Any American Horror Story fans? Favorite season and least favorite?

2»

Replies

  • NYRhockey00
    NYRhockey00 Posts: 1,196 Member
    Season 1 was incredible .....the rest have gotten progressively worse.
  • MamaMc3
    MamaMc3 Posts: 213 Member
    Here's my list.

    1. Coven
    2. Murder House
    3. Hotel
    4. Asylum
    5. Freak Show (I didn't even bother watching the last couple of episodes!)
  • AskTracyAnnK28
    AskTracyAnnK28 Posts: 2,817 Member
    Murder House was my favorite...and from time to time I'll watch it again on Netflix. I enjoyed Coven...and loved the additions of Kathy Bates and Angela Bassett. But I couldn't stand Asylum, never finished Freak Show and couldn't get past the 2nd episode of Hotel :(
  • This content has been removed.
  • HStheBusyBee
    HStheBusyBee Posts: 1,366 Member
    I loved Coven. As a true 90s kid, I got major The Craft flashbacks :) Least favourite was murder house but I still really liked it.
  • ghouli
    ghouli Posts: 207 Member
    From favorite to least favorite:

    1. Murder House
    2. Hotel
    3. Asylum
    4. Coven
    5. Freakshow

    I really liked Asylum until they started bringing in a bunch of stuff that never really got wrapped up/felt like they just threw it in there, like the aliens that were never explained, the whole "aw man I love you both so I'm just gonna marry both of you and then weird crap is gonna stat happening", things out in the woods, etc etc. Same reason why I didn't like Freakshow, it just felt really incomplete to me. And the finale for Freakshow felt like such a cop-out, oh let's just kill everyone the end.

    Coven I was just disappointed because it was about WITCHES and there's so much cool stuff you can do with witches! But it was just "wear all black, witch b*tch, omg I'm the supreme and also wtf there's a centaur thing?" lol.

    Murder House will always be my favorite season, but Hotel got me interested in the series again.
  • michaelafoor916
    michaelafoor916 Posts: 710 Member
    I LOVE AMHS!!!!

    my ranking would be

    1. Freakshow
    2. Asylum
    3. Murder House
    4. Hotel
    5. Coven

    I don't know what it was about Coven that I just couldn't get into. I watched it and it was okay but not my favorite. I'm surprised a lot of people didn't like freak show. that was my absolute favorite ever!
  • SmurfBunny1027
    SmurfBunny1027 Posts: 150 Member
    Loved the first three. Couldn't even pick a favorite from them. Didn't enjoy Freak Show at all. Kept waiting for it to get better, and it never did. Haven't seen Hotel yet. We watch them when they show up on Netflix.
  • deaddolly
    deaddolly Posts: 107 Member
    Murder House is my #1 -- wonderful!!!! Loved it all.
    #2 Asylum - brought back my Catholic school nightmares
    #3 Hotel - loved it
    #4 Coven - loved the Voodoo parts, bored with the rest
    #5 Freakshow - didn't think there was much of a story line.
  • deaddolly
    deaddolly Posts: 107 Member
    I really liked all the blood in Hotel. I loved the look of the Hotel and the characters, especially Liz Taylor. The end was ok...it seems most of AHS endings disappoint a bit. I'm a die-hard horror fan and am so glad this is on TV!
  • Badger_Girl99
    Badger_Girl99 Posts: 2,220 Member
    LOVE that show! Season ! (Murder House) was the best...and was not a fan of Asylum.
  • Phoenix_2015
    Phoenix_2015 Posts: 499 Member
    Loved Murder House...Freakshow was shite...
  • ghouli
    ghouli Posts: 207 Member
    Does anyone have any guesses for what the next season will be? I guess Ryan Murphy puts hints for the theme of the next season in the shows but I never catch them.
  • deaddolly
    deaddolly Posts: 107 Member
    ghouli wrote: »
    Does anyone have any guesses for what the next season will be? I guess Ryan Murphy puts hints for the theme of the next season in the shows but I never catch them.

    I never get those clues either!!!! I know Gaga will be back...but that's about it.
  • dbanks80
    dbanks80 Posts: 3,685 Member
    deaddolly wrote: »
    ghouli wrote: »
    Does anyone have any guesses for what the next season will be? I guess Ryan Murphy puts hints for the theme of the next season in the shows but I never catch them.

    I never get those clues either!!!! I know Gaga will be back...but that's about it.

    I did not know that. I am trying to think back on past seasons but the clues are way over my head! LOL

  • ghouli
    ghouli Posts: 207 Member
    dbanks80 wrote: »
    deaddolly wrote: »
    ghouli wrote: »
    Does anyone have any guesses for what the next season will be? I guess Ryan Murphy puts hints for the theme of the next season in the shows but I never catch them.

    I never get those clues either!!!! I know Gaga will be back...but that's about it.

    I did not know that. I am trying to think back on past seasons but the clues are way over my head! LOL

    Yeah, I remember during Freakshow he kept saying ~ hurdurdurdur everyone look for clues for what the theme of next season (which was Hotel) will be! ~ A lot of people thought it was going to be space or something because of all the space-ish references in Freakshow and then when Hotel came out I was like huh????? What???? WHERE WERE THE CLUES??? Apparently they're crazy subtle hints haha, like one of the clues during Freakshow was a paper cup with a top hat. Which was a reference to an old movie called Top Hat which had a similar storyline to Lady Gaga's character. If the hints are that small, I'm never going to catch them :p
  • pie_eyes
    pie_eyes Posts: 12,964 Member
    ghouli wrote: »
    Does anyone have any guesses for what the next season will be? I guess Ryan Murphy puts hints for the theme of the next season in the shows but I never catch them.

    Some have mentioned a haunted ship , which I'm not crazy about. Another one is a boarding school, which I'm also not crazy about.

    I was talking earlier about how they should do a futuristic one with androids of dead loved ones and so on

    There's also the theme they introduced in Hotel of all the seasons actually taking place in the same universe with past characters coming back that I think they should live up to a little bit.

    Though how I don't know

    There was also talk of a "cabin in the woods" type of theme. Who knows. I'm excited as heck to find out
  • sedentarygeek
    sedentarygeek Posts: 55 Member
    1. Asylum
    2. Murder House
    3. Coven
    4. Freak show
  • dbanks80
    dbanks80 Posts: 3,685 Member
    pie_eyes wrote: »
    ghouli wrote: »
    Does anyone have any guesses for what the next season will be? I guess Ryan Murphy puts hints for the theme of the next season in the shows but I never catch them.

    Some have mentioned a haunted ship , which I'm not crazy about. Another one is a boarding school, which I'm also not crazy about.

    I was talking earlier about how they should do a futuristic one with androids of dead loved ones and so on

    There's also the theme they introduced in Hotel of all the seasons actually taking place in the same universe with past characters coming back that I think they should live up to a little bit.

    Though how I don't know

    There was also talk of a "cabin in the woods" type of theme. Who knows. I'm excited as heck to find out

    I think they should do a prison one and do taping on Alcatraz.

  • fernbusby
    fernbusby Posts: 11 Member
    deaddolly wrote: »
    I really liked all the blood in Hotel. I loved the look of the Hotel and the characters, especially Liz Taylor. The end was ok...it seems most of AHS endings disappoint a bit. I'm a die-hard horror fan and am so glad this is on TV!
    deaddolly wrote: »
    I really liked all the blood in Hotel. I loved the look of the Hotel and the characters, especially Liz Taylor. The end was ok...it seems most of AHS endings disappoint a bit. I'm a die-hard horror fan and am so glad this is on TV!

  • fernbusby
    fernbusby Posts: 11 Member
    My favourite was probably The Hotel season, next Asylum, I liked Murder House and Freakshow equally and I liked Coven the least as it reminded me of the film, The Craft and felt like it was aimed more at teenage girls then adults.
    I enjoyed every season though :)
    Looking forward to seeing where they go with it next!
  • Presleykay22
    Presleykay22 Posts: 2,449 Member
    Loved the first season lost interest after that.
  • BariTheOldMe
    BariTheOldMe Posts: 92 Member
    Loved Murder House (no other season came close), loathed Freak Show


    On a side note, Soundtrack to all is amazing
  • tryingtolive1
    tryingtolive1 Posts: 245 Member
    Hotel and Asylum were my favorites.
  • pie_eyes
    pie_eyes Posts: 12,964 Member
    No judging or anything of anybody but I'm kind of amazed how people can say Hotel was their favorite? That had to of been the worst one to date.

    If anybody wants to explain why they liked Hotel I'm extremely interested

    I liked it but I kinda like every season in each of its own ways
  • Dekayla13
    Dekayla13 Posts: 64 Member
    I loved all of the other seasons but two episodes in and I gave up on Hotel. I might go back and watch it some day if I'm hard up for something to watch. I hope the next season is awesome, though.

    1 Murder House
    2 Asylum
    3 Freakshow
    4 Coven
This discussion has been closed.