Calorie Prioritization - Yes, a calorie is a calorie….
ndj1979
Posts: 29,136 Member
Seeing the whole calorie is not a calorie thing come up a few times in this forum, so just wanted to lay out some thoughts on the subject for everyone.
From an energy standpoint, all calories are created equally; however, this does not mean that all calories are nutritionally the same.
So while 100 calories of carrots = 100 calories of cookies from an energy standpoint, they are not nutritionally the same.
What this means when one is bulking is that one should prioritize calorie intake into three tiers.
Tier One = make sure that you eat nutritionally dense foods like vegetables, fish, rice, etc, so that one gets adequate micronutrients (nutrition)
Tier Two = deals with macronutrients and making sure that one is hitting protein and fat minimums.
tier three = filling in the rest of your day with calorie dense foods to make sure that one is getting into a caloric surplus. The recommendation is that after one gets micronutrients and protein and fat minimums, that the rest of your day should be filled in with carbs.
So over the course of the day one should be meeting micronutrient goals, hitting macronutrients, and then fill in with calorie dense foods to get into a surplus.
This does NOT mean that I am saying eat 2500 calories of pizza or donuts, as it would then be impossible to get adequate nutrition and hit macros.
enjoy the bulking!
From an energy standpoint, all calories are created equally; however, this does not mean that all calories are nutritionally the same.
So while 100 calories of carrots = 100 calories of cookies from an energy standpoint, they are not nutritionally the same.
What this means when one is bulking is that one should prioritize calorie intake into three tiers.
Tier One = make sure that you eat nutritionally dense foods like vegetables, fish, rice, etc, so that one gets adequate micronutrients (nutrition)
Tier Two = deals with macronutrients and making sure that one is hitting protein and fat minimums.
tier three = filling in the rest of your day with calorie dense foods to make sure that one is getting into a caloric surplus. The recommendation is that after one gets micronutrients and protein and fat minimums, that the rest of your day should be filled in with carbs.
So over the course of the day one should be meeting micronutrient goals, hitting macronutrients, and then fill in with calorie dense foods to get into a surplus.
This does NOT mean that I am saying eat 2500 calories of pizza or donuts, as it would then be impossible to get adequate nutrition and hit macros.
enjoy the bulking!
0
Replies
-
Seeing the whole calorie is not a calorie thing come up a few times in this forum, so just wanted to lay out some thoughts on the subject for everyone.
From an energy standpoint, all calories are created equally; however, this does not mean that all calories are nutritionally the same.
So while 100 calories of carrots = 100 calories of cookies from an energy standpoint, they are not nutritionally the same.
What this means when one is bulking is that one should prioritize calorie intake into three tiers.
Tier One = make sure that you eat nutritionally dense foods like vegetables, fish, rice, etc, so that one gets adequate micronutrients (nutrition)
Tier Two = deals with macronutrients and making sure that one is hitting protein and fat minimums.
tier three = filling in the rest of your day with calorie dense foods to make sure that one is getting into a caloric surplus. The recommendation is that after one gets micronutrients and protein and fat minimums, that the rest of your day should be filled in with carbs.
So over the course of the day one should be meeting micronutrient goals, hitting macronutrients, and then fill in with calorie dense foods to get into a surplus.
This does NOT mean that I am saying eat 2500 calories of pizza or donuts, as it would then be impossible to get adequate nutrition and hit macros.
enjoy the bulking!
That makes me sad...
But good post.
0 -
Excellent points!! Can we also make the point that, no matter how you look at it...one pound of anything DOES weigh exactly the same as one pound of anything else? That argument just drives me NUTS!0
-
Seeing the whole calorie is not a calorie thing come up a few times in this forum, so just wanted to lay out some thoughts on the subject for everyone.
From an energy standpoint, all calories are created equally; however, this does not mean that all calories are nutritionally the same.
So while 100 calories of carrots = 100 calories of cookies from an energy standpoint, they are not nutritionally the same.
What this means when one is bulking is that one should prioritize calorie intake into three tiers.
Tier One = make sure that you eat nutritionally dense foods like vegetables, fish, rice, etc, so that one gets adequate micronutrients (nutrition)
Tier Two = deals with macronutrients and making sure that one is hitting protein and fat minimums.
tier three = filling in the rest of your day with calorie dense foods to make sure that one is getting into a caloric surplus. The recommendation is that after one gets micronutrients and protein and fat minimums, that the rest of your day should be filled in with carbs.
So over the course of the day one should be meeting micronutrient goals, hitting macronutrients, and then fill in with calorie dense foods to get into a surplus.
This does NOT mean that I am saying eat 2500 calories of pizza or donuts, as it would then be impossible to get adequate nutrition and hit macros.
enjoy the bulking!
That makes me sad...
But good post.
ha! well I am not saying that you could not do that….
0 -
JustMissTracy wrote: »Excellent points!! Can we also make the point that, no matter how you look at it...one pound of anything DOES weigh exactly the same as one pound of anything else? That argument just drives me NUTS!
In the argument of calorie prioritizing, this doesnt matter or even relate.
One thing i would probably add to the discussion at hand is the various effects of macronutrients
Protein - aids in muscle development, increases satiety and high thermal effect of food (aka - increased calories burned through metabolism)
Fats - aids in hormone regulation, and can increase satiety in some people (low TEF)
Carbs - provides energy, creates anitcabolic environment to promote muscle growth, and moderate TEF.0 -
Excellent post0
-
Nice.
I still started my day with a Dulce De Leche doughnut though. Hope I'm doing it right.0 -
good advice all around, not just for bulking. Well stated.0
-
Where do fruits and vegetables sit on this ranking? Sure they are carbs but does it make a difference if the carb budget is filled with doughnuts instead of salads?0
-
Where do fruits and vegetables sit on this ranking? Sure they are carbs but does it make a difference if the carb budget is filled with doughnuts instead of salads?Seeing the whole calorie is not a calorie thing come up a few times in this forum, so just wanted to lay out some thoughts on the subject for everyone.
From an energy standpoint, all calories are created equally; however, this does not mean that all calories are nutritionally the same.
So while 100 calories of carrots = 100 calories of cookies from an energy standpoint, they are not nutritionally the same.
What this means when one is bulking is that one should prioritize calorie intake into three tiers.
Tier One = make sure that you eat nutritionally dense foods like vegetables, fish, rice, etc, so that one gets adequate micronutrients (nutrition)
0 -
AAha. Got it. My priority is protein first (and fat seems to come along for the ride), carbs from veggies, then everything else. I love my carbs so I never have trouble fitting them in.0
-
Seems like reasonable advice for those trying to lose or maintain as well (except for the surplus). cheers. Good thread.0
-
-
Great post! It's my opinion that most people over exaggerate their micronutrient "needs."0
-
I agree that micro-nutrients, as long as we're eating a balanced diet, tend to find their way all on their own. Because I had Bariatric surgery however, absorption of micro-nutrients is a concern. I had a NSV victory last week. My nails got overly long without splitting or peeling. They are noticeably stronger than a month ago. My new supplement regimen is working!0
-
I agree that micro-nutrients, as long as we're eating a balanced diet, tend to find their way all on their own. Because I had Bariatric surgery however, absorption of micro-nutrients is a concern. I had a NSV victory last week. My nails got overly long without splitting or peeling. They are noticeably stronger than a month ago. My new supplement regimen is working!
congrats!0 -
bumping because I can ….0
-
This post makes me happy 0
-
It's funny that you think you're getting all your nutritional needs when most of the time you're getting upwards to 1000 calories from alcohol and food with high sugar. Hard to take what you say serious when you don't practice what you preach at all. Nice journal.0
-
It's funny that you think you're getting all your nutritional needs when most of the time you're getting upwards to 1000 calories from alcohol and food with high sugar. Hard to take what you say serious when you don't practice what you preach at all. Nice journal.
so now we are diary shaming?
that is funny coming from someone with a closed diary.
and if you are looking at Thanksgiving weekend, yea, my macros and micros were off, but I am not worried about a few days here and there...
0 -
It's funny that you think you're getting all your nutritional needs when most of the time you're getting upwards to 1000 calories from alcohol and food with high sugar. Hard to take what you say serious when you don't practice what you preach at all. Nice journal.
so now we are diary shaming?
that is funny coming from someone with a closed diary.
and if you are looking at Thanksgiving weekend, yea, my macros and micros were off, but I am not worried about a few days here and there...
Only 1000?? Lightweight. I had that much alcohol and pie before 3 pm this weekend.
Of course, only a fool would take a couple days over a holiday, and assume one eats like that every day.0 -
It's funny that you think you're getting all your nutritional needs when most of the time you're getting upwards to 1000 calories from alcohol and food with high sugar. Hard to take what you say serious when you don't practice what you preach at all. Nice journal.
Yeah, if a pilot told me the laws of gravity, I couldn't take them seriously as they regularly go up without falling back to Earth.
See the fallacious thinking in judging statements based on who says them rather than the statements themselves?0 -
It's funny that you think you're getting all your nutritional needs when most of the time you're getting upwards to 1000 calories from alcohol and food with high sugar. Hard to take what you say serious when you don't practice what you preach at all. Nice journal.
So you judge a persons diary while keep yours closed. Would you like to evaluate mine next, I would love your input.0 -
It's funny that you think you're getting all your nutritional needs when most of the time you're getting upwards to 1000 calories from alcohol and food with high sugar. Hard to take what you say serious when you don't practice what you preach at all. Nice journal.
So you judge a persons diary while keep yours closed. Would you like to evaluate mine next, I would love your input.
I'll evaluate yours.
Clearly needs more tacos, but that's true of everyone's diary.0 -
It's funny that you think you're getting all your nutritional needs when most of the time you're getting upwards to 1000 calories from alcohol and food with high sugar. Hard to take what you say serious when you don't practice what you preach at all. Nice journal.
So you judge a persons diary while keep yours closed. Would you like to evaluate mine next, I would love your input.
I'll evaluate yours.
Clearly needs more tacos, but that's true of everyone's diary.
Bro, do you even Taco Tuesday?
And besides, it's margarita monday!0 -
bump0
-
Great thread @ndj19790
-
thorsmom01 wrote: »Great thread @ndj1979
thx0 -
Agree!! 0
-
This thread needs a big chocolate cake with a file in it. <nods>0
-
+1thorsmom01 wrote: »Great thread @ndj1979
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.3K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 424 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions