is a shame.
120-140 cals per slice??? Wow, that's a lot....I use rye bread. A fairly large piece is only 70 cals. And I've even weighed it to make sure.
Perhaps find different types of bread that will be a little easier for you to fit in.
0 -
Nothing wrong with bread. It's your calorie total you need to watch -- and you are only going to be miserable if you make your cuts in the areas that give you the most pleasure. So, rather than avoiding bread altogether, I would recommend only eating REALLY GOOD BREAD.
Like, buy from an artisan baker, or, better yet, bake your own! Don't waste calories on stupid spongy factory bread, rather include in each day a sensibly sized piece of well-made, delicious, chewy, crusty BREEEEEEAD. Eat it slowly and without distraction. Enjoy every bite. Refuse to feel guilty, you planned for it!
weigh your food and log everything...I bet you'll find a daily treat of deliciously crafted bread can fit in to most days if you're willing to cut elsewhere.
Yes! OP, focus on quality and not quantity. Go for good, nutrient dense bread and please, for the love of god, do NOT eliminate bread and eat rice cakes instead! I'm not hating on rice cakes, but if you are going to eat carbs, eat wholesome, satisfying ones.0 -
bread is the staff of life, and it really isnt very calorically dense for the average white roll or hunk french bread loaf.
I personally love bread,potatoes, and rice, and I eat all three of them nearly everyday. I have a carb centric way of eating, that makes me happy. I see others on here who have a gelato based diet and they love that.
Its all calories in vs. out, so only eat the stuff you love.0 -
I bake my own from scratch. It's a lot harder to overeat bread when it takes several hours to make it first.0
-
I can relate, as bread/pastries were a huge weak point for me. My problem in the decision on whether to have it or not, is do I want to waste so much of my calorie intake on bread, which will be burnt off in no time, plus not fill me....temporary satisfaction? I've had this thought with a number of food products. I like the input from others about low cal breads, which I may look into, but for me it may cause the desire to eat it regularly again. If you are on a regime of burning a lot of calories a day, it shouldn't be a problem, but I don't have that luxury. I'm burning about a meals worth a food a day to get my deficit where it needs to be, and yet enjoy some of my luxuries I know would be tough to beat. It comes down to what you want to sacrifice the most, and what you can do without. Just remember, there are alternatives and if you decide to say no, it does get easier once you know what your daily caloric intake is, and is it worth having that indulgence?
I promised myself to lay low on those items that negatively affected me until I get to my target weight, and then I could see about getting them back into my diet when I am at a maintaining point.
Good luck!0 -
the sweet multigrain rolls I buy at walmart are 80 cals a piece, and their brand french bread is only 900 for the whole damn loaf. A loaf of supermarket cheap-o bread is about 1500 for the whole loaf....
0 -
The real bad thing about commercial made bread, well most of them anyway, contain L-cysteine http://www.vrg.org/blog/2011/03/09/l-cysteine-in-bread-products-still-mostly-sourced-from-human-hair-duck-feathers-hog-hair/0
-
Bread used to be my go-to food. If I ate mindlessly, I could easily finish a loaf in a day. I keep the bread in my freezer now and take it out one slice at a time. Now I likely eat one slice of bread and various crackers in a day.
I love different textured breads. Try a Silver Hills Squirrely or Little Big. I am fond of sourdoughs, rye, and pumpernickel. When I could not find a decent pumpernickel anywhere, I found a recipe and made it at home, slicing it thin.
I find the Weight Watchers breads too insubstantial to hold up a sandwich.
....and I am in Menopause range too!0 -
wow, 48 old? This 57 yr old doesn't think so ;-) I agree with finding some really good quality breads. As long as its in your calorie range, Log, plan and enjoy :-)0
-
When I figure it out, I'll let you know!
Bread is so good! Even the Italian one, with all it's lovely sesame seeds, at the grocery store is good. I just cut the white bread out.
I switched over to whole grain stuff - it took me a long time to find even one thing that had any little bit of whole grain in it that I liked, but I've found one. It's quite tasty and I never have the urge to pop four of them in the toaster and chow down.
Rice cakes really are great, if you happen to like them. They're not too hot for sandwiches, though.
IMO, 48 doesn't count as "older." 52 begins "older." It's subjective, but you're not there yet, lol. 0 -
I very much like bread also I have not cut it out completely but I have dramatically reduced my intake. My go to sandwich was PB and J. I did have to cut that out.0
-
WalkingAlong wrote: »I can see bread being a problem. Some of us don't get a lot of calories for weight loss. Bread is high calorie and not filling. For the calories in two slices of bread or a roll, I'd rather have something with more fiber and protein, or even fat, that would leave me fuller, longer.
Do I avoid it completely? No. But during weight loss, a daily sandwich isn't on my wish list. And forget heading to the bread bin for snacks. A slice of pizza now and then- yes.
I agree with this completely. I'm not even in weight loss mode. In fact, I'm bulking at the moment. I still avoid bread/grains 90% of the time.
I love good bread, and I love pasta. I think it and pasta used to make up a large % of my diet. It just doesn't do anything for me hunger-wise and tends to make me crave more bread. I pretty much eliminated it in May 2013. I wasn't overweight but I did drop 10 lbs pretty easily by making this one switch. Why? I think it allowed me to eat more food with less calories and less hunger.
I don't miss it any more. I eat way more vegetables and fruit than I used to. I don't get tired/groggy after eating. The biggest pain is eating out while avoiding it, especially if you want something quick, like fast food. However, I don't have any allergies, so if I really want pizza or a bahn mi or whatever, I have it. Most of the time though, it just isn't worth the extra calories for me so I skip it.
It was hard for the first couple of weeks. After that? No big deal.
0 -
I would not survive without bread! I would only suggest buying better quality bread. Whole grains instead of white. And eat it in moderation. I am not a salad person. I prefer a yummy hot sandwich. I have switched to gluten free bread, but that is just because of my digestive issues. I could not eliminate bread. In fact, I could not eliminate anything I like. I think the key to long term success is to upgrade, i.e., find healthier ways to still enjoy the things you like. If you can afford it, buy better quality items of the things you like and moderation in all things. If its a trigger for you, don't keep a lot of it at home.0
-
St Joseph's makes a really good whole wheat & oatmeal pita as well as a lavash bread (for making wraps) that are delicious, soft, and VERY low cal... only 50-60 per generous serving. I have found them at Walmart and at Martin's grocery stores near the deli section. The only drawback to them is that they are on the high side in sodium. But if you are careful with your fillings, they work VERY well into my daily goals. I can make a pita sandwich or wrap that comes in under 200 calories and WAY HIGH in flavor.0
-
Unless you have carb/gluten sensitivity issues or it's starting to mold, bread isn't bad for you. If it's a trigger food for you, I wouldn't buy it, and instead look for lower calorie tortillas/wraps.
Great advice. I do great with sliced bread but that Artisan French Bread from Safeway, well, that is tougher for me. I've been using more tortillas and found some great recipes on Pinterest that I really like.0 -
Has anyone noticed that the thinner wraps have no fewer calories than the slice of bread? One eight inch tortilla, 81 calories. One slice of Wonder bread, 79 calories.
I guess you can get away with it as the tortilla will wrap itself around all that goodness, whereas with bread one would have to eat it open-faced.0 -
So, now you know it is OK to eat bread.
I, over the length of my weight loss journey, lost my taste for bread as a staple in my diet. Now I only eat it if it is really tasty and special- like fresh out of the oven, or a chocolate croissant.
As others have said, you are not old, I am 61 and not old, hahaha.
I did my weight loss during menopause, if you need a friend who has been there, done that, send me a friend request.
Cheers, h.0 -
WalkingAlong wrote: »I can see bread being a problem. Some of us don't get a lot of calories for weight loss. Bread is high calorie and not filling. For the calories in two slices of bread or a roll, I'd rather have something with more fiber and protein, or even fat, that would leave me fuller, longer.
Do I avoid it completely? No. But during weight loss, a daily sandwich isn't on my wish list. And forget heading to the bread bin for snacks. A slice of pizza now and then- yes.
I agree with this completely. I'm not even in weight loss mode. In fact, I'm bulking at the moment. I still avoid bread/grains 90% of the time.
I love good bread, and I love pasta. I think it and pasta used to make up a large % of my diet. It just doesn't do anything for me hunger-wise and tends to make me crave more bread. I pretty much eliminated it in May 2013. I wasn't overweight but I did drop 10 lbs pretty easily by making this one switch. Why? I think it allowed me to eat more food with less calories and less hunger.
I don't miss it any more. I eat way more vegetables and fruit than I used to. I don't get tired/groggy after eating. The biggest pain is eating out while avoiding it, especially if you want something quick, like fast food. However, I don't have any allergies, so if I really want pizza or a bahn mi or whatever, I have it. Most of the time though, it just isn't worth the extra calories for me so I skip it.
It was hard for the first couple of weeks. After that? No big deal.
Same here. Once I stopped eating it I also stopped craving it. I do not miss it, nor do I miss that heavy, groggy feeling after eating it. YMMV.0 -
Way fewer ingredients. And no HFCS.Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »allanakern wrote: »i get sara lee 45 calorie bread.. its good and i can have a little more because of the low cals.
Other than the fact that it's got a TON of unnecessary ingredients, this isn't a bad idea if bread is't a trigger food for you OP.
As someone who's also going through menopause, I understand where you're coming from.
I haven't eliminated bread, but I do now get that every meal doesn't need to be built around it. That said, a good sandwich is awesome. We keep 100 calorie sandwich thins (with a very small ingredient list) around, as well as ezekiel tortillas for when I want a good sandwich or wrap.
This is a reasonable option too:
http://thomasbreads.com/products/100-whole-wheat-bagel-thins-bagels
Again, this assumes you don't find it hard to control your appetite when you eat bread.
I've tried both. Do the sandwich thins have "better" ingredients? I never really paid attention.
0 -
Why would we be giving up bread??0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 430 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions