100 lbs in six months
Replies
-
Nice work on the weight loss, but I do have a caution.
You generally eat 1000-1400 calories per day. That's not nearly enough to hit your body's various needs. In general people rebound and gain weight because extreme dieting reduces their lean body mass. I hope you will consider increasing your calorie intake for the sake of your health.
He's dr supervised, as I am on 1100 a day. He def should follow his dr's advice.
0 -
TavistockToad wrote: »snowflake930 wrote: »TavistockToad wrote: »tryitonemoretime wrote: »tryitonemoretime wrote: »What do you do?
100 lbs in 6 months is too much
Most likely you will gain it back
What makes you say that? If OP is eating at a calorie deficit or maintaining calories he should have no problem keeping it off.
Everybody who lose weight will gain it all the weight back, and more
Some gain it fast, others gain it in longer period of time. Especially when you lose too soon, youll gain it soon too.
:laugh:
while a high percentage of people DO gain weight back, not everyone does...
Are you hangry by any chance?
The actual statistics show that a very high percentage of people gain the weight back, no matter how they lost the weight.
Losing weight is a difficult thing to do, for all of us, no matter how much we have to lose.
Keeping the weight off, for over 5 years is even harder to do.
Losing the weight is a very big deal!
Congrats again!
is that not what i said!? :huh:
Sorry, I did not mean you. I meant the quote from "tryitonemoretime".
I agree with what you said. I apologize to you and the OP
0 -
tryitonemoretime wrote: »tryitonemoretime wrote: »What do you do?
100 lbs in 6 months is too much
Most likely you will gain it back
What makes you say that? If OP is eating at a calorie deficit or maintaining calories he should have no problem keeping it off.
Everybody who lose weight will gain it all the weight back, and more
Some gain it fast, others gain it in longer period of time. Especially when you lose too soon, youll gain it soon too.
I think tryingitonemoretime should probably give up because with that attitude, why bother. I have lost and maintained a 260 lb weight loss for the past 4 years. The only way you gain it back is to stop paying attention to what you are eating and decrease your activity. However, its not inevitable that you will do that. You have done an awesome job, keep up the good work and stay focused. Ignore negative people (who probably haven't learned how to maintain- if they even got to goal, which is doubtful with a piss poor attitude- so turn bitter and try to drag everyone down with them). BTW I also haven't had a drink in 7 years, a cigarette in 9.
0 -
Nice work on the weight loss, but I do have a caution.
You generally eat 1000-1400 calories per day. That's not nearly enough to hit your body's various needs. In general people rebound and gain weight because extreme dieting reduces their lean body mass. I hope you will consider increasing your calorie intake for the sake of your health.
He's dr supervised, as I am on 1100 a day. He def should follow his dr's advice.
Agreed. A lot of people on MFP seem to think that they are qualified to tell random people on the internet how they should go about eating and exercising.0 -
jkestens63 wrote: »tryitonemoretime wrote: »tryitonemoretime wrote: »What do you do?
100 lbs in 6 months is too much
Most likely you will gain it back
What makes you say that? If OP is eating at a calorie deficit or maintaining calories he should have no problem keeping it off.
Everybody who lose weight will gain it all the weight back, and more
Some gain it fast, others gain it in longer period of time. Especially when you lose too soon, youll gain it soon too.
I think tryingitonemoretime should probably give up because with that attitude, why bother. I have lost and maintained a 260 lb weight loss for the past 4 years. The only way you gain it back is to stop paying attention to what you are eating and decrease your activity. However, its not inevitable that you will do that. You have done an awesome job, keep up the good work and stay focused. Ignore negative people (who probably haven't learned how to maintain- if they even got to goal, which is doubtful with a piss poor attitude- so turn bitter and try to drag everyone down with them). BTW I also haven't had a drink in 7 years, a cigarette in 9.
^^This X10!
And congratulations to you jkestens63, on your amazing accomplishment and dedication. It takes a huge commitment to maintain! Well done!
0 -
I am so proud of you. My personal trainer had a man that lost 100 pounds in six months. I know you put in a lot of hard work and restraint on food cravings. I have lost 26 pounds since January 19 so I am trying to catch up with you.0
-
Nice work on the weight loss, but I do have a caution.
You generally eat 1000-1400 calories per day. That's not nearly enough to hit your body's various needs. In general people rebound and gain weight because extreme dieting reduces their lean body mass. I hope you will consider increasing your calorie intake for the sake of your health.
He's dr supervised, as I am on 1100 a day. He def should follow his dr's advice.
Nowhere in his profile or in the OP does he say that he's on a doctor supervised 1200 calorie diet. I also know that the nutritional training for most doctors is not very much. As I said, I was concerned his body's needs are not being met and that he is losing lean mass (which will reduce his BMR). This extends to others who want his type of success and are not being monitored by a doctor, but see his post and follow what he is doing.0 -
Never change MFP.... never change.-1
-
I ve seen so many people losing 100+ lbs and came back again after 1-2 years.
Congrattdfgggghh-3 -
tryitonemoretime wrote: »tryitonemoretime wrote: »What do you do?
100 lbs in 6 months is too much
Most likely you will gain it back
What makes you say that? If OP is eating at a calorie deficit or maintaining calories he should have no problem keeping it off.
Everybody who lose weight will gain it all the weight back, and more
Some gain it fast, others gain it in longer period of time. Especially when you lose too soon, youll gain it soon too.
Srsly? too bad you've lost hope. can't help you with thattryitonemoretime wrote: »I ve seen so many people losing 100+ lbs and came back again after 1-2 years.
Congrattdfgggghh
Because they were on a diet not a lifestyle change.
C'mon be optimistic!0 -
Nice work on the weight loss, but I do have a caution.
You generally eat 1000-1400 calories per day. That's not nearly enough to hit your body's various needs. In general people rebound and gain weight because extreme dieting reduces their lean body mass. I hope you will consider increasing your calorie intake for the sake of your health.
He's dr supervised, as I am on 1100 a day. He def should follow his dr's advice.
Agreed. A lot of people on MFP seem to think that they are qualified to tell random people on the internet how they should go about eating and exercising.
Well, really, it's not difficult to understand the more or less general rules of TDEE and weight loss. Outside of medical conditions, it's the same. You don't need to be a doctor to understand the safety and/or danger associated with different forms of weight loss. Appeals to authority are good in some ways, but also a logical fallacy in other ways, too.
And I'm sure people talking about OP's calorie goal were doing so out of concern. Many people don't understand how their bodies lose weight and end up eating far less than they should. Without other info, no one had any reason to suspect this might not have been the case for OP.0 -
tryitonemoretime wrote: »I ve seen so many people losing 100+ lbs and came back again after 1-2 years.
Congrattdfgggghh
uhhh?
0 -
tryitonemoretime wrote: »I ve seen so many people losing 100+ lbs and came back again after 1-2 years.
Congrattdfgggghh
yourself included presumably?0 -
Also to the judgemental commenters - you didn't bother to read this man's history and all of his health issues - maybe then it would make more sense to you. Please get the facts before making judgement about other's weight loss journeys. They aren't all the same - we aren't all in the same boat. I'm betting he has the support of physicians and nutritionists considering his health history!0
-
so awesome! congrats!0
-
hezemakiah wrote: »Also to the judgemental commenters - you didn't bother to read this man's history and all of his health issues - maybe then it would make more sense to you. Please get the facts before making judgement about other's weight loss journeys. They aren't all the same - we aren't all in the same boat. I'm betting he has the support of physicians and nutritionists considering his health history!
I have seen only one commenter make a judgmental comment: that OP would regain it all. She seems to have been thoroughly disagreed with by all.
But as you pluralized judgmental 'commenters,' I'd add: his history and health issues weren't shared... so how would anyone know otherwise unless they did some digging? It would have been very helpful for OP to express, "I did some more extreme measures under medical supervision, but here I am!"
I would add, though, that one of your earlier comments in the thread ("No matter how you've done it you've done it") is downright dangerous. There is a reason doctors are heavily involved when an extreme weight loss plan is put into place; it's because there are still negative side-effects, but they see the quick weight loss as more pivotal than doing it slower for that particular person.0 -
hezemakiah wrote: »Also to the judgemental commenters - you didn't bother to read this man's history and all of his health issues - maybe then it would make more sense to you. Please get the facts before making judgement about other's weight loss journeys. They aren't all the same - we aren't all in the same boat. I'm betting he has the support of physicians and nutritionists considering his health history!
Therein lies the problem.0 -
tinascar2015 wrote: »Wow, well done you! What an amazing transformation! You are one very handsome man, if I might say. And I'm guessing you're not totally disabled anymore? What is your cardiolgist saying now?
Thank you for the compliments. My Cardiologist is very proud of me. My heart is much much better and yes I am under his care. He has reduced my carvedilol to the lowest level and he is considering reducing my afib medicine but that will require hospital monitoring. My lasix (80mg/day) is half what it used to be. I am very health conscious now and follow the DASH diet which I view as a life long diet. If you see in my diary any references to Daddy's Own, it means that I made my own recipe without salt.0 -
Thank you for the compliments. My Cardiologist is very proud of me. My heart is much much better and yes I am under his care. He has reduced my carvedilol to the lowest level and he is considering reducing my afib medicine but that will require hospital monitoring. My lasix (80mg/day) is half what it used to be. I am very health conscious now and follow the DASH diet which I view as a life long diet. If you see in my diary any references to Daddy's Own, it means that I made my own recipe without salt.
Happy to hear! Great job and best of luck on your continued journey to better health!! 0 -
we should all just focus on this man's accomplishment... stop quoting and dragging the drama on.0
-
OP = Good for YOU!!! poo poo to all the naysayers... and O-H-I-O for good measure =P0
-
great job0
-
Great job!0
-
Mr. Potts, I think you have done a fabulous job! I know this could not have been easy for you, especially with your serious health conditions. And yet, here you are, making your own recipes, and now, even getting in some exercise. You are an inspiration to me and I will remember your story on my lowest days when I struggle to move or to make a healthy meal. Many, many best wishes to you!0
-
Awesome job!0
-
I would add, though, that one of your earlier comments in the thread ("No matter how you've done it you've done it") is downright dangerous. [/quote]
Why? His daily calories are between 1200 to 1400. While very low it's not super extreme. It's possible that with changes of macros that he might have gotten more nutrients out of this diet than his past higher calorie version. I am willing to bet that a.) his medical tests are far better and b.) he feeling far better. I have never heard of any deaths of people losing a lot of weight in a short time except maybe the surgeries. I think that the "anything greater than the 1-2 pounds per week is dangerous" is right up there with the food pyramid and world is flat logic.0 -
Nice work on the weight loss, but I do have a caution.
You generally eat 1000-1400 calories per day. That's not nearly enough to hit your body's various needs. In general people rebound and gain weight because extreme dieting reduces their lean body mass. I hope you will consider increasing your calorie intake for the sake of your health.
He's dr supervised, as I am on 1100 a day. He def should follow his dr's advice.
Nowhere in his profile or in the OP does he say that he's on a doctor supervised 1200 calorie diet. I also know that the nutritional training for most doctors is not very much. As I said, I was concerned his body's needs are not being met and that he is losing lean mass (which will reduce his BMR). This extends to others who want his type of success and are not being monitored by a doctor, but see his post and follow what he is doing.
Read the About Me on his profile0 -
Nice work on the weight loss, but I do have a caution.
You generally eat 1000-1400 calories per day. That's not nearly enough to hit your body's various needs. In general people rebound and gain weight because extreme dieting reduces their lean body mass. I hope you will consider increasing your calorie intake for the sake of your health.
He's dr supervised, as I am on 1100 a day. He def should follow his dr's advice.
Nowhere in his profile or in the OP does he say that he's on a doctor supervised 1200 calorie diet. I also know that the nutritional training for most doctors is not very much. As I said, I was concerned his body's needs are not being met and that he is losing lean mass (which will reduce his BMR). This extends to others who want his type of success and are not being monitored by a doctor, but see his post and follow what he is doing.
Read the About Me on his profile
Right. It doesn't say that. YOU read it. Read what it actually says - not what you think he means.0 -
Nice work on the weight loss, but I do have a caution.
You generally eat 1000-1400 calories per day. That's not nearly enough to hit your body's various needs. In general people rebound and gain weight because extreme dieting reduces their lean body mass. I hope you will consider increasing your calorie intake for the sake of your health.
He's dr supervised, as I am on 1100 a day. He def should follow his dr's advice.
Nowhere in his profile or in the OP does he say that he's on a doctor supervised 1200 calorie diet. I also know that the nutritional training for most doctors is not very much. As I said, I was concerned his body's needs are not being met and that he is losing lean mass (which will reduce his BMR). This extends to others who want his type of success and are not being monitored by a doctor, but see his post and follow what he is doing.
Read the About Me on his profile
I did. You go back and read it again. It does not specifically state that the doctor told him to eat 1200 calories. I can copy and paste it all here if you would like.0 -
Nice work on the weight loss, but I do have a caution.
You generally eat 1000-1400 calories per day. That's not nearly enough to hit your body's various needs. In general people rebound and gain weight because extreme dieting reduces their lean body mass. I hope you will consider increasing your calorie intake for the sake of your health.
He's dr supervised, as I am on 1100 a day. He def should follow his dr's advice.
Nowhere in his profile or in the OP does he say that he's on a doctor supervised 1200 calorie diet. I also know that the nutritional training for most doctors is not very much. As I said, I was concerned his body's needs are not being met and that he is losing lean mass (which will reduce his BMR). This extends to others who want his type of success and are not being monitored by a doctor, but see his post and follow what he is doing.
Read the About Me on his profile
I skipped all the stuff leading up to his weight gain. Please bold the part where his doctor told him to eat 1200 calories.
Well, I got so bad that I couldn't walk at the grocery store, I couldn't get my breath and I was huffing and puffing and sweating after every activity. That is when I weighed 342 lbs and I am only 5'8". They admitted me into the hospital on Sept 8, 2014 and they took almost 20 lbs of fluid off of me in 5 days. I felt a lot better!!! I committed to getting healthy.
I searched my nutrition books and the stores and found that the only thing I could conveniently eat that was low sodium and had good potassium levels were fruits and vegetables. Now mind you, I hated fruits and vegetables. So I loaded the kitchen table and fridge with them. I ate things I never dreamed of, mangoes, papayas, pomegranates, persimmons (the fruit of the gods) and developed an extreme liking for them all. There is nothing better when you're thirsty than a juicy tomato from the fridge or a cucumber or an orange, or a better breakfast than an avocado, banana, apple and orange. I jokingly tell people that I eat like a gorilla now. To be more correct, I eat very similarly to the DASH diet, a heart healthy diet.
I wrote down everything I ate and drank, weighed myself daily and measured my urine output. I ate all that I wanted and was never ever hungry. I watched my fluid output and only drank enough to replenish my fluids. I took lots of medicines for my heart and water weight. Well the pounds started to come off fast. As I said I have lost 68 lbs and avg 0.75 lbs a day. I found myself a phone app that graphed my daily weights. It let me add my weights retroactively and provided a trend analysis line so that I could predict when I will reach my goal. That is fun. I decided that I would eat this way for the rest of my life, adding a daily meat serving of course.
My doctors changed my medicine a couple times which required two more hospital stays. I soon felt better and better and cleaned up my old dishes and started cooking again. It became necessary to calculate my recipes and portions so Self Magazine Nutrition and My Fitness Pal fit the bill. I found a phone app called Monitor Your Weight that analyzes weight loss and provided a trend analysis so I can predict my weight loss. So, now I am having a lot of fun creating low-salt, high-potassium recipes and recording everything that I eat. I invested in a kitchen scale and for no more than $18 it became another life changer.
Now armed with my heart pills, my top of the line bathroom scales, my graphing weight loss app called Monitor Your Weight, my new kitchen scales, My Fitness Pal, the Self Nutrition Data site and my recumbent exercise bike, I feel that I am in complete control. Next step is to incorporate exercise!!!0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions
Do you Love MyFitnessPal? Have you crushed a goal or improved your life through better nutrition using MyFitnessPal?
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!
Share your success and inspire others. Leave us a review on Apple Or Google Play stores!