Weight lifting vs. Cardio
Replies
-
Do NOT wait to lift. You are going to look so much better as your near goal if you don't wait. The less muscle you lose due to a progressive strength training program will help your body composition, and you may find you don't need to drop as low on the scale, in order to look as good/as small as you'd like.0
-
How do you get credit for calories burned for weight training in MFP? I don't see anywhere to log calories burned. I'd like to get info to log one hour of weight training if it's possible. I go every two days.0
-
feemailady wrote: »How do you get credit for calories burned for weight training in MFP? I don't see anywhere to log calories burned. I'd like to get info to log one hour of weight training if it's possible. I go every two days.
There is not a large calorie burn for weight lifting. You can log it under cardio but take it with a grain of salt. I have never once logged weight training for calories burned.0 -
middlehaitch wrote: »Simplistically put:
The body burns fat and to a lesser extent muscle at the same time while losing weight. This is inevitable and can't be avoided.
(I can't remember the percentage breakdown)
However, doing some kind of strength training keeps the muscles working. If the muscles are working the body keeps repairing them and is less inclined to use them as an energy reserve. This will help lessen the loss of muscle while losing, not negate it.
Otherwise- use them; or lose them.
Having an adequate protein supply helps in muscle repair and retrention amongst other things and that is why it is important to hit that micro first for a lot of people.
Someone else, hopefully, will come along
And expand on or correct this explanation of how I understand the benefit of lifting while losing.
Cheers, h.
Protein, water and sleep to repair muscle. You're right.
The issue I was pointing is that people on a diet are not on a healthiest enough diet to support muscle growth (protein).
Neglect to feed and care for your muscles and you won't see the kind of results you'll be expecting.
It's not just about grabbing something heavy and lifting it for twenty minutes then eat 1,200 calories for the day and only having consumed 20% of protein and 10% of carbs because you're counting calories.
When weight lifting you have to bring in enough protein and carbs for your muscles while also staying under your own calorie goal.
It's your own formula.
For instance, 50% of my diet is carbs, 25% Protein, 25% Fat, and I'm Active and set to Maintain. So that comes out to 2,700 I have to eat daily to keep my body and muscles in tip top, growing shape.0 -
I no for me I have lost over 135 pounds -and have lifted from the beginning-glad I did so I don't have any lose skin-I lift one day next day cardio-I like doing HIIT workouts-so lifting will help burn fat-I prefer to do cardio like after I lift-sometime I do treadmill to warm up0
-
Great post and fab responses - so what lifting program would you recommend for someone (a women in particular) starting out? I like the idea of free weights but never sure what I should be doing (yes there are trainers hanging around the gym but I would prefer to hear from people who have actually struggled with weight!!!!)
Thank you :-)0 -
I have just finished the first round of the All Pro routine. I chose it over a 5x5 routine because it increases reps (8-12) before increasing weight. I like to feel comfortable with a weight before upping it (weight chicken).
Like all the programmes start lifting at a low weight, but one that is heavy for you, and concentrate on form first.
Also, all the lifting programmes can be started with hand weights. I liked learning to squat, with weight, using a body bar rather than a kettle bell or hand weights. It emulates the centre of gravity needed for barbell squats.
Cheers, h.
http://forum.bodybuilding.com/showthread.php?t=41958430 -
arditarose wrote: »feemailady wrote: »How do you get credit for calories burned for weight training in MFP? I don't see anywhere to log calories burned. I'd like to get info to log one hour of weight training if it's possible. I go every two days.
There is not a large calorie burn for weight lifting. You can log it under cardio but take it with a grain of salt. I have never once logged weight training for calories burned.
That depends on the lifting session. 2 x 20's with only 30 seconds between sets, mixed in with core work nets me about a 425 calorie burn for an hour.0 -
I am a huge advocate of lifting. You will build some muscle or at least control the loss as you lose body fat. Make sure your protein intake is high. I do very little cardio, but good job working out and burning those calories!0
-
Just restarted this journey to get fit (and basically change everything I've ever done) at 6m postpartum my core is a bit (ok a lot) behind but I also just started SL5x5. I love it.0
-
Not sure why people like playing F***-Marry-Kill with weight training and cardio. You can f*** and marry them both, while killing all your fitness objectives.0
-
jeremywm1977 wrote: »Not sure why people like playing F***-Marry-Kill with weight training and cardio. You can f*** and marry them both, while killing all your fitness objectives.
Not in so many words, lol but I agree.0 -
Neither are necessary for weight loss (though they can make things easier) but both are pretty essential to basic, general fitness.0
-
SingingSingleTracker wrote: »arditarose wrote: »feemailady wrote: »How do you get credit for calories burned for weight training in MFP? I don't see anywhere to log calories burned. I'd like to get info to log one hour of weight training if it's possible. I go every two days.
There is not a large calorie burn for weight lifting. You can log it under cardio but take it with a grain of salt. I have never once logged weight training for calories burned.
That depends on the lifting session. 2 x 20's with only 30 seconds between sets, mixed in with core work nets me about a 425 calorie burn for an hour.
I wouldn't consider that strength training. when you get to 15+ reps it is more like resisted endurance training, very little strength gains will be made. plus the benefit for strength training is not the cals burned.
Also how did you calculate those cals burned? If you used an HRM it will be waaaaaay off. HRM's are only somewhat accurate for a narrow range of activity (steady state cardio) even all cardio but in intervals the HRM will be way off. the calculating embedded in the device assumes steady state.0 -
You can do both, but the time to start lifting is now. A really easy program to start with is Strong Lifts 5x5. There's tons of information and videos on that website. The program is really easy to follow and there's even a free app to track your progress. You can find a bunch of programs on BodyBuilding.com, but I found the Strong Lifts site more understandable and user friendly when I was new to lifting.
Honestly, one of my only regrets for my weight loss was the lack of weight training from the very beginning.0 -
Lifting is life!!!!
0 -
charliebird wrote: »Great post and fab responses - so what lifting program would you recommend for someone (a women in particular) starting out? I like the idea of free weights but never sure what I should be doing (yes there are trainers hanging around the gym but I would prefer to hear from people who have actually struggled with weight!!!!)
Thank you :-)
strong lifts or all pro beginner routine are great beginner programs0 -
90% of getting the body you want is 100% from lifting.. Truth.. 84%0
-
Start lifting now. Here's a good article: http://www.muscleforlife.com/how-much-cardio/0
-
middlehaitch wrote: »However, doing some kind of strength training keeps the muscles working. If the muscles are working the body keeps repairing them and is less inclined to use them as an energy reserve. This will help lessen the loss of muscle while losing, not negate it.
Otherwise- use them; or lose them.
I've seen this stated previously, but it's never quite made sense to me. I can see that walking or other "easier" activities aren't really pushing muscles to repair and rebuild, but if I push hard on a run, I definitely have muscle burn that I equate with microtears and repair of muscles. How is that functionally different from lifting to tear down and build up muscle?0 -
I've always wondered why people think they should wait until they lose weight to do strength training. While you lose weight, you lose both fat and muscle. Strength training minimizes muscle gains because, hello, who wants to lose muscle? There are exactly zero reasons to not strength train while losing weight.
The best time to start lifting is yesterday.0 -
Both, though I would use the term strength training rather than lifting.
There are way to incorporate both that might not be as great as the extremes of one or the other, but you can build cardio lifting heavy and build muscle doing higher intensities of cardio.
IMO people often take extreme views and think that all cardio requires running forever, and that all strength training involves lifting towards the upper end of capability. I think there is a lot of common ground in the middle personally.0 -
I started lifting in Nov last year and never thought in a million years how much I would love it. I have learned more to go by the feel of my clothing and look of my body rather than that number on the scales.0
-
streamgirl wrote: »middlehaitch wrote: »However, doing some kind of strength training keeps the muscles working. If the muscles are working the body keeps repairing them and is less inclined to use them as an energy reserve. This will help lessen the loss of muscle while losing, not negate it.
Otherwise- use them; or lose them.
I've seen this stated previously, but it's never quite made sense to me. I can see that walking or other "easier" activities aren't really pushing muscles to repair and rebuild, but if I push hard on a run, I definitely have muscle burn that I equate with microtears and repair of muscles. How is that functionally different from lifting to tear down and build up muscle?
You do get some benefit in that regard just as you get some cardiovascular benefit from lifting...but you don't get as much cardiovascular benefit from lifting as you would doing exercise that is specific to cardiovascular fitness just as you won't get as much benefit for muscle development and muscle maintenance with cardiovascular work as you would with resistance training which is specific to that goal.
You also have to consider that you have a lot more muscles in your body than just your legs and that's primarily what you'd be working while running.0 -
I've done a lot of research on this and lifting burns more calories than just cardio including after your workout is complete. So lifting is the best way to go in that sense... Hooray!! HOWEVER you need cardio for your cardiovascular health that you can't get from lifting alone. So I say finish each lifting session with 10 min of cardio. It can be overwhelming to start with, but I always map out my workout before I go and I still watch YouTube videos even while in the gym if I am unsure of an exercise! Best of luck!0
-
I highly recommend strength training because its a great fat burner then if you wanna do cardio afterwards then maybe do 45 mins of tradmill walk incline at 15% and 3 kmh. Hope that helps0
-
streamgirl wrote: »middlehaitch wrote: »However, doing some kind of strength training keeps the muscles working. If the muscles are working the body keeps repairing them and is less inclined to use them as an energy reserve. This will help lessen the loss of muscle while losing, not negate it.
Otherwise- use them; or lose them.
I've seen this stated previously, but it's never quite made sense to me. I can see that walking or other "easier" activities aren't really pushing muscles to repair and rebuild, but if I push hard on a run, I definitely have muscle burn that I equate with microtears and repair of muscles. How is that functionally different from lifting to tear down and build up muscle?
Even walking, as exercise, will strengthen muscle initially if you haven't walked at a good pace and/or distance previously.
Running/walking involves a reasonable set of muscles and all will benefit. However it does not provide enough progressive resistance for the muscles to progress at the same rate as they would employing a progressive compound lifting programme.
Running/walking further will build up endurance in the muscle.
Running/walking faster will build more strength in the muscle. At a higher speed the footfall has a slightly greater impact, resistance.
There is a limit to both of the above for the average person, so any type of muscle development is limited to that. Muscle will be retained, but as these exercises are steady state there is minimal comparative progression.
Generally a state of status quo is reached where the muscle is repairing for maintenance.
Think of doing bicep curls with a 5 lbs dumbbell.
You will get the greater return doing 10 reps when you first do them. 6 month later that same exercise will provide no benefit except maintaining the muscle as is.
Progressive compound lifting on the other hand stresses the muscles each session by rep and/or weight increases so the muscle is rebuilt to that greater stress load.
One can max out on lifting and maintain their status quo by not progressing.
Muscles adapt to their use. Atrophy when not used.
Cheers, h.
0 -
Do both. Weight lifting before cardio.0
-
SingingSingleTracker wrote: »arditarose wrote: »feemailady wrote: »How do you get credit for calories burned for weight training in MFP? I don't see anywhere to log calories burned. I'd like to get info to log one hour of weight training if it's possible. I go every two days.
There is not a large calorie burn for weight lifting. You can log it under cardio but take it with a grain of salt. I have never once logged weight training for calories burned.
That depends on the lifting session. 2 x 20's with only 30 seconds between sets, mixed in with core work nets me about a 425 calorie burn for an hour.
I wouldn't consider that strength training. when you get to 15+ reps it is more like resisted endurance training, very little strength gains will be made. plus the benefit for strength training is not the cals burned.
Also how did you calculate those cals burned? If you used an HRM it will be waaaaaay off. HRM's are only somewhat accurate for a narrow range of activity (steady state cardio) even all cardio but in intervals the HRM will be way off. the calculating embedded in the device assumes steady state.
Well, not all weight training is created equal which is why I posted with regard to calorie burn. The OP mentioned "weight lifting" - not a specific phase within a structured program.
I use periodization in my training every year (mountain bike racer). Coach just put me through three weeks of 2 x 20's. Now I am on to the next phase of three weeks of 2 x 15's which is more weight on the bars, but slower lifts. And by the end of my 24 week training I will have moved through all the usual phases of a periodized program: preparation, hypertrophy, strength, power, and finally a transition to maintenance during the racing months. I've done this multiple years, so I know plates will be adding on as I move through it and the reps drop way down.
However, the sessions I've been through burned through the kcals.
The 2 x 20 sessions...
My Monday session.
5 minute cardio warm up
2 x 20 seated rows
2 x 20 deadlifts
2 x 20 ham curls
10 minutes core work
2 x 20 knee extensions
2 x 20 bench
2 x 20 straight arm lat pulls
2 x 20 bench arm pulls
10 minutes core work
5 minute stretching
Wednesday
5 mins of cardio warm up
2x20 Power clean
2x20 pushpress barbell
2x20 glute bridge 1-leg
10 minutes core work
box blast 20 each leg
dumbbell 1 arm snatch 20 reps each side
2x20 standing straight arm pull down
10 mins core work
5 minutes of stretching
It doesn't burn as much as 60 minutes on the bike (unless I'm in recovery pace), but it is what it is. You can say it's "way off", or
0 -
Start weight lifting now not only for the benefits of strength training but because it boosts your metabolism as well.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.6K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions