People can be so unnerving...
Leana088
Posts: 581 Member
My friend is a shorty like me. Okay a little shorter. I'm 5'2 and she's 5'0. Other than that, we are pretty much the same. I eat 1300-1500 a day depending on if I exercise. But she's only eating 1000-1100 a day and it's, a little unnerving for me. She doesn't exercise at all. She sits around most of the day.
I'm not sure if this is healthy for her, but her diet seems okay-ish to me, if a little boring. I've tried convincing her to eat more, but she says she doesn't need more food and she's convinced she's healthy. This is about what she eats EVERY. SINGLE. DAY.
Breakfast: 1 slice whole wheat toast, half cup cottage cheese with 1 fruit.
AM Snack: 1 rice cake with 1 teaspoon peanut butter
Lunch: 200g chicken breast, boneless skinless flavoured with spices. 250grams mixed vegetables. (She's taken to buying frozen mixed veg like me, the mixes are mostly non-starchy stir fry veg).
PM Snack: Some almonds, not sure how much
Dinner: 200g white fish, pan fried in 1 tablespoon extra light margarine and spices, with 250g mixed vegetables.
This diet kind of seems balanced to me, it's just the quantity that I'm worried about. But I can't convince her to eat more with all the rabbit grub (veggies haha) she's eating because they fill her up. What would you tell her?
Oh, and the quantities above are based on me knowing how many packages of those things she goes through. We buy at the same store, and same brands (we go shopping together).
The devil in me wants to sneak some nutella into her cart sometimes...
I'm not sure if this is healthy for her, but her diet seems okay-ish to me, if a little boring. I've tried convincing her to eat more, but she says she doesn't need more food and she's convinced she's healthy. This is about what she eats EVERY. SINGLE. DAY.
Breakfast: 1 slice whole wheat toast, half cup cottage cheese with 1 fruit.
AM Snack: 1 rice cake with 1 teaspoon peanut butter
Lunch: 200g chicken breast, boneless skinless flavoured with spices. 250grams mixed vegetables. (She's taken to buying frozen mixed veg like me, the mixes are mostly non-starchy stir fry veg).
PM Snack: Some almonds, not sure how much
Dinner: 200g white fish, pan fried in 1 tablespoon extra light margarine and spices, with 250g mixed vegetables.
This diet kind of seems balanced to me, it's just the quantity that I'm worried about. But I can't convince her to eat more with all the rabbit grub (veggies haha) she's eating because they fill her up. What would you tell her?
Oh, and the quantities above are based on me knowing how many packages of those things she goes through. We buy at the same store, and same brands (we go shopping together).
The devil in me wants to sneak some nutella into her cart sometimes...
0
Replies
-
Tell her nothing and tend to yourself. Unless you're with her 24/7, you have no idea what she's eating.0
-
honestly being that short and doing 0 activity she might be a rare case that can get away on that little. though eventually she will probably tire of the lack of variety in her diet. rather than up the calories (unless she starts working out) i would say add some variety. u get different nutrients from different foods0
-
The frustrating part is she's two glasses of milk away from eating the same amount as me, but nope. Stubborn.0
-
Let her take care of her self. Unless she is eating absolutely nothing, it's none of your business0
-
All you can do is share your knowledge. What she does with it is her business. If you do well and enjoy your diet she may want to copy you. If not, it's up to her.0
-
True I guess it isn't my business. Just my kind heart wanting to help...if I had one.0
-
-
I'm a total cardio bunny, but if she has chosen to forgo exercise and the extra calories, that's her choice. I don't believe in VLCDs but I have had very tiny friends eat around 1100 calories and be healthy with it. If you've already said your piece, don't bring it up again. You're her friend, not her mom.0
-
^^^ ThatKaren_libert wrote: »All you can do is share your knowledge. What she does with it is her business. If you do well and enjoy your diet she may want to copy you. If not, it's up to her.
Do your own thing, let her worry about herself, if she asks or comments on it, then give her the benefit of your knowledge and advice. Forcing the issues will just cause issues in your friendship.0 -
I won't say anything. She tried to push it onto me once, and then while looking at her, I ate a cupcake. She looked so disgusted for a while. Lol
0 -
Why am I impressed with her 200g of chicken breast? That woman is serious about her protein haha.
Also seems a lot like my 238g of chicken thigh dinner last night. Also does she use any oil etc to prepare her foods? She could indeed be eating more than the 1000-1100 calories you think she is. Hopefully if she gets bored of her meals, she will add gradually rather than go crazy. The diet base doesn't look too too bad for a tiny, sedentary woman, to me 0 -
Why am I impressed with her 200g of chicken breast? That woman is serious about her protein haha. Also seems a lot like my 238g of chicken thigh dinner last night. Also does she use any oil etc to prepare her foods? She could indeed be eating more than the 1000-1100 calories you think she is. Hopefully if she gets bored of her meals, she will add gradually rather than go crazy. The diet base doesn't look too too bad for a tiny, sedentary woman, to me
I actually, for curiosity purposes, entered her diet into my diary, on my macros. She gave me the "blueprint" for it when she wanted me to try it...
She is actually eating about 1050-1100 a day, and hitting all MY macros, except for fat. Heck she even gets 25g of fibre a day, which I struggle with. And she's getting her 100g of protein a day. She gets about 20g of fat a day. I think...not too sure now. I just remember being impressed with the fibre and protein.0 -
Considering I'm 5 feet tall and MFP has me at 1260 calories a day to lose 0.5lb/week...1100 really isn't too far off depending on what her weight is if she really and truly hardly moves at all.
I played around with this calculator:
https://www.bcm.edu/cnrc-apps/healthyeatingcalculator/eatingCal.html
And at my goal weight of 115, it gives me 1243 calories if I'm pretty much inactive.
So....not really a stretch for her to eat so little, depending on her current weight.
I would leave it alone unless you notice she looks unwell. She seems to be eating nutritious enough stuff so she can't be doing too much harm.
~Lyssa0 -
Why am I impressed with her 200g of chicken breast? That woman is serious about her protein haha. Also seems a lot like my 238g of chicken thigh dinner last night. Also does she use any oil etc to prepare her foods? She could indeed be eating more than the 1000-1100 calories you think she is. Hopefully if she gets bored of her meals, she will add gradually rather than go crazy. The diet base doesn't look too too bad for a tiny, sedentary woman, to me
I actually, for curiosity purposes, entered her diet into my diary, on my macros. She gave me the "blueprint" for it when she wanted me to try it...
She is actually eating about 1050-1100 a day, and hitting all MY macros, except for fat. Heck she even gets 25g of fibre a day, which I struggle with. And she's getting her 100g of protein a day. She gets about 20g of fat a day. I think...not too sure now. I just remember being impressed with the fibre and protein.
Frankly, since you exercise and she doesn't, and we have no idea what her accurately logged day might look like, she might actually be netting more calories than you...
0 -
Unfortunately, us short ladies don't need much to get by... I wish I was a bit taller for so many reasons!
I think she's doing better than most with those calories. Lots of protein in there! Maybe encouraging her to go on a walk would be better. Though, you can't change people
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
As far as minerals and vitamins go, I don't think she'd be too far off. The mixed vegetable packs have a lot of variety. There are different mixes. I use them too, I don't eat as much as she currently does (friggen 500grams of veg a day), I eat about half that a day of those mixes, and my recent blood work came back with no deficiencies.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Unsubscribe...0
-
Yeah, at 5 feet even and sedentary, she's likely meeting her basic nutritional needs. (And I am also WAY impressed at 200 g of chicken breast...I can barely choke down a 100g portion! Sits like a brick in my stomach without satisfying.)
It does look like a diet of sadness to me, but she's old enough to decide that for herself.0 -
Cortneyrenee04 wrote: »Unfortunately, us short ladies don't need much to get by... I wish I was a bit taller for so many reasons!
I think she's doing better than most with those calories. Lots of protein in there! Maybe encouraging her to go on a walk would be better. Though, you can't change people
I also wish I was taller. I'd love to be able to eat 2000 a day and lose.
0 -
HeySwoleSister wrote: »Yeah, at 5 feet even and sedentary, she's likely meeting her basic nutritional needs. (And I am also WAY impressed at 200 g of chicken breast...I can barely choke down a 100g portion! Sits like a brick in my stomach without satisfying.)
It does look like a diet of sadness to me, but she's old enough to decide that for herself.
Actually, if you cook chicken breast fillets in some butter with a good spice mix it tastes nice. I've done it in a protein pinch.
Yeah, she is detached from food. She eats to stay alive and doesn't mind eating bland stuff. I myself would not be able to eat unless it was tasty. I don't eat just for the sake of eating.
0 -
I'm 6'1" and I have 1,850 a day to lose a pound a week, but my activity level are low most days.Cortneyrenee04 wrote: »Unfortunately, us short ladies don't need much to get by... I wish I was a bit taller for so many reasons!
I think she's doing better than most with those calories. Lots of protein in there! Maybe encouraging her to go on a walk would be better. Though, you can't change people
I also wish I was taller. I'd love to be able to eat 2000 a day and lose. 0 -
Why does it matter what and how much your friend is eating? Does she have a medical issue you haven't said that she's ignoring or what?
To me, you're coming off very food policey. So she doesn't eat what you think she eats. Why is that a problem for you?
Off-topic: I'm kinda tired of reading about "us shorties" who can't eat more than 1200 because of shortness. I'm 5'1" and I eat 1800. Height isn't the single thing that makes up how much you can eat and lose weight.0 -
Seriously- it is none of your business. If I knew one of my friends was analyzing everything I ate and posting about it, I would consider them creepy and no longer be friends.0
-
Why does it matter what and how much your friend is eating? Does she have a medical issue you haven't said that she's ignoring or what?
To me, you're coming off very food policey. So she doesn't eat what you think she eats. Why is that a problem for you?
Off-topic: I'm kinda tired of reading about "us shorties" who can't eat more than 1200 because of shortness. I'm 5'1" and I eat 1800. Height isn't the single thing that makes up how much you can eat and lose weight.
I apologise if that's the way I sounded. I was kind of concerned about the amount she's eating and general nutrition.
Off-topic: Obviously not. How much I eat varies from 1300-1500. But this was about her, not me. If I exercised more, I could also live of 1800, but since I can only walk for cardio, that would mean walking an additional hour and a half a day. Never meant to sound sorry for myself. 0 -
Seriously- it is none of your business. If I knew one of my friends was analyzing everything I ate and posting about it, I would consider them creepy and no longer be friends.
Actually it's not really analyzing since she shared the diet with me. But yeah, you're right. Come to think of it, it does sound a bit creepy now.
Guess I wrote it in a moment of panic about her health.0 -
its not your body.
period. end of story.0 -
Liftng4Lis wrote: »Tell her nothing and tend to yourself. Unless you're with her 24/7, you have no idea what she's eating.
This.
Leana, why do you care about your friend's diet?0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions