myfitnesspal saying 1133 calories remaining

dst3023
dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
edited November 12 in Health and Weight Loss
Hi been using myfitnesspal for a long time now. I have just increased my exercise to 1100 per day and eating to 1700 calories a day and have noticed this

1133 CALORIES REMAINING, 1700 GOAL, 1667 FOOD, 1100 EXERCISE =567 NET

my exercise are as follows
Cardiovascular
Aerobics, step, with 10-12 inch step 11min @ 200cal
Rowing Level 10 11min @ 100cal
Treadmill (Weigh Loss) Incline 14, Speed 4.0 36min @ 600cal
Elliptical Trainer 11min @‌

Strength Training
Incline Chest Press 4sets @10 - 35kg
Fly (Chest) 4sets @10 - 35kg
Chest Press 4sets @10 - 55 kg
Rear Deltoid (Chest) 4sets @15 - 90 kg

calories are tracked with a Polar FT4

can i be advised as to if im burning or consuming to much this is my fitness plan that I do everyday except Sundays. Thanks
«1

Replies

  • holly55555
    holly55555 Posts: 306 Member
    I don't eat back my workout calories. I just selected an activity level that accounts for it.

    You aren't supposed to log your exercise if you added it into your activity level when you set your goal. In example, if you selected that you are active because you workout 3-5 times a week, that is already accounted for in your calories.

    I think it's easier to select your activity level based on exercise instead of logging exercise because MFP greatly overestimates exercise and it's really hard to keep an accurate count of. Maybe just do it that way?
  • 4legsRbetterthan2
    4legsRbetterthan2 Posts: 19,590 MFP Moderator
    MFP includes your daily deficit in your daily goal. This means that if you did not exercise above and boyond what you set your activity level to you will lose your desired amount of weight each week eating that goal. To account for exercise you basically "earn" the calories you burn and are supposed to eat them back.

    If you are willing to share your stats (age, weight, sex) people might be able to help make sure your current calculations are accurate.

  • ndj1979
    ndj1979 Posts: 29,136 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    Hi been using myfitnesspal for a long time now. I have just increased my exercise to 1100 per day and eating to 1700 calories a day and have noticed this

    1133 CALORIES REMAINING, 1700 GOAL, 1667 FOOD, 1100 EXERCISE =567 NET

    my exercise are as follows
    Cardiovascular
    Aerobics, step, with 10-12 inch step 11min @ 200cal
    Rowing Level 10 11min @ 100cal
    Treadmill (Weigh Loss) Incline 14, Speed 4.0 36min @ 600cal
    Elliptical Trainer 11min @‌

    Strength Training
    Incline Chest Press 4sets @10 - 35kg
    Fly (Chest) 4sets @10 - 35kg
    Chest Press 4sets @10 - 55 kg
    Rear Deltoid (Chest) 4sets @15 - 90 kg

    calories are tracked with a Polar FT4

    can i be advised as to if im burning or consuming to much this is my fitness plan that I do everyday except Sundays. Thanks

    MFP burn estimates are overrated so you should only eat back half of what they say you burned.

    so in your above example....

    Goal 1700 burned 1100 < take half of that = 550 burned means that you need to eat 2250 - 550 burned = 1700 net calories.

  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    holly55555 wrote: »
    I don't eat back my workout calories. I just selected an activity level that accounts for it.

    You aren't supposed to log your exercise if you added it into your activity level when you set your goal. In example, if you selected that you are active because you workout 3-5 times a week, that is already accounted for in your calories.

    I think it's easier to select your activity level based on exercise instead of logging exercise because MFP greatly overestimates exercise and it's really hard to keep an accurate count of. Maybe just do it that way?

    activity level set at sedentry
    Thanks

  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    MFP includes your daily deficit in your daily goal. This means that if you did not exercise above and boyond what you set your activity level to you will lose your desired amount of weight each week eating that goal. To account for exercise you basically "earn" the calories you burn and are supposed to eat them back.

    If you are willing to share your stats (age, weight, sex) people might be able to help make sure your current calculations are accurate.
    Thanks 37, Male, 5ft-7",

  • Iron_Feline
    Iron_Feline Posts: 10,750 Member
    edited February 2015
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.

