Smoothie Diet
Replies
-
The wraps worry me more than anything else, to be honest.
They are not sustainable and only give artificial results. I used to do wrestling and we would use that approach for making a weight class because sweating out water weight could help making the cut superficially. The problem is that it involves sweating out hydration that you need to function, especially if you're exercising.
After those weigh ins, we would replenish and often end up at the same weight we were before. It was uncomfortable and not something I would recommend for weight loss. Yes, you can "trick" the scale and have a momentary boost of confidence, but are you planning to not replenish after working out?0 -
My dad did the smoothie diet for 2 weeks, and lost about 14lbs. He was only allowed 1 ral meal a day and the rest was smoothie. Sure it sounded like a good idea but not only was h starving everyday, he gained that weight right back
0 -
I know a lot of people are going to hate my answer, but you do not need to go on a specific diet to lose weight. It's all about Calories in versus Calories out. You don't need to eat exclusively smoothies to lose weight, and, especially when you're looking into losing a large amount of weight, you need an option that you know you can sustain on for months/years afterwards.
I cant thonk of a single reasonable person who would hate this answer.
OP its about creating sustainable habits to carry with you for the rest of your life. A crazy fad diet - like an all smoothie diet - isn't sustainable.
But setting a reasonable calorie deficit and eating the foods you love in moderation is. You dont need to give up chocolate cake nor do you need to only consume smoothies. Its all about balance and sustainability.
some people need a break from chocolate cake...a reset. this does not make it a fad. 2 weeks of nutritous smoothies is not a bad idea.
0 -
oh yea quest bar rather than protein filled greek yogurt (23 gr) per cup ,fresh fruit ( fiber) and fat releasing spinach, and potassim and probiotic packed bananas. Go on with your bad self with your smoothies, they sound yummy!perseverance14 wrote: »
If you are going to do that for one meal watch your total fiber for the day, that can mess up your digestion and back things up if you don't get enough. How about a quest bar for breakfast, good protein and fiber. At least add bananas and berries, things like that which give you good fiber and make sure to have enough protein, have some balance.Miamorcapers wrote: »I'm surprised by everyone's reactions to smoothies. From the information I looked up I honestly thought a smoothie could be equivalent to meal if you made it the right way. Guess I have a lot to learn.
0 -
poohpoohpeapod wrote: »I know a lot of people are going to hate my answer, but you do not need to go on a specific diet to lose weight. It's all about Calories in versus Calories out. You don't need to eat exclusively smoothies to lose weight, and, especially when you're looking into losing a large amount of weight, you need an option that you know you can sustain on for months/years afterwards.
I cant thonk of a single reasonable person who would hate this answer.
OP its about creating sustainable habits to carry with you for the rest of your life. A crazy fad diet - like an all smoothie diet - isn't sustainable.
But setting a reasonable calorie deficit and eating the foods you love in moderation is. You dont need to give up chocolate cake nor do you need to only consume smoothies. Its all about balance and sustainability.
some people need a break from chocolate cake...a reset. this does not make it a fad. 2 weeks of nutritous smoothies is not a bad idea.
2 weeks of ONLY smoothies, not meeting your calorie or macros is a bad idea. I'm sorry there's just no such thing as a 'reset'.
If it's not sustainable for the rest of your life then it IS a fad diet. It's also a fad diet because you'll lose the weight, but gain it back.0 -
poohpoohpeapod wrote: »I know a lot of people are going to hate my answer, but you do not need to go on a specific diet to lose weight. It's all about Calories in versus Calories out. You don't need to eat exclusively smoothies to lose weight, and, especially when you're looking into losing a large amount of weight, you need an option that you know you can sustain on for months/years afterwards.
I cant thonk of a single reasonable person who would hate this answer.
OP its about creating sustainable habits to carry with you for the rest of your life. A crazy fad diet - like an all smoothie diet - isn't sustainable.
But setting a reasonable calorie deficit and eating the foods you love in moderation is. You dont need to give up chocolate cake nor do you need to only consume smoothies. Its all about balance and sustainability.
some people need a break from chocolate cake...a reset. this does not make it a fad. 2 weeks of nutritous smoothies is not a bad idea.
Hahhahahahahaha resets are crocks.
0 -
poohpoohpeapod wrote: »
oh yea quest bar rather than protein filled greek yogurt (23 gr) per cup ,fresh fruit ( fiber) and fat releasing spinach, and potassim and probiotic packed bananas. Go on with your bad self with your smoothies, they sound yummy!perseverance14 wrote: »
If you are going to do that for one meal watch your total fiber for the day, that can mess up your digestion and back things up if you don't get enough. How about a quest bar for breakfast, good protein and fiber. At least add bananas and berries, things like that which give you good fiber and make sure to have enough protein, have some balance.Miamorcapers wrote: »I'm surprised by everyone's reactions to smoothies. From the information I looked up I honestly thought a smoothie could be equivalent to meal if you made it the right way. Guess I have a lot to learn.
I'm sorry fat releasing spinach? Where does one find that in the store? Also probiotic packed bananas...
0 -
_HeartsOnFire_ wrote: »poohpoohpeapod wrote: »
oh yea quest bar rather than protein filled greek yogurt (23 gr) per cup ,fresh fruit ( fiber) and fat releasing spinach, and potassim and probiotic packed bananas. Go on with your bad self with your smoothies, they sound yummy!perseverance14 wrote: »
If you are going to do that for one meal watch your total fiber for the day, that can mess up your digestion and back things up if you don't get enough. How about a quest bar for breakfast, good protein and fiber. At least add bananas and berries, things like that which give you good fiber and make sure to have enough protein, have some balance.Miamorcapers wrote: »I'm surprised by everyone's reactions to smoothies. From the information I looked up I honestly thought a smoothie could be equivalent to meal if you made it the right way. Guess I have a lot to learn.
I'm sorry fat releasing spinach? Where does one find that in the store?
In the magical aisle next to the Unicorn meat.
0 -
poohpoohpeapod wrote: »I know a lot of people are going to hate my answer, but you do not need to go on a specific diet to lose weight. It's all about Calories in versus Calories out. You don't need to eat exclusively smoothies to lose weight, and, especially when you're looking into losing a large amount of weight, you need an option that you know you can sustain on for months/years afterwards.
I cant thonk of a single reasonable person who would hate this answer.
OP its about creating sustainable habits to carry with you for the rest of your life. A crazy fad diet - like an all smoothie diet - isn't sustainable.
But setting a reasonable calorie deficit and eating the foods you love in moderation is. You dont need to give up chocolate cake nor do you need to only consume smoothies. Its all about balance and sustainability.
some people need a break from chocolate cake...a reset. this does not make it a fad. 2 weeks of nutritous smoothies is not a bad idea.
Hahhahahahahaha resets are crocks.
You…I like you...0 -
poohpoohpeapod wrote: »I know a lot of people are going to hate my answer, but you do not need to go on a specific diet to lose weight. It's all about Calories in versus Calories out. You don't need to eat exclusively smoothies to lose weight, and, especially when you're looking into losing a large amount of weight, you need an option that you know you can sustain on for months/years afterwards.
I cant thonk of a single reasonable person who would hate this answer.
OP its about creating sustainable habits to carry with you for the rest of your life. A crazy fad diet - like an all smoothie diet - isn't sustainable.
But setting a reasonable calorie deficit and eating the foods you love in moderation is. You dont need to give up chocolate cake nor do you need to only consume smoothies. Its all about balance and sustainability.
some people need a break from chocolate cake...a reset. this does not make it a fad. 2 weeks of nutritous smoothies is not a bad idea.
I like cake. I just reset my body with pizza.
_HeartsOnFire_ wrote: »poohpoohpeapod wrote: »
oh yea quest bar rather than protein filled greek yogurt (23 gr) per cup ,fresh fruit ( fiber) and fat releasing spinach, and potassim and probiotic packed bananas. Go on with your bad self with your smoothies, they sound yummy!perseverance14 wrote: »
If you are going to do that for one meal watch your total fiber for the day, that can mess up your digestion and back things up if you don't get enough. How about a quest bar for breakfast, good protein and fiber. At least add bananas and berries, things like that which give you good fiber and make sure to have enough protein, have some balance.Miamorcapers wrote: »I'm surprised by everyone's reactions to smoothies. From the information I looked up I honestly thought a smoothie could be equivalent to meal if you made it the right way. Guess I have a lot to learn.
I'm sorry fat releasing spinach? Where does one find that in the store? Also probiotic packed bananas...
Possibly next to the Raspberry Keytones and the Green Tea Extract Pills... that's my guess.0 -
Laurend224 wrote: »_HeartsOnFire_ wrote: »poohpoohpeapod wrote: »
oh yea quest bar rather than protein filled greek yogurt (23 gr) per cup ,fresh fruit ( fiber) and fat releasing spinach, and potassim and probiotic packed bananas. Go on with your bad self with your smoothies, they sound yummy!perseverance14 wrote: »
If you are going to do that for one meal watch your total fiber for the day, that can mess up your digestion and back things up if you don't get enough. How about a quest bar for breakfast, good protein and fiber. At least add bananas and berries, things like that which give you good fiber and make sure to have enough protein, have some balance.Miamorcapers wrote: »I'm surprised by everyone's reactions to smoothies. From the information I looked up I honestly thought a smoothie could be equivalent to meal if you made it the right way. Guess I have a lot to learn.
I'm sorry fat releasing spinach? Where does one find that in the store?
In the magical aisle next to the Unicorn meat.
Also near the fairy dust?
Have they learned how to can Unicorn rainbow farts yet?
0 -
_HeartsOnFire_ wrote: »poohpoohpeapod wrote: »I know a lot of people are going to hate my answer, but you do not need to go on a specific diet to lose weight. It's all about Calories in versus Calories out. You don't need to eat exclusively smoothies to lose weight, and, especially when you're looking into losing a large amount of weight, you need an option that you know you can sustain on for months/years afterwards.
I cant thonk of a single reasonable person who would hate this answer.
OP its about creating sustainable habits to carry with you for the rest of your life. A crazy fad diet - like an all smoothie diet - isn't sustainable.
But setting a reasonable calorie deficit and eating the foods you love in moderation is. You dont need to give up chocolate cake nor do you need to only consume smoothies. Its all about balance and sustainability.
some people need a break from chocolate cake...a reset. this does not make it a fad. 2 weeks of nutritous smoothies is not a bad idea.
Hahhahahahahaha resets are crocks.
You…I like you...
Danke =]
0 -
-
Love me some smoothies. You got some good advice here but I think at the early stages of weight loss it's not really practical to rely on an all-smoothie diet because it's not sustainable for more than 10-15 pounds.
Did you really remake your whole profile with a vowel missing? :huh:0 -
Love me some smoothies. You got some good advice here but I think at the early stages of weight loss it's not really practical to rely on an all-smoothie diet because it's not sustainable for more than 10-15 pounds.
An all smoothie diet is not sustainable ... PERIOD!
A new account for you?0 -
brianpperkins wrote: »Love me some smoothies. You got some good advice here but I think at the early stages of weight loss it's not really practical to rely on an all-smoothie diet because it's not sustainable for more than 10-15 pounds.
An all smoothie diet is not sustainable ... PERIOD!
A new account for you?
I failed to click over... this is her trolling the forum account.0 -
Laurend224 wrote: »Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »FatFreeFrolicking wrote: »curryrussell wrote: »Holy cow the "Here's what you need to do" crowd needs to calm down. @Miamorcapers - Do what you wanna do, if you feel the wraps make you sweat more, do it. IF you feel the shakes are taking some of your calories out of your day do it. Ignore all these "experts" and just keep up the good work!
Sorry buddy but wraps and smoothies aren't sustainable for long-term success
I'm trying to fathom how she could be getting anywhere near enough calories from just smoothies based on the one she posted.
She can't. Not with that recipe. Mine are closer to 500 calories, and I only have one a day, usually for breakfast/first meal. I guess I could technically have 3 of those a day, but somehow I still think I would be looking to chew something and wind up over my calories.
Ditto.0 -
brianpperkins wrote: »Love me some smoothies. You got some good advice here but I think at the early stages of weight loss it's not really practical to rely on an all-smoothie diet because it's not sustainable for more than 10-15 pounds.
An all smoothie diet is not sustainable ... PERIOD!
A new account for you?
Um.. okay...Thanks for agreeing.
I didn't agree with your misconception that it would even be sustainable for just a few pounds ... it is completely unsustainable ... PERIOD!0 -
brianpperkins wrote: »Love me some smoothies. You got some good advice here but I think at the early stages of weight loss it's not really practical to rely on an all-smoothie diet because it's not sustainable for more than 10-15 pounds.
An all smoothie diet is not sustainable ... PERIOD!
A new account for you?
Um.. okay...Thanks for agreeing.[/quote]
Yeah they DIDN'T agree with you. Smoothie diet is NOT sustainable period. Key word there being NOT. Plus they won't meet what they need nutrient wise, therefore it can be unhealthy. So. yeah, there's that.0 -
PrizePopple wrote: »brianpperkins wrote: »Love me some smoothies. You got some good advice here but I think at the early stages of weight loss it's not really practical to rely on an all-smoothie diet because it's not sustainable for more than 10-15 pounds.
An all smoothie diet is not sustainable ... PERIOD!
A new account for you?
I failed to click over... this is her trolling the forum account.
Wow.. rude. Go find one post where I'm "trolling the forum" on this account.
I think everything you posted here is the example of 'trolling the forum' on this account.
I mean, suggesting that a smoothie diet is sustainable in ANY way is trolling.0 -
This content has been removed.
-
PrizePopple wrote: »brianpperkins wrote: »Love me some smoothies. You got some good advice here but I think at the early stages of weight loss it's not really practical to rely on an all-smoothie diet because it's not sustainable for more than 10-15 pounds.
An all smoothie diet is not sustainable ... PERIOD!
A new account for you?
I failed to click over... this is her trolling the forum account.
Wow.. rude. Go find one post where I'm "trolling the forum" on this account.
PROHIBITED USES
MyFitnessPal imposes certain restrictions on Your use of the Services. You represent and warrant that you will not: (a) "stalk" or otherwise harass any person, or contact any person who has requested not to be contacted; (b) provide false, misleading or inaccurate information to MyFitnessPal or any other member; (c) impersonate, or otherwise misrepresent affiliation, connection or association with, any person or entity; (d) create more than one unique public profile;
You're breaking MFP TOS honey.0 -
I love smoothies and I've been having a green smoothie occasionally for breakfast, but I agree with the others that trying to do nothing but smoothies would lead to failure for me. You might be able to make one with good enough macros and micros that you could have it three times per day and be okay nutritionally, but I think you'd be pretty miserable.
I'd suggest just doing one for breakfast and then making yourself a balanced lunch and dinner. You can use the recipe builder for anything that you cook, and you can find most packaged foods in the database. For more info on logging (because it seems like you might have some questions) read this thread:
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/discussion/1234699/logging-accurately-step-by-step-guide/p1
And can I just say that I find your attitude toward those giving advice so refreshing. A lot of times when we tell people that what they're doing isn't necessary or may not work they get really defensive. It's so nice to see someone willing to take advice.0 -
Oh Topaz…just stop…He said it wasn't at all…you said it was for 10-15 lbs…which is wrong. WRONG.
So stop trolling. Please. It's unbecoming…and you are breaking MFP rules…so I'd expect a smack down from a mod soon enough…
-1 -
PrizePopple wrote: »Love me some smoothies. You got some good advice here but I think at the early stages of weight loss it's not really practical to rely on an all-smoothie diet because it's not sustainable for more than 10-15 pounds.
Did you really remake your whole profile with a vowel missing? :huh:
Oh no!
0 -
I'm going to tell you guys a secret, but lets keep it between us. There's this magical liquid called sweat. If you can work hard enough to make it escape your body a few times a week (at least) then you don't have to worry about outlandish diets like a month long smoothie craze.
0 -
poohpoohpeapod wrote: »I know a lot of people are going to hate my answer, but you do not need to go on a specific diet to lose weight. It's all about Calories in versus Calories out. You don't need to eat exclusively smoothies to lose weight, and, especially when you're looking into losing a large amount of weight, you need an option that you know you can sustain on for months/years afterwards.
I cant thonk of a single reasonable person who would hate this answer.
OP its about creating sustainable habits to carry with you for the rest of your life. A crazy fad diet - like an all smoothie diet - isn't sustainable.
But setting a reasonable calorie deficit and eating the foods you love in moderation is. You dont need to give up chocolate cake nor do you need to only consume smoothies. Its all about balance and sustainability.
some people need a break from chocolate cake...a reset. this does not make it a fad. 2 weeks of nutritous smoothies is not a bad idea.
where is this reset button for metabolism?0 -
0
-
Ja_ja_jakeya wrote: »I'm going to tell you guys a secret, but lets keep it between us. There's this magical liquid called sweat. If you can work hard enough to make it escape your body a few times a week (at least) then you don't have to worry about outlandish diets like a month long smoothie craze.
You don't have to work out to lose weight. It can be done by diet alone.0 -
But if you're so in a hurry to lose weight, then it only makes sense to combine diet and exercise to get the best result. Far better than a month of nothing but smoothies!Ja_ja_jakeya wrote: »I'm going to tell you guys a secret, but lets keep it between us. There's this magical liquid called sweat. If you can work hard enough to make it escape your body a few times a week (at least) then you don't have to worry about outlandish diets like a month long smoothie craze.
You don't have to work out to lose weight. It can be done by diet alone.
0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions