ON vs. PES Select vs. Cellucor vs. Other?
morkiemama
Posts: 894 Member
Okay, so I am coming to the end of my ON GS 100% Whey tub and I was looking to try something new! Overall, out of the brands I have tried, I like ON and it is a good price point. However, if another brand tasted better with similar (or better) stats, I would be willing to pay a higher price.
There are more high quality, reasonably priced options on the market than there used to be, so I am not sure ON is an obvious pick anymore. I have seen good reviews on PES Select, but I have only used whey powders. How different are blends? I also saw some good reviews for Cellucor.
Pretty much I am looking for a new powder to try and open to suggestions!
Or if you think sticking with ON is best, I would like to hear from you, too!
Your input is welcomed and appreciated
There are more high quality, reasonably priced options on the market than there used to be, so I am not sure ON is an obvious pick anymore. I have seen good reviews on PES Select, but I have only used whey powders. How different are blends? I also saw some good reviews for Cellucor.
Pretty much I am looking for a new powder to try and open to suggestions!
Or if you think sticking with ON is best, I would like to hear from you, too!Your input is welcomed and appreciated
0
Replies
-
Try natural factors whey factors grass fed. I just switched over to it last week , and I find it is the best tasting easiest to digest protein powder I've ever had. (no gas,nobloating,bubblyguts). It mixes incredibly well with water, almond milkd cereal, oats you name it.0
-
Try natural factors whey factors grass fed. I just switched over to it last week , and I find it is the best tasting easiest to digest protein powder I've ever had. (no gas,nobloating,bubblyguts). It mixes incredibly well with water, almond milkd cereal, oats you name it.
Thank you for weighing in! 0 -
I would love to hear a few ideas as well. Most of what I have is ON. I do use Rule 1 chocolate fudge whey which is darn good. I have heard that the Cellucor flavoring is pretty good and more updated. I tried some of their BCAA's and it was the best tasting fruit punch I have had. I do want to try some more natural stuff as all the Sucralose and artificial sweeteners can't be good for us. All of the bcaa's have them too.0
-
I would love to hear a few ideas as well. Most of what I have is ON. I do use Rule 1 chocolate fudge whey which is darn good. I have heard that the Cellucor flavoring is pretty good and more updated. I tried some of their BCAA's and it was the best tasting fruit punch I have had. I do want to try some more natural stuff as all the Sucralose and artificial sweeteners can't be good for us. All of the bcaa's have them too.
I have heard that about Cellucor, too. I would like to hear from people that have tried it (and maybe even previously had ON to compare).
I am also interested in learning about blends rather than straight whey and if it would be an option for me.
Thanks for coming to the discussion. I hope more people weigh in.
0 -
If price isn't an issue, then use ON. It's good stuff, real top quality. The only reason I don't use it is because of the price.0
-
The ON Gold Standard 100% Casein tastes good; but, I've found that it doesn't mix well, though, except in smaller amounts. I mix it with water (from room temps to warm; i.e., 68F - 90F): typically, ~50 g / 500 ml. (Before bedtime)
And, the ON Gold Standard 100% Whey tastes good and mixes well. I mix with water or almond milk (cold, ~40F): ~40g - 50g / 500 ml. (After getting up in the mornings)0 -
I love ON GS - I've tried probably 10 flavors and most of them are delicious! If you like it, and it works for you price-wise and calorie/macro-wise, stick with it! It's hard enough finding a brand you enjoy the taste of!
Currently finishing up my 5lb container of Chocolate Mint and have a 5lb container of Chocolate Coconut ready to go (already tried it once - amazing, as usual!)
I order from Amazon.com - save a few bucks, get free shipping, it's a win-win0 -
That fake sweet after-taste gets me on certain favors, so this might be something to look into. I imagine it alters the macro makeup though. 0 -
TyronnePanaino wrote: »If price isn't an issue, then use ON. It's good stuff, real top quality. The only reason I don't use it is because of the price.
Thanks! I appreciate the input. 0 -
The ON Gold Standard 100% Casein tastes good; but, I've found that it doesn't mix well, though, except in smaller amounts. I mix it with water (from room temps to warm; i.e., 68F - 90F): typically, ~50 g / 500 ml. (Before bedtime)
And, the ON Gold Standard 100% Whey tastes good and mixes well. I mix with water or almond milk (cold, ~40F): ~40g - 50g / 500 ml. (After getting up in the mornings)
Thanks for the temperature suggestions!
Would you recommend rotating casein into my regimen? I know that it is slower absorbing, but that is about it. I also know it is thicker, which I imagine makes consumption worse ha ha.
0 -
Cellucor has some very good flavors- I haven't tried ON so I can't weigh in on them-. I use the cellucor Molten Chocolate. It's 29.99 for a 2lb right now on Bodybuilding. It's the only protein powder I have found that I can mix with just water. Hope that helps
0 -
ActuarialChef wrote: »I love ON GS - I've tried probably 10 flavors and most of them are delicious! If you like it, and it works for you price-wise and calorie/macro-wise, stick with it! It's hard enough finding a brand you enjoy the taste of!
Currently finishing up my 5lb container of Chocolate Mint and have a 5lb container of Chocolate Coconut ready to go (already tried it once - amazing, as usual!)
I order from Amazon.com - save a few bucks, get free shipping, it's a win-win
Can you recommend any flavors? I liked the extreme milk chocolate and the strawberry, but didn't care for the double Dutch chocolate (I think it was). I know some flavors can get scary in protein ha ha.
You have a very valid point. Why switch if it is working and there are flavors to try? I think I was getting caught up in the hype of new kid on the block.
I bought previously from GNC, but I will need to check out Amazon (love them)! I could even shop through Amazon smile and donate.
0 -
Cellucor has some very good flavors- I haven't tried ON so I can't weigh in on them-. I use the cellucor Molten Chocolate. It's 29.99 for a 2lb right now on Bodybuilding. It's the only protein powder I have found that I can mix with just water. Hope that helps
Thanks for joining in! I am still open to hearing from non-ON folks, but there do sure seem to be a lot of them lol!
I have heard such good things about Cellucor's taste, but have yet to see anyone compare it to a brand I have tried. I know there is a promotion going on, so I was looking into it.
0 -
morkiemama wrote: »Cellucor has some very good flavors- I haven't tried ON so I can't weigh in on them-. I use the cellucor Molten Chocolate. It's 29.99 for a 2lb right now on Bodybuilding. It's the only protein powder I have found that I can mix with just water. Hope that helps
Thanks for joining in! I am still open to hearing from non-ON folks, but there do sure seem to be a lot of them lol!
I have heard such good things about Cellucor's taste, but have yet to see anyone compare it to a brand I have tried. I know there is a promotion going on, so I was looking into it.
I been with Cellucor for awhile. I used to use Epiq which was really good, just not worth the price tag. On Bodybuilding.com you can order "sample" packs which have 4-5 servings in them or I think GNC has them.0 -
Trutein is worth the money. Also Muscle Pharm Combat PP is good.0
-
morkiemama wrote: »ActuarialChef wrote: »I love ON GS - I've tried probably 10 flavors and most of them are delicious! If you like it, and it works for you price-wise and calorie/macro-wise, stick with it! It's hard enough finding a brand you enjoy the taste of!
Currently finishing up my 5lb container of Chocolate Mint and have a 5lb container of Chocolate Coconut ready to go (already tried it once - amazing, as usual!)
I order from Amazon.com - save a few bucks, get free shipping, it's a win-win
Can you recommend any flavors? I liked the extreme milk chocolate and the strawberry, but didn't care for the double Dutch chocolate (I think it was). I know some flavors can get scary in protein ha ha.
You have a very valid point. Why switch if it is working and there are flavors to try? I think I was getting caught up in the hype of new kid on the block.
I bought previously from GNC, but I will need to check out Amazon (love them)! I could even shop through Amazon smile and donate.
Sure! Let's see... (going through my Amazon order history to refresh my memory):
Cookies & Cream -- ehh. Not crazy about the small chunks of cookie in the shake. Good flavor though. Might be good if you're the type that makes frozen shakes with protein powder, frozen milk/water, etc.
Vanilla Ice Cream -- good, but a little plain. Better for mixing with other things (i.e. baking)
Double Rich Chocolate -- I thought this one was good, but had a strange after-taste
Banana Cream -- so so so good!
Caramel Toffee Fudge -- another one with a slight after-taste, but I think it might have just been the toffee part.
Cake Batter -- 5 stars! This one was delicious!
Chocolate Mint -- tastes like a thin mint -- sooo good
Chocolate Coconut -- tastes like a mounds bar. delicious blended with 2 frozen bananas + coconut greek yogurt + cocoa powder for a 500-calorie BEAST of a shake (this is what I had last night haha)
Haven't tried any of the "fruity" flavors besides banana, because I can't imagine drinking them. Although the strawberry might taste like strawberry milk, which I loved as a kid haha. Maybe I'll try that one next...0 -
ActuarialChef wrote: »morkiemama wrote: »ActuarialChef wrote: »I love ON GS - I've tried probably 10 flavors and most of them are delicious! If you like it, and it works for you price-wise and calorie/macro-wise, stick with it! It's hard enough finding a brand you enjoy the taste of!
Currently finishing up my 5lb container of Chocolate Mint and have a 5lb container of Chocolate Coconut ready to go (already tried it once - amazing, as usual!)
I order from Amazon.com - save a few bucks, get free shipping, it's a win-win
Can you recommend any flavors? I liked the extreme milk chocolate and the strawberry, but didn't care for the double Dutch chocolate (I think it was). I know some flavors can get scary in protein ha ha.
You have a very valid point. Why switch if it is working and there are flavors to try? I think I was getting caught up in the hype of new kid on the block.
I bought previously from GNC, but I will need to check out Amazon (love them)! I could even shop through Amazon smile and donate.
Sure! Let's see... (going through my Amazon order history to refresh my memory):
Cookies & Cream -- ehh. Not crazy about the small chunks of cookie in the shake. Good flavor though. Might be good if you're the type that makes frozen shakes with protein powder, frozen milk/water, etc.
Vanilla Ice Cream -- good, but a little plain. Better for mixing with other things (i.e. baking)
Double Rich Chocolate -- I thought this one was good, but had a strange after-taste
Banana Cream -- so so so good!
Caramel Toffee Fudge -- another one with a slight after-taste, but I think it might have just been the toffee part.
Cake Batter -- 5 stars! This one was delicious!
Chocolate Mint -- tastes like a thin mint -- sooo good
Chocolate Coconut -- tastes like a mounds bar. delicious blended with 2 frozen bananas + coconut greek yogurt + cocoa powder for a 500-calorie BEAST of a shake (this is what I had last night haha)
Haven't tried any of the "fruity" flavors besides banana, because I can't imagine drinking them. Although the strawberry might taste like strawberry milk, which I loved as a kid haha. Maybe I'll try that one next...
Thank you for taking the time to look this up and type it all out! Awesome detailed review. It is much appreciated
0 -
morkiemama wrote: »ActuarialChef wrote: »morkiemama wrote: »ActuarialChef wrote: »I love ON GS - I've tried probably 10 flavors and most of them are delicious! If you like it, and it works for you price-wise and calorie/macro-wise, stick with it! It's hard enough finding a brand you enjoy the taste of!
Currently finishing up my 5lb container of Chocolate Mint and have a 5lb container of Chocolate Coconut ready to go (already tried it once - amazing, as usual!)
I order from Amazon.com - save a few bucks, get free shipping, it's a win-win
Can you recommend any flavors? I liked the extreme milk chocolate and the strawberry, but didn't care for the double Dutch chocolate (I think it was). I know some flavors can get scary in protein ha ha.
You have a very valid point. Why switch if it is working and there are flavors to try? I think I was getting caught up in the hype of new kid on the block.
I bought previously from GNC, but I will need to check out Amazon (love them)! I could even shop through Amazon smile and donate.
Sure! Let's see... (going through my Amazon order history to refresh my memory):
Cookies & Cream -- ehh. Not crazy about the small chunks of cookie in the shake. Good flavor though. Might be good if you're the type that makes frozen shakes with protein powder, frozen milk/water, etc.
Vanilla Ice Cream -- good, but a little plain. Better for mixing with other things (i.e. baking)
Double Rich Chocolate -- I thought this one was good, but had a strange after-taste
Banana Cream -- so so so good!
Caramel Toffee Fudge -- another one with a slight after-taste, but I think it might have just been the toffee part.
Cake Batter -- 5 stars! This one was delicious!
Chocolate Mint -- tastes like a thin mint -- sooo good
Chocolate Coconut -- tastes like a mounds bar. delicious blended with 2 frozen bananas + coconut greek yogurt + cocoa powder for a 500-calorie BEAST of a shake (this is what I had last night haha)
Haven't tried any of the "fruity" flavors besides banana, because I can't imagine drinking them. Although the strawberry might taste like strawberry milk, which I loved as a kid haha. Maybe I'll try that one next...
Thank you for taking the time to look this up and type it all out! Awesome detailed review. It is much appreciated
No problem at all! I search through Amazon reviews for the flavors I want to try, too. I want to know what other people think before I spend $50+ on a 5lb container of it!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions