What to cut out. An explanation please.
stevew_68
Posts: 126 Member
Someone did explain this in a post of mine, but I cannot find it.
Can someone please explain in simplest terms that a beginner can understand, to lose weight, what do I need to cut out or keep low? Is it sugars, saturated fats and carbs? I spoke to a barista briefly at Costa Coffee yesterday who is also a personal trainer. Im sure he said sugars, saturated fats and carbs. He also said that I dont really need to worry about calories as long as the others are low.
An explanation in simplest terms would be appreciated.
Also the sorts of foods I need to eat and avoid.
Thanks
Can someone please explain in simplest terms that a beginner can understand, to lose weight, what do I need to cut out or keep low? Is it sugars, saturated fats and carbs? I spoke to a barista briefly at Costa Coffee yesterday who is also a personal trainer. Im sure he said sugars, saturated fats and carbs. He also said that I dont really need to worry about calories as long as the others are low.
An explanation in simplest terms would be appreciated.
Also the sorts of foods I need to eat and avoid.
Thanks
0
Replies
-
None... just eat at a calorie deficit.0
-
I would recommend the opposite of what your barista said. Cut back calories for weight loss. You don't need to cut out sugar and carbs or saturated fat unless you have a medical need to do so. Use a calculator like scooby or IIFYM to figure out a reasonable deficit and macro split.0
-
Nothing.
You don't need to cut out any foods, unless there's a medical reason (or lifestyle choice, such as not eating meat, etc.).
All you need to lose weight is a calorie deficit. As long as you are burning more calories than you are consuming, you will lose weight.
I encourage you to read the stickied posts in the forums. There's lots of great information to be had from those.
On a side note, I really wouldn't take advice from some random barista in a coffee shop, who just happens to be a personal trainer. Personal trainers are also not registered dieticians, and as such, are not necessarily qualified to give nutrition advice.0 -
.0
-
Calories (the amount) do matter. If you're eating healthy foods that amount to more than you burn, you'll still gain weight. You only NEED to cut foods out if they're for medical reasons or trigger a binge.0
-
if you're using MyFitnessPal....counting calories is where it's at. You can eat what you like and what tastes good to you, if you're following portion control and counting your calories. Personal trainers may know a lot about working your bodies, but they don't alway know much or anything about feeding them....they seem to spout a lot of bro-science.
That said...while you can lose weight by counting calories and eating junky food....you will do yourself a favor if you also pay attention to nutrition. No fancy fad foods....sensible healthy eating. The stuff you already know....fruits and veggies are good for you. Closer to nature is probably healthier. Processed is probably not such a good choice. But don't become such a purist that you don't enjoy what you're eating. Be willing to try things you haven't tried before, or cook things a new way...you'll find healthy foods are interesting and delicious!0 -
Just use My Fitness Pal to see how many calories to eat each day. Then, try to stay within that amount. If you want, you can try to stay within the right percentages MFP gives you for fats, sodium, protein, carbs, etc. But, that isn't absolutely necessary to lose. Neither is exercise. You can still lose if you just eat the right amount of calories. Sticking to the right percentages and exercise are more for improving your health than your weight. So, start by seeing how many calories MFP says to eat, and then try to stick to that.0
-
I agree calorie deficit is the way to go. Portion control is the key. I avoid pizza not because is bad for me but because it is very tempting for me and I tend to overeat. Decide what you are going to eat AND record the number of calories before you consume them. It helps you decide whether you want to REALLY have that piece of pie or not.0
-
First off, you do not HAVE to cut anything out. I just want to make that really clear. Behaviourally, feelings of deprivation are often a cause of lapsed diets. If you really want it, eat a bit.
One of the popular ways to lose weight without reducing the quantity of food you eat is to maximize high nutrient/ low calorie foods like fruit, veggies, lean protein, and minimize low nutrient/high calorie foods that contain few essential nutrients per calorie. An example would be to eat an apple over an equal amount of calories of table sugar, both because the apple will help you feel fuller, and it contains a lot of benefits (fibre, vitamins, minerals) that the sugar doesn't.
As long as you keep your calorie intake lower than your output, you will lose weight, regardless of what you eat.
If you are interested in making sure you get adequate nutrition and want to feel less hungry, fruits and vegetables and lean protein will be helpful, and processed foods that are low in nutrients and high in calories, while they won't necessarily derail you, waste calories with no real physical benefit to you.0 -
-
Assuming you're here because you've chosen MFP as the way to lose weight, nothing. Just cut back. Eat less, move more.
Read this: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1080242/a-guide-to-get-you-started-on-your-path-to-sexypants/p1
If you have other health goals, then the answer may be a tad different.0 -
Thats fantastic. Thank you to you all. Thats made it a lot easier to understand. The way I see it, for myself, just going off this week alone, I have been working at a deficit every day BUT I have not had the exercise to go with it, for medical reasons, which I am trying to build up.
On that note, as I am nearly always on a deficit, is it worth adjusting my target to a lower amount of calories. I keep getting the message that I have not used enough calories, when I finalise everything at night.0 -
-
I lost 60lbs eating everything I love but just at a calorie deficit! If you cut things out then it's not sustainable. Just eat real foods in moderation - and I can't stress this enough... WEIGH AND MEASURE EVERY BITE THAT GOES INTO YOUR MOUTH - then log it on MFP!
Best of luck! You can do this0 -
you only get that message if you are below 1200 calories, you should not have a deficit below that
0 -
I cut out eating whatever I want, whenever I want. That's it, really.0
-
I keep getting the message that I have not used enough calories, when I finalise everything at night.
That being said, weigh your foods on a food scale to ensure you're not eating more than you think.
0 -
Processed food, all that is ready...sugar, bread, bubbles, beer, or at least try less. I lost 100lbs in 3 years, maintaining now for a year by eating 1800 a day.0
-
In the absence of a medical condition, you do NOT need to specifically cut out (or down) any particular food, food group, or macronutrient. Pay attention to overall calories & eat at a (reasonable, sustainable) deficit.0
-
In the absence of a medical condition, you do NOT need to specifically cut out (or down) any particular food, food group, or macronutrient. Pay attention to overall calories & eat at a (reasonable, sustainable) deficit.
All this ^^^^
Reiterating the bold bit - you don't have to starve to lose weight.
0 -
I will add this.... Candy is very calorie dense, you get a few bites for 100 calories spent. Where as, fresh vegetables are the opposite, You can eat a ton of cucumber or green peppers or lettuce for that same 100 calories. So, you want to aim at balancing that out.0
-
hastingsmassage wrote: »Processed food, all that is ready...sugar, bread, bubbles, beer, or at least try less. I lost 100lbs in 3 years, maintaining now for a year by eating 1800 a day.
There is nothing wrong with "processed foods", sugar, bread, carbonated drinks or beer. There's no need to cut these things out. Just exercise moderation when eating ALL foods and maintain a calorie deficit.0 -
For me counting calories is most important. Do I cut stuff out? Kind of, I choose not to drink my calorie but sometimes have coffee. I use to love soda. I stopped for 6 months and now I don't like it as much. Also I want to eat the most food for less calories so I tend to eat more veggies and low calorie foods. Instead of pasta I eat spaghetti squash. Instead of regular bread I eat 90 cal hungry girl flat bread or whole wheat thin slice bread. I could never go no carb or no sugar. I would never succeed like that. I'm down 62lbs with not much exercise.0
-
I would recommend monitoring your calorie intake and keep that number at a deficit as your FIRST priority. That is 80% of the battle. The reason the trainer recommended you eat lower amounts of sugar and carbs is that those types of macronutrients do not make you feel full. Think of this example: if you eat pancakes with syrup for breakfast, you are more likely to want to overeat because they are not as filling as eating eggs, whey protein or other high quality proteins.
On the days that I meet my goal of 2,200 per day (which is the target set by MyFitnessPal) eating mostly carbs, I am almost always still hungry at the end of the day. When, however, I eat more high-quality proteins my satiety (meaning, my level of fullness) is much more satisfied. The feeling of fullness, to me, comes by eating the right types of foods.
I hope this makes sense, and you take this into consideration in your own life. It will make your weight loss journey more manageable.0 -
I think that others have sufficiently answered this - eat a calorie deficit.0
-
I wish there was a like button. You would get one. lol
My cals are set to 2000, which I set myself as I thought thats what men should have.
TBH, when people mention Macros, my mind blows. I will have to learn about that. Dieting seems a lot more complex that some people ( not you guys, but slimming clubs etc ) make it out to be.
Do you think I should drop my daily calorie goal. Here is a screen shot of my net cals for the last 7 days.
0 -
Here is my suggestion - go to the Scooby Workshop calculator, Enter your details, put a deficit of 15-20% max. Eat as much food as you can while trying to lose weight - better to lose more slowly and retain as much muscle as you can while losing. You don't win anything for losing quicker than anyone else, but you can lose a lot more than weight.
I'm 5'6", 147 lb and 45 yr old...to lose weight at my activity level, I can eat close to 2000 calories. If I were to be someone who can't exercise or move much, I'd be able to eat 1400 calories...so if you are male and bigger than me, you should be eating WELL above 1200 calories.0 -
It's not complex - all you need is a reasonable calorie deficit. It only becomes that way when you start worrying about certain foods being bad and others being good. Macros are for general wellbeing, reaching certain fitness goals, and feeling more satiated.
http://iifym.com/iifym-calculator/ Calculate your calories and macros using this and eat the same amount every day. This will show you your basal metabolic rate which is what you burn existing. You should not net below that. Or set MFP to your activity level and to a reasonable loss per week and eat back exercise calories.0 -
I'm 232.4 lbs, 6'1, 46 years old and next to no exercise, but trying to build up by getting walking again. ( back problems )0
-
In the Scooby calculator at sedentary and a 20% deficit, it shows you should be eating 2040 calories. You will lose on average 1 lb a week (but you might lose more). Honestly, why not do it the slow way...you'll learn how to eat for life, portions etc. And as you add more exercise to your programme, you can eat more. If you want a higher deficit, I would not go beyond 25% cut.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions