Do you reckon I have IBS?
noobletmcnugget
Posts: 518 Member
Back in September I started living in a house with friends at university. We cook together, which means my diet changed a lot. We eat a lot of vegetables each day - always including onion, mushrooms, broccoli, and often beans (high FODMAP foods), which I don't eat at home.
Ever since then I've experienced pretty severe bloating and gas, and irregular bowel movements, which don't seem to go away.
Do you think cutting out these foods will improve my symptoms? Could they be irritating my bowel? I've read about low FODMAP diets, and was wondering whether you think I'd be able to not completely cut out wheat and lactose (seeing as though I've eaten these my whole life without any serious issues).
Also, I don't really know how to tell my friends I want to cut out these things. We always cook big batches of stuff together, because it works out a lot cheaper that way, and our kitchen is tiny so trying to cook separate meals is a massive hassle.
I'm just so sick of being bloated and feeling uncomfortable.
Advice please!
Ever since then I've experienced pretty severe bloating and gas, and irregular bowel movements, which don't seem to go away.
Do you think cutting out these foods will improve my symptoms? Could they be irritating my bowel? I've read about low FODMAP diets, and was wondering whether you think I'd be able to not completely cut out wheat and lactose (seeing as though I've eaten these my whole life without any serious issues).
Also, I don't really know how to tell my friends I want to cut out these things. We always cook big batches of stuff together, because it works out a lot cheaper that way, and our kitchen is tiny so trying to cook separate meals is a massive hassle.
I'm just so sick of being bloated and feeling uncomfortable.
Advice please!
0
Replies
-
1. If you think they might be causing the issues, try cutting them out
2. I have no idea if you'd be able to cut out wheat and lactose. Many people can, but I don't know you personally. I think if my other options were diarrhea or constipation, I'd manage.
3. Here's your script: "Friends, I think I might be intolerant of these foods: ______________. Would you be willing to try planning meals for the next week without those ingredients so I can test the theory?"
4. Understand that your friends might be willing to do this this, or they may suggest you prepare separate meals for yourself.
5. Whatever their response, handle it gracefully and be prepared to fix your own food if they can't accommodate you.0 -
It could be all the fiber that you now eat (and never did in the past). Have you ever tried Gas-X? It will help with the gas, but the bloating could mean that you are intolerant of something. Try eliminating one veggie at a time. This way you know what you can't eat. Those are all good veggies that you shouldn't just cut out. Bean-O is another medication you can get over the counter. You'll be grateful for adjusting to healthy eating in the long run.0
-
It could be all the fiber that you now eat (and never did in the past). Have you ever tried Gas-X? It will help with the gas, but the bloating could mean that you are intolerant of something. Try eliminating one veggie at a time. This way you know what you can't eat. Those are all good veggies that you shouldn't just cut out. Bean-O is another medication you can get over the counter. You'll be grateful for adjusting to healthy eating in the long run.
Wouldn't I need to cut everything out and then reintroduce, rather than eliminating one by one? I know, I love veggies so it sucks that I might have to cut some of them out really. I'll research those medications! I've always been pretty skeptical about that sort of stuff though. Plus I'd much rather identify trigger foods and just avoid them rather than spend money on long-term meds. Thanks for the reply!
0 -
If you increase your fiber intake via veggies and beans make sure you are also increasing your water intake to help keep things regular. If you didn't eat a lot of veggies before it and you are not super consistent on your intake still, that may be causing the periods of discomfort.
0 -
noobletmcnugget wrote: »It could be all the fiber that you now eat (and never did in the past). Have you ever tried Gas-X? It will help with the gas, but the bloating could mean that you are intolerant of something. Try eliminating one veggie at a time. This way you know what you can't eat. Those are all good veggies that you shouldn't just cut out. Bean-O is another medication you can get over the counter. You'll be grateful for adjusting to healthy eating in the long run.
Wouldn't I need to cut everything out and then reintroduce, rather than eliminating one by one? I know, I love veggies so it sucks that I might have to cut some of them out really. I'll research those medications! I've always been pretty skeptical about that sort of stuff though. Plus I'd much rather identify trigger foods and just avoid them rather than spend money on long-term meds. Thanks for the reply!
Another thought is that if you never ate all of that stuff in the past, your gut may not have the right microbes to handle it. Maybe a course of probiotics would help.0 -
PeachyPlum wrote: »1. If you think they might be causing the issues, try cutting them out
2. I have no idea if you'd be able to cut out wheat and lactose. Many people can, but I don't know you personally. I think if my other options were diarrhea or constipation, I'd manage.
3. Here's your script: "Friends, I think I might be intolerant of these foods: ______________. Would you be willing to try planning meals for the next week without those ingredients so I can test the theory?"
4. Understand that your friends might be willing to do this this, or they may suggest you prepare separate meals for yourself.
5. Whatever their response, handle it gracefully and be prepared to fix your own food if they can't accommodate you.
I don't think I'd find it difficult to cut out wheat and lactose... except form pasta, which is a major staple for me haha. I'll just have to say that to my friends and see what they say. It's not so much preparing my own food I'm worried about, but them being annoyed at me complicating things and the budgeting situation. Thanks for the help
0 -
If you increase your fiber intake via veggies and beans make sure you are also increasing your water intake to help keep things regular. If you didn't eat a lot of veggies before it and you are not super consistent on your intake still, that may be causing the periods of discomfort.
That's what I thought too, but considering I've been eating basically the same diet (with these foods nearly every day) for 8 months I thought things would've leveled out by now. I'm definitely going to try to increase water intake though. Hopefully that'll help. I'm also going to avoid diet drinks and chewing gum with sweeteners (which are high FODMAP) too.0 -
noobletmcnugget wrote: »It could be all the fiber that you now eat (and never did in the past). Have you ever tried Gas-X? It will help with the gas, but the bloating could mean that you are intolerant of something. Try eliminating one veggie at a time. This way you know what you can't eat. Those are all good veggies that you shouldn't just cut out. Bean-O is another medication you can get over the counter. You'll be grateful for adjusting to healthy eating in the long run.
Wouldn't I need to cut everything out and then reintroduce, rather than eliminating one by one? I know, I love veggies so it sucks that I might have to cut some of them out really. I'll research those medications! I've always been pretty skeptical about that sort of stuff though. Plus I'd much rather identify trigger foods and just avoid them rather than spend money on long-term meds. Thanks for the reply!
Another thought is that if you never ate all of that stuff in the past, your gut may not have the right microbes to handle it. Maybe a course of probiotics would help.
I did think that too, and I did research probiotics but I gathered that the general consensus was that there was no conclusive evidence for their effectiveness. Maybe I'll do a bit more research.0 -
I don't have any solution for you, but I just wanted to add that this is an issue for me too. Well, back when I ate very unhealthy, I would get terrible stomach pains & cramps 3-5 times a week. But I was regular. Now I rarely ever get that (maybe twice in the past year), but I'm no longer regular and I do get more gassy. I don't know why, and I don't know how to fix it, but I think the other replies have some good ideas. I'd still prefer this over excruciating stomach cramps from eating any day.0
-
PeachyPlum wrote: »1. If you think they might be causing the issues, try cutting them out
2. I have no idea if you'd be able to cut out wheat and lactose. Many people can, but I don't know you personally. I think if my other options were diarrhea or constipation, I'd manage.
3. Here's your script: "Friends, I think I might be intolerant of these foods: ______________. Would you be willing to try planning meals for the next week without those ingredients so I can test the theory?"
4. Understand that your friends might be willing to do this this, or they may suggest you prepare separate meals for yourself.
5. Whatever their response, handle it gracefully and be prepared to fix your own food if they can't accommodate you.
Oh, also, quick question, do you know how long it takes after elimination to see improvements? Thanks!
0 -
noobletmcnugget wrote: »noobletmcnugget wrote: »It could be all the fiber that you now eat (and never did in the past). Have you ever tried Gas-X? It will help with the gas, but the bloating could mean that you are intolerant of something. Try eliminating one veggie at a time. This way you know what you can't eat. Those are all good veggies that you shouldn't just cut out. Bean-O is another medication you can get over the counter. You'll be grateful for adjusting to healthy eating in the long run.
Wouldn't I need to cut everything out and then reintroduce, rather than eliminating one by one? I know, I love veggies so it sucks that I might have to cut some of them out really. I'll research those medications! I've always been pretty skeptical about that sort of stuff though. Plus I'd much rather identify trigger foods and just avoid them rather than spend money on long-term meds. Thanks for the reply!
Another thought is that if you never ate all of that stuff in the past, your gut may not have the right microbes to handle it. Maybe a course of probiotics would help.
I did think that too, and I did research probiotics but I gathered that the general consensus was that there was no conclusive evidence for their effectiveness. Maybe I'll do a bit more research.
I agree that the science is super new and there isn't a lot to go on - I got an angry belly once from eating some sick oysters, and nothing helped until I did one bottle of probiotics and one box of Pepcid-AC. The symptoms never came back after that. So actually it could have been either/or that worked 0 -
jessieleah wrote: »I don't have any solution for you, but I just wanted to add that this is an issue for me too. Well, back when I ate very unhealthy, I would get terrible stomach pains & cramps 3-5 times a week. But I was regular. Now I rarely ever get that (maybe twice in the past year), but I'm no longer regular and I do get more gassy. I don't know why, and I don't know how to fix it, but I think the other replies have some good ideas. I'd still prefer this over excruciating stomach cramps from eating any day.
Luckily I've never really suffered from abdominal pain or cramping, whether eating healthily or unhealthily. I'm glad you've seen improvement!0 -
This happened to me, and I suggest eliminating everything at once for about 2-3 months, then slowly reintroducing. I cut out everything high in FODMAPs and when I got the okay from my doctor to bring stuff back in, I started with gluten, then lactose. I am now currently eating low fodmap entirely besides gluten and lactose both about 2-3x a week, and I feel about a million times better.0
-
I would try eliminating some foods from my diet, ie dairy, gluten, sugar for a week or so at a time. If no change, I'd consult a doctor. They'll ask if you've eliminated them anyway so you'll have an answer. It may be food related, but sudden onset bowel changes can be a symptom of something more serious. I don't mean to be a downer and it's probably not serious, but if you make changes and your bowels don't, it doesn't hurt to have a professional opinion.0
-
hillarysiegel24 wrote: »This happened to me, and I suggest eliminating everything at once for about 2-3 months, then slowly reintroducing. I cut out everything high in FODMAPs and when I got the okay from my doctor to bring stuff back in, I started with gluten, then lactose. I am now currently eating low fodmap entirely besides gluten and lactose both about 2-3x a week, and I feel about a million times better.
That's reassuring to hear you had success with the elimination method! How long did it take after eliminating to see any improvement? Was it quite quick or did it take the whole 2-3 months? Also, if you reintroduce a food group and you find out it's a trigger, do you have to eliminate everything for 2-3 months again or just until the symptoms subside?
0 -
tanisavelina wrote: »I would try eliminating some foods from my diet, ie dairy, gluten, sugar for a week or so at a time. If no change, I'd consult a doctor. They'll ask if you've eliminated them anyway so you'll have an answer. It may be food related, but sudden onset bowel changes can be a symptom of something more serious. I don't mean to be a downer and it's probably not serious, but if you make changes and your bowels don't, it doesn't hurt to have a professional opinion.
I'll definitely consult a doctor if I do it and don't see any improvements. It's the fact that the onset of symptoms was so close to my change in diet that makes me think it is a dietary thing rather than a serious problem, but I'll definitely look into it if that's not the case.0 -
Maybe you need to bring it up with your friends because there may be a chance they are also experiencing "issues" like you and are too worried to say anything. If that's the case, then you can all just agree to start cooking new foods!0
-
tephanies1234 wrote: »Maybe you need to bring it up with your friends because there may be a chance they are also experiencing "issues" like you and are too worried to say anything. If that's the case, then you can all just agree to start cooking new foods!
It would be good if that happened! I'll have to see I guess.
0 -
Are you using canned beans? I know if I buy dried beans and soak them overnight before cooking them, I don't have any issues. When I eat out or use canned beans it's Russian roulette.
Are you eating raw broccoli and onions? I would try eating them cooked, gets rid of some of the sulfur.
0 -
ClubSilencio wrote: »Are you using canned beans? I know if I buy dried beans and soak them overnight before cooking them, I don't have any issues. When I eat out or use canned beans it's Russian roulette.
Are you eating raw broccoli and onions? I would try eating them cooked, gets rid of some of the sulfur.
Yeah, I always use canned beans. Maybe I'll give dried beans a go.
Nope, I always cook the broccoli and onions. I heard that about the sulfur too.
0 -
I've found the log on MFP to be super helpful with my food intolerances. After I eat something I put a food note if I had any problems afterwards, keeping track of how I felt after each meal helped me pinpoint the most likely causes and have eliminated them completely. So far i'm on my third day of no serious reactions.0
-
noobletmcnugget wrote: »hillarysiegel24 wrote: »This happened to me, and I suggest eliminating everything at once for about 2-3 months, then slowly reintroducing. I cut out everything high in FODMAPs and when I got the okay from my doctor to bring stuff back in, I started with gluten, then lactose. I am now currently eating low fodmap entirely besides gluten and lactose both about 2-3x a week, and I feel about a million times better.
That's reassuring to hear you had success with the elimination method! How long did it take after eliminating to see any improvement? Was it quite quick or did it take the whole 2-3 months? Also, if you reintroduce a food group and you find out it's a trigger, do you have to eliminate everything for 2-3 months again or just until the symptoms subside?
i re-eliminated until symptoms subsided! I have also found that the following medications/supplements help IMMENSELY with symptoms:
-prilosec
-zegerid
-citrucel
-align0 -
I might be reaching here, but are you dehydrated? You posted the other day that you don't think you have to drink water0
-
I might be reaching here, but are you dehydrated? You posted the other day that you don't think you have to drink water
I've been making a conscious effort to drink more since then, with no improvement, but I'll continue doing so. Also, my drinking habits had been like that my entire life. I only started to experience these symptoms in september, as soon as I introduced new foods.0 -
You should see a doctor because IBS symptoms can be indicative of bigger problems. IBS is actually a diagnosis of elimination (they don't find another explanation). Also, if you plan to do an elimination protocol, especially eliminating FODMAPs, see a dietitian. That is pretty intensive elimination and needs to be done right.0
-
Just wanted to say today I avoided eating any onion, broccoli, or mushrooms today and the bloating is SIGNIFICANTLY better than usual, and I don't feel gassy or uncomfortable at all.
I know it might just be due to eating a decreased volume of food, or might just be coincidence, but this gives me hope.
0 -
You need to see a doctor to rule out anything else. A lot of IBD have similar symptoms to ibs like crohns or ulcerative colitis.0
-
I have severe IBS and colitis, I don't find a problem with veggies but definitely with anything too refined like bread, cake etc. And anything fatty like red meats. I think I'm also a little lactose intolerant. I would say Keep away from anything wheat based especially refined ones which release gluten through the process it takes to make it as this sticks to the gut stopping it from working properly. I also take acidophilus probiotic when I'm feeling bad and bloated (feels like I have someone's hands inside me squeezing and twisting my guts). Also try buscopan you can get it over the counter and is a godsend I'd you have IBS as it's a anti-spasmodic. But do speak to your GP, they usually like to check it out just to be sure it's nothing sinister.0
-
I know you may not have a lot of faith in probiotics but I say you give it a try for a month or so and see how you feel. I went with a gastroenterologist and she suggested I do the low fodmap and take probiotics at the same time. I haven't been strictly on that diet but I think what has worked wonders is the probiotics. I had tried some before and nothing would happen and then I tried these called Jarro-Dophilus EPS (I take 2-3 daily) and I've been doing waaaay better. Last night I was even able to drink a beer and felt fine after. I also take an aloe vera concentrate before breakfast, I don't know if you'd like to try that too. Hopefully you try this and it works because just a few months ago I was in your shoes and I felt totally miserable, I feel your pain!0
-
If you increase your fiber intake via veggies and beans make sure you are also increasing your water intake to help keep things regular. If you didn't eat a lot of veggies before it and you are not super consistent on your intake still, that may be causing the periods of discomfort.
I have to second drinking a lot of water when you're increasing your Fiber.
Last week I noticed I was severely constipated & realized it was from too much fiber & protein & not drinking enough water to keep things moving.
I also eat prunes whenever I feel constipated & usually by the next day with the prunes & water I am more regular.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions