Why am i not losing weight, is my diet wrong, can i eat what i want as long as i stick in calorie ra

2

Replies

  • wkwebby
    wkwebby Posts: 807 Member
    Do you have any medical conditions? Your food is high in carbs and not much protein. PCOS, diabetes (or prediabetes), or insulin resistance will make it very difficult to lose weight on a carb high diet.
  • esjones12
    esjones12 Posts: 1,363 Member
    edited February 2015
    Just set up MFP correctly and it will give you the correct amount of calories to eat. See here for explanation: http://fit101.org/the-step-by-step-guide-to-losing-weight-with-myfitnesspal/

    Weigh and measure all your food. Stay around your calorie range and the weight should start coming off in a few weeks. If you are doing an hour of decent intensity on a bike you should probably eat some of those calories back, or you will create a large deficit that could lead to fatigue, irritability, hunger, etc. You simply log your approximate burn and then you have more calories to eat! Your deficit is already calculated in, so you can eat those back and still lose weight.

    The important thing is to MEASURE AND LOG ALL YOUR FOOD ACCURATELY.
  • SwankyTomato
    SwankyTomato Posts: 442 Member
    because when i was pregnant i use to eat loads because i was hungry and now im left overweight. it is big on my frame, but i think your right maybe im eating more than i think because i dont weigh my food or anything. i just try and make rough estimates.

    There is your issue. You have to buy a food scale and weigh in GRAMS.

  • dalhectar
    dalhectar Posts: 52 Member
    An alternative to weighing food, especially if you tend to eat prepackaged food, is to guess your portion size as a percentage of the container. I might not know how many ounces of chicken I eat, but I know that I bought 7.5 pounds of Chicken breast at Costco divided into 6 packages and ate half of a package, so I put in .625 pounds of chicken.

    You might not know how much pasta in grams you ate, but if you ate half a box you can put that in.
  • PurpleTina
    PurpleTina Posts: 390 Member
    tea
    chicken, potatoes, veg - 277

    agreed, it could be accurate; but then if it was a baked potato measuring 3-4" that would be nearly 300 cals, without adding the chicken.

    Lots of useful info from everyone here OP; I think the message 'weigh your food' is really consistent, and the only way to track things properly.
  • Hannahjane123456
    Hannahjane123456 Posts: 116 Member
    a better get myself a scale then
  • Hannahjane123456
    Hannahjane123456 Posts: 116 Member
    so hopefully if i eat about 1400 calories and weigh everything and do my exercising i should see results
  • DemoraFairy
    DemoraFairy Posts: 1,806 Member
    PurpleTina wrote: »
    tea
    chicken, potatoes, veg - 277

    agreed, it could be accurate; but then if it was a baked potato measuring 3-4" that would be nearly 300 cals, without adding the chicken.

    I know, which is why I said it was a quick guess. I went with the lowest calories for each thing I could find to show it could be achieved in 1500 calories, and clearly it can easily be achieved with lots of room to spare. But equally up all the portion sizes a bit and change some of the brands and it could easily go over 1500, and it looks like this is the case! As you say, weighing everything is important.
  • DemoraFairy
    DemoraFairy Posts: 1,806 Member
    so hopefully if i eat about 1400 calories and weigh everything and do my exercising i should see results

    You might as well stick with 1500 calories for now since you may have been eating way more than that. If I were you I'd eat how you were for a day but weigh it all out just to see how much you were eating, knowing your maintenance will be really useful!
  • Liftng4Lis
    Liftng4Lis Posts: 15,151 Member
    because when i was pregnant i use to eat loads because i was hungry and now im left overweight. it is big on my frame, but i think your right maybe im eating more than i think because i dont weigh my food or anything. i just try and make rough estimates.

    Here you go
  • QuilterInVA
    QuilterInVA Posts: 672 Member
    Rough estimates don't work. Get a scale and measure all your food. If you aren't losing, your are eating too much.
  • berlynnwall
    berlynnwall Posts: 669 Member
    How long have you been doing this without losing? It doesn't matter what you eat, as long as you're in your calorie range (though what you eat can affect fluctuations, so you have to track the overall trend). Are you weighing everything? Do you eat back your exercise calories?

    for about 4 weeks and i weigh myself everyday and the scale just keeps sticking between 147 and 150 pounds. i just try to stick to the set amount 1500 calories a day, i dont understand the eating back thing.

    do u think i should cut my calories down?

    i had a baby 9 weeks ago so could this not be affecting it?


    Some women see hormone fluctuations for quite a while after having a baby, and that can affect weight loss. I know how frustrating it can be trying to lose pregnancy weight, but your baby is still very young and I think you should focus more on taking care of yourself* and your child. A lot of women find that it takes about a year to get back to pre- baby weight, and that makes sense because it took about a year to put the weight on.

    * what I mean by that is not that you shouldn't exercise, but that you could maybe stand to eat more nutritious food,and cut back a little of the workouts.
  • SwankyTomato
    SwankyTomato Posts: 442 Member
    edited February 2015
    PurpleTina wrote: »
    agreed, it could be accurate; but then if it was a baked potato measuring 3-4" that would be nearly 300 cals, without adding the chicken.

    Lots of useful info from everyone here OP; I think the message 'weigh your food' is really consistent, and the only way to track things properly.

    The last potato I ate was 500 grams and then I added sour cream, lol.

    Unless you weigh those suckers you have no idea the calorie count.




  • LovingLife_Erin
    LovingLife_Erin Posts: 328 Member
    Did you say you also had a baby 9 weeks ago? Your body might need time to adjust. If you're breastfeeding then you might want to adjust your calories for that as well to make sure you have enough calories for milk production. Honestly, weigh your food, log, and don't stress if all the baby weight doesn't come off right away... Let your body adjust.
  • HeySwoleSister
    HeySwoleSister Posts: 1,938 Member
    9 weeks postpartum, you are still losing a lot of the weight you gained naturally during pregnancy. Drink LOTS of water, there is a good deal of fluid weight put on during pregnancy, and if you are breastfeeding, you especially need to stay hydrated.

    And, just so you know, my starting weight was 145, and I'm quite a bit taller than you. I've only been eating 1300 per day. Now, I'm quite a bit OLDER than you, too, so my TDEE is also lower, but I do think 1500 sounds high...UNLESS you are breastfeeding on demand (that means whenever baby wants, no schedule, no skipping night feedings), in which case, 1500 is probably not enough.
  • angela3333
    angela3333 Posts: 1 Member
    Ok, i am sorry you cannot out train a bad diet. You cannot eat anything you want and lose fat/weight. Eating clean is a must and eliminate foods high in sodium, fat, processed foods, etc. Protein, carbs and fat are a necessity at the percentages recommended for your body type. Nutrition is 90% of losing weight and exercise is essential in maintaining your lean mass and aiding in losing weight.
  • brianpperkins
    brianpperkins Posts: 6,124 Member
    angela3333 wrote: »
    Ok, i am sorry you cannot out train a bad diet. You cannot eat anything you want and lose fat/weight. Eating clean is a must and eliminate foods high in sodium, fat, processed foods, etc. Protein, carbs and fat are a necessity at the percentages recommended for your body type. Nutrition is 90% of losing weight and exercise is essential in maintaining your lean mass and aiding in losing weight.

    Yet people have lost weight on Twinkie diets when calories are controlled.

    CICO is 100% of losing weight.
  • janejellyroll
    janejellyroll Posts: 25,763 Member
    angela3333 wrote: »
    Ok, i am sorry you cannot out train a bad diet. You cannot eat anything you want and lose fat/weight. Eating clean is a must and eliminate foods high in sodium, fat, processed foods, etc. Protein, carbs and fat are a necessity at the percentages recommended for your body type. Nutrition is 90% of losing weight and exercise is essential in maintaining your lean mass and aiding in losing weight.

    Are you saying that if I eat at a calorie deficit, but foods high in fat or processed foods are in my diet, I will not lose weight? That doesn't seem logical.
  • DemoraFairy
    DemoraFairy Posts: 1,806 Member
    angela3333 wrote: »
    Ok, i am sorry you cannot out train a bad diet. You cannot eat anything you want and lose fat/weight. Eating clean is a must and eliminate foods high in sodium, fat, processed foods, etc. Protein, carbs and fat are a necessity at the percentages recommended for your body type. Nutrition is 90% of losing weight and exercise is essential in maintaining your lean mass and aiding in losing weight.

    So have you just ignored the people that say they've lost weight eating processed, unhealthy foods, or do you not believe them?
  • PeachyCarol
    PeachyCarol Posts: 8,029 Member
    angela3333 wrote: »
    Ok, i am sorry you cannot out train a bad diet. You cannot eat anything you want and lose fat/weight. Eating clean is a must and eliminate foods high in sodium, fat, processed foods, etc. Protein, carbs and fat are a necessity at the percentages recommended for your body type. Nutrition is 90% of losing weight and exercise is essential in maintaining your lean mass and aiding in losing weight.

    Nope. A calorie deficit is all that is needed to lose weight. Dietary make-up will go towards body composition, nutrition, and satiety.

    What the heck is eating "clean" anyway?

    Moderate intake of anything in the context of an overall well-balanced diet that restricts calories such that a person is running at a caloric deficit will result in weight loss.

  • This content has been removed.
  • mburgess458
    mburgess458 Posts: 480 Member
    angela3333 wrote: »
    Ok, i am sorry you cannot out train a bad diet. You cannot eat anything you want and lose fat/weight. Eating clean is a must and eliminate foods high in sodium, fat, processed foods, etc. Protein, carbs and fat are a necessity at the percentages recommended for your body type. Nutrition is 90% of losing weight and exercise is essential in maintaining your lean mass and aiding in losing weight.

    The first sentence is correct. You can't out train a diet in which you're over eating. It's really easy to eat thousands of calories and virtually impossible to train enough to burn thousands of calories.

    As others have said, the rest of your post if bro-science crap.
  • marissafit06
    marissafit06 Posts: 1,996 Member
    Did you say you also had a baby 9 weeks ago? Your body might need time to adjust. If you're breastfeeding then you might want to adjust your calories for that as well to make sure you have enough calories for milk production. Honestly, weigh your food, log, and don't stress if all the baby weight doesn't come off right away... Let your body adjust.

    This. If you are breastfeeding it can be difficult to lose weight. If you are bf, you should be mindful of what you are eating and make sure it is enough to sustain you and baby. Even at your height if you are breastfeeding/pumping you are probably not eating enough.
  • honkytonks85
    honkytonks85 Posts: 669 Member
    Are you measuring everything? Are you logging every last thing you put in your mouth (eg drinks). Are you guessing calories burned while exercising or are you using a HRM?
  • honkytonks85
    honkytonks85 Posts: 669 Member
    I have lost weight purely on a deficit. I do NOT rule out any particular foods (I eat processed foods) and I don't worry about carbs at all.

    I have lost 143 lbs / 65 kg with this method.
  • abarriere
    abarriere Posts: 135 Member
    Everyone is different post baby. Some people the weight comes off easily. Some people hold onto the weight. There are many hormonal factors going on right now. I would just try to be healthy, be active, and enjoy your little one, as they are only little for such a short time. Revisit in a few months when your hormona level out. It has taken a year for me for the weight to start coming off, apart from the initial baby weight loss
  • Hannahjane123456
    Hannahjane123456 Posts: 116 Member
    How long have you been doing this without losing? It doesn't matter what you eat, as long as you're in your calorie range (though what you eat can affect fluctuations, so you have to track the overall trend). Are you weighing everything? Do you eat back your exercise calories?

    for about 4 weeks and i weigh myself everyday and the scale just keeps sticking between 147 and 150 pounds. i just try to stick to the set amount 1500 calories a day, i dont understand the eating back thing.

    do u think i should cut my calories down?

    i had a baby 9 weeks ago so could this not be affecting it?


    Some women see hormone fluctuations for quite a while after having a baby, and that can affect weight loss. I know how frustrating it can be trying to lose pregnancy weight, but your baby is still very young and I think you should focus more on taking care of yourself* and your child. A lot of women find that it takes about a year to get back to pre- baby weight, and that makes sense because it took about a year to put the weight on.

    * what I mean by that is not that you shouldn't exercise, but that you could maybe stand to eat more nutritious food,and cut back a little of the workouts.

    How would I know if I'm having hormone fluctches?
  • Hannahjane123456
    Hannahjane123456 Posts: 116 Member
    I'm not breast feeding but I know my breast still leek a bit sometimes
  • does it matter with all the exercising though, because ive read on the internet if u dont eat back your calories u wont lose weight and your body will go into starvation mode.

  • So u have to eat the calories u burned? Not understanding this?
This discussion has been closed.