    Also 1700 cals for a man with that much exercise seems very low. I'd eat at last half your exercise calories back and see where you are in a month.
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    .....erm sunday is my rest day for workouts

  • Iron_Feline
    Iron_Feline Posts: 10,750 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    .....erm sunday is my rest day for workouts

    DO you do the SAME strength training every day?
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    .....erm sunday is my rest day for workouts

    DO you do the SAME strength training every day?
    erm yes except sundays
  • Iron_Feline
    Iron_Feline Posts: 10,750 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    dst3023 wrote: »
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    .....erm sunday is my rest day for workouts

    DO you do the SAME strength training every day?
    erm yes except sundays

    You are doing yourself a disservice,

    Your muscles need time to recover - you should not work them out the same way two days in a row, certainly not 6. Your routine is horribly unbalanced. Why no legs? No squats or deadlifts

    Find a good program and do that - look into Starting strength, stronglift 5x5 or nerd fitness.

    Either do a program that focuses on compound lifts or a good split program. I suggest compound lifts - squats, deadlifts, bench as you are clearly a beginner.
  • Daiako
    Daiako Posts: 12,545 Member
    Bruh. Never skip leg day. Eat back half of those calories. Never skip leg day.
  • yopeeps025
    yopeeps025 Posts: 8,680 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    dst3023 wrote: »
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    .....erm sunday is my rest day for workouts

    DO you do the SAME strength training every day?
    erm yes except sundays

    If you are in fact doing the same muscle groups everyday well then someone told you how to lift weights wrong.
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    dst3023 wrote: »
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    I hope you are not doing that strength workout everyday - muscles need time to recover.

    Please tell us you alternate with a leg day.
    .....erm sunday is my rest day for workouts

    DO you do the SAME strength training every day?
    erm yes except sundays

    You are doing yourself a disservice,

    Your muscles need time to recover - you should not work them out the same way two days in a row, certainly not 6. Your routine is horribly unbalanced. Why no legs? No squats or deadlifts

    Find a good program and do that - look into Starting strength, stronglift 5x5 or nerd fitness.

    Either do a program that focuses on compound lifts or a good split program. I suggest compound lifts - squats, deadlifts, bench as you are clearly a beginner.
    thanks will look into this

  • markiend
    markiend Posts: 461 Member
    I wouldn't be using a HRM to track accurate burns for lifting. They are best for steady state cardio and even then they are guestimating
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    Do you do any leg or back training at all?

    yes I do just dont log them all Rotary Calf, Calf Press, Leg Press & Leg Extensions also these AB Crunches, Seated Row
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    markie166 wrote: »
    I wouldn't be using a HRM to track accurate burns for lifting. They are best for steady state cardio and even then they are guestimating
    I dont use HRM when doing Lifts or Weights

  • yopeeps025
    yopeeps025 Posts: 8,680 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    Do you do any leg or back training at all?

    yes I do just dont log them all Rotary Calf, Calf Press, Leg Press & Leg Extensions also these AB Crunches, Seated Row

    Did you make up your own lifting program you do?

  • jacksonpt
    jacksonpt Posts: 10,413 Member
    Taking everything at face value, no that's not OK. ~600 cals per day is not enough. It's probably not a big deal short term, but over time you'll likely see some negative side effects. How much you care about those side effects is up to you.

    Speaking more generally, it's hard to say if it's ok or not as there are sooo many variables, assumptions and estimates involved. Try it for a month and see how you do.
    • If you're making good progress, with good energy levels and good workouts, then keep at it.
    • If you're making good progress, but don't have decent energy or your workouts are suffering, eat a bit more.
    • If you're not making progress but feel good and your workouts are good, eat a bit less.
    • If you're not making pogress and you don't have good energy/workouts suffer, start over and rethink what you're doing.
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    yes my gp advised me to concentrate on my chest area as i have lost 3stone to date and wanted to rid the excess fat on the chest area
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    jacksonpt wrote: »
    Taking everything at face value, no that's not OK. ~600 cals per day is not enough. It's probably not a big deal short term, but over time you'll likely see some negative side effects. How much you care about those side effects is up to you.

    Speaking more generally, it's hard to say if it's ok or not as there are sooo many variables, assumptions and estimates involved. Try it for a month and see how you do.
    • If you're making good progress, with good energy levels and good workouts, then keep at it.
    • If you're making good progress, but don't have decent energy or your workouts are suffering, eat a bit more.
    • If you're not making progress but feel good and your workouts are good, eat a bit less.
    • If you're not making pogress and you don't have good energy/workouts suffer, start over and rethink what you're doing.
    600 calories not sure where you got that from.
  • jacksonpt
    jacksonpt Posts: 10,413 Member
    edited February 2015
    dst3023 wrote: »
    1133 CALORIES REMAINING, 1700 GOAL, 1667 FOOD, 1100 EXERCISE = 567 NET

    I rounded.
  • Iron_Feline
    Iron_Feline Posts: 10,750 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    yes my gp advised me to concentrate on my chest area as i have lost 3stone to date and wanted to rid the excess fat on the chest area

    Don't take lifting advice from a GP unless they lift. You can't spot reduce.

    A balanced progressive program is best, not one you have made up.
  • yopeeps025
    yopeeps025 Posts: 8,680 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    yes my gp advised me to concentrate on my chest area as i have lost 3stone to date and wanted to rid the excess fat on the chest area

    chest fat suck for a guy right? I know the feeling
    1. You cannot spot reduce the chest area you will just have to keep losing weight.

    Like you might have a feeling I plan to get down to really low body fat to see if it is a hormone issue. So if it is needed single digit body fat%.

  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    yes my gp advised me to concentrate on my chest area as i have lost 3stone to date and wanted to rid the excess fat on the chest area

    Don't take lifting advice from a GP unless they lift. You can't spot reduce.

    A balanced progressive program is best, not one you have made up.
    ok thanks can you suggest a plan for me

  • yopeeps025
    yopeeps025 Posts: 8,680 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    dst3023 wrote: »
    yes my gp advised me to concentrate on my chest area as i have lost 3stone to date and wanted to rid the excess fat on the chest area

    Don't take lifting advice from a GP unless they lift. You can't spot reduce.

    A balanced progressive program is best, not one you have made up.
    ok thanks can you suggest a plan for me

    Strong lift 5x5 is a beginner MFP favorite program.
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    yopeeps025 wrote: »
    dst3023 wrote: »
    yes my gp advised me to concentrate on my chest area as i have lost 3stone to date and wanted to rid the excess fat on the chest area

    chest fat suck for a guy right? I know the feeling
    1. You cannot spot reduce the chest area you will just have to keep losing weight.

    Like you might have a feeling I plan to get down to really low body fat to see if it is a hormone issue. So if it is needed single digit body fat%.
    its not hormone issue as was sent for numerous blood test to confirm this only have vitamin d deficiency.
  • debrag12
    debrag12 Posts: 1,071 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    yes my gp advised me to concentrate on my chest area as i have lost 3stone to date and wanted to rid the excess fat on the chest area

    you can't spot reduce
  • Iron_Feline
    Iron_Feline Posts: 10,750 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    dst3023 wrote: »
    yes my gp advised me to concentrate on my chest area as i have lost 3stone to date and wanted to rid the excess fat on the chest area

    Don't take lifting advice from a GP unless they lift. You can't spot reduce.

    A balanced progressive program is best, not one you have made up.
    ok thanks can you suggest a plan for me

    Already did

    starting strength

    stronglift 5x5

    nerd fitness
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    jacksonpt wrote: »
    dst3023 wrote: »
    1133 CALORIES REMAINING, 1700 GOAL, 1667 FOOD, 1100 EXERCISE = 567 NET

    I rounded.

    Thanks I see now what would you suggest
  • dst3023
    dst3023 Posts: 65 Member
    dst3023 wrote: »
    dst3023 wrote: »
    yes my gp advised me to concentrate on my chest area as i have lost 3stone to date and wanted to rid the excess fat on the chest area

    Don't take lifting advice from a GP unless they lift. You can't spot reduce.

    A balanced progressive program is best, not one you have made up.
    ok thanks can you suggest a plan for me

    Already did

    starting strength

    stronglift 5x5

    nerd fitness
    Thanks
This discussion has been closed.