Wheat bread
Breannarosebrooks
Posts: 18 Member
Does it make a big difference switching from white bread to 100% whole wheat??
0
Replies
-
Calorie wise? No0
-
supposedly whole wheat has more nutritional value, but keyword is supposedly because I don't want the nutritional debate people to come yell at me
calorie wise I don't believe there is a large difference. 0 -
I loooove sour dough, whole wheat is good but sour dough. Yum0
-
No. There is no significant difference in the nutrition between the two. I used to bake bread. Essentially, bread is bread. Enjoy what you like.
0 -
Thank you. My dad always made it seem like it is better to eat wheat bread if ur trying to lose weight. I like white0
-
It's about the calories0
-
Ok thnks 0
-
There might be some minor macronutrient and micronutrient differences (fibre and iron for example, based on quick glance at some labels), you can make that up elsewhere. I don't mind either for bread, but homemade is the best! 0
-
Yes, there is a huge difference. First of all, you should try to make at least half of your grains whole grains. Switching to wheat bread is a really great way to do that. I'll explain why it's important.
When refining a grain (as they do to make white bread) they remove part of the grain. This part contains fiber and other nutrients.
White bread breaks down very quickly, meaning it converts into sugar quickly, and spikes your blood sugar. This causes insulin to be released, which will lower your blood sugar. This is the sugar crash that you might experience with any other food with a high glycemic index. (Glycemic index is how quickly the food turns to sugar). When your blood sugars drop, you start to want more sugar, so you get hungry. White bread doesn't do you much good.
On the other hand, whole grain bread has more complex carbohydrates and fiber, which take longer to break down. You're getting smaller amounts of sugar throughout the day, so your blood sugar doesn't spike and crash, and you will be fuller longer.
So, calorie-wise, there's not a huge difference. But nutrition is about so much more than calories. If you want to make life a little bit easier for yourself, treat your body right and give it the whole grains.0 -
lisaloolovesblue wrote: »Yes, there is a huge difference. First of all, you should try to make at least half of your grains whole grains. Switching to wheat bread is a really great way to do that. I'll explain why it's important.
When refining a grain (as they do to make white bread) they remove part of the grain. This part contains fiber and other nutrients.
White bread breaks down very quickly, meaning it converts into sugar quickly, and spikes your blood sugar. This causes insulin to be released, which will lower your blood sugar. This is the sugar crash that you might experience with any other food with a high glycemic index. (Glycemic index is how quickly the food turns to sugar). When your blood sugars drop, you start to want more sugar, so you get hungry. White bread doesn't do you much good.
On the other hand, whole grain bread has more complex carbohydrates and fiber, which take longer to break down. You're getting smaller amounts of sugar throughout the day, so your blood sugar doesn't spike and crash, and you will be fuller longer.
So, calorie-wise, there's not a huge difference. But nutrition is about so much more than calories. If you want to make life a little bit easier for yourself, treat your body right and give it the whole grains.
not all "whole wheat" is whole grain.0 -
Try Ezeckel Bread. It would be in the natural freezer section. It is awesome and has the added benefit of protein0
-
lisaloolovesblue wrote: »Yes, there is a huge difference. First of all, you should try to make at least half of your grains whole grains. Switching to wheat bread is a really great way to do that. I'll explain why it's important.
When refining a grain (as they do to make white bread) they remove part of the grain. This part contains fiber and other nutrients.
White bread breaks down very quickly, meaning it converts into sugar quickly, and spikes your blood sugar. This causes insulin to be released, which will lower your blood sugar. This is the sugar crash that you might experience with any other food with a high glycemic index. (Glycemic index is how quickly the food turns to sugar). When your blood sugars drop, you start to want more sugar, so you get hungry. White bread doesn't do you much good.
On the other hand, whole grain bread has more complex carbohydrates and fiber, which take longer to break down. You're getting smaller amounts of sugar throughout the day, so your blood sugar doesn't spike and crash, and you will be fuller longer.
So, calorie-wise, there's not a huge difference. But nutrition is about so much more than calories. If you want to make life a little bit easier for yourself, treat your body right and give it the whole grains.
The GI difference between white and whole wheat isn't that great, and this is especially so because people generally don't eat just bread but eat it with other foods (which will typically reduce GI -- like meat or cheese or butter or peanut butter).
I personally prefer whole wheat (and don't care about bread anyway, so don't eat much), and whole wheat has a few more nutrients and more fiber, but if you have a diet that provides those anyway worrying about whole wheat vs. white in bread or pasta may not be a big deal. (And it depends on how much you eat.)
For example whole wheat pasta in a carbonara, no vegetables, is likely to be a less nutritious choice (although it can still be tasty and fit in a day) than a white pasta with shrimp and lots of vegetables.
Also, the focus on GI and blood sugar isn't significant for most people, and there have been found to be individual differences in terms of the effects the foods have. Rather than making academic distinctions it makes more sense to see if you are getting too hungry too quickly after eating and then make changes.0 -
huge difference...cut out any white flour and sugars and youll strip fat easily....0
-
Fiber FTW. Whole wheat (and not just 'wheat') is more filling.0
-
I can definitely see why people get confused because theres so many different conflicting opinions.0
-
-
clutchitalian wrote: »huge difference...cut out any white flour and sugars and youll strip fat easily....
Nope. I cut out all white products and ate only whole grains 90% of the time and still packed on the pounds. Weight loss is calories in/out. Not what those calories are made of, with the exception of medical differences in your body, and products with alcohol.
I ate homemade white bread for the first time in years this past week. Quite a few slices in my calorie allotment over a few days. Previously I'd only exposed myself to white bread when eating out. I removed daily Lite beers(s). I lost weight almost 2 lbs after having been stalled for weeks. Removing alcohol was the key, adding white bread made me a bit gassy and of course I didn't feel as full but in no way was it a factor inhibiting fat loss.0 -
ya alcohol is a killer thats my only vice......i lost 25lbs in 6 weeks with low carb diet...under 50mg per day it forces ur body to burn fat............0
-
clutchitalian wrote: »ya alcohol is a killer thats my only vice......i lost 25lbs in 6 weeks with low carb diet...under 50mg per day it forces ur body to burn fat............
A calorie deficit forces your body to burn fat.0 -
The calories are about the same. You can look that up so you aren't just relying on Internet opinion.
The national food guide encourages us to eat whole grains more often but you can do that other ways. Like having buckwheat as a side.0 -
whole grains are the best i cant remember the last time i ate white bread0
-
clutchitalian wrote: »huge difference...cut out any white flour and sugars and youll strip fat easily....
Not if you're in a caloric surplus you won't. White flour and sugars don't cause weight gain or prevent weight loss, that's entirely false.0 -
guinevere96 wrote: »I can definitely see why people get confused because theres so many different conflicting opinions.
That's because many people know nothing about basic nutrition and/or physiology and believe all the woo they read instead.
The correct answer to the OP is that, if calories are kept equivalent, there will be absolutely no difference (in terms of weight loss) in switching from white to whole wheat bread. None. Zero. Nada. Zilch. Zip.0 -
Other than it that it tastes better (to me personally), there isn't much difference. Just eat the kind you like. Even nutritionally the difference is not substantial enough to make the switch if you prefer white. Whole wheat has 1 gram of fiber and protein more than white bread per 1 oz slice. You can easily make up for that loss and more by snacking on a small vegetable.0
-
guinevere96 wrote: »I can definitely see why people get confused because theres so many different conflicting opinions.
That's because many people know nothing about basic nutrition and/or physiology and believe all the woo they read instead.
The correct answer to the OP is that, if calories are kept equivalent, there will be absolutely no difference (in terms of weight loss) in switching from white to whole wheat bread. None. Zero. Nada. Zilch. Zip.
In term of weight loss, definitely. But bread with fiber is more filling.amusedmonkey wrote: »Other than it that it tastes better (to me personally), there isn't much difference. Just eat the kind you like. Even nutritionally the difference is not substantial enough to make the switch if you prefer white. Whole wheat has 1 gram of fiber and protein more than white bread per 1 oz slice. You can easily make up for that loss and more by snacking on a small vegetable.
Depends. The whole wheat bread I used to eat had like 3 to 5g of fiber. It DID make a difference and was more filling.
In the end though, for most people, it won't make a huge difference either way, and whole wheat bread often has more calories too.0 -
guinevere96 wrote: »I can definitely see why people get confused because theres so many different conflicting opinions.
That's because many people know nothing about basic nutrition and/or physiology and believe all the woo they read instead.
The correct answer to the OP is that, if calories are kept equivalent, there will be absolutely no difference (in terms of weight loss) in switching from white to whole wheat bread. None. Zero. Nada. Zilch. Zip.
In term of weight loss, definitely. But bread with fiber is more filling.amusedmonkey wrote: »Other than it that it tastes better (to me personally), there isn't much difference. Just eat the kind you like. Even nutritionally the difference is not substantial enough to make the switch if you prefer white. Whole wheat has 1 gram of fiber and protein more than white bread per 1 oz slice. You can easily make up for that loss and more by snacking on a small vegetable.
Depends. The whole wheat bread I used to eat had like 3 to 5g of fiber. It DID make a difference and was more filling.
In the end though, for most people, it won't make a huge difference either way, and whole wheat bread often has more calories too.
I agree. I think one can't really say "wheat" bread and "white" bread with any meaning. There are so many breads on the market. Mine have short ingredient lists, a better nutritional profile and quite a bit more fiber. It's 100% whole wheat.
Is bread a make or break? No. Can I have white bread and nosh on some veggies? Sure. Or I can have wheat bread AND the veggies.
Every little positive change adds up.0 -
Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »guinevere96 wrote: »I can definitely see why people get confused because theres so many different conflicting opinions.
That's because many people know nothing about basic nutrition and/or physiology and believe all the woo they read instead.
The correct answer to the OP is that, if calories are kept equivalent, there will be absolutely no difference (in terms of weight loss) in switching from white to whole wheat bread. None. Zero. Nada. Zilch. Zip.
In term of weight loss, definitely. But bread with fiber is more filling.amusedmonkey wrote: »Other than it that it tastes better (to me personally), there isn't much difference. Just eat the kind you like. Even nutritionally the difference is not substantial enough to make the switch if you prefer white. Whole wheat has 1 gram of fiber and protein more than white bread per 1 oz slice. You can easily make up for that loss and more by snacking on a small vegetable.
Depends. The whole wheat bread I used to eat had like 3 to 5g of fiber. It DID make a difference and was more filling.
In the end though, for most people, it won't make a huge difference either way, and whole wheat bread often has more calories too.
I agree. I think one can't really say "wheat" bread and "white" bread with any meaning. There are so many breads on the market. Mine have short ingredient lists, a better nutritional profile and quite a bit more fiber. It's 100% whole wheat.
Is bread a make or break? No. Can I have white bread and nosh on some veggies? Sure. Or I can have wheat bread AND the veggies.
Every little positive change adds up.
I guess I was going by my personal experience. Both of my white and whole wheat bread are made of the same ingredients: flour (whole wheat flour in case of wheat bread), water, yeast, salt and just enough sugar to activate the yeast. That's about it. So they aren't much different in terms of nutrition apart from that single gram of fiber and protein. More fiber is not important to me because due to my preferences I routinely get 40+ grams on a low day.
I guess for people who eat a lot of bread and not enough fiber this could make a difference. In this case, a true bran bread is even better. Some brands make high fiber white bread too. It wouldn't be a whole vs white issue anymore, it would be more of a brand issue at this point.
0 -
amusedmonkey wrote: »Sabine_Stroehm wrote: »guinevere96 wrote: »I can definitely see why people get confused because theres so many different conflicting opinions.
That's because many people know nothing about basic nutrition and/or physiology and believe all the woo they read instead.
The correct answer to the OP is that, if calories are kept equivalent, there will be absolutely no difference (in terms of weight loss) in switching from white to whole wheat bread. None. Zero. Nada. Zilch. Zip.
In term of weight loss, definitely. But bread with fiber is more filling.amusedmonkey wrote: »Other than it that it tastes better (to me personally), there isn't much difference. Just eat the kind you like. Even nutritionally the difference is not substantial enough to make the switch if you prefer white. Whole wheat has 1 gram of fiber and protein more than white bread per 1 oz slice. You can easily make up for that loss and more by snacking on a small vegetable.
Depends. The whole wheat bread I used to eat had like 3 to 5g of fiber. It DID make a difference and was more filling.
In the end though, for most people, it won't make a huge difference either way, and whole wheat bread often has more calories too.
I agree. I think one can't really say "wheat" bread and "white" bread with any meaning. There are so many breads on the market. Mine have short ingredient lists, a better nutritional profile and quite a bit more fiber. It's 100% whole wheat.
Is bread a make or break? No. Can I have white bread and nosh on some veggies? Sure. Or I can have wheat bread AND the veggies.
Every little positive change adds up.
I guess I was going by my personal experience. Both of my white and whole wheat bread are made of the same ingredients: flour (whole wheat flour in case of wheat bread), water, yeast, salt and just enough sugar to activate the yeast. That's about it. So they aren't much different in terms of nutrition apart from that single gram of fiber and protein. More fiber is not important to me because due to my preferences I routinely get 40+ grams on a low day.
I guess for people who eat a lot of bread and not enough fiber this could make a difference. In this case, a true bran bread is even better. Some brands make high fiber white bread too. It wouldn't be a whole vs white issue anymore, it would be more of a brand issue at this point.
Yeah, I'm 100% with you. I don't eat much bread, though, and tend to like whole grain better anyway. I agree with Sabine that simply making better choices is a good step, so choosing whole grain or baking at home would both be positive steps.
I grew up with whole grain (store bought) and didn't like store bought bread, but do like home made bread and both white and whole grain home made options. I also don't eat much bread so for me this discussion is more about pasta (I do whole grain at home but the fiber difference is minimal and don't care at a restaurant).0 -
Both the whole grain and white bread available at our local grocery store are often made with a lot of processed ingredients which don't sound that appealing. I also noticed some breads have colouring, corn syrup, and other unhealthy ingredients. Personally, I'd be more concerned with the ingredients list than the nutrients list for bread.0
-
Nothing like a good piece of freshly baked Italian scali bread with sesame seeds! I don't eat much bread but when I do it has to be phenomenal in texture and taste, I don't care if it's white, wheat, pumpernickel... I am about calories in / calories out vs. nutritional value when it comes to bread. It depends on what your goals are. If you're trying to eat clean I'd just pay attention to labels and avoid bread with a lot of processing and additives. Or read "wheat belly" and avoid grains entirely. If you're just trying to lose weight first, eat what you like and stick to a lower calorie choice.
0
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions