Low carb
laurengilbert08
Posts: 22 Member
I'm trying to do low carb high protien/ fat. Is this the best way for weight loss? What are the best macros???
0
Replies
-
Low carb works in the same way any diet works...it puts you into an energy deficit. There's nothing magical about going low carb....carbs don't make you fat.
There are certain metabolic health conditions for which going low carb can be beneficial...but outside of that, it's not necessary.
Also, there is no one size fits all macro ratio. If you do low carb I would recommend low carb high fat, moderate . Low carb is generally less than 100 grams.0 -
The best way to lose weight is just eat at a calorie deficit. All these fads such as low carb etc are is another way of creating a deficit. If you are able to eat like that long term that's fine. Everyone is different so just find a method of eating that is sustainable for you. For a lot of people low carb is very difficult to sustain (despite what the Fanboys/girls say) but if you think you can eat like that long term give it a go or you could just eat normal foods just less of it by using MFP to accurately track your calories. (Remember to weigh all solids and measure liquids)0
-
Ive lost 7 stone in 2 years but I now think I need to tone up and build lean muscel but also still loose! I'm so confused! It takes over your life!0
-
I could never eat low carb. I eat between 250-350gr of carbs/day on about 1850-1950 cals maintaining on goal wt at 119 5'6". If you like higher protein foods then go for it. What gets me is people force feeding themselves nasty protein shakes and eating foods they don't like because they "have" to hit MFP protein goals. I usually get about 1/2-2/3 of the protein goal on MFP. I do not like too many high density protein foods because I feel more "weighed down" so to speak, but everything I eat has protein. Fruits and veggies have protein! There is no reason to choose a cheese stick over an apple because you "need" more protein...unless you just prefer the cheese stick. Just eat at a calorie deficit of foods you enjoy that make you feel energetic. That is the best way to do a lifestyle change.0
-
laurengilbert08 wrote: »Ive lost 7 stone in 2 years but I now think I need to tone up and build lean muscel but also still loose! I'm so confused! It takes over your life!
You are overthinking it if it's taking over your life.
Eat well. If you are near your goal weight, eat at a SMALL deficit. You should be losing VERY slowly as you get closer to your maintenance weight, so that when you get there, you'll barely notice a change in your eating.
If you want to preserve your muscle and be more fit, add protein to your diet and exercise to your life. Carbohydrates are good for energy, they don't "make you fat" or any such nonsense. Protein will help preserve muscle mass, exercise will help you be fit. That's all.
0 -
Low carb has been shown in case studies, that people lose more fat on the same calorie diets than a low fat diet. However, that can mainly be attributed to water weight in a lot of cases. Low carb however does have that added benefit of aiding a lot of other issues with excessive weight, such as blood sugar and blood pressure. There is also added cognitive gains, when choosing to fuel your brains with ketones instead of glucose. It has also been shown to help prevent neuron degradation, especially in neurological disease cases. It is effective in treating diabetes, bipolar, epilepsy, Parkinson's, and Alzheimer's. Most keto dieters will use the paleo diet, which most doctors will prefer with going on a whole food paleo diet, instead of eating processed foods. However, it is very important to keep up on Electrolytes and make sure you get plenty of Potassium, as you liver will require more to function in a low carb diet.
If choosing low carb, it should not just for weight loss, but the other added health benefits as well. Try researching in to an ketosis diet, but also speak with your doctor.0 -
Low carb has been shown in case studies, that people lose more fat on the same calorie diets than a low fat diet. However, that can mainly be attributed to water weight in a lot of cases. Low carb however does have that added benefit of aiding a lot of other issues with excessive weight, such as blood sugar and blood pressure. There is also added cognitive gains, when choosing to fuel your brains with ketones instead of glucose. It has also been shown to help prevent neuron degradation, especially in neurological disease cases. It is effective in treating diabetes, bipolar, epilepsy, Parkinson's, and Alzheimer's. Most keto dieters will use the paleo diet, which most doctors will prefer with going on a whole food paleo diet, instead of eating processed foods. However, it is very important to keep up on Electrolytes and make sure you get plenty of Potassium, as you liver will require more to function in a low carb diet.
If choosing low carb, it should not just for weight loss, but the other added health benefits as well. Try researching in to an ketosis diet, but also speak with your doctor.
Link to studies please0 -
Low carb however does have that added benefit of aiding a lot of other issues with excessive weight, such as blood sugar and blood pressure. There is also added cognitive gains, when choosing to fuel your brains with ketones instead of glucose. It has also been shown to help prevent neuron degradation, especially in neurological disease cases.
