Skip to content
  • Register
    • We are pleased to announce that on March 4, 2025, an updated Rich Text Editor will be introduced in the MyFitnessPal Community. To learn more about the upcoming changes, please click here. We look forward to sharing this new feature with you!

    The best peanut butter?

    Posts: 26,368 Member
    edited November 2024 in Food and Nutrition
    My husband finished the jar yesterday... So we need to buy more.

    But I'm curious... I typically go with the 'natural' stuff without adding anything, but taste-wise... which brand is the best?

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register
    «134

    Replies

    • Posts: 17 Member
      I really like the Jiff Natural. It's no stir, not crazy pricey, and better than the store brand.
    • Posts: 561 Member
      I'm not sure if this is in Canada only but I love the Kraft 100% natural peanut butter.
    • Posts: 10,322 Member
      Nuts & More
    • Posts: 303 Member
      I'm totally in love w peanut butter & co white chocolate wonderful.
    • Posts: 1,941 Member
      Jif or peter pan, definitely. Natural peanut butter is like dry and oily at the same time.
    • Posts: 15,357 Member
      Natural peanut butter breaks my plastic spoon when I try to stir in the oil at work... :down:

      I have the worst excuses really. Sadly, I really like the flavor of great value crunch peanut butter, but that's likely not what you're looking for since it has additives.
    • Posts: 960 Member
      I love peter pan
    • Posts: 69 Member
      Whole Foods 360 natural peanut butter. It's the family favorite and is a surprising bargain.
    • Posts: 2,561 Member
      carliekitty wrote: »
      I'm totally in love w peanut butter & co white chocolate wonderful.

      You and me both! I don't think it tastes like white chocolate, though. I think it tastes just like regular peanut butter mixed with marshmallow creme...which is just amazing.
    • Posts: 846 Member
      Homemade!
    • Posts: 1,460 Member
      Another vote for Kraft 100% natural peanut butter. Although I've been meaning to try my hand at making my own...
    • Posts: 1,941 Member
      chesnity3 wrote: »
      I love peter pan
      Fun fact- peter pan is preferred among alot of sensory issue kids/autistic kids because it is the smoothest on the market.

    • Posts: 85 Member
      home made.. 100% peanuts.. no nonsense
    • Posts: 756 Member
      I love almond butter.
    • Posts: 563 Member
      Teddie all natural peanut butter.
      Ingredients: salt. Peanuts.

      If I go with almond butter then I get woodstock farms all natural kind as well.
      Ingredients: Almonds.

      Both brands are non GMO.
    • Posts: 4,397 Member
      Peter Pan Honey Roasted. Best peanut butter ever.
    • Posts: 357 Member
      edited February 2015
      Extra Crunchy Skippy
    • Posts: 17,890 Member
      My favorite is "Africa's Finest" creamy - no added sugar, 99% peanuts, salt, emulsifier.

      peanut butter & co white chocolate wonderful - agree it's more like candy :p

      Almond butter, love that too, w/pear, or yogurt, and maple syrup! And Justin's chocolate hazelnut butter, in yogurt; it's too grainy to eat separately.
    • Posts: 37 Member
      My favorite is Smuckers Natural. I stir it up once and then put it in the refrigerator upside down and don't have to stir it again. The problem is I like it too much and it is hard to resist lol.

      I also like Skippy Natural No Stir Super Chunk.
    • Posts: 47
      edited February 2015
      I just noticed one of my friends had chocolate sunflower seed almond butter in her diary. Uh #1 does this exist #2 why didn't I know #3 why isn't it in and around my facial area?
    • Posts: 863 Member
      primalsarah wrote: »
      I really like the Jiff Natural. It's no stir, not crazy pricey, and better than the store brand.

      ^ tHIS!

    • Posts: 521 Member
      I_Will_End_You wrote: »
      Peter Pan Honey Roasted. Best peanut butter ever.

      Truer words have not been spoken! Peter Pan is my friend. Every.Single.Day.
    • Posts: 2,493 Member
      Peanut butter & co cinnamon and raisin
      Peanut butter & co white chocolate
      Peanut butter & co dark chocolate
      Manbake cookie butter
      Nuts N more toffee crunch peanut butter
      Nuts N more chocolate coconut almond butter
      Hognuts Sweet Home Almonana Almond Butter 5Hognuts Caramel Amaretto Macchiato Cashew and Peanut Butter
      Hognuts Bourbon Vanilla Crunch Peanut Butter Hognuts Maple & Pecan Peanut Butter
    • Posts: 1,382 Member
      KREMA - CREAMY

      Ingredients - Peanuts (nothing else) Tastes great!!!!
    • Posts: 1 Member
      I like Market Pantry (Target brand) peanut butter - ingredients are peanuts and salt. I just have to stir it when I open it, then keep in the fridge and it doesn't separate.
    • Posts: 811 Member
      I like the one from Bulk Barn. You get to crush your own nuts. Add some sea salt and away you go :)
    • Posts: 4,252 Member
      Teddie or Nature's Promise organic PB.

      All natural PB tastes better to me.
    • Posts: 2,228 Member
      Jif's whipped maple brown sugar PB
    • Posts: 27 Member
      raised on Teddie- love it and so do our kids.
    • Unknown
      Unknown
      edited February 2015
      This content has been removed.
    This discussion has been closed.

    Welcome!

    It looks like you're new here. Sign in or register to get started.
    Sign In
    Register

    Quick Links

    Categories