Ignore sugars in fruit?
myweightloss2016
Posts: 147 Member
Hi there,
I have a question !
When I eat fruit (I like having 3-4 pieces a day), I immediately get over my sugar goal
Fruit is healthy, and I know that too much is bad due to the natural sugars, but hey, 3 pieces can't be bad, right?
How do you guys do this?
I have a question !
When I eat fruit (I like having 3-4 pieces a day), I immediately get over my sugar goal
Fruit is healthy, and I know that too much is bad due to the natural sugars, but hey, 3 pieces can't be bad, right?
How do you guys do this?
0
Replies
-
To be clear... don't ignore, track as calories/carbs.
Sugar is not bad per se as long as you are cautious about how much refined sugar you ingest.
Chronic ingestion of 50 grams or more of refined/processed sugars a day has known health risks. Sugars from whole foods however cannot be lumped into the same ballpark.0 -
To be clear... don't ignore, track as calories/carbs.
Sugar is not bad per se as long as you are cautious about how much refined sugar you ingest.
Chronic ingestion of 50 grams or more of refined/processed sugars a day has known health risks. Sugars from whole foods however cannot be lumped into the same ballpark.
Thanks for your comment.0 -
MFP looks at all sugars. So I changed my settings to track fiber instead (no health issues).
As long as you are meeting macros...protein, fat and then carbs.........don't worry about it.0 -
Stop eating so much fruit!
Switch to consuming more vegetables, especially leafy greens.0 -
azulvioleta6 wrote: »Stop eating so much fruit!
Switch to consuming more vegetables, especially leafy greens.
But why?
Why can't OP have her pineapple AND her spinach too?
0 -
-
I don't track sugar as it's irrelevant to me, just a sub-set of carbs.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
3 or 4 fruits is considered "so much"?azulvioleta6 wrote: »Stop eating so much fruit!
Switch to consuming more vegetables, especially leafy greens.
If you are going over your sugar limit, it is too much.
Sugar is sugar is sugar. Your body doesn't say "oh, this is fruit so I am going to totally ignore this sugar."0 -
This content has been removed.
-
azulvioleta6 wrote: »
3 or 4 fruits is considered "so much"?azulvioleta6 wrote: »Stop eating so much fruit!
Switch to consuming more vegetables, especially leafy greens.
If you are going over your sugar limit, it is too much.
Why?
The problem is the sugar limit is a percentage of calories.
15% of, say, 1800 calories is reasonably high.
15% of 1200 calories means 45 grams. I've hit 45 grams on a day when I had a piece of fruit, a little dairy, and lots of veggies (especially if I happen to include beets or sweet potatoes as one of my starchier options that day).
Also, none of the reasons given for limiting sugar suggest that eating 3-4 pieces of fruit is a problem. In fact, that's often recommended (along with veggies, of course). For example, the reason the WHO gives for its low (5%) recommendation for added sugars is calories, making sure you have a nutrient dense diet, and dental issues.
So what's the reasoning that says that 50-60 grams of sugar from fruit, veggies, and dairy is something to be worried about?0 -
MFP looks at all sugars. So I changed my settings to track fiber instead (no health issues).
As long as you are meeting macros...protein, fat and then carbs.........don't worry about it.
+1. Do you have any health issues that require keeping track of sugar grams? If not ditch the sugar column and enjoy some yummy summer fruits!
0 -
This content has been removed.
-
Just turn off the warning, I used to get it all the time before I turned it off. There's really no reason to limit your sugar intake if you're already limiting your calories.0
-
This content has been removed.
-
Go to Food tab and then Settings Tab. Food-Settings-Change Nutrients Tracked-Save0
-
Fruit is completely natural and healthy and delicious and extremely nutritious do not cut it out as long as you are still able to maintain your calories you should be able to have what ever you want! Bursting with healthy vitamins and nutrients!!0
-
don't track your sugar0
-
I used to ignore it. I would almost always be over my recommended sugar intake for a day but I ate a lot of fruit so I thought it was okay. But once I started limiting *all* sugar to 45g a day, I started actually losing weight at the rate I expected. Not saying this is a solution for everyone but it's working for me. I have maybe 2 fruit servings a day plus 5-6 vegetable servings. And I try to keep the fruit on the lower sugar end (berries, peaches, apples vs. mangos, pineapple, bananas).0
-
azulvioleta6 wrote: »
3 or 4 fruits is considered "so much"?azulvioleta6 wrote: »Stop eating so much fruit!
Switch to consuming more vegetables, especially leafy greens.
If you are going over your sugar limit, it is too much.
Sugar is sugar is sugar. Your body doesn't say "oh, this is fruit so I am going to totally ignore this sugar."
The WHO recommendations for sugar are only about added sugars, fruit juices, liquid sugars like honey and maple syrup. The WHO clearly mentions that they do not consider the 10% (or 5%) limit to apply to sugars from diary, or fruit.0 -
Lol @ the fruit denier. Ip youll be fine with 3 or 4 pieces. I wouldnt worry about the sugar in fruit, focus on your deficit for losing weight. Tracking fibre is more importnat than sugar imo.0
-
azulvioleta6 wrote: »If you are going over your sugar limit, it is too much.
Sugar is sugar is sugar. Your body doesn't say "oh, this is fruit so I am going to totally ignore this sugar."
Actually, it sort of does. When you eat fruit, it is already paired with fiber which affects how your body metabolizes it. This is a major reason why refined sugars are so bad, since they are so quickly broken down.
Additionally, most fruits are chock full of antioxidants and some even have been shown to have a positive effect on managing both blood glucose and blood lipid levels after a meal.
The big concern is if you are diabetic, have had a gastric bypass, or have other medical issues that may impact how your body processes sugars. With a gastric bypass, for example, the potential impact of fruit sugar can be much higher than normal simply because once sugar enters the small intestine, the differences between fruit and refined sugars disappear.0 -
myweightloss2016 wrote: »Hi there,
I have a question !
When I eat fruit (I like having 3-4 pieces a day), I immediately get over my sugar goal
Fruit is healthy, and I know that too much is bad due to the natural sugars, but hey, 3 pieces can't be bad, right?
How do you guys do this?
Track your fruit. Try to fit it into your macros. If you can, avoid extra sugar in beverages (coffee, tea), and enjoy your fruit!0 -
azulvioleta6 wrote: »
3 or 4 fruits is considered "so much"?azulvioleta6 wrote: »Stop eating so much fruit!
Switch to consuming more vegetables, especially leafy greens.
If you are going over your sugar limit, it is too much.
Sugar is sugar is sugar. Your body doesn't say "oh, this is fruit so I am going to totally ignore this sugar."
The WHO recommendations for sugar are only about added sugars, fruit juices, liquid sugars like honey and maple syrup. The WHO clearly mentions that they do not consider the 10% (or 5%) limit to apply to sugars from diary, or fruit.
This confuses so many people, especially newbies. If MFP can't track free sugars separately from fruit and dairy sugars, there shouldn't be a limit at all.
I cringe when people decide to stop eating fruit because of that stupid sugar limit. All those vitamins and minerals, not to mention water and fibre lost. And for no reason whatsoever.
I turned it off as soon as they added it.
0 -
Wow, lots of comments!
Okay, I can definitely work with that. Fruit keeps me away from the bad stuff and I guess, that eating an apple, some strawberries and a banana a day is better than eating unhealthy *kitten*.
I limit my calories to 1200 a day, so yeah the sugar recommendation is really low.
Thanks for all the helpful answers!0 -
3 or 4 fruits is considered "so much"?azulvioleta6 wrote: »Stop eating so much fruit!
Switch to consuming more vegetables, especially leafy greens.azulvioleta6 wrote: »
3 or 4 fruits is considered "so much"?azulvioleta6 wrote: »Stop eating so much fruit!
Switch to consuming more vegetables, especially leafy greens.
If you are going over your sugar limit, it is too much.
Sugar is sugar is sugar. Your body doesn't say "oh, this is fruit so I am going to totally ignore this sugar."
What is the sugar limit?
What would my sugar limit be?
MFP's limit is 15% of calories. UK rdi is 18% so typically 90 grams a day.
0 -
3 or 4 fruits is considered "so much"?azulvioleta6 wrote: »Stop eating so much fruit!
Switch to consuming more vegetables, especially leafy greens.
The median is probably about 1 hence the health propaganda aimed at the fruit avoiders.0 -
MFP looks at all sugars. So I changed my settings to track fiber instead (no health issues).
As long as you are meeting macros...protein, fat and then carbs.........don't worry about it.
This is what I do. As a T2 diabetic, you would think I need to track sugars, right? My doctor (certified diabetic educator) has told me that tracking sugars separately from carbs is not necessary unless the diabetic is on insulin. I just track total carbs and stay under the limit my Dr. gave me (180 g) even when I earn a ton of exercise calories. My a1c has held steady in the normal range for a year now (diagnosed 16 months ago)
For most people, getting enough fiber is much more important than limiting sugars. As the daughter of someone who died of colon cancer, it is especially important to me to keep my lower GI system as healthy as possible.
ETA: I do limit myself to one serving of fruit daily and eat a lot of veggies, but this is how I prefer to keep my total carbs under the limit while raising my fiber. I enjoy a slice of whole grain bread 2-3 times daily and often have brown rice or potatoes with dinner so I get my carbs that way, along with fiber.
0 -
Your body needs a certain amount of carbs, protein, healthy fats, vitamins and minerals. Too little of any of those, and your body will start craving. Fruit is a great source of carbs, vitamins, and minerals. So are veggies. If you eat a lot of processed foods, you get a lot of hidden sugar and you should eat more veggies than fruit. If you eat at home a lot and avoid packaged stuff, you can eat more fruit.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions