Deleting this app
tgrieger87
Posts: 37 Member
This app is so frustrating I might have to delete it soon.. I went from 239 to 195 no problem. Hit my goals, and now I just want to maintain since I really don't have anything to lose without looking weird. Everytime I complete my diary though it says I'll weigh 300+ lbs in 5 weeks or some other BS. On top of that, I changed my goals to maintain instead of lose weight and the caloric goals didn't change at all... Soooo I'm going to log carefully, continue to crush workouts, and end up losing weight at the same clip as before? Makes me not want to even open this thing. If anyone knows how I can fix this please let me know, otherwise goodbye app. Get your stuff together MFP.
0
Replies
-
Email customer support. It might take a minute to get back to you, but they've always been helpful to me.0
-
Don't give up on this app, it's great.
Try changing your setting to get the calorie goal you want. Or continue to log and eat your goal regardless of what MFP gives you.2 -
Thanks guys. I tried emailing, but haven't heard anything back yet. I have changed the settings and nothing updates, that's why it's so frustrating because I'm pretty sure the numbers it has given me are wrong now.0
-
For changing to maintenance, try doing it on the website rather than the app. It shouldn't make a difference, but maybe it will.
For what it says you will weigh in 5 weeks after you complete your diary - don't hit the button to complete your diary at the end of the day. I stopped doing that months ago. Those estimates are well known to be way off and it doesn't accomplish anything except put a notification on your newsfeed. You can even edit the day afterwards.1 -
I don't think I've ever "completed" a day. I mean what if I wanted to get up and have a snack later that night and I've already completed the day?
Anyways if you know what your maintenance calories need to be. Eat those, forget what app says and move forward.0 -
I didn't even know you could "complete" a day0
-
For sure. I guess I would just like to have my maintenance calories figured out by the app. I suppose I could easily do it myself though and just not use the numbers they provide... Still a pain in the *kitten* if my maintenance goes up to 1800 and my app is showing 1500 max or something everyday.. Thanks for the replies though I won't delete!0
-
tgrieger87 wrote: »For sure. I guess I would just like to have my maintenance calories figured out by the app. I suppose I could easily do it myself though and just not use the numbers they provide... Still a pain in the *kitten* if my maintenance goes up to 1800 and my app is showing 1500 max or something everyday.. Thanks for the replies though I won't delete!
Go to your profile and under goals you can enter your own calorie goal. Work out your TDEE and enter that number as the goal you want to achieve0 -
No, your profile is not filled out correctly. I just went there, and somehow you set it up so that you are 2015 years old.
eta: Get that squared away, and I'd bet one of two things: 1) your problem will be fixed; 2) you filled out something else incorrectly.1 -
I don't think I've ever "completed" a day. I mean what if I wanted to get up and have a snack later that night and I've already completed the day?
Anyways if you know what your maintenance calories need to be. Eat those, forget what app says and move forward.
If you complete your day, you can still make changes and additions to your diary.
ETA: Completing my diary is very helpful to me. It tells my brain, "You've eaten all of your calories. You're done for the day." It helps me to control the urge to be snacky in the evenings when I really don't need anything to eat.1 -
No, your profile is not filled out correctly. I just went there, and somehow you set it up so that you are 2015 years old.
eta: Get that squared away, and I'd bet one of two things: 1) your problem will be fixed; 2) you filled out something else incorrectly.
yeah, this.
Recheck your height, weight, age, goal (maintain) and then resubmit. Garbage in...
"Completing" your day's food diary does nothing other than generate that message and a post to your newsfeed, so just don't complete it if it annoys you. I don't complete a day's entry.0 -
I complete my dairy but I ignore the whatever I'm supposed to weigh in such and such days. I mean, its unlikely honestly with things changing as they do.1
-
Thank you all for the suggestions. I think the whole issue stemmed from updating on my phone rather than the website. In order to maintain though it went from 1560 calories/day to 3,350.... That sound like a mistake to anyone? I still plan on burning at least 2500 calories a week, but that seems awfully high!0
-
I have noticed when updating my calorie goal manually on my phone, if my internet connection isn't very good when I hit save, it doesn't save. I usually wait a few seconds to see whether it changed it or not. Sometimes I have to try it again.
And depending on your stats and activity, you may need to eat more than you think to maintain. If you really question it, check with another site. I like to use IIFYM when I want a second opinion. I have had a great experience with the app, I just know I have to make it work for my purposes, not whatever it may think.
For being 195 lbs and not having more to lose, it sounds like you were in a pretty large deficit if you were previously eating 1560. (I am 5'0", currently 185 lbs and eating 1900, maintain around 2600.)0 -
My PT at the gym told me to go on Google, type in BMR and use the calculator on the BMI site, which is the first website option it brings up (no, I didn't get them wrong, they are actually two different things). My PT is also a qualified nutritionist and he said use the BMR calculator to work out how many calories you need to consume to survive, then add 300 additional calories for "activity", but not to go over 2,500 for males or 2,000 for females...so if your calories come in at 2,400, don't increase to 2,700, just consume up to 2,500 per day.
If you go into nutrtion on this app, you can change the amount of calories you can allow yourself each day by clicking on "goal". Again my PT uses this app himself, so showed me what to do, seems to be working so far.
Hope this helps some way0 -
tgrieger87 wrote: »Thank you all for the suggestions. I think the whole issue stemmed from updating on my phone rather than the website. In order to maintain though it went from 1560 calories/day to 3,350.... That sound like a mistake to anyone? I still plan on burning at least 2500 calories a week, but that seems awfully high!
I thought that 1560 sounded really low for maintenance for you. I am 5'8", 140lbs (42 yrs old) and maintain around at 2000 cals. Not sure if 3000 is correct but seems more accurate than 1500. Try scoobysworkshop.com. They also have some good calculators to help get a good idea of what maintenance would be for you.
0 -
tgrieger87 wrote: »Thank you all for the suggestions. I think the whole issue stemmed from updating on my phone rather than the website. In order to maintain though it went from 1560 calories/day to 3,350.... That sound like a mistake to anyone? I still plan on burning at least 2500 calories a week, but that seems awfully high!
If you're active, not really. That sounds at least reasonable.0 -
Rushbrook60 wrote: »My PT at the gym told me to go on Google, type in BMR and use the calculator on the BMI site, which is the first website option it brings up (no, I didn't get them wrong, they are actually two different things). My PT is also a qualified nutritionist and he said use the BMR calculator to work out how many calories you need to consume to survive, then add 300 additional calories for "activity", but not to go over 2,500 for males or 2,000 for females...so if your calories come in at 2,400, don't increase to 2,700, just consume up to 2,500 per day.
If you go into nutrtion on this app, you can change the amount of calories you can allow yourself each day by clicking on "goal". Again my PT uses this app himself, so showed me what to do, seems to be working so far.
Hope this helps some way
Are you saying this is how to figure your maintenance calories? Because I am a female, and even eating your "max" calories suggestion, I would lose weight. And if the OP is a 195 lb lean male who is doing hard lifting sessions, he probably needs more than 2500 to maintain.
Also, the site does not suggest to just "add 300 for activity." It says to use a multiplier. Using said multiplier brought me to 2600, which as I said above is close to my maintenance. And much more than you're saying I should eat...0 -
I thought that 1560 sounded really low for maintenance for you. I am 5'8", 140lbs (42 yrs old) and maintain around at 2000 cals. Not sure if 3000 is correct but seems more accurate than 1500. Try scoobysworkshop.com. They also have some good calculators to help get a good idea of what maintenance would be for you. [/quote]
Yeah I was eating healthy, and around 1500 cals a day and at least burning 700-900 calories every 2 days or so. Lost like 45 lbs in just over 4 months. Just feels dangerous to start eating so much more even if I do continue to stay active. Obviously I know my body and would be able to tell if I'm gaining weight, but still scary after all the hard work!0 -
tgrieger87 wrote: »I thought that 1560 sounded really low for maintenance for you. I am 5'8", 140lbs (42 yrs old) and maintain around at 2000 cals. Not sure if 3000 is correct but seems more accurate than 1500. Try scoobysworkshop.com. They also have some good calculators to help get a good idea of what maintenance would be for you.
Yeah I was eating healthy, and around 1500 cals a day and at least burning 700-900 calories every 2 days or so. Lost like 45 lbs in just over 4 months. Just feels dangerous to start eating so much more even if I do continue to stay active. Obviously I know my body and would be able to tell if I'm gaining weight, but still scary after all the hard work![/quote]
If you work it backwards, you were losing about 2.5 lbs a week, yes?
2.5 lbs x 500 calories (500 calorie deficit per day needed to lose one pound a week) = 1250 deficit. So adding 1250 daily *should* put you close to maintenance. 1250 + the 1500 you've been eating = 2750
Just a rough estimate, as none of that is exact, but you get the idea.
If you are concerned, maybe start by adding in 100-200 calories every week or two. "Reverse diet" as they say.
You will probably notice your strength increasing a lot as you get out of that deficit! And that will be FUN! lol0 -
TresaAswegan wrote: »Rushbrook60 wrote: »My PT at the gym told me to go on Google, type in BMR and use the calculator on the BMI site, which is the first website option it brings up (no, I didn't get them wrong, they are actually two different things). My PT is also a qualified nutritionist and he said use the BMR calculator to work out how many calories you need to consume to survive, then add 300 additional calories for "activity", but not to go over 2,500 for males or 2,000 for females...so if your calories come in at 2,400, don't increase to 2,700, just consume up to 2,500 per day.
If you go into nutrtion on this app, you can change the amount of calories you can allow yourself each day by clicking on "goal". Again my PT uses this app himself, so showed me what to do, seems to be working so far.
Hope this helps some way
Are you saying this is how to figure your maintenance calories? Because I am a female, and even eating your "max" calories suggestion, I would lose weight. And if the OP is a 195 lb lean male who is doing hard lifting sessions, he probably needs more than 2500 to maintain.
Also, the site does not suggest to just "add 300 for activity." It says to use a multiplier. Using said multiplier brought me to 2600, which as I said above is close to my maintenance. And much more than you're saying I should eat...
My PT said that to be your supposed weight for your height, then the max is the 2000 or 2500. If you're aiming to gain weight, then eat more, if you're aiming to loose weight, eat less.
With the website, he said ignore the bit with the multiply because it is assuming you will burn a certain amount of calories everyday through exercise. When you exercise, you generally know what you've burnt (whether through this app calculating it based on how much time you put into the exercise or the gym equipment telling you) so you would add the exercise to the app accordingly and you, in effect, get those calories back to eat again (and obviously you only get those calories back on the day you burn them rather than the website assuming you will be performing exercise and burning those calories everyday, and therefore able to eat them)...the website doesn't give you the option to add in your expected calories burnt from exercise so is basing it on an assumed amount from how active you may or may not be, everyday, whereas by using the app, you are getting a far more accurate reading (ie. Your max is 2000, which you eat, but in the meantime you burn 300 at the gym, which effectively means you can eat 2300 because you've gained 300 of those calories back through burning them and technically have still only eaten 2000).
Like I say the website is basing your calories on a guessed amount of burnt calories through exercise everyday so you could actually be burning more or less than the website guesses, hence why the app works better. According to the website, for me to lose weight, after the multiply, I should have been eating more than 2000 calories because it is assuming I am burning a certain amount of calories everyday, but that wouldn't work because it's over what a female should consume to make the body function so it actually not going to work because it'll just keep me fat by eating too much.
Did you know that your body burns 1000 calories each day just by functioning the likes of your heart pumping blood round your body, blinking, talking etc....I must admit, having had a nutritionist explain this to me really helped me get a better insight as to how and why we need to be sensible about eating.
If it helps to explain better, my daily calories are 2000 after the 300 activity calories have been included (based on the nutritionist/PT knowledge and advice)...on Monday, I burnt 400 calories at the gym so could technically eat the whole 2000 plus the 400 I burnt so gained back, making my total consumption 2400 (I didn't but could have)...yesterday I didn't go to the gym, so could only have up to my total 2000...today, I went gym but only burnt 250 calories, so could eat 2250 (again not that I need to).
Hope this gives a little insight0 -
Rushbrook60 wrote: »TresaAswegan wrote: »Rushbrook60 wrote: »My PT at the gym told me to go on Google, type in BMR and use the calculator on the BMI site, which is the first website option it brings up (no, I didn't get them wrong, they are actually two different things). My PT is also a qualified nutritionist and he said use the BMR calculator to work out how many calories you need to consume to survive, then add 300 additional calories for "activity", but not to go over 2,500 for males or 2,000 for females...so if your calories come in at 2,400, don't increase to 2,700, just consume up to 2,500 per day.
If you go into nutrtion on this app, you can change the amount of calories you can allow yourself each day by clicking on "goal". Again my PT uses this app himself, so showed me what to do, seems to be working so far.
Hope this helps some way
Are you saying this is how to figure your maintenance calories? Because I am a female, and even eating your "max" calories suggestion, I would lose weight. And if the OP is a 195 lb lean male who is doing hard lifting sessions, he probably needs more than 2500 to maintain.
Also, the site does not suggest to just "add 300 for activity." It says to use a multiplier. Using said multiplier brought me to 2600, which as I said above is close to my maintenance. And much more than you're saying I should eat...
My PT said that to be your supposed weight for your height, then the max is the 2000 or 2500. If you're aiming to gain weight, then eat more, if you're aiming to loose weight, eat less.
With the site, he said ignore the bit with the multiply because when you exercise, you generally know what you've burnt and would add it to the app and you, in effect, get those calories back to eat again...the website doesn't give you the option to add in your expected calories burnt from exercise so is basing it on an assumed amount from how active you may or may not be, whereas by using the app, you are getting a far more accurate reading (ie. Your max is 2000, which you eat, but in the meantime you burn 300 at the gym, which effectively means you can eat 2300 because you've gained 300 of those calories back through burning them and technically have still only eaten 2000).
Like I say the website is basing your calories on a guessed amount of burnt calories through exercise so you could actually be burning more or less than the website guesses, hence why the app works better. According to the app, for me to lose weight, I should have been eating more than 2000 calories, but that wouldn't work because it's over what a female should consume to make the body function so it actually not going to work because it'll just keep me fat lol.
Did you know that your body burns 1000 calories each day just by functioning the likes of your heart pumping blood round your body, blinking, talking etc....I must admit, having had a nutritionist explain this to me really helped me get a better insight as to how and why we need to be sensible about eating.
You can actually set your calorie goal to include your exercise. I do this, I just ignore what MFP suggests I eat and set my own calorie goal based on my TDEE. My exercise is generally the same. Same workouts, same cardio. Every single week. No reason for me to log all of it when I already know how much I need to eat. But regardless of that...
Many women maintain their weight eating more than 2000 calories. Many women can lose weight eating more than 2000 calories. Same for men and 2500. Bodies are individual, and some people require a lot more than others. Someone who is very active will require much more than someone who is sedentary.
There are no set numbers for which men and women cannot eat more than, like you are suggesting. Those are just recommendations, and not everyone will fall under them.0 -
You're right about eating more, after exercise, hence how I explained the total consumption. If you are very active, of course you will need more because you've burnt off a lot of what you've consumed. For Monday, because I'd burnt 400 calories, I could have eaten a total of 2400, which was effectively only 2000 because I'd burnt 400 of those off and gained them back and I'd still have lost weight even though I'd eaten more than 2000. Now if someone who had been inactive all day had eaten 2400 calories, then that wouldn't have had the same effect on their body because they hadn't burnt off the extra to eat. As time goes on and my body shrinks (hopefully), my calorie intake will adjust...with any luck, by being healthier, I'll be fitter and go to the gym more often, and my calorie intake will adjust to include that too. I'm not reliant on MFP site generating my calories for me, I'm using my PT's method which is far more accurate than what MFP reckons I should have, and I'm changing my calorie intake based on the BMR calculator system (tried and tested scientific calculation from some very intelligent man many moons ago, before we were even born).
I'm not saying what you are saying is wrong, I think maybe we just haven't understood each others explanations...the joys of text/written responses rather than verbal, it's not always easy to get the point across. I have no reason to doubt what a qualified nutritionist would advise on so I'm now putting it to the test.
But each to their own and we'll each do as we see fit.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.7K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.3K Health and Weight Loss
- 176K Food and Nutrition
- 47.5K Recipes
- 232.6K Fitness and Exercise
- 431 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.6K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8.1K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.4K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.8K MyFitnessPal Information
- 23 News and Announcements
- 1.2K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions