Screw you Protein Bar!
joepratt503
Posts: 191 Member
So, yea, I love them. They taste good, they have solid macros (the good ones do), they taste good, they are convenient, and...well...they taste good. The good news is they have nutrients in them, the bad is that they are very "dense" and the volume just ins't there.
I do understand that most, if not all, of us already know this but sometimes you accidentally re-learn something and it just makes you feel silly. This AM, I ate eggs, potato, and oatmeal which were ALMOST identical to the macros on my typical morning protein bar (which I eat with coffee). Imagine my surprise when it dawned on me that this plate of food was the "same" as that evil bar! Where nutritionally they may be mostly the same, the sheer volume of stuff in my face was significantly higher and prevented me from being as hungry as quickly as I normally would.
Yes, they do have a time/place, no I will not stop eating them, but I will need to make a more concerted effort to not take the easy way out.
I do understand that most, if not all, of us already know this but sometimes you accidentally re-learn something and it just makes you feel silly. This AM, I ate eggs, potato, and oatmeal which were ALMOST identical to the macros on my typical morning protein bar (which I eat with coffee). Imagine my surprise when it dawned on me that this plate of food was the "same" as that evil bar! Where nutritionally they may be mostly the same, the sheer volume of stuff in my face was significantly higher and prevented me from being as hungry as quickly as I normally would.
Yes, they do have a time/place, no I will not stop eating them, but I will need to make a more concerted effort to not take the easy way out.
0
Replies
-
Congratulations on your "AHA!" moment!!0
-
Yeah, I think they're tasty and I especially like them when I'm travelling and don't have the ability to cook as much. . . . but the calorie density keeps me from eating them regularly. I just don't feel as full after having one as I would after less dense food.0
-
That's the thing I'm trying to get my husband to realize right now. He was seeing a nutritionist our doctor recommended, and she has him using protein bars and shakes as meal replacements. He complains that he's hungry all the time and feels deprived. "Look, the fish tacos I just made for dinner are the equivalent nutrition of your protein bar! Eat real food that matches the nutrients"... but he keeps coming back to what the nutritionist said, even after he fired her. (She was crazy and pretty stupid.)
I only use the protein bars right before a swim to give me that extra carry-through, and sometimes I'll have an Ensure Protein shake after my long walk (4 miles) to get my 'boost' back.0 -
Yeah I had that moment after stocking up on Quest bars... and now they've been sitting in my pantry for months...0
-
Had this same realization 2 days ago. Only like them when traveling or on work breaks when time limited! Very much a volume eater. Add me!0
-
I have protein bars when I'm hiking (along with other treats) or when I'm out running around and get hungry but know I'll be eating a real meal in an hour or two. They only temporarily stop tummy growling for me so I could never be successful using them as a meal replacement.
Now I really want fish tacos for dinner. I have most the ingredients. ...
-1 -
I used to eat a protein bar for breakfast in the car, but have moved to microwaveable low-cal breakfast sandwiches. I now eat a protein bar after work while heading to the gym. I have T2 diabetes, and if I don't eat something before I exercise, my blood sugar goes too low.0
-
I just now ate one because I don't get to eat lunch today at work. After a heavier breakfast, it works for me. Quick and fewer calories than a bag of chips or candy bar with the added bonus of the protein.0
-
I agree with you, but man....it's tough to get 20g protein and 13g of fiber under 200 calories, and easy and tastes good. Tough.
Oatmeal only has a few grams of fiber per serving, so does potato. And they come with a whole lotta starch. Maybe you can put the breakdown of what you ate in this thread? I'd be interested to see. Especially, I'd be interested in meals that would replace a quest bar for the same amount of calories....would be interesting. Maybe I'll start a thread ....0 -
I guess I never found a bar that I liked enough. I'd much rather a plate of food too but definitely helps when on the go.0
-
I agree with you, but man....it's tough to get 20g protein and 13g of fiber under 200 calories, and easy and tastes good. Tough.
Oatmeal only has a few grams of fiber per serving, so does potato. And they come with a whole lotta starch. Maybe you can put the breakdown of what you ate in this thread? I'd be interested to see. Especially, I'd be interested in meals that would replace a quest bar for the same amount of calories....would be interesting. Maybe I'll start a thread ....
I think if you add egg whites into the mix you could get the protein up pretty quickly while still leaving room for a greater volume of calories. I am on a serious egg white omelette kick though so I might be biased.0 -
She'd love you forever and ever and ever and ever!!!!!!
I'm almost done with my Pure Protein bars (dislike the chocolate deluxe and should stuck with chewy chocolate chip). I have my B up bars go taste test and then some musclepharms I think.
These days I just eat half a proten bar for an early afternoon snack. I went off the turkey jerky when I was having tooth problems and haven't gone back yet.0 -
I often have to drive 60-100 miles each way to get to my assigned job for the day. Throwing a protein bar or an Atkins Harvest bar into my backpack makes it easy to say no to the convince store stop for a bag of chips.0
-
LOL yea protein bars are def convenient. I've been addicted to the power crunch bars but recently I've found this easy recipe (link below) and changed my life. I'll stick to the power crunch bars for the lower sugar/carbs snack but for a solid pre or post workout bar...this one gets the job done very well
http://cms.bbcomcdn.com/fun/docs/2014/bpi-white-choc-pb-cinnamon-bars.pdf0 -
I love protein bars for exactly the opposite reason: they help me hit my macros without having to eat myself sick.0
-
I hate breakfast so a protein bar, an orange, and a coffee means I am getting more to eat than I generally would.
Cheers, h.
( I have a protein bar shelf like some have a treat/snack shelf. Variety is good)0 -
I like my protein bars for lunch because lunch is usually rushed for me. I'm focused on getting lunch down the three kids and sorting out stuff I have to do in the afternoons, so a protein bar and an apple and some peanut butter is my go to. Don't have to cook it, delicious, decent macros.0
-
Exactly, see definition of "supplement" and eat food first then add the bars only if you need them.0
-
I agree with you, but man....it's tough to get 20g protein and 13g of fiber under 200 calories, and easy and tastes good. Tough.
Oatmeal only has a few grams of fiber per serving, so does potato. And they come with a whole lotta starch. Maybe you can put the breakdown of what you ate in this thread? I'd be interested to see. Especially, I'd be interested in meals that would replace a quest bar for the same amount of calories....would be interesting. Maybe I'll start a thread ....
Jerky and oatbran maybe? Problem with eating bars is you really don't know what you are getting anyway. If you look at the Pure Protein bars and many others they use a lot of gelatin and collagen to increase the protein but it's not the type of protein you need. Many protein powders use amino spiking techniques to increase the nitrogen content, and thus the protein grams listed, with cheap aminos like taurine and many tests have shown they don't live up to the macro numbers listed nor the ingredients listed.
So your bar may not really be anything more than a placebo.0 -
Homemade protein bars anyone? They're quite fun & easy to make0
-
I love protein bars because I'm a picky eater. Don't eat meat, can't eat eggs [allergy], don't like beans or tofu. So I guess it depends on why you're eating them and what other foods you eat. I get Power Crunch bars because they're $15 for a box.0
-
-
Yep - for emergencies only!
0 -
Wheelhouse15 wrote: »
Jerky and oatbran maybe? Problem with eating bars is you really don't know what you are getting anyway. If you look at the Pure Protein bars and many others they use a lot of gelatin and collagen to increase the protein but it's not the type of protein you need. Many protein powders use amino spiking techniques to increase the nitrogen content, and thus the protein grams listed, with cheap aminos like taurine and many tests have shown they don't live up to the macro numbers listed nor the ingredients listed.
So your bar may not really be anything more than a placebo.
Or just don't buy *kitten* protein / bars. My initial comment was more of a comical "F I am hungry" post than one to get into a supplement discussion. In truth, I am going right where I want to with my program.0 -
Strange, I actually find the high fiber protein bars keep me full longer than a big bowl of oatmeal or something, even when I usually add some greek yogurt and protein powder to improve the macros (and I like the taste!).0
-
joepratt503 wrote: »Wheelhouse15 wrote: »
Jerky and oatbran maybe? Problem with eating bars is you really don't know what you are getting anyway. If you look at the Pure Protein bars and many others they use a lot of gelatin and collagen to increase the protein but it's not the type of protein you need. Many protein powders use amino spiking techniques to increase the nitrogen content, and thus the protein grams listed, with cheap aminos like taurine and many tests have shown they don't live up to the macro numbers listed nor the ingredients listed.
So your bar may not really be anything more than a placebo.
Or just don't buy *kitten* protein / bars. My initial comment was more of a comical "F I am hungry" post than one to get into a supplement discussion. In truth, I am going right where I want to with my program.
I agree, don't buy protein bars unless you need to. Sounds like you have your diet on point so that's a great start.0 -
I bought a large box of Clif builder bars (20g protein per bar, 250 calories) at Costco and I eat them a lot. They're good for someone who needs food on the go and has a small stomach (like me). I used to fill up on chocolate bars and sweets and gained a bunch of weight and I find I can't always sit down to eat a whole portion of food. As someone who gets extremely full on half a serving of oatmeal (made with soy milk, protein powder, and berries), they're good for me to reach my protein and calorie goals without reaching for chocolate bars while on the go. You don't need protein bars to survive, but they can be handy for some.0
-
Protein bars are great on the go...and only then.0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 426 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions