Sugar free
lawanddean
Posts: 46 Member
just started to try and go sugar free, anyone tried it?
0
Replies
-
idk if I can go completely sugar free. I searched "Sugar" in this area and saw your post. I'm 48 and went to the doctor and found out my glucose levels are nearing the diabetic levels. My mom has diabetes and I don't want to become diabetic if I can help it. Yesterday was my first day on this and I was under on everything EXCEPT sugar. Although most of it was from apples and peaches - it wasn't all from fruit. But even things that I don't expect to have sugar have it. Right now I'd be happy with just limiting my sugar to well below what my daily requirement allows.0
-
Are you trying to go sugar free or added sugar free? Because fruits and veggies have sugars but they also have a lot of nutrients.
Having said that, sugar isn't the devil.. calories are. Going sugar free won't guarantee weight loss if is your objective. But depending on your goals, reducing sugars (e.i. added sugars) can lead to more nutrient dense food choices and may help keep you in a deficit.
Personally, i believe in eating 80-90% of my calories from nutrient dense sources and the rest from treats. For me, moderation has worked well.0 -
Absolutely not. Sugar is in fruits so there isn't any way I'm giving those up. Also, there is no inherent advantage to giving up sugar. Sugar is just a carb, and like all other carbs has 4 calories per gram. Calories determine weight loss so you can certainly have sugar providing you still maintain your calorie deficit. Now I don't eat tons of things with lots of added sugar as those foods are usually less filling with higher calories. I'd rather use my calories on more filling foods. That is no to say I don't eat things with added sugar in moderation, I do. The point is, eating sugar free isn't necessary at all for weight loss, and is actually a bad idea IMO because it places a HUGE restriction on what you can eat, especially fruit.lawanddean wrote: »just started to try and go sugar free, anyone tried it?
0 -
I do limit the amount of sugary foods I eat, but no, not sugar free. I find going high fiber works better for me than worrying over grams of sugar.0
-
Nope!! Lost 121 pounds and reverse my heart disease all while eating sugary foods. I also do approx. 80/20.0
-
Funny, I just had this conversation with my son last night. I told him I was sorry he was giving up fruit. Shocked, he replied, "I'm not giving up fruit! I'm talking about the bad sugar; refined sugar!" I wished him well.
Now that my diabetes is in remission, I eat a little more refined sugar in my day. This month I made a home-made jam from my sister's rhubarb and I must say it's very good. This recipe called for soaking the rhubarb for 48 hours in the sugar (a delightful word; macerate). I used up every sugar I had in the house to make it including white refined sugar, corn syrup, agave syrup, and honey. Based on the proportions of sugar, I'd say the resulting product is mostly fructose.
It's very, very good. I eat in moderation just as I am cautious with fats and butter, no more than a tablespoon at a serving.0 -
Yeah, I gave it up, it's easy. Don't buy products with sugar in it. After a few weeks of no sugar you won't miss it. There's nutritionally very little positive about sugar.0
-
I take it you mean you are looking to reduce your sugar - good for you. great thing to cut back on to reduce the calories.
0 -
tennisdude2004 wrote: »I take it you mean you are looking to reduce your sugar - good for you. great thing to cut back on to reduce the calories.
This^
Cutting out 100% of added sugar is not necessary for weight loss. Temporary changes made to lose weight don't help you maintain the weight you lost. For me maintenance is actually harder than losing, so logging a sugary treat here, or a sugary treat there teaches me what a portion looks like. Only lifestyle changes for me.0 -
i watch my sugars, particularly added sugars as i have a medical condition and sugars from all sources can make me very ill if i have too much particularly in liquid forms (sugary drinks, smoothies etc)
i once had a no added sugar jelly without reading the label, heart rate shot right up, hot, sweaty, dizzy and then i passed out..... stupid me the little pot had 22 grams of it, twas made from fruit juice0 -
Nope. Nor do I wish to. I'm doing just fine without eliminating foods that I enjoy.0
-
I eat very little sugar, but I am eating a very low carbohydrate high fat diet to treat insulin resistance and autoimmune issues. My sugar grams are usually under 10g per day, and often barely register. I do not eat a lot of fruit except a handful of berries here or there, which suits me because I never have eaten more than one fruit a day. I do not eat grains, and skip most starchy veggies like potatoes.
I eat nothing that has added sugars if I can avoid it.
I find it very easy to eat this way. Cutting my sugars way back also led to the added benefit of my sugar and carb cravings being eliminated. This is no small feat since I used to have a pop every day and had candy on a weekly basis.
One does not need to severely restrict sugar in order to lose weight, but if you have IR, other health issues affected by sugar, or intense sugar cravings, cutting sugar may help. Sugar is not needed for health but most people want it in their lives. Just remember that those issues will return if you increase your sugar intake again.0 -
If you mean added sugars, I reduced them a great deal. I take in less than the recommended maximum amount. It wasn't easy. I struggled (and failed) sometimes, but in the end, I did it. I focus on the healthiness of my diet and that guides my food choices. If the food will harm me, it's out. If it's perfectly healthy for me, it's in. If it's somewhere in the middle, I make a judgement call. I want an overall healthy diet that tastes great and gives me all my vitamins and minerals.
If you mean ALL sugar, no way...and for the same reasons.
I cut most of the added sugars because those foods are high-cal, low-nutrient foods that aren't going to help me with my goals. I need the fruits and veggies because they do give me what I need. And berries are so very, very yummy.
0 -
lawanddean wrote: »just started to try and go sugar free, anyone tried it?
I gave up added sugar for a period of time for my own reasons.
You have to know what your reasons are and specifically what you are trying to do (for example I think it is not a good idea to give up some foods with sugar, like vegetables and fruits and dairy -- I've generally increased my consumption of those). I also think unless you have a specific reason for cutting out added sugar for a time or in general and simply think you consume too much of it that it's often best to start by just cutting down. Why make it all or nothing?
But if you have specific questions about what I did I'm open to them. On the whole it wasn't much more than just not eating them and I didn't really feel any different. (I mostly eat whole foods and don't put sugar in beverages so it meant cutting out sweets--my consumption from processed things is pretty low already.)0 -
Funny, I just had this conversation with my son last night. I told him I was sorry he was giving up fruit. Shocked, he replied, "I'm not giving up fruit! I'm talking about the bad sugar; refined sugar!" I wished him well.
Now that my diabetes is in remission, I eat a little more refined sugar in my day. This month I made a home-made jam from my sister's rhubarb and I must say it's very good. This recipe called for soaking the rhubarb for 48 hours in the sugar (a delightful word; macerate). I used up every sugar I had in the house to make it including white refined sugar, corn syrup, agave syrup, and honey. Based on the proportions of sugar, I'd say the resulting product is mostly fructose.
It's very, very good. I eat in moderation just as I am cautious with fats and butter, no more than a tablespoon at a serving.
Yum. I should try making jam, although I never use jam on anything now so it would be more for fun/because it sounds delicious. (Anything with rhubarb is up my alley.)0 -
tennisdude2004 wrote: »I take it you mean you are looking to reduce your sugar - good for you. great thing to cut back on to reduce the calories.
Going "sugar free" does not = "reducing sugar."0 -
One thing a lot of people forget when looking for added sugars in foods is that many products contain concentrated "natural" sugars (like using concentrated apple juice as a sweetener instead of cane sugar). I personally do not avoid sugar. I'm just working on calories right now and my sweet tooth is too strong for me to cut back drastically (I'd probably binge).0
-
Well progres so far I've limited sugar, I only have it from fruit and I've limited that, I'm eating much more but more healthy foods and I've lost 7 pounds in a week and feel amazing. I'm not touching process foods again, I wish I had tried this years ago0
-
Also I've increased my calories from 1400 which was recommended by this site too 2000 as my food now is high in calories (nuts, dairy) I've always struggled to lose weight unless I exercise but having twin babies has meant I am unable to go to the gym 5 times a week (which I did pre babies) I've never thought it was possible to eat more, do less exercise (which I'm not recommending as I will be back to the gym ASAP) and still lose weight which isn't water retention0
-
lawanddean wrote: »just started to try and go sugar free, anyone tried it?
Nah, exersise in futility.
Natural sugar in most foods. Added sugar same chemically as natural sugar. Calorie deficit for weight loss. Varied diet for health. Food I like for mental sanity.0 -
lemurcat12 wrote: »tennisdude2004 wrote: »I take it you mean you are looking to reduce your sugar - good for you. great thing to cut back on to reduce the calories.
Going "sugar free" does not = "reducing sugar."
It does if you don't read everything so literally!
The other day I was out of breath (but guess what? I could still breath).
0 -
Yes exactly, I did mean added sugar free and reduce sugar intake from fruit and veg0
-
tennisdude2004 wrote: »lemurcat12 wrote: »tennisdude2004 wrote: »I take it you mean you are looking to reduce your sugar - good for you. great thing to cut back on to reduce the calories.
Going "sugar free" does not = "reducing sugar."
It does if you don't read everything so literally!
The other day I was out of breath (but guess what? I could still breath).
Out of breath is an expression in a way sugar free is not.
So not a good analogy.
I would also disagree that reducing sugar from veg is a good thing.0 -
Whilst fruit and veg are good for you, if you want to lose weight eating too much fruit which is high in sugar could have adverse effects. Especially dried fruit which is high in calories and sugar, fruit juices and smoothed. I no longer have any of these and have seen really positive results0
-
lawanddean wrote: »Well progres so far I've limited sugar, I only have it from fruit and I've limited that, I'm eating much more but more healthy foods and I've lost 7 pounds in a week and feel amazing. I'm not touching process foods again, I wish I had tried this years agolawanddean wrote: »Also I've increased my calories from 1400 which was recommended by this site too 2000 as my food now is high in calories (nuts, dairy) I've always struggled to lose weight unless I exercise but having twin babies has meant I am unable to go to the gym 5 times a week (which I did pre babies) I've never thought it was possible to eat more, do less exercise (which I'm not recommending as I will be back to the gym ASAP) and still lose weight which isn't water retention
I hate to be a Debbie Downer here, but with 7 lbs lost in a week much of it likely is water retention. Not saying you shouldn't keep doing what you're doing, but I don't think you lost 7 lbs of fat in a week.
0 -
lawanddean wrote: »Well progres so far I've limited sugar, I only have it from fruit and I've limited that, I'm eating much more but more healthy foods and I've lost 7 pounds in a week and feel amazing. I'm not touching process foods again, I wish I had tried this years ago
I LOVE it! When you said "sugar free", I assumed that you did not mean you would stop eating fruit or drinking milk or consuming ANY possible source of sugar because that would be a statistically unusual situation and if that really WERE your intent, I would have expected you to expound upon all the strict rules you would have to follow. I don't know why people here take everyone so literally when, to me, your intent was clear. But I LOVE that you didn't engage, you just came back and reported SUCCESS! WTG!
0 -
Tbf you may be right as I've lost 2 inches off my belly, 1 from my thighs and 2 from my bum and my face is thinner, so the sugar may have been holding onto water as I've been dieting since last August and lost 2 stone but was stuck for the past 4 months at the same weight so the sugar thing may have kick started the water retention loss. But apart from that I have high levels of energy, no mood swings and sleep amazingly, I do think that it from giving up sugar0
-
Thanksgoldthistime wrote: »lawanddean wrote: »Well progres so far I've limited sugar, I only have it from fruit and I've limited that, I'm eating much more but more healthy foods and I've lost 7 pounds in a week and feel amazing. I'm not touching process foods again, I wish I had tried this years ago
I LOVE it! When you said "sugar free", I assumed that you did not mean you would stop eating fruit or drinking milk or consuming ANY possible source of sugar because that would be a statistically unusual situation and if that really WERE your intent, I would have expected you to expound upon all the strict rules you would have to follow. I don't know why people here take everyone so literally when, to me, your intent was clear. But I LOVE that you didn't engage, you just came back and reported SUCCESS! WTG!
0 -
Thank you I appreciate that 0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions