Coffee While Dieting - Yes, or No???
Replies
-
No, unless you're drinking a lot of calories, which it doesn't sound like you are. I use the same creamer, & while I'm sure it's not "good" for you, it's only like 35 cal. I find that coffee mid-morning & mid-afternoon (between meals) keeps me from being super hungry all day long. 4 cups sounds like a lot to me personally, in terms of caffeine but it's probably what you're used to.0
-
Tall red-eye with splenda and cinnamon every morning. You'll have to fight me to make me let go of my coffee.0
-
I would say reduce or cut it out if you can, (most need it to do desk jobs and stay focused because it alters (and has altered) a person's physiology and psychology (caffeine is listed as a neurotoxin by the EPA)). Coffee being healthy is one of the biggest lies and once a person is hooked, it becomes a life time crutch. Caffeine interferes with the proper operation of many organs and imbalances a person's metabolism (it is a diuretic because the body is doing its best to get the crap out of your body). If you are going to do coffee it is best to at least skip the (processed) sugar as it adds up quickly and is calories (fuel) that the body gladly takes in and must be used. Artificial sweeteners are worse in many ways, not only do they interfere with proper organ function (some actually have been proven to cause permanent damage to various organs) most all artificial sweeteners actually increase hunger beyond willpower including a desire for real sugar.
I lost 20 pounds in 3 months from a plateau of no weight loss. What I did was quit the occasional 8 ounces of ice cream, the daily 20 ounce cup of coffee with sugar and milk, and one 5.3 ounce daily yogurt with fruit. I lost the fatty liver and visceral fat quickly and it has not come back.
Neurotoxins - substances that are poisonous or destructive to nerve tissue. Caffeine is listed in the strongest classification as a substantial neurotoxin by the EPA.
http://www.epa.gov/ncct/toxcast/files/summit/48P Mundy TDAS.pdf0 -
*sip*0
-
I like my coffee. I did switch from flavored creamers to plain half and half to cut the calories a bit.0
-
Could never do without. 2tsp of sugar and 2TBS of creamer (International Delight sweet cream) usually is what I do. It keeps it to around 100cal and I work it in.0
-
Coffee being healthy is one of the biggest lies and once a person is hooked, it becomes a life time crutch.
Lots of bad science here, but I'll focus in on this particular scare tactic.
OP seems to drink it already, so it's probably too late, but I don't see why it's the one thing you apparently can't quit here.
I have never found it that tough to quit. Yes, a bad few days sometimes.
Of course, I generally do choose to drink it again because I enjoy the way it tastes. No doubt that's my altered brain fooling me.0 -
lemurcat12 wrote: »Coffee being healthy is one of the biggest lies and once a person is hooked, it becomes a life time crutch.
Lots of bad science here, but I'll focus in on this particular scare tactic.
OP seems to drink it already, so it's probably too late, but I don't see why it's the one thing you apparently can't quit here.
I have never found it that tough to quit. Yes, a bad few days sometimes.
Of course, I generally do choose to drink it again because I enjoy the way it tastes. No doubt that's my altered brain fooling me.
To the original poster, I guess I was not fair. If you can go without coffee, GREAT, else drink it black if you can (that I cannot do). Find what works for you because when it comes to weight loss it is just one part of the total effort. I cannot do coffee black so i have reduced to just when I NEED to perform focused tasks. I did stop for a few months here and there but I still find days to operate that need becomes reality.
EDIT (To some coffee is a great alternative to snacks and its health risks are not immediate but accumulative. Sometimes one person's poison is another person's cure. Enjoy the coffee if it helps but like most here are saying try to cut back on the sugar and creamer)
Your information provides some contradiction and much self opinion, finalized with sarcasm, with no counter of facts to the information provided.
You made a correct statement in that "OP seems to drink it already, so it's probably too late". There is a different need for the ability to keep focus and need for caffeine, not calling it an addiction. If I were a landscaper or more physical job I would likely be able to drop coffee or drink only when I want. Being a programmer and data analyst, I require extensive focus and coffee is something I find myself coming back to in order to remain seated and accomplish focused tasks. Because I am hooked. My 1 or 2 cups of coffee a week now is much less than my 8 cups a day a couple years back. I no longer wake up with headaches! I do not claim to be perfect and I do not need to lie about coffee that I consume as being super healthy to protect such a claim. The fact is most of us are hooked and we do it! You still do too! Coffee alters a person's physiology of their body and alters their brain.
Science? Actually I just touched on the surface and did not include a number of health issues. The difference is I pointed to an actual supposedly reliable source of the EPA with one of my claims. Most people whom have had acid reflux know or have been told to drop coffee. I know a few such people. Caffeine bypasses the barriers to the fetus and the breast resulting in feeding the baby caffeine before it is even born (HOOKED). If you need studies for me to back my statements, I will provide them. The couple friends that I know that have gone through heart surgery have been strictly told by their doctor to remove caffeine from their diet completely. Tell me where you find error in my statements and I will provide reference. Caffeine is a purine and promotes gout attacks. A Billion dollars can buy much bad science and will find the Starbucks label on most of these studies in the news. It is easy for a 20 year old punk and say "haha coffee is great" because they read the news but as age settles in, the truth becomes reality, then let the punk speak.
http://www.healthambition.com/negative-effects-of-coffee/?PageSpeed=noscript (with links to studies)
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17023692
http://www.caffeineinformer.com/harmful-effects-of-caffeine
http://chealth.canoe.com/channel_condition_info_details.asp?disease_id=161&channel_id=2039&relation_id=72596
I have many more links if needed. Go defame somewhere else please!
0 -
I love cold coffee and I've given up on creamer and any type of sweetener by mixing my vanilla protein powder into cold coffee. It's like drinking a good for you frappuccino.0
-
if you want to drink coffee, then drink it. just log any sweetener/ creamer you use accurately.0
-
Caffeine is listed in the strongest classification as a substantial neurotoxin by the EPA.
Here's just a few other things that the EPA lists as neurotoxins: aspartame, THC, monosodium glutamate (MSG), fluoride, bisphenol A. In other words, that's artificial sweeteners, weed, Chinese food, tap water, and canned foods.Most people whom have had acid reflux know or have been told to drop coffee. I know a few such people.
That's because coffee is acidic, not because it has caffeine. They were likely also told to avoid citrus sodas like Sprite and things like orange juice.Caffeine bypasses the barriers to the fetus and the breast resulting in feeding the baby caffeine before it is even born (HOOKED).
Alcohol crosses the placental barrier, too. That doesn't mean men and nonpregnant women can't drink booze.Science? Actually I just touched on the surface and did not include a number of health issues. The difference is I pointed to an actual supposedly reliable source of the EPA with one of my claims.
Bodybuilders are the masters of cutting body fat while preserving lean body mass. For decades, they've used caffeine (and ephedrine) to suppress appetite in order to achieve the appropriate caloric deficit required to lose body fat. I am not sure how you can argue that. Everything has health issues -- the latest and greatest includes not eating grilled red meat because cancer. Black coffee is totally fine, and actually, there was a study in February in humans that found drinking dark roast coffee protects against DNA breakage.
Sure, be reasonable about your caffeine intake (just like you should be reasonable about your alcohol intake), and be sure to log honestly about whatever you add to your coffee. But it's absolutely fine to drink coffee and the caffeine will suppress your appetite, making it easier to stick to a caloric deficit.
(edited to fix formatting)0 -
Why not drink milk with coffee ? Has heaps of vitamins and nutrients in it and tastes good.0
-
ladymiseryali wrote: »I drink several cups. I have my primary cup with my breakfast. I put one tbsp heavy cream, one tbsp butter, one tbsp coconut oil, one tbsp sugar-free creamer and two tbsp whipped cream. I sweeten with liquid stevia. It keeps me full for most of the day, which is wonderful.
This sounds awesome. You should sell this recipe to Starbucks.0 -
lemurcat12 wrote: »Coffee being healthy is one of the biggest lies and once a person is hooked, it becomes a life time crutch.
Lots of bad science here, but I'll focus in on this particular scare tactic.
OP seems to drink it already, so it's probably too late, but I don't see why it's the one thing you apparently can't quit here.
I have never found it that tough to quit. Yes, a bad few days sometimes.
Of course, I generally do choose to drink it again because I enjoy the way it tastes. No doubt that's my altered brain fooling me.
To the original poster, I guess I was not fair. If you can go without coffee, GREAT, else drink it black if you can (that I cannot do).
I don't know why drinking real coffee would be difficult. It tastes far better black.
Not really the topic raised by your post, though. Just kind of oddly contradictory.Your information provides some contradiction and much self opinion, finalized with sarcasm, with no counter of facts to the information provided.
I'll argue with the "information provided" when information supporting the rather extreme claims--once hooked, life time crutch!--is provided. It has not been, and I don't believe it can be.There is a different need for the ability to keep focus and need for caffeine, not calling it an addiction.
Whatever, addiction wouldn't bother me much--it's certainly possible to be physically dependent in a way on caffeine which is why it's unpleasant (for a short time) to quit.If I were a landscaper or more physical job I would likely be able to drop coffee or drink only when I want. Being a programmer and data analyst, I require extensive focus and coffee is something I find myself coming back to in order to remain seated and accomplish focused tasks. Because I am hooked.
Or maybe because you don't get enough sleep or have issues with focusing that caffeine helps you with and would even if you'd never previously had it.My 1 or 2 cups of coffee a week now is much less than my 8 cups a day a couple years back. I no longer wake up with headaches!
This sounds like it's in fact an addiction (or whatever) that can be kicked.Most people whom have had acid reflux know or have been told to drop coffee.
This offers no support for your claim that it alters your brain forever.Caffeine bypasses the barriers to the fetus and the breast resulting in feeding the baby caffeine before it is even born (HOOKED).
Doctors these days actually say that coffee in moderation during pregnancy can be fine, but in any case this offers no support for your claim that it alters the brain of an adult forever.The couple friends that I know that have gone through heart surgery have been strictly told by their doctor to remove caffeine from their diet completely.
Again, no support for the claim in question. It's not exactly shocking that people with certain health conditions might not benefit from caffeine, given its effects.Tell me where you find error in my statements and I will provide reference.
I thought I was pretty clear before, but that caffeine alters your brain forever and that once you get "hooked" you can't quit it.
Defame, LOL!0 -
Do you enjoy drinking coffee? If yes, then keep drinking it. If no, then stop. Personally I drink 2-3 cups per day (a small amount of creamer, no sugar) and it hasn't hampered me any. I just make it fit into my goals because I enjoy it and would like to remain out of jail; caffeine withdrawal is a beast, haha. I think that's more negative of an effect than going without will ever be.0
-
I have lost 175 pounds and drink a cup every morning0
-
Lourdesong wrote: »What are the negative effects you read? I find it's a decent appetite suppressant. But even if it weren't, it's like no calories black, and I love it so...so much.
When I did the Ideal Protein Diet, my weight-loss coach said "NO COFFEE". I just followed the rules without asking why and lost weight through Ketosis. But I'm back on coffee now. :-)0 -
kickassbarbie wrote: »Just drink it if you like it coffee won't harm your weight loss. Just out of pure curiosity (because little short of death will part me from my coffee) what is so bad about coffee and/or coffee mate?
I don't know what is *supposed* to be bad about coffee during a diet - perhaps the "dehydration"??? However, when I did the Ideal Protein Diet, my weight-loss coach said "NO COFFEE". I just followed the rules without asking why and lost weight through Ketosis. But I'm back on coffee now. I do the Sugar-Free Coffee Mate and at the end of the day still manage to stay around 1450 Calories. :-)0 -
The only negative effects I could imagine would happen if you load your coffee with cream, sugar, flavoring, etc. and don't budget out your calories appropriately. The coffee itself is not a problem at all. I budget 1 cup of milk (2% of whole) each day for my coffee. No problems whatsoever with losing.
When I did the Ideal Protein Diet, my weight-loss coach said "NO COFFEE" because it would dehydrate me too much, and I would have to drink more water to compensate, which could mess up my electrolytes. I'm back on coffee now. I do the Sugar-Free Coffee Mate French Vanilla, log every Calorie, and at the end of the day still manage to stay around 1450 Calories. :-)0 -
surfteam1689 wrote: »The only negative effects I could imagine would happen if you load your coffee with cream, sugar, flavoring, etc. and don't budget out your calories appropriately. The coffee itself is not a problem at all. I budget 1 cup of milk (2% of whole) each day for my coffee. No problems whatsoever with losing.
When I did the Ideal Protein Diet, my weight-loss coach said "NO COFFEE" because it would dehydrate me too much, and I would have to drink more water to compensate, which could mess up my electrolytes. I'm back on coffee now. I do the Sugar-Free Coffee Mate French Vanilla, log every Calorie, and at the end of the day still manage to stay around 1450 Calories. :-)
The whole idea of coffee being dehydrating has always puzzled me. I might understand it being less hydrating than 100% water but the drink itself is mostly water. So the idea of it somehow reducing the amount of water inside of you after drinking it doesn't make sense to me.0 -
I drink a pot of coffee a day (sometimes more) and I haven't seen any problems. Load it down with calories and that could be a problem.0
-
galvitron1 wrote: »Keep the coffee because
- It contains antioxidants
- It helps to raise heart rate, thus burning more calories
- It counts as water intake. The amount of water lost via caffeine is negligible compared to the intake.
- Coffee helps you to clear out...um..."solid waste" better, which is one of the main mechanisms for unwanted weight exiting the body
+1
I drink 2-3 cups of black coffee every morning.
0 -
-
I drank one cup of coffee a day while pregnant with both my kids, and while breastfeeding, and yet my toddler has had no coffee or caffeine containing foods, even after weaning.... How on earth is she hooked?0
-
While dieting. Hmm. What about the rest of your life? Will you want to go back to it after you've stopped dieting or is it a permanent change? Cos if it won't work long term then maybe just keep drinking it. Google the benefits of drinking it, there's plenty of those as well0
-
IIt's a low calorie pleasure and how many of those are there? !!0
-
I still drink coffee but I've never drank more than 2 cups a day anyway. I personally do not do artificial sweeteners. I take mine with raw turbinado sugar and milk. If you can afford to have it in your calories I don't see why not, just make sure to drink plenty of water.0
-
Coffee is a necessity. I drink mine black.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 423 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions