Fighting Tooth and Nail Over Every Pound Lost
seyhell
Posts: 3 Member
Why is it that I feel as though I'm dying when I eat the proper amount of calories and healthy foods, while combining that with exercise? If I am only losing a pound over several months, is it really necessary for my body to protest so loudly? What can I do to fight back to the hunger pangs?
0
Replies
-
All calorie deficit is just that. As long as you will be losing weight, you will not be feeding your body the calories it needs. You must be at a deficit of calories, in other words not enough calories for your body at your current weight and hieght, in order to lose weight.
For me, more exscersize means more hunger, and the 'earned' calories don't ever seem to be enough to satisfyextra hunger generated by the excersize.
So you get to choose, hunger or weight loss.
Thats pretty much it.
Sometimes people find eating more protien curbs hunger, for others carbs do the trick, even choclate candy will be satiating for some. Its a bit of an experiment and takes a bit of time to find how it works for you personally.
Best wishes.0 -
All calorie deficit is just that. As long as you will be losing weight, you will not be feeding your body the calories it needs. You must be at a deficit of calories, in other words not enough calories for your body at your current weight and hieght, in order to lose weight.
For me, more exscersize means more hunger, and the 'earned' calories don't ever seem to be enough to satisfyextra hunger generated by the excersize.
So you get to choose, hunger or weight loss.
Thats pretty much it.
Sometimes people find eating more protien curbs hunger, for others carbs do the trick, even choclate candy will be satiating for some. Its a bit of an experiment and takes a bit of time to find how it works for you personally.
Best wishes.
I don't agree with this at all...I have not been hungry during my weight loss and you don't have to be hungry all the time.
If you are hungry it's time to look at how big of a deficit you have...what you are eating and if it's really hunger.
To feel fuller longer eat more protein and fats...
If you aren't losing as fast as you think you should maybe look at your logging as well.8 -
I second that you don't have to be hungry to lose weight. Start by picking foods that take up more volume to fill you up...lot's of whole foods. Also, you may be under-eating. How many calories are you eating/day? If you're bottomed out end not making steady progress, you should start slowly working your intake up. Also, doing more fats and protein in your diet will make you be fuller.3
-
Some people are hungry when cutting back and some aren't. Just because certain individuals are not doesn't invalidate OP's experience with hunger.7
-
All calorie deficit is just that. As long as you will be losing weight, you will not be feeding your body the calories it needs. You must be at a deficit of calories, in other words not enough calories for your body at your current weight and hieght, in order to lose weight.
For me, more exscersize means more hunger, and the 'earned' calories don't ever seem to be enough to satisfyextra hunger generated by the excersize.
So you get to choose, hunger or weight loss.
Thats pretty much it.
Sometimes people find eating more protien curbs hunger, for others carbs do the trick, even choclate candy will be satiating for some. Its a bit of an experiment and takes a bit of time to find how it works for you personally.
Best wishes.
I don't agree with this at all...I have not been hungry during my weight loss and you don't have to be hungry all the time.
If you are hungry it's time to look at how big of a deficit you have...what you are eating and if it's really hunger.
To feel fuller longer eat more protein and fats...
If you aren't losing as fast as you think you should maybe look at your logging as well.
Totally agree! I'm almost at my target of 4 stone lost since January this year, I should reach my target in about 1 month averaging 2lbs a week throughout. I've not felt hungry, I've not craved and I can actually say I've enjoyed myself! I don't exercise enough which is something I'm working on so I've mainly lost but sticking the MFP's recommendation for 1200 calories a day. The one thing most people forget is to drink enough water, on top of other beverages. I started drinking a lot of water right from the start and I am convinced it kept both the hunger and cravings away. It was almost like a drug as I felt so good and had so much energy.
You will get there, make sure you are drinking plenty of water (not just tea/coffee/carbonates/juice etc) and log everything you eat.2 -
Drink plenty of water!!! It helps a lot!1
-
MrsBaaadger wrote: »All calorie deficit is just that. As long as you will be losing weight, you will not be feeding your body the calories it needs. You must be at a deficit of calories, in other words not enough calories for your body at your current weight and hieght, in order to lose weight.
For me, more exscersize means more hunger, and the 'earned' calories don't ever seem to be enough to satisfyextra hunger generated by the excersize.
So you get to choose, hunger or weight loss.
Thats pretty much it.
Sometimes people find eating more protien curbs hunger, for others carbs do the trick, even choclate candy will be satiating for some. Its a bit of an experiment and takes a bit of time to find how it works for you personally.
Best wishes.
I don't agree with this at all...I have not been hungry during my weight loss and you don't have to be hungry all the time.
If you are hungry it's time to look at how big of a deficit you have...what you are eating and if it's really hunger.
To feel fuller longer eat more protein and fats...
If you aren't losing as fast as you think you should maybe look at your logging as well.
Totally agree! I'm almost at my target of 4 stone lost since January this year, I should reach my target in about 1 month averaging 2lbs a week. I've not felt hungry, I've not craved and I can actually say I've enjoyed myself! I don't exercise enough which is something I'm working on so I've mainly lost but sticking the MFP's recommendation for 1200 calories a day. The one thing most people forget is to drink enough water, on top of other beverages. I started drinking a lot of water right from the start and I am convinces it kept both the hunger and cravings away. It was almost like a drug as I felt so good and had so much energy.
You will get there, make sure you are drinking plenty of water (not just tea/coffee/carbonates/juice rec) and log everything you eat.
wow 4 stone since Jan! did you have any plateaus along the way?1 -
Some people are hungry when cutting back and some aren't. Just because certain individuals are not doesn't invalidate OP's experience with hunger.
again if you are hungry the chances are one of the following is true
too big of a deficit
types of foods
not knowing hunger from appetite
and I didn't see anyone invalidate it just letting them know they don't have to be hungry to lose weight.4 -
MrsBaaadger wrote: »All calorie deficit is just that. As long as you will be losing weight, you will not be feeding your body the calories it needs. You must be at a deficit of calories, in other words not enough calories for your body at your current weight and hieght, in order to lose weight.
For me, more exscersize means more hunger, and the 'earned' calories don't ever seem to be enough to satisfyextra hunger generated by the excersize.
So you get to choose, hunger or weight loss.
Thats pretty much it.
Sometimes people find eating more protien curbs hunger, for others carbs do the trick, even choclate candy will be satiating for some. Its a bit of an experiment and takes a bit of time to find how it works for you personally.
Best wishes.
I don't agree with this at all...I have not been hungry during my weight loss and you don't have to be hungry all the time.
If you are hungry it's time to look at how big of a deficit you have...what you are eating and if it's really hunger.
To feel fuller longer eat more protein and fats...
If you aren't losing as fast as you think you should maybe look at your logging as well.
Totally agree! I'm almost at my target of 4 stone lost since January this year, I should reach my target in about 1 month averaging 2lbs a week. I've not felt hungry, I've not craved and I can actually say I've enjoyed myself! I don't exercise enough which is something I'm working on so I've mainly lost but sticking the MFP's recommendation for 1200 calories a day. The one thing most people forget is to drink enough water, on top of other beverages. I started drinking a lot of water right from the start and I am convinces it kept both the hunger and cravings away. It was almost like a drug as I felt so good and had so much energy.
You will get there, make sure you are drinking plenty of water (not just tea/coffee/carbonates/juice rec) and log everything you eat.
wow 4 stone sonce Jan! did you have any plateau's along the way?
Only once around my birthday which lasted a few weeks but I was still losing even if it was only 0.5lb. I've only had 1 weigh in where I've gained and it was less than 0.5lb!2 -
Open your diary.
People will help you find mistakes you may be making.
Opinion - 90% of the battle is eating right. Exercise for health and to feel good.2 -
JanetYellen wrote: »Open your diary.
People will help you find mistakes you may be making.
Opinion - 90% of the battle is eating right. Exercise for health and to feel good.
define "eating right"1 -
Some people are hungry when cutting back and some aren't. Just because certain individuals are not doesn't invalidate OP's experience with hunger.
again if you are hungry the chances are one of the following is true
too big of a deficit
types of foods
not knowing hunger from appetite
and I didn't see anyone invalidate it just letting them know they don't have to be hungry to lose weight.
I'm seeing "I'm not hungry" from other people responding and interpreting it to mean "so you don't need to either". She is experiencing hunger but not everyone does is my only point.1 -
MrsBaaadger wrote: »MrsBaaadger wrote: »All calorie deficit is just that. As long as you will be losing weight, you will not be feeding your body the calories it needs. You must be at a deficit of calories, in other words not enough calories for your body at your current weight and hieght, in order to lose weight.
For me, more exscersize means more hunger, and the 'earned' calories don't ever seem to be enough to satisfyextra hunger generated by the excersize.
So you get to choose, hunger or weight loss.
Thats pretty much it.
Sometimes people find eating more protien curbs hunger, for others carbs do the trick, even choclate candy will be satiating for some. Its a bit of an experiment and takes a bit of time to find how it works for you personally.
Best wishes.
I don't agree with this at all...I have not been hungry during my weight loss and you don't have to be hungry all the time.
If you are hungry it's time to look at how big of a deficit you have...what you are eating and if it's really hunger.
To feel fuller longer eat more protein and fats...
If you aren't losing as fast as you think you should maybe look at your logging as well.
Totally agree! I'm almost at my target of 4 stone lost since January this year, I should reach my target in about 1 month averaging 2lbs a week. I've not felt hungry, I've not craved and I can actually say I've enjoyed myself! I don't exercise enough which is something I'm working on so I've mainly lost but sticking the MFP's recommendation for 1200 calories a day. The one thing most people forget is to drink enough water, on top of other beverages. I started drinking a lot of water right from the start and I am convinces it kept both the hunger and cravings away. It was almost like a drug as I felt so good and had so much energy.
You will get there, make sure you are drinking plenty of water (not just tea/coffee/carbonates/juice rec) and log everything you eat.
wow 4 stone sonce Jan! did you have any plateau's along the way?
Only once around my birthday which lasted a few weeks but I was still losing even if it was only 0.5lb. I've only had 1 weigh in where I've gained and it was less than 0.5lb!
Amazing!1 -
Some people are hungry when cutting back and some aren't. Just because certain individuals are not doesn't invalidate OP's experience with hunger.
again if you are hungry the chances are one of the following is true
too big of a deficit
types of foods
not knowing hunger from appetite
and I didn't see anyone invalidate it just letting them know they don't have to be hungry to lose weight.
I'm seeing "I'm not hungry" from other people responding and interpreting it to mean "so you don't need to either". She is experiencing hunger but not everyone does is my only point.
Good point, everyone is different. Nice to get some tips from others for ways not to feel hungry though :-)0 -
Why is it that I feel as though I'm dying when I eat the proper amount of calories and healthy foods, while combining that with exercise? If I am only losing a pound over several months, is it really necessary for my body to protest so loudly? What can I do to fight back to the hunger pangs?
I Have To Fight to Lose Every Pound also. It is a battle as my body wants to put back anything I lose back on.3 -
I envy the people who can lose weight without feeling hungry. I can pretty much guarantee for me that past a certain weight (not *anywhere* near underweight), a certain amount of hunger is inevitable to lose. It makes the sustainability of lower weights really questionable for me, but I am still trying to see if I can figure out a way to get to AND sustain my "optimal" weight.
I have the opposite reaction as gamliela to most exercise, it helps me be less hungry overall and I get to eat more calories and still lose at the desired rate. So you might have to experiment with that to see how it makes you feel (and even within exercise, low intensity vs. high intensity vs. strength, etc.)
Fiber and veggies can bulk out meals and that helps a bit. Make sure your protein is high enough. Are you drinking enough water?
Meal timing can help (do multiple smaller meals or fewer but bigger meals satisfy you more?)2 -
I'm generally not hungry either... not a judgment, just a difference. When I overeat, it's usually temptation winning over goals.
That being said, maybe those of us who aren't hungry while in a calorie deficit have some advice worth hearing.
Annnd this is where I get bashed for encouraging "clean" eating along with calories in vs calories out... Calories matter. Oh yes, they matter. At the same time, I am hungrier on the days I decide to eat a sandwich (within my calories) rather than a big salad, baked chicken, onion soup, broccoli, and cottage cheese for the same amount of calories. I know there isn't a clear definition of clean eating; we all have to find what works for us individually. You can eat MORE food though, when you skip the alcohol, the pop tart, the chips, or whatever it is that's calorie dense but less filling.
For those who have been successful eating those things, that's awesome. I'm not saying it's wrong... for you. However, different things can help different people, and I'm just offering one suggestion that's helped me
To the original poster, good luck, and you can do this! You have many people who are here to help you along your journey, and many great suggestions. 4 -
I can't even see @seyhell food diary. So if her first post in her first discussion is complaining about something she doesn't allow us to see, I'm not going to engage here.2
-
I'm gonna agree with the folks here saying that if you're hungry, either you have too large of a deficit or you need to consider different foods. I too lose weight without hunger. BUT, I've taken the time to experiment a little to see what kinds of food keep me feeling "full" and satisfied and not hungry longest.
The gist of MFP is a calorie is a calorie when it comes to a deficit to drive weightloss. However, what foods you choose does in fact have an effect on your blood sugar levels and how satisfied you feel.
Some thoughts to try (since we don't know your particular habits and style, if you're already doing one of these, then you could try the opposite. We're all different, and we all handle "hunger" different):
Eat smaller meals more often. // Eat 2-3 larger meals per day with no/little snacking
Skip breakfast // Eat a BIG breakfast
Don't eat after 4 pm // Save calories for an evening snack/reward
Eat high fat/low carb // Eat low fat high carb
Exercise in the morning // Exercise at night
"Eat back" your exercise calories // Don't eat back your exercise calories
Eat "slower" carbs // have something sweet with meals to activate the "reward" center of your brain
Eat only when you're truly hungry // stop paying attention to hunger cues and eat on a specific schedule4 -
Some people are hungry when cutting back and some aren't. Just because certain individuals are not doesn't invalidate OP's experience with hunger.
again if you are hungry the chances are one of the following is true
too big of a deficit
types of foods
not knowing hunger from appetite
and I didn't see anyone invalidate it just letting them know they don't have to be hungry to lose weight.
I'm seeing "I'm not hungry" from other people responding and interpreting it to mean "so you don't need to either". She is experiencing hunger but not everyone does is my only point.
that's is your interpretation.
you seem to miss the part where it says "you don't need to be hungry" and missing where the questions about deficit and types of foods being eaten are asked.
And if you are hungry I will ask the same questions of you...what is your deficit? are you eating enough "filling foods"
For example...I am peckish right now so I will eat a greek yogurt. Lots of protein and low calories and it will get me to my lunch.
Same thing will happen at about 4pm...so again greek yogurt.
But I eat a lot of protein, fats and don't choose too lose to much too fast and have a steep deficit...0 -
I agree, it's very difficult. Try lots of low calorie high fiber vegetables and hot tea to fill the void.0
-
Some people are not polite, smh...this is a place to build each other up!
Op, I think each individual may be different. Personally, I'm always a "tad" hungry. But it's gotten better. I have a handful of nuts in between meals and veggies and it's helped a lot, as well as water. Hope that helps!-1 -
melissakathrynablett wrote: »Some people are not polite, smh...this is a place to build each other up!
Op, I think each individual may be different. Personally, I'm always a "tad" hungry. But it's gotten better. I have a handful of nuts in between meals and veggies and it's helped a lot, as well as water. Hope that helps!
But statements like yours is not helpful either.
What is is your deficit per day? Is it too aggressive?0 -
I'm gonna agree with the folks here saying that if you're hungry, either you have too large of a deficit or you need to consider different foods. I too lose weight without hunger. BUT, I've taken the time to experiment a little to see what kinds of food keep me feeling "full" and satisfied and not hungry longest.
The gist of MFP is a calorie is a calorie when it comes to a deficit to drive weightloss. However, what foods you choose does in fact have an effect on your blood sugar levels and how satisfied you feel.
Some thoughts to try (since we don't know your particular habits and style, if you're already doing one of these, then you could try the opposite. We're all different, and we all handle "hunger" different):
Eat smaller meals more often. // Eat 2-3 larger meals per day with no/little snacking
Skip breakfast // Eat a BIG breakfast
Don't eat after 4 pm // Save calories for an evening snack/reward
Eat high fat/low carb // Eat low fat high carb
Exercise in the morning // Exercise at night
"Eat back" your exercise calories // Don't eat back your exercise calories
Eat "slower" carbs // have something sweet with meals to activate the "reward" center of your brain
Eat only when you're truly hungry // stop paying attention to hunger cues and eat on a specific schedule
I'm going to try high fat low carb. I was "hungry" all the time on high carb low fat. I haven't tried the keto diet yet. I hope everyone finds their best "fit" and can empathize with OP.1 -
Types of food make a massive difference. I've had a rough few weeks and just allowed myself to stray from the wagon for a while. I generally steer away from starchy carbs whilst in a deficit because they just aren't filling enough. This proved to be massively true on Saturday when I had two heart pasta based meals (still with lots of protein), was well over maintenance calories even and still went to bed hungry. Yet when losing and avoidable carb dominant meals I have little to no issues with hunger.
It can take some experimenting, some find carbs more satisfying, some prefer protein and fats (like me). I still have those things just less often because ain't nobody got time for hunger if it can be avoided!1 -
Something I've been made aware of... hunger is a feeling. Like being tired, angry, etc. So as long as I get my calories in set by MFP, my body is fine. These feelings will pass, and I don't have to act on them.4
-
Something I've been made aware of... hunger is a feeling. Like being tired, angry, etc. So as long as I get my calories in set by MFP, my body is fine. These feelings will pass, and I don't have to act on them.
is that really hunger then?
I ask because my hunger is my stomach actually is empty...it's a physical manifestation of the requirement for food. If I go too long I get dizzy, weak and lightheaded...my stomache growls and rumbles etc.
now my appetite is totally different...ie when I feel like I want to eat a couple more wings after eating 5 already...it's not hunger driving it...that would be appetite.0 -
Something I've been made aware of... hunger is a feeling. Like being tired, angry, etc. So as long as I get my calories in set by MFP, my body is fine. These feelings will pass, and I don't have to act on them.
is that really hunger then?
I ask because my hunger is my stomach actually is empty...it's a physical manifestation of the requirement for food. If I go too long I get dizzy, weak and lightheaded...my stomache growls and rumbles etc.
now my appetite is totally different...ie when I feel like I want to eat a couple more wings after eating 5 already...it's not hunger driving it...that would be appetite.
Idk honestly, but I get what you're saying, as far as semantics go I know, for me, I have to equate this to something I've learned, called HALT- basically to never get too Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired. When I do, I act up in all kinds of ways 
0 -
I'm gonna agree with the folks here saying that if you're hungry, either you have too large of a deficit or you need to consider different foods. I too lose weight without hunger. BUT, I've taken the time to experiment a little to see what kinds of food keep me feeling "full" and satisfied and not hungry longest.
The gist of MFP is a calorie is a calorie when it comes to a deficit to drive weightloss. However, what foods you choose does in fact have an effect on your blood sugar levels and how satisfied you feel.
Some thoughts to try (since we don't know your particular habits and style, if you're already doing one of these, then you could try the opposite. We're all different, and we all handle "hunger" different):
Eat smaller meals more often. // Eat 2-3 larger meals per day with no/little snacking
Skip breakfast // Eat a BIG breakfast
Don't eat after 4 pm // Save calories for an evening snack/reward
Eat high fat/low carb // Eat low fat high carb
Exercise in the morning // Exercise at night
"Eat back" your exercise calories // Don't eat back your exercise calories
Eat "slower" carbs // have something sweet with meals to activate the "reward" center of your brain
Eat only when you're truly hungry // stop paying attention to hunger cues and eat on a specific schedule
I'm going to try high fat low carb. I was "hungry" all the time on high carb low fat. I haven't tried the keto diet yet. I hope everyone finds their best "fit" and can empathize with OP.
I eat LCHF for this very reason (welcome to the dark side, bwahahaha... lol, just kidding). I was constantly hungry on a calorie restricted, lower fat, higher fiber way of eating (think the USDA guidelines). Making the switch to carb restriction made ll the difference in the world for me. I had set out to lose 25lbs of baby weight after my third child was born. On LCHF it came off so quickly and easily I just kept going and lost a total of 50 lbs (and got to a size I hadn't seen in 20 years!) without going hungry. Have stuck with this way of eating for three years now (even through my fourth pregnancy) and kept the weight off. I only wish I had tried it decades ago. I'd suggest you go over to the low carb forum and read the stickies there, and prepare yourself adequately before starting. They're a great group and its very active over there; I'm sure you'll get answers to any and all questions you might have!
http://community.myfitnesspal.com/en/group/394-low-carber-daily-forum-the-lcd-group
Good luck!2 -
Something I've been made aware of... hunger is a feeling. Like being tired, angry, etc. So as long as I get my calories in set by MFP, my body is fine. These feelings will pass, and I don't have to act on them.
is that really hunger then?
I ask because my hunger is my stomach actually is empty...it's a physical manifestation of the requirement for food. If I go too long I get dizzy, weak and lightheaded...my stomache growls and rumbles etc.
now my appetite is totally different...ie when I feel like I want to eat a couple more wings after eating 5 already...it's not hunger driving it...that would be appetite.
I agree - if you can distract yourself or wait for hunger to "pass" it's not really true hunger, more of a false hunger (be it a craving, boredom, habit, low blood sugar, whathaveyou). It can feel very real, but it's not the same as that actual stomach rumbling feeling.Something I've been made aware of... hunger is a feeling. Like being tired, angry, etc. So as long as I get my calories in set by MFP, my body is fine. These feelings will pass, and I don't have to act on them.
is that really hunger then?
I ask because my hunger is my stomach actually is empty...it's a physical manifestation of the requirement for food. If I go too long I get dizzy, weak and lightheaded...my stomache growls and rumbles etc.
now my appetite is totally different...ie when I feel like I want to eat a couple more wings after eating 5 already...it's not hunger driving it...that would be appetite.
Idk honestly, but I get what you're saying, as far as semantics go I know, for me, I have to equate this to something I've learned, called HALT- basically to never get too Hungry, Angry, Lonely, Tired. When I do, I act up in all kinds of ways
I'm familiar with HALT, but the first thing is to not let yourself get too hungry. If you ignore hunger, aren't you going to get too hungry? I think that's where differentiating between true hunger and just a desire to eat comes into play.
1
Categories
- All Categories
- 1.4M Health, Wellness and Goals
- 393.4K Introduce Yourself
- 43.8K Getting Started
- 260.2K Health and Weight Loss
- 175.9K Food and Nutrition
- 47.4K Recipes
- 232.5K Fitness and Exercise
- 427 Sleep, Mindfulness and Overall Wellness
- 6.5K Goal: Maintaining Weight
- 8.5K Goal: Gaining Weight and Body Building
- 153K Motivation and Support
- 8K Challenges
- 1.3K Debate Club
- 96.3K Chit-Chat
- 2.5K Fun and Games
- 3.7K MyFitnessPal Information
- 24 News and Announcements
- 1.1K Feature Suggestions and Ideas
- 2.6K MyFitnessPal Tech Support Questions