I respectfully disagree as not to confuse the OP. I eat what most people here would call a 'high carb' diet of mainly fruits, veggies, legumes, and whole grains. This has not contributed to high blood pressure. In fact, it is perfect, my triglycerides from fasting blood sugar are perfect, my good cholesterol is in the 70's; my ratio is 2.3. Every single health stat I had taken a few weeks ago is absolutely perfect. Do not confuse the OP by saying that a higher carb ratio is a path to all these diseases you mention.0 -
For me, yes it was / is the best way.
If you eat fewer calories than you eat, you will lose weight. The keys for me to hitting those calorie goals are portion control, fitness (heavy lifting & slow uphill climbs), frequent small meals & snacks, and I limit my carbs.
The last two items leave me feeling satiated much of the day which helps me control my eating.
I shoot for 100g of carbs per day but if you consistently hit below 135g then you get the benefits of a mild keto. I do not worry too much about hitting my protein goal. I do what I can to try to reach it without using protein bars & shakes in excess.
0 -
laurengilbert08 wrote: »Ive lost 7 stone in 2 years but I now think I need to tone up and build lean muscel but also still loose! I'm so confused! It takes over your life!
Bottom line: If you eat fewer calories than you ingest you will lose weight. If you lift heavy weights you will build or maintain muscle.
That said, there are plenty of studies that show that one group of low carb and other not, both groups lost the same WEIGHT, but the low carb group lost more FAT and maintained or gained more muscle. Obese people tended to gain "significant" muscle.
Young lean weightlifters and anyone into endurance sports like running, swimming, biking need alot of carbs. Obese or overweight people benefit alot from low carb.0 -
Deficit.
Also, I'd like to see the links to said studies showing benefits in regards to neurological issues, please.0 -
Deficit.
Also, I'd like to see the links to said studies showing benefits in regards to neurological issues, please.
No kidding.
I have seen some studies that link very low carb diets to depression and sleep disorders, but I don't think they are absolutely conclusive. But, carbohydrates do enhance tryptophan and serotonin production, which both impact sleep and mood, so, who knows?0 -
OP, if you are interested in talking to others who eat low carb, please join us in the Low Carber Daily Forum: http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-lcd-group
As for the benefits re: neurological issues, the book Grain Brain: The Surprising Truth about Wheat, Carbs, and Sugar--Your Brain's Silent Killers by Dr. David Perlmutter addresses those issues pretty well. There is a reason why Alzheimer's is called "type 3 diabetes".0 -
Neurological disorders, like epilepsy, are treated with keto diets under medical supervision. The ketones provide an alternative fuel source for the brain since these disorders can have something to do with glucose metabolism in the brain.Deficit.
Also, I'd like to see the links to said studies showing benefits in regards to neurological issues, please.
0 -
Neurological disorders, like epilepsy, are treated with keto diets under medical supervision. The ketones provide an alternative fuel source for the brain since these disorders can have something to do with glucose metabolism in the brain.Deficit.
Also, I'd like to see the links to said studies showing benefits in regards to neurological issues, please.
True, but it's a leap to take treatment of specific medical disorders and extrapolate to some kind of magical performance in the general population.
(See also: EVERYONE should care about the Glycemic Index!!!!!!)0 -
I don't eat low carb but I do remove most grains from my diet to lose weight... eating mainly vegetables, legumes, quinoa and some fruit, I also don't skimp on fats like EV (extra virgin) coconut oil and EV olive oil I eat alot of seeds that up my omega 3s. I don't eat alot of protein but include a little with every meal.0
-
Neurological disorders, like epilepsy, are treated with keto diets under medical supervision. The ketones provide an alternative fuel source for the brain since these disorders can have something to do with glucose metabolism in the brain.Deficit.
Also, I'd like to see the links to said studies showing benefits in regards to neurological issues, please.
True, but it's a leap to take treatment of specific medical disorders and extrapolate to some kind of magical performance in the general population.
(See also: EVERYONE should care about the Glycemic Index!!!!!!)
Thank you! Agreed.0 -
So a (non-objective) book and a broad statement about medical treatment of a specific disorder.
I would be very interested to read the literature behind the statements made about Parkinson's, and Alzheimer's. There is no snark behind this, I couldn't care less what other people fill their dietary intake with. I am genuinely curious about the science behind the claims made in this thread.0 -
Neurological disorders, like epilepsy, are treated with keto diets under medical supervision. The ketones provide an alternative fuel source for the brain since these disorders can have something to do with glucose metabolism in the brain.Deficit.
Also, I'd like to see the links to said studies showing benefits in regards to neurological issues, please.
True, but it's a leap to take treatment of specific medical disorders and extrapolate to some kind of magical performance in the general population.
(See also: EVERYONE should care about the Glycemic Index!!!!!!)
Amen. I have a relative with gout, a form of arthritis. To avoid bringing on painful inflammation, she has to avoid meat, fish, alcohol, and high fat foods. The gout diet is mostly fruits, vegetables, beans and complex carbohydrates - pretty much the polar opposite of a keto diet. Is it the right diet for her? Absolutely. Is it the right diet for everyone? Nope.
0 -
laurengilbert08 wrote: »I'm trying to do low carb high protien/ fat. Is this the best way for weight loss? What are the best macros???
LCHF would typically be 20 - 25% protein, 5 or 10% carbohydrate, and fat the rest. Protein might be up to 35% of calories. You can set these with "Custom goals" in steps of 5.
0 -
low carb sounds like torture to me
no way in hells beautiful meadow would i do it
basically give me all your potatoes please0 -
I eat low carb, just because it keeps me full and helps me lose weight quickly. I think every body is different. I also have a history of diabetes in my family, so I intend to always eat fairly low carb and low sugar. My macros tend be around 60% fat, 10% carb, and 30% protein.0
-
laurengilbert08 wrote: »I'm trying to do low carb high protien/ fat. Is this the best way for weight loss? What are the best macros???
LCHF would typically be 20 - 25% protein, 5 or 10% carbohydrate, and fat the rest. Protein might be up to 35% of calories. You can set these with "Custom goals" in steps of 5.
I would consider that "very low carb".0 -
I'll just defer to Feinman :
Very low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet (VLCKD)
•Carbohydrate, 20–50 g/d or <10% of the 2000 kcal/d diet, whether or not ketosis occurs. Derived from levels of carbohydrate required to induce ketosis in most people.
•Recommended early phase (“induction”) of popular diets such as Atkins Diet or Protein Power.
Low-carbohydrate diet: <130 g/d or <26% total energy
•The ADA definition of 130 g/d as its recommended minimum.
Moderate-Carbohydrate Diet: 26%–45%
•Upper limit, approximate carbohydrate intake before the obesity epidemic (43%).
High-Carbohydrate Diet: >45%
•Recommended target on ADA websites.
•The 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommends 45%–65% carbohydrate. The average American diet is estimated to be ∼49% carbohydrate.0 -
I'll just defer to Feinman :
Very low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet (VLCKD)
•Carbohydrate, 20–50 g/d or <10% of the 2000 kcal/d diet, whether or not ketosis occurs. Derived from levels of carbohydrate required to induce ketosis in most people.
•Recommended early phase (“induction”) of popular diets such as Atkins Diet or Protein Power.
Low-carbohydrate diet: <130 g/d or <26% total energy
•The ADA definition of 130 g/d as its recommended minimum.
Moderate-Carbohydrate Diet: 26%–45%
•Upper limit, approximate carbohydrate intake before the obesity epidemic (43%).
High-Carbohydrate Diet: >45%
•Recommended target on ADA websites.
•The 2010 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommends 45%–65% carbohydrate. The average American diet is estimated to be ∼49% carbohydrate.
That is what I'm talking about. Sorry, I thought you were saying a LC diet was <10%.
Thanks for posting this.0 -
Study carried out by Stanford University costing 2 million dollars involving 300 women:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eREuZEdMAVo
0 -
Thanks @prasadsurve that was a great video. I watched the first ten minutes and I plan to watch the whole thing later.0
-
I am so this way and im on an extremely low carb *but doctor recommended, so haters can eat it* Low carb is really great when you realize cheese can be low carb. whipped cream cheese is my religion nowsalembambi wrote: »low carb sounds like torture to me
no way in hells beautiful meadow would i do it
basically give me all your potatoes please
its what heaven tastes like
0 -
Look in to calorie cycling first? The idea is eat the same total calories each week ie. if your goal is 1500 a day - 10,500 a week, cycle each day. One day might be 1300, the next 1700 but add up to the same amount each week. The idea is it confuses your body so you don't plateau
-To be honest, I do low carb 5/6 days a week. I eat whatever fruit and vegetables I want but no grains or starches. I think this has had more of an effect than anything, I'm not eating as much sugar therefore not as hungry, bloated or tired. My body does fine on low carb, high protein and fat even with regular training. Everyone has different responses so the only way you'll know is to try
0 -
Nutrition 101: Carbohydrates
by Elle Penner, MyFitnessPal Registered Dietitian
Love ‘em or leave ‘em (personally, I’m a fan), carbohydrates are found in pretty much everything – fruits and vegetables, grains, nuts and seeds, dairy, sweets, soda, the list goes on. Carbohydrates provide around half of the energy in a well balanced diet, 45-65% of calories according to the most recent Dietary Guidelines for Americans0